What A Bagel Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 51 votes
What A Bagel Logo

Choose My State

NY

What A Bagel Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Beverages

Coffee

$1.75 - $2.25

Tea

$1.75 - $2.25

Hot Chocolate

$1.75 - $2.25

Espresso

$2.00

Small.

Cappuccino

$2.75

Small.

Pint of Milk

$1.50

10 oz. Tropicana Bottle

$1.50

14 oz. Tropicana Container

$2.00

Vitamin Water

$2.25

Gatorade

$2.25

20 oz. Soda

$2.00

Starbucks Frapuccino Bottle

$2.50

Poland Spring Bottled Water

$1.50

Red Bull

$2.75

Yoo-hoo

$2.00

Snapple

$2.00

Boylan Soda

$1.25

Nesquik

$2.50


Bagels

1 Bagel

$1.00

2 Bagels

$2.00

3 Bagels

$3.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

4 Bagels

$4.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

5 Bagels

$5.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

6 Bagels

$6.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

7 Bagels

$7.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

8 Bagels

$8.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

9 Bagels

$9.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

10 Bagels

$10.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

11 Bagels

$11.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.

13 Bagels

$12.00

If more than one is chosen, please specify quantities of bagel flavors in the special instructions box.


Good Morning

Muffin

$2.00

Muffin with Jelly

$2.50

Plain Croissant

$2.00

Flavored Croissant

$2.00

Buttered Bagel

$1.50

1 Egg on a Bagel

$1.75

1 Egg White on a Bagel

$1.75

1 Egg with Cheese on a Bagel

$2.50

Sausage and Cheese on a Bagel

$3.25

1 Egg, Bacon and Cheese on a Bagel

$3.25

BLT

$4.50

BLT with Turkey Bacon

$5.00


Cream Cheese on Bagel

Plain Cream Cheese on Bagel

$2.50

Not sliced.

Plain Lite Cream Cheese on Bagel

$2.50

Not sliced.

Scallion Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Scallion Lite Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Vegetable Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Vegetable Lite Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Strawberry Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Bacon Garlic and Herb Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Olive and Pimento Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Scallion Bacon Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Jalapeno Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.00

Not sliced.

Scallion Nova Cream Cheese on Bagel

$3.25

Not sliced.

Nova Spread on Bagel

$3.25

Not sliced.


Cream Cheese by 1/4 lb. and 1/2 lb.

Plain Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Plain Lite Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Scallion Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Scallion Lite Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Vegetable Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Vegetable Lite Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Cinnamon Walnut Raisin Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Strawberry Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Bacon Garlic and Herb Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Olive and Pimento Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Scallion Bacon Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Jalapeno Cream Cheese

$2.00 - $4.00

Scallion Nova Cream Cheese

$2.13 - $4.25

Nova Spread

$2.13 - $4.25


Boar's Head Cold Cuts on a Bagel

Boar's Head Ham on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Turkey on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Roast Beef on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Bologna on a Bagel

$4.75

Boar's Head Pastrami on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Smoked Peppered Turkey on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Salami on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head Liverwurst on a Bagel

$4.75

Boar's Head Honey Turkey on a Bagel

$5.50

Boar's Head American Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50

Boar's Head Swiss Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50

Boar's Head Cheddar Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50

Boar's Head Mozzarella Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50

Boar's Head Provolone Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50

Boar's Head Muenster Cheese on a Bagel

$4.50


Boar's Head Cold Cuts by 1 lb.

1 lb. of Boar's Head Ham

$9.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Turkey

$10.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Roast Beef

$9.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Bologna

$6.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Pastrami

$9.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Smoked Pepper Turkey

$9.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Salami

$8.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Liverwurst

$6.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Honey Turkey

$10.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head American Cheese

$6.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Swiss Cheese

$8.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Cheddar Cheese

$8.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Mozzarella Cheese

$7.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Provolone Cheese

$7.99

1 lb. of Boar's Head Muenster Cheese

$7.99


Homemade Salad on a Bagel

Chicken Salad on a Bagel

$5.00

Tuna Salad on a Bagel

$5.00

Healthy Salad on a Bagel

$5.00

Egg Salad on a Bagel

$4.50

Baked Salmon Salad on a Bagel

$6.00

White Fish Salad on a Bagel

$6.00

Chopped Chicken Liver Salad on a Bagel

$5.00

Chopped Herring Salad on a Bagel

$4.50

Seafood Salad on a Bagel

$5.00


Homemade Salad by 1/2 lb. and 1 lb.

Chicken Salad

$4.50 - $8.99

Tuna Salad

$4.50 - $8.99

Healthy Salad

$5.00 - $9.99

Egg Salad

$3.50 - $6.99

Baked Salmon Salad

$6.00 - $11.99

White Fish Salad

$6.00 - $11.99

Chopped Chicken Liver Salad

$4.50 - $8.99

Chopped Herring Salad

$4.00 - $8.99

Seafood Salad

$5.00 - $9.99

Smoked Trout Salad

$20.00

1 lb.


Appetizing

Nova Scotia Salmon on a Bagel

$7.50

Belly Lox Salty on a Bagel

$7.00

Kippered Salmon on a Bagel

$8.50


Appetizing by the lb.

1/4 lb. of Nova Scotia Salmon

$8.00

1/4 lb. of Belly Lox Salty

$7.50

1/4 lb. of White Fish Salad

$3.00

1 lb. of Sable

$50.00

1 lb. of Sturgeon

$50.00

Herring Filet

$3.25

Sour cream and onion.

1 lb. of Kippered Salmon

$32.00

1 lb. of White Fish

$20.00


Name Your Game

Balboa

$5.95

Hot roast beef, melted cheese, garlic powder and ranch dressing.

Italian Combo

$6.50

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato and onion.

Bagel Club

$6.50

Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and dressing.

Tuna Melt

$5.95

Tuna, melted cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Chicken Melt

$5.95

Chicken, melted cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Bird Song

$6.50

Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted Swiss cheese and honey mustard.

Mike's Favorite

$6.50

Chicken salad, bacon, cheese and hot sauce.

Our Reuben

$6.50

Hot pastrami, Swiss, Russian dressing and coleslaw.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading