Menu With Price > Menu > Turtle Island Restaurant & Catering

Turtle Island Restaurant & Catering Menu and Prices

4.8 based on 246 votes

Choose My State

Turtle Island Restaurant & Catering Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Appetizers

Coconut Shrimp

$11.75

Fried & served w/ orange horseradish marmalade sauce

Coral Shrimp

$10.75

Wrapped in cellophane noodles & fried w/ an oriental soy sauce

Buffalo, Jerked or Boom-Boom Shrimp

$10.75

Just like wings with shrimp instead

Shrimp Sampler

$12.50

Combination of coconut, coral & choice of buffalo, boom or jerked shrimp

Thai-Seared Tuna*

$13.50

Over greens & seaweed salad w/ oriental sauce, wasabi & ginger

Bacon-Wrapped Sea Scallops

$12.75

Flash-fried, w/ a orange horseradish marmalade

Jalapeno & Cheese Crab Bites

$10.50

Fried-flash, w/a red pepper remoulade

Turtle Island Hot Crab Dip

$11.75

Served w/ baked sliced garlic bread

Low Country Shrimp & Grits

$10.50

Small version of the entree

"Big Easy" Grouper Fingers

$10.75

Served w/ a mandarin orange sauce

Mussels

$11.50

A full pound, served in garlic butter or marinara & bread

Calamari

$10.75

Lightly fried, served w/ marinara sauce

Calamari

Price may varies

Calamari-'kickin' (w/ fried jalapenos) or caribbean (w/ fried banana peppers) add $0.75

Wings Over Oak Island

$6.00 - $9.75

Boom boom, lemon pepper, caribbean jerk or buffalo

From the SteamerYou peel, pick or shuck 'em! All seafood dusted with old bay seasoning

Dozen Oysters or Clams

$10.75

Snow Crab Cluster

$8.00 - $15.25

Cajun Crawfish

$11.00

Full pound, when available

Baker's Dozen Oysters or Clams*

$12.50

On the half-shell

Soups

Caribbean Black Bean Soup

$4.50 - $5.75

Topped w/ scallions and a dollop of sour cream

Annie's Clam Soup

$4.75 - $5.75

SaladsDressings: blue cheese, cusabi (cucumber wasabi), ranch, thousand island, balsamic vinaigrette, honey mustard, creamy italian, french or mango vinaigrette

Classic Caesar Salad

$8.25

W/ a homemade anchovy caesar dressing, topped w/ parmesan & croutons

Iceberg Wedge Salad

$8.75

W/ crumbled blue cheese, onion & bacon

Large Garden Salad

$8.25

Small Garden or Caesar Side Salad

$4.75

Choice of SaladAll items seasoned unless otherwise requested

Grilled Blackened or Cold Boiled Shrimp

$7.25

Grilled or Blackened Tuna*

$9.25

Grilled or Blackened Scallops

$12.25

Grilled or Blackened Chicken

$6.25

Entree SpecialtiesAll dinner served w/ choice of two: chef's potato, fries, grits, black beans & rice, fresh veggies, cole slaw, sweet potato chips or garden salad. Substitute a side caesar salad for $2 extra

Low Country Shrimp & Grits

$19.50

Fresh shrimp in low country shrimp gravy over creamy stone ground grits, topped w/ scallions, bacon & parmesan cheese w/ 1 side

Ocracoke Crab Cakes

$21.50

Served w/ red pepper remoulade

Grilled Shrimp Skewers

$21.50

W/ a key lime, coconut soy sauce

Herb-Crusted Stuffed Flounder

$21.75

W/ crab stuffing, baked & topped w/ hollandaise

Fresh Tuna*

$22.25

Grilled, jerked or blackened, cooked to your liking

1/2# Blue Crab Meat

$22.50

Sauteed in butter, herbs & scallions

Scallops

$22.75

Grilled or blackened

Grouper

Blackened, Grilled or Fried

$21.75

Grouper Oscar

$26.50

Topped w/ crab meat, asparagus & hollandaise

Caribbean Grilled Grouper

$22.75

W/ caribbean spices, over greens topped w/ pineapple mango mint salsa

Rib Eye Steak*

$23.75

12 oz. Angus beef, grilled, blackened or jerked, topped w/ flash fried onion tanglers

Filet Mignon w/ Bearnaise*

$26.75

7 oz. Angus beef, bacon - wrapped & grilled

Filet Mignon Oscar-Style*

$29.00

Bacon wrapped & topped w/ crabmeat, asparagus & hollandaise

2-6 Oz. Jamaican Jerked Pork Rib Eyes

$19.75

Served w/ black beans & rice and 1 side

Chicken

$18.75

Grilled, blackened or caribbean grilled & topped w/ a pineapple mango mint salsa

Broiled Cold Water Lobster Tails

Two 7 oz. Tails, split & baked, w/ drawn butter

Filet & Lobster Tail*

7 oz. Filet & one lobster tail, prepared as above

PastaAll served over chef's choice of pasta & garlic bread and 1 side. Chef's potato, fries, grits, black beans & rice, fresh veggies, cole slaw, sweet potato chips or garden salad. Substitute a side caesar salad for $2 extra

Marinara

$15.50

Traditional, chunky tomato sauce with fresh herbs and seasoning

Primavera

$16.25

Fresh veggies & garlic, sauteed in olive oil, tossed in an alfredo sauce

Scampi

$23.50

Shrimp sauteed in olive oil, butter, scallions, white wine and garlic

Pasta Add-OnsAll items seasoned unless otherwise requested. Add to your pasta any one item:

Grilled or Blackened Scallops

$12.25

Grilled or Blackened Tuna*

$9.25

Grilled or Blackened Shrimp

$7.25

Grilled or Blackened Chicken

$6.25

Calabash-Style Fried SeafoodServed w/ chef's potato, fries, grits, sweet potato chips or black bean & rice, w/ slaw & hushpuppies. Substitute a side garden or caesar salad instead of slaw - $2.50 Extra. Make scallops a choice for $6 extra, $2.50 Extra for broiled. Choice of: one - $16.5; Two - $17.5; Three - $18.25; Four - $19.50; Deluxe (all the above) - $23; deluxe (including scallops) - $29

Shrimp

Price may varies

Oysters

Price may varies

Clam Strips

Price may varies

Deviled Crab & Flounder

Price may varies

SandwichesServed with fries or sweet potato chips and pickle. Please let your server know what you would like on your sandwich, otherwise, it will be served plain. Available topping: lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion, mayo or mustard. Customize it for $0.75 Extra for each, your choice: bacon, provolone or american, grilled mushrooms (when available), onions or peppers plain or fried banana or jalapeno peppers

Prime-Rib

$12.75

Blackened, grilled or jerked

Caribbean Jerk Pork Loin

$10.75

Thin slices of jerked pork on fresh bread

Chicken

$10.50

Fried, blackened, grilled or jerked

Filet of Fish

$11.50

Fried, blackened, grilled or jerked

Hamburger*

$10.50

8 oz. Angus beef, grilled to your taste

Shrimp or Oyster Burger

$10.75

Fried, on a toasted bun

Crab Cake Sandwich

$11.50

On a toasted bun

Children's Menu12 and under only please

Fried Seafood

$9.25

Shrimp, clam strips or fish w/ fries & hushpuppies

Pasta

$7.25

Chef's pasta w/ marinara, butter or alfredo sauce

Fresh Chicken Tenders

$8.25

Served w/ honey mustard or ranch & fries

Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$7.00

Served w/ fries

Mini Corn Dogs

$7.25

Served w/ honey mustard dipping sauce & fries

Sides

Basket of Fries, Onion Rings or Sweet Potato Chips

$4.75

Hushpuppies, Fried Banana Peppers or Jalapenos Peppers

$4.75

Cole Slaw, Chef's Potato, Grits, Vegetables or Black Beans & Rice

$2.75

Extra Bread

$1.75

Beverages

Iced Tea, Hot Tea, Coffee

$2.00

Unlimited refills

Soft Drinks

$2.25

Coke, diet coke, sundrop, sprite, ginger ale - one refill

San Pellegrino Sparkling Water

$4.00

Bottled Water

$2.50

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.