Tyler's Tender Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 92 votes
Tyler's Tender Logo

Choose My State

IN

Tyler's Tender Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


SaladsDressing choices caesar, ranch, blue cheese, fat-free rasberry vinaigrette, fat free french, thousand island, honey mustard or italian.

Strawberry Spinach Salad

$7.99

Fresh strawberries, toasted pecans, red onions and our signaure dressing top a bed of fresh cut spinach. Everyon has a secret, this dressing is ours.

Mandarin Spinach Salad

$7.99

Mandarin oranges, toasted pecans, craisins, crumbled blue cheese & our signature dressing top a bed of fresh cut spinach. Add grilled or crispy chicken for $2.00

Taco Salad

$7.99

A freshly made taco sheel filled with iceburg and romaine lettuce, shredded cheddar cheese and diced tomatoes topped with our homemade chill. Served with taco sauce and sour cream.

Caesar Salad

$7.99

Choice of grilled or crispy chicken, romaine lettuce, shaved asiago cheese, croutons and caesar dressing.

Conductor's Chicken Salad

$7.99

Choice of grilled or crispy chicken, onions, tomatoes, diced cucumbers and shredded american cheese.


Entrees

Bistro Filet

$11.59

Tender and juicy usda choice, served with mashed potatoes and gravy and vegetable of the day.

Pot Roast Melt

$9.29

Tender slow roasted beef served on golden brown garlic toast with mashed potatoes and gravy, grilled onions and peppers, topped with mozzarella cheese.

Mini Bacon Cheeseburgers

$10.99

3 Mini bacon cheeseeburgers with your choice of toppings. Served with fries or chips and one side car.

Chicken Tender Dinner

$9.99

Crispy chicken tenderloin strips served with your choice of dipping sauce. Sserved with fries or chips and one side car

Fish and Chips Dinner

$10.99

Breaded grouper portions served with tartar sauce. Served with fries or chips and one side car.

Tilapia

$10.99

Tortilla crusted tilapia with a blend of chipotle and lime seasonlng. Served with garlic mashed and vegetable of the day.


First Class Car SandwichesOur specialty sandwiches are served with our homemade potato chips, fries, applesauce, apple slloes, fruit cup or mandarin oranges. Substitute any other side car for $1.00

Porchetta panino

$7.99

Smoked ham, hard salami and crisp bacon, topped with provolone cheese, caramelized red onions,fresh tomato, arugula and creamy caesar dressing, pressed between slices of panini bread.

East Chicago Panino

$7.99

Beef pastrami, hard salami, swiss cheese, creamy pesto, grilled onions and peppers, and sun dried tomato ranch dressing pressed between slices of panini bread.

Hot Honey Panino

$7.49

Oven roasted turkey, crisp bacon, fresh tomato, arugula and honey mustard, pressed between slices of garlic roasted red pepper bread.

Pesto Club Panino

$7.49

Sliced oven roasted turkey breast and corned beef topped with provolone cheese, arugula and sun dried tomato ranch, pressed between slices of panini bread

Ham & Pastrami Cuban

$7.99

Ham, pastrami, cheddar and swiss cheese, dill pickle slices and honey mustard, pressed to a delicate crunch on a submarine bun.

Toasted Pastrami

$7.99

Thinly shaved pastrami smothered in provolone cheese, mustard, onion, lettuce and tomato on a submarine bun.

Chicken Quesadilla

$7.99

Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese and crumbled bacon on a grilled tortilla.

Smothered Strip Steak

$8.49

Our delicious strip steak smothered with roasted green peppers and onions topped with mozzarella cheese served on a submarine bun add $0.50 for mushrooms

Signature Pot Roast Sandwich

$8.49

Seasoned pot roast served on our pretzel bread. Horseadish available on request.


Depot SandwichesOur sandwiches are served with our homemade potato chips, fries, applesauce, apple slices fruit cup or mandarin oranges. Substitute any other side car for $1.00, or add an extra angus patty to any burger for $1.50 our angus burger are fresh, never frozen

Angus Burger

$8.49

Served with your choice of toppings. Add 0.50, for cheese, $0.75 for bacon

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$7.99

Our angus burger topped with swiss cheese and mushrooms grilled right in.

Patty Melt

$6.99

Out angus burger, 2 slices of american cheese and caramelized onions served on grilled marble rye.

Double Bacon Cheddar Burger

$8.99

Two of our angus burgers with cheddar cheese and two strips of bacon served with your choice of toppings.

Veggie Burger

$6.99

Th original garden burger served with your choice of toppings. Add 0.50, for cheese

Crispy Chicken

$7.29

A breaded breast of chicken served with mayo, red onions, lettuce and tomato.

Grilled Chicken

$7.29

A grilled breast of chicken served with honey mustard, red onions, tomato and lettue.

Grilled Cheese On Pretzel Bread

$5.49

American cheese melted on pretzel bread. Make it a grown up and add tomato and bacon for an extra buck.

Grilled Ham & Cheese

$5.99

Served with swiss cheese on white, wheat, or sourdough bread.

Club Car

$8.99

Slow roasted, hand carved turkey breast served cold with bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and red onion on white, wheat or sourdough bread.

Corned Beef Reuben

$7.99

Served with thousand island dressing, swiss cheese and sauerkraut on grilled marble rye.

Chicago Style Hot Dog

$4.99

Mustard, relish, onions, sport peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes and sprinkled with celery salt.


The First Stop

Pretzel Sticks

$4.99

Large baked and salted soft preizels served with cheese.

Chicken Wings

$5.99

Spicy chicken wings tossed in hot buffalo wing sauce, served with ranch dressing.

Bosco Sticks

$4.99

Cheese- filled bosco brand breadsticks topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce.

Cheese Sticks

$5.99

Large deep fried, breaded mozzarella cheese sticks served with marinara sauce.

Fried Mushrooms

$5.99

Breaded, deep fried mushrooms, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

Fried Pickles

$5.99

Breaded, deep fried pickle spears served with your choice of dipping sauce.

Chili Cheese Fries

$5.99

A generous portion of our hot crinkle fries smothered in chili and cheese.

Combo Platter

$9.99

Fried pickles, mushrooms and cheese sticks.


WrapsDelicately wrapped in a large flour or spinach tortilla

Steak & Bleu Wrap

$8.29

Grilled strip steak with bleu cheese, onions, peppers, tomatoes, crisp romaine lettuce. and a-1 sauce.

Zesty Chicken Wrap

$8.29

Seasoned grilled chicken, toasted pecans, craisins, crisp romaine lettuce and zesty mayonnaise

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$8.29

Diced grilled chicken, parmesan cheese, crisp romaine lettuce, tomato and caesar dressing.

Rancher's Wrap

$8.29

Crispy or grilled chicken, crisp romaine lettuce, diced tomato, cheddar cheese with ranch dressing.


Side Cars

Soups or Chili

$2.69 - $3.99

Our hearty chicken noodle soup, or substitute our soup of the day or homemade chili.

Sweet Potato Tater Tots

$2.69

Seasoned with maple sugar and cinnamon.

Onion Rings

$2.49

Served with your choice of dipping sauce.

Side or Caesar Salad

$2.89

Served with your choice of dressing. Add $2.00 for grilled or crispy chicken

Cole Slaw

$2.29

Our crisp cole slaw, made fresh daily.

Mashed Potatoes & Gravy

$2.69

Garlic mashed available

French Fries or Potato Chips

$2.49

A generous portion of our hot crinkle fries or our specially seasoned potato chips cheddar cheese cup available for $0.99

Vegetable of the Day

$2.69


Lil' EnginesOur kids items include our petato chips, fries, fruit cup, fresh veggle of the day, mash and gravy, apple sauce, apple slices or mandarin oranges and any selt drink. Add a scoop of ice cream for dessert for only $0.99

Hot Dog

Price may varies

Served with your choice of toppings.

Popcorn Shrimp

Price may varies

Served with cocktail sauce.

Mini Cheeseburger

Price may varies

A 2 oz. burger served with your choice of toppings. Add $25.00, each for bacon, add a cheeseburger for $1.00

Mini Corn Dogs

Price may varies

Cheese Quesadilla

Price may varies

Grilled Cheese

Price may varies

Served with american cheese on white or wheat bread.

Chicken Nuggets

Price may varies

Served with your choice of dipping sauce.

Zach's Mac & Cheese

Price may varies

A delicious favorite.

Pizza

Price may varies

Our 7 mini cheese plzza with or without pepperoni.


The Final Stop

Box Car Split

$5.29

Ice Cream

$1.29 - $2.19

Chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, peppermint, mint chocolate chip, birthday cake, rainbow sherbet and cookies and cream

The Chocolate Caboose

$3.29

Two scoops of vanilla ice cream served with 3 brownie bites and hot tudge.

The Caramel Apple Caboose

$3.29

Two scoops of vanilla ice cream served with 3 apple crescents and hot caramel

Dirt and Worms

$2.99

Pudding, crushed orec cookies and gummy worms.

The Train Wreck

$6.99

Take 25 minutes, pre orders appreciated. Serves4. Fresh baked chocolate chips cookies smothered in ice cream topped with chocolate, caramel and whipped cream

Fresh Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich

$2.49

Create your own. Two cookies sandwiched with your choice of ice cream


Drinks

Bottled Water

Price may varies

Soft Drinks

Price may varies

Sierra mist, pink lemonade, orange, dr peppere fruit punch, root beer, and iced tea regular or raspberry

Coffee, Hot tea or Hot Chocolate

Price may varies

Root Beer or Orange Float

Price may varies

Milk

Price may varies

White or chocolate

Milk Shakes

Price may varies

Chocolate, caramel, vanilla or strawberry


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading