Willoughby's Bar & Grill Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 98 votes
Willoughby's Bar & Grill Logo

Choose My State

PA

Willoughby's Bar & Grill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

The Birds Wings

$9.00

Buffalo hot, mild butter hot, knob creek BBQ, cracked pepper & bacon ranch, thai chili, gorgonzola & pepperocini butter, brown ale honey mustard, smoked sea salt and montreal pepper rub, mango habane

Jalapeno Cheese Balls

$7.00

Smoked jalapeno relish and horseradish cheddar cheese poppers served with pepper bacon ranch

Cigar Box

$11.00

Crispy wonton cigar trio, lump crab casino with thai chili sauce, philly cheese steak, buffalo chicken and gorgonzola

Lobster Crab Dip

$10.00

Lobster and crab tossed with a creamy tarragon and mascarpone cheese sauce baked golden brown, served with sesame and corn tortillas

Clam Strips Casino

$8.00

Battered jumbo clam strips with a casino bacon tartar dip served with sweet potato waffle fries

Candied Bacon Chicken Quesadilla

$10.00

Grilled chicken, colby jack cheddar, asiago, candied pepper bacon served with a fresh tomato cilantro salad

Willoughby’s Personal Nachos

$7.00

Corn and sesame tortilla chips, queso cheese, black bean, sweet corn and steak chili served with chipotle sour cream and guacamole

All Three Combo - Grilled Steak & Onion

$15.00

All Three Combo - Grilled Chicken

$15.00

All Three Combo - Knob Creek BBQ Pulled Pork

$15.00

Loaded Baked Potato Skins

$7.00

Topped with candied bacon and cheddar cheese served with chipotle sour cream

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$8.00

Creamy blend of asiago and feta mixed with spinach and roasted artichokes topped with tomato basil salad, served with corn and sesame tortilla

Twister Sticks

$7.00

Savory baked pretzel sticks with smoked sea salt and cheese queso jalapeno dip

Trophy Fries

$8.00

Statue of our loaded house fries layered with steak chili, queso, cheddar, and cilantro tomato salsa, served with pepper bacon ranch and chipotle sour cream

Thai Calamari

$10.00

Wasabi fried calamari with bok choy, sesame seeds, and water chestnuts served with Thai chili drizzle

Pizza Du Jour

$8.00

Daily pizza creation

Sweet Potato & Pub Rings

$8.00

Waffle cut sweet potato fries with beer battered red onion rings, served with a spicy maple dipping sauce

Grand Slam Sliders

$12.00

Slider trio of kobe beef with caramelized onions and baby ports served with roasted pepper balsamic ketchup, texas brisket BBQ, red onion rings and nappa cabbage slaw, knob creek BBQ pulled pork


Soups

Soup Du Jour

$5.00

Steak Chili

$6.00


Salads

The Bachelor

$13.00

Romaine & spinach spring mix with loaded potato skins, grilled 6 oz. sirloin, cherry tomatoes, black pepper bacon bits, gorgonzola crumbles, caramelized onions tossed with balsamic vinaigrette

Ahi Tuna Crunch

$12.00

Sesame encrusted tuna over mixed greens, toasted almond slivers, golden raisins, garbanzo beans, red onion, mandarin wedges, cherry tomatoes tossed with citrus ponzu vinaigrette with toasted sesame c

Buffalo Chicken

$11.00

Crispy buttermilk fried buffalo chicken tenders, field greens spring mix, bacon, cherry tomatoes, carrot wedges, gorgonzola crumbles, tossed with bleu cheese dressing

TY Cobb

$12.00

Fresh spring mix, grilled chicken, tavern ham, hard boiled egg, crumbled bacon, bell peppers, roasted corn & black bean cilantro salsa, cherry tomatoes, red onions, avocado, tossed with bacon ranch

Classic Caesar

$9.00

Crisp romaine, herb roasted croutons, shaved parmesan, tossed with caesar dressing available with grilled chicken, or shrimp $12.00

House Classic

$9.00

Fresh spring and romaine mix, carrots, onions, and cherry tomatoes with choice of dressing available with grilled chicken, or shrimp $12.00


Entrees

Slow Roasted Baby Back Ribs

$18.00 - $23.00

Glazed in our knob creek bourbon BBQ or memphis dry rubbed, served with baked 3 cheese mac and coleslaw

Big Bang Pork Chop

$20.00

Grilled 14 oz. mesquite pork chop stacked over jalapeno corn bread topped with crispy onions straws and knob creek BBQ and mashed potatoes

Willoughby’s Bone In Rib Eye

$30.00

Smoked sea salt & black pepper grilled 20 oz. bone-in rib-eye, served with seasonal vegetables and mashed potatoes

Steak Frites

$20.00

12 oz. sliced sirlion steak topped with melted gorgonzola & pepperocini butter served over fries

Grilled Kobe Meatloaf

$17.00

Char-grilled kobe prime beef meatloaf over mashed potatoes, served with roasted pepper balsamic ketchup and seasonal vegetables

Surf n turf

$25.00

Charbroiled 6oz. filet mignon topped with candied bacon crumbles & grilled shrimp skewer, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato

Fish & Chips

$16.00

Lager battered Icelandic haddock fried golden brown served with jicama nappa cabbage slaw and house fried chips

Lump Crab Cakes

$22.00

Broiled golden lump crab cakes with chesapeake tartar, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato

Yellow Fin Ahi Tuna

$21.00

Seared sesame seed encrusted ahi tuna served with wasabi aioli, citrus ponzu vinaigrette, pepper bacon cilantro salad, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato

Bruschetta Salmon

$22.00

Grilled atlantic salmon with a parmesan and panko crust over wilted spinach with a pesto cream reduction and tomato basil salad, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato

Grilled Captain’s Chicken

$18.00

Chicken breasts topped with lump crab and asparagus finished with a scampi butter sauce, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato

Southern Fried Chicken & Waffles

$17.00

Crispy battered chicken breasts over sweet potato waffle fries, served with brown ale mustard and nappa cabbage slaw

Chicken Cordon Bleu

$18.00

Grilled chicken, ham, shaved swiss finished with a whole grain mustard cream garlic sauce, served with seasonal vegetables and baked potato


PastasIncludes side salad

Willoughby’s Chicken Fettuccine

$17.00

Pan seared chicken breasts, cherry tomato, spinach, artichokes, roasted peppers, fresh basil, tossed in a lemon white wine cream sauce over fettuccine

Shrimp & Andouille Diablo

$18.00

Seared jumbo shrimp & andouille, bell peppers, bacon tossed in a spicy vodka blush over penne

Veggie Primavera

$15.00

Penne pasta served with a garlic wine butter sauce with fire roasted primavera veggies, add chicken or shrimp $3.00

Steak & Bleu Fettuccine

$18.00

Grilled sirloin served over fettuccine with mushroom and red peppers, tossed in a gorgonzola alfredo

Pasta Du Jour

Price may varies

Chef’s featured pasta creation


Signature BurgersServed with fries or bar chips, additional patty to any burger $3.00

The Big House

$12.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with pepper bacon, steak chili, onion rings, and cheddar cheese on toasted salt & pepper bun

The Californian

$11.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with caramelized onions, pepper jack cheese, avocado, lettuce, tomato, and smoked jalapeno mayo on a toasted pretzel bun

Bruschetta Burger

$11.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with fresh bruschetta, crisp romaine, melted mozzarella & asiago with roasted garlic rosemary aioli, and smoked balsamic glaze on toasted salt & pepper bun

Flying Dutchmen

$11.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with, fried egg, tavern ham, brown ale mustard melted american, lettuce, tomato on a toasted salt & pepper bun

Shroom Burger

$10.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with sauteed baby portobello, aged swiss, red pepper hummus on toasted salt & pepper bun

The Roast

$12.00

½ pound prime blend burger topped with slow roasted pulled pork, bourbon BBQ, nappa cabbage slaw, cheddar cheese on a toasted pretzel bun

The Spanky

$11.00

½ pound prime blend burger with pepper bacon topped with caramelized onions, knob creek BBQ, melted cheddar, lettuce, tomato on toasted pretzel bun

Classic

$10.00

½ pound prime blend burger with pepper bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato on toasted pretzel bun


Signature SandwichesServed with fries or bar chips

Chicken BLT

$9.00

Grilled chicken breast, pepper bacon, swiss, avocado, brown ale honey mustard, lettuce, and tomato on toasted pretzel bun

Club Box

$10.00

Grilled tavern ham and oven roasted turkey with melted provolone and american cheese with nappa cabbage slaw, pepper bacon, lettuce, tomato, and 1000 island sauce on triple decker wheat berry toast

The Castro Cuban

$10.00

Pulled pork, tavern ham, aged swiss, slivered pickle slices, cuban mojo citrus mayo on pressed club roll

Beefin Cheddar

$10.00

Slow roasted beef brisket, caramelized onions, horseradish cheddar and aioli with lettuce and tomato on toasted pretzel roll

Kobe Hometown Meatball

$10.00

House made Kobe meatballs, marinara, mozzarella, shaved parmesan, roasted peppers, spinach & basil on toasted club roll

Buffalo Chicken

$9.00

Battered chicken tossed in buffalo sauce with bleu cheese dressing, served with lettuce and tomato on a toasted pretzel bun

Kickin Crab

$12.00

Lump maryland crab cake, leaf lettuce, tomato, chesapeake lime aioli on toasted pretzel bun

Portobello Burger

$10.00

Charbroiled balsamic portobello, vegetable hummus, spring mix, tomato, asiago & romano cheese

The Po Boy

$10.00

Fried oysters and clams, crispy onion straws, cilantro tomato salsa, thai chili, and chesapeake lime aioli, served with nappa cabbage slaw on toasted club roll

Stuffed Gyro

$10.00

Shaved lamb, lettuce, tomato, onion with tzatziki on pita stuffed with french fries


Signature CheesesteaksServed with fries or bar chips

The Hangover

$10.00

Grilled shaved rib-eye, melted cheddar and bleu cheese, onions, fries, and buffalo sauce on toasted philly steak roll

The Vet

$10.00

Shaved rib-eye sauteed onions, melted cheese whiz, american cheese on toasted philly steak roll

California Chicken

$10.00

Grilled chicken, american cheese, candied bacon, onions, peppers, mayo, lettuce and tomato on a toasted philly steak roll


Sides

Side Salad

$3.00

Caesar

$3.00

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

$3.00

Seasonal Vegetable

$3.00

Roasted Sweet Corn & Black Beans

$3.00

Baked Potato

$3.00

Mac & Cheese

$3.00

Fries

$3.00

Waffle Sweet Potato Fries

$3.00

Bar Chips

$3.00

Nappa Cabbage Slaw

$3.00


Non Alcoholic Drinks

Coke

Price may varies

Diet Coke

Price may varies

Sprite

Price may varies

Root Beer

Price may varies

Ginger Ale

Price may varies

Iced Tea

Price may varies

Raspberry Tea

Price may varies

Lemonade

Price may varies

Coffee

Price may varies

Hot Tea

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading