Whistling Willie's Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 148 votes
Whistling Willie's Logo

Choose My State

NY

Whistling Willie's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Hot Soft Pretzels

$9.00

The ultimate American grill and pub appetizer with a jalapeno beer cheese dip

Crispy Calamari

$12.00

Cornmeal fried with a sweet chili dipping sauce

Cheetos Fried Zucchini Sticks

$8.00

House made ranch for dipping

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks

$8.00

Fried up crisp and golden

Chicken Spring Rolls

$10.00

Roasted pulled chicken, black beans, corn, cilantro and jack cheese in a crispy wonton wrapper served with a mango mojito cream and chili dip

Cajun Shrimp Tacos

$9.00

Two soft shell tacos with Cajun dusted shrimp, shredded cabbage, smoked cheese, pico de gallo and guacamole

Roasted Portobello Quesadilla

$10.00

Spinach, fire-roasted peppers and goat cheese, with guacamole and sour cream

Volcano Shrimp

$11.00

Breaded crispy shrimp tossed in our spicy boom boom sauce with Asian slaw

Willie's Wings

$11.00

Marinated and roasted then fried to order and tossed with your choice of sauce: Sticky Chipotle Lime, Honey BBQ, Spiced Parmesan Garlic, Buffalo, Honey Sriracha

Slider Tasting Trio

$10.00

Three of our famous house made mini burgers each with a separate topping of Wisconsin cheddar - barbeque onions - buffalo bleu

Super Nachos

$10.00

We cook our own chips and load them with re-fried beans, black olives, jalapenos, tomatoes, salsa, sour cream, guacamole, cheddar and jack cheeses

Spicy Tuna Poke Bowl

$13.00

Diced Ahi tuna dressed in a soy ginger and sesame dressing with guacamole and wonton chips


Sides

Parmesan Polenta

$5.00

Asian Slaw

$5.00

Sweet Fries

$5.00

Grilled Potato

$4.00

Lemon-Parm Asparagus

$7.00

Broccoli

$7.00

Grilled Zucchini

$6.00

Truffle Fries

$6.00

Spinach

$7.00


Willie's Famous Char Grilled BurgersHand made with house ground prime hanger steak and Willie's secret seasonings. Served on a toasted brioche bun with a half sour pickle, cole slaw and house-cut fries. Sweet potato fries +$1

The Topless

$13.00

Bun less over mixed greens with tomato and red onion

Surf and Turf

$18.00

Topped with lobster chunks, spinach and lemon chili mayo

The Buffalo Bleu

$15.00

Thin sliced house pickled cucumbers, crumbled bleu cheese and Franks red hot

The Smokehouse Burger

$16.00

House smoked cheddar, BBQ pork belly topped with a fried egg and onion straws

The "Red Eye"

$15.00

Coffee rubbed and grilled with a Wild Turkey honey barbeque sauce, cherry hardwood smoked bacon and pepper jack cheese

Goat Cheese Stuffed Turkey Burger

$15.00

Baby arugula and a spicy chipotle ketchup

The Plain Jane

$13.00

Simply grilled with lettuce and tomato

The West Sider

$14.00

Horseradish cheddar, rosemary mustard dressing on a warm pretzel roll

All American Burger

$14.00

The classic American cheeseburger

Smother Mother

$14.00

A smothering of caramelized onions and mushrooms topped with melted Swiss and American cheese

The Ultimate Vegetable Burger

$13.00

Garden vegetables and chickpeas, served topless style with avocado and a lemon yogurt sauce

The Whistler

$14.00

Aged cheddar and bourbon bacon


Soups

Baked French Onion Soup

$7.00

Chef's Soup of the Day

$6.00

Please ask your server for details

Willie's Wicked Chili

$8.00

House ground steak, white and red beans, tomato broth


Salads

Chopped Cobb Salad

$14.00

Mixed greens, grilled chicken, tomatoes, onion, cucumbers, avocado, bacon, bleu cheese, hard cooked egg and red wine vinaigrette

Butter Poached Lobster Salad

$19.00

Arugula, endive, scallions, roast corn, baby tomatoes, avocado, mango vinaigrette

La Manzanita

$15.00

Mixed greens and kale, diced apples, cool cucumber, organic cherry tomatoes, roasted pecans, fresh corn and fried chicken strips in a honey mustard dressing

Classic Caesar

$10.00

Romaine hearts with traditional Caesar dressing topped with shaved Romano cheese and garlic croutons

Sashimi Tuna Salad

$17.00

Pan seared Ahi tuna, mixed greens, mango, avocado, crispy wontons and a cilantro lime vinaigrette

Fresh Kale & Salmon Salad

$19.00

Goat cheese, orange segments, candied sunflower seeds, spice rubbed salmon, hard cider vinaigrette

Fresh Vegetable Salad

$14.00

Asparagus, green beans, tomato, cucumber, apple, edamame, red cabbage, romaine and shaved parmesan all chopped with pomegranate vinaigrette


Cold Beverages

Root Beer

$2.75

Seltzer

Price may varies

Iced Tea

Price may varies

Brewed fresh daily

Sierre Mist

Price may varies

Pepsi

Price may varies

Diet Pepsi

Price may varies

Arnold Palmer

$3.75

Fresh tea and lemonade

Lemonade

$3.75

In house made

Red Bull

$4.00

San Pellegrino

$6.00

Sparkling

$6.00


Hot Beverages

Espresso

$4.00

Cappuccino

$4.75

Coffee

$2.50

Hot Tea

$3.25

Hot Chocolate

$4.00


Specialty Drinks

Wicked Tea

$9.00

Jack Daniels Tennessee Honey, freshed brewed tea, in house lemonade

Pomegranate Margarita

$9.50

Fresh sour mix, Grand Marnier and Cointreau, with 1800 tequila

Sangria

$9.00

Choose between Red and White, both made fresh with oranges and apples (seasonal)

Mojito

$9.50

A classic mint and rum concotion

Blueberry Mojito

$9.75

The original with a fresh twist of fruit and hint of lemon

Twisted Tea

$5.00

Classic spiked tea served over ice in a Willies pint glass

Bloody Mary

$9.50

Tito's Vodka, bacon, salted rim, pickled asparagus and green beans served in a chilled pint glass

Willie's Passion Martini

$10.50

Sky passion fruit vodka, OJ, lemon and passion fruit juice

Maple Manhattan

$10.00

Maple bourbon, bitters, sweet vermouth

Gin Rickey

$9.00

Gin, lime and soda in this refreshing cocktail


Bottle Selection

Budweiser/Light

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra

Price may varies

Amstel Light

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Miller Lite

Price may varies

Corona/Light

Price may varies

Heineken

Price may varies


SandwichesLunch Fix Half Sandwich and Soup or House Salad for $12.50

Shrimp Po'boy

$15.00

Crispy cornmeal crusted shrimp, crab mayo, avocado, sriracha and shredded cabbage on a toasted ciabatta

Grilled Cheese and Short Rib

$16.00

Shredded short ribs, swiss, cherry wood smoked bacon, caramelized onions, horseradish mayo on grilled country rye, pickle and fries

Roast Chicken Panini

$15.00

Marinated slow roasted white meat chicken sliced thin and topped with guacamole, jack cheese, tomato and cherry wood smoked bacon on pressed flatbread, fries and pickle

Southwestern Chicken Wrap

$14.00

BBQ chicken, bacon, black beans, roasted peppers, red onion, jack cheese, tortilla chips and chipotle ranch dressing

Porky Pig

$14.00

Slow cooked BBQ pulled pork with cool coleslaw and cheddar jack cheese on a warm roll, pickle and sweet potato fries

The New Yorker

$14.00

Hot pastrami piled high with swiss cheese, caramelized onions and spicy brown mustard on a warm pretzel bun, sweet potato fries and a pickle

Buttermilk Chicken Sand

$15.00

Breaded chicken fried to order, drizzled with honey and served with a whipped bleu cheese, tomato bacon jam and our house Asian slaw

Roast Salmon BLT

$17.00

Thin sliced salmon with smoked bacon, baby arugula, plum tomatoes, roasted pepper balsamic mayo on a toasted thick cut country rye with Asian slaw

Portobello Panini

$15.00

Baked Portobello mushroom, fire roasted pepper, baby arugula, plum tomato, fresh mozzarella and chipotle mayo on pressed flatbread, truffle fries and pickle

Pit Beef Dip

$16.00

Shaved steak slices, onions, and Swiss cheese on a garlicky French bread with horseradish mayo and au jus to dip


EntreesAll entrees will include our house salad with choice of dressing

NY Strip Steak

$21.00

Horseradish and Bleu Cheese crust, mashed potatoes and a rich brown sauce with mushroom

Fish and Chips

$19.00

Guinness battered Alaskan cod, roast corn tartar sauce, shoestring fries, pickle and malt vinegar

Willie's Famous Root Beer BBQ Baby Rack Ribs

$20.00

Rubbed and slow roasted with root beer BBQ sauce, served with corn bread and a house slaw

Veal Meatloaf Stack

$21.00

Roast garlic mashed potatoes, buttered broccoli spears, red wine and gorgonzola

Beer Braised Short Ribs

$23.00

Smashed potatoes, spinach, crispy onions

Hibachi Steak

$22.00

Soy marinated hanger steak, wilted cabbage and mushrooms, wasabi mash and tempura asparagus

Moroccan Chicken

$18.00

Roast tomato and harissa sauce, ancient grain medley, grilled chicken topped with asparagus

Herb Crusted Salmon

$21.00

Freshly chopped herbs, polenta and spinach with a lemon reduction

Alicia's Lobster and Crab Mac

$21.00

Fresh lobster and crab meat, creamy cheese sauce, garlic panko crust, truffle oil drizzle

Parma Pizza

$16.00

Woodfired 12" personal pie topped with organic arugula and cherry tomatoes, prosciutto, truffle oil, parmesan cheese and a fig balsamic glazze

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$15.00

Tangy BBQ sauce, red onion, smoked gouda and cilantro


Beers on TapHappy Hour 4-6 Monday Through Friday Half off 16oz Drafts Bar Only. Rotating Series check out our boards or ask your server what's on tap!

Lagunitas IPA

Price may varies

Moderately hoppy and well balanced, copious cascade and centennial hops with crystal malt. An IPA built to make you want another sip

Peekskill Brewery's Eastern Standard IPA

Price may varies

Local craft beer loaded with simcoe and citra hops

Stella Cidre

Price may varies

Crisp and refreshing Belgian cider made with hand-picked apples

Ithaca Flower Power IPA

Price may varies

Smooth big body finish that boasts pineapple and grapefruit

Two Roads Lil Heaven Session IPA

Price may varies

Made with four exotic hops-Azacca, Calypso, Mosaic and Equinox.Taste is of tropical fruits specifically passion fruit, grapefruit and apricots. Finishes with just enough toasted character to balance.

Captain's Kolsch

Price may varies

This German style beer is the perfect blend between Ale and Lager, hailing from Pleasantville, NY

Blue Moon Belgian White

Price may varies

Unfilitered wheat ale spiced in the Belgian tradition for an uncommonly smooth taste

Breckenridge Vanilla Porter

Price may varies

Smooth roasted chocolate with a creamy vanilla finish. Vanilla Beans from Paupau New Guinea and Madagascar

WW Hometown Honey Brown

Price may varies

Our house brew made only for us! Golden amber in color, made with Manitoba White Clover honey, medium-bodied lager. Brewed in Rochester, NY

Beer Flight

Price may varies

You pick any four of our drafts, served in 5oz glasses

Long Board Island Lager

Price may varies

Crisp, smooth, refreshing with slightly spiced Hawaiian Malt

Dogfish 60 Minute IPA

Price may varies

Powerful yet balanced east coast IPA with citrus characteristics

Guinness Stout

Price may varies

Perfected over 200 years. Refreshing, full dark

Sam Adams Seasonal

Price may varies

Fresh seasonal offering from The Sam Adams Brewing Co.

Newburgh Brown Ale

Price may varies

Verging on black, this beer pours with a light tan head and beautiful ruby highlights in the glass. The flavor is dominated by malty sweetness and gentle hints of chocolate and toffee

Stella Artois

Price may varies

Classic European Pilsner since 1708


Main

Simple Grilled Cheese

$7.00

Served with fries

Baked Mac and Cheese

$6.00

A homemade classic with a Willie's twist

Grilled Chicken and Vegetable with fries

$8.00

Chef's choice of vegetable

6oz Hamburger with fries

$8.00

Plain or with cheese

Pasta with butter

$5.00

Fusilli pasta

Crispy Chicken Strips

$8.00

Served with mash or shoestring potatoes

Breaded Mozzarella Sticks

$7.00

Breaded and served golden and crisp


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading