Water Buffalo Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 112 votes
Water Buffalo Logo

Choose My State

WI

Water Buffalo Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starters

Colossal Onion Rings

$8.99

Buttermilk battered with a blue cheese dipping sauce

Mussels

$12.99

Gluten free. Pancetta cream sauce with garlic-rubbed ciabatta

Louisiana Crab Cakes

$11.99

Julienned vegetables and spicy remoulade

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$11.99

Gluten free. Grilled or fried, with creamy slaw and blue cheese dressing

Grilled Rustic Flatbread

$10.99

New selection featured weekly

Bruschetta

$8.99

Seasonal tomatoes, garlic and basil

Chicken Rolls

$10.99

Puff pastry, spicy chicken, onion, poblano pepper, queso blanco, cilantro and avocado sour cream

Sesame Ahi Tuna

$12.99

Gluten free. Organic mixed greens, toasted sesame aioli


Fresh SaladsFor an additional charge, we will gladly add beef tenderloin, chicken, salmon, tuna or shrimp to any salad

Grilled Chicken

$11.99

Gluten free. Organic mixed greens, red grapes, cucumber, blue cheese, golden raisins, walnuts and sweet & sour dressing

Tex-Mex

$10.99

Gluten free. Romaine. grilled corn, tomato, roasted poblano, bell pepper, red cabbage and avocado with chipotle ranch

Blackened Salmon caesar

$12.99

Grated parmesan and croutons

Cobb

$11.99

Gluten free. Avocado, nueske’s ham, applewood smoked bacon, tomato, blue cheese, cucumber, hard boiled egg and romaine with green goddess dressing

Beef Tenderloin Asparagus

$13.99

Soft-boiled egg, walnuts, croutons, organic mixed greens and balsamic vinaigrette

House

$4.99 - $7.99

Gluten free. Organic mixed greens, grape tomatoes, cucumber, applewood smoked bacon, baby mozzarella, croutons with red wine vinaigrette


Housemade Soups

Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup

$3.99

Soup Du Jour

$3.99


Signature Entrees

Tuna Steak

$20.99

Sesame aioli, julienned vegetables and sesame seeds

Aged Beef Filet

$24.99

Gluten free. House mash, asparagus, herbed compound butter and balsamic reduction

Three Cheese Ravioli

$15.99

Mascarpone, ricotta, parmesan, shallots, garlic and sage brown butter sauce

Chicken & Dumplings

$15.99

Carrots, celery, onions and peas

Beef Tenderloin Kebab

$19.99

Gluten free. Peppers, onions, mushrooms and red wine demi-glace with house mash or seasoned quinoa

Grilled Meatloaf

$17.99

House blended grass-fed beef, berkshire pork and pancetta with house mash and amber ale gravy

Beef and Sausage Lasagna

$15.99

Italian seasoned beef and sausage, artichoke cream cheese, marinara and chilled basil pesto

Grilled Atlantic Salmon

$22.99

Gluten free. Julienned vegetables, teriyaki soy glaze and seasoned quinoa

Truffled Mac and Cheese

$16.99

Cremini mushrooms, peas, parmesan, fresh breadcrumbs and fusilli pasta

Friday Fish Fry

$15.99

Only available on friday / lunch portions available until 4pm. Champagne-battered alaskan cod with fries, creamy slaw and rye bread


SandwichesAvailable until 4 p.m. Choice of fries, creamy slaw or fresh fruit

Egg Salad B.L.T.

$11.99

Applewood smoked bacon, celery, lettuce, tomato on grilled sourdough

Corned Beef

$12.99

Sauerkraut, swiss, thousand island dressing on toasted rye

Cheesesteak

$14.99

Shaved prime rib, peppers, cheddar on a fresh hoagie roll

Pretzel Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup

$11.99

White cheddar and fontina cheese

Nueske’s Ham & Cheese

$13.99

House mustard, cornichons, swiss and chive butter on a seeded kaiser roll

Dagwood

$12.99

Smoked turkey, nueske’s ham, thousand island dressing, cucumber, tomato, iceburg lettuce and cornichons on panini bread

Grass-Fed Signature Burger

$13.99

Roasted tomato aioli, pimento cheese spread and green chili on a brioche roll

Black Bean Burger

$11.99

Poblano peppers, avocado and crispy onion on a brioche roll

Meatloaf

$12.99

House blended grassfed beef, berkshire pork and pancetta with crispy onions

Colossal Fried Chicken

$12.99

Southern style: spicy remoulade, iceburg lettuce, tomato, red onion on a brioche roll or buffalo style: buffalo sauce, blue cheese and creamy slaw on a brioche roll


Sides to Share

White Mac & Cheese

$4.99

House Mash

$4.99

Gluten free

Seasonal Veggies

$4.99

Gluten free

Creamy Slaw

$4.99

Gluten free

Fries With Garlic Aioli

$4.99

Seasonal Fruit

$4.99

Gluten free


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading