Tomato Pie Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 96 votes
Tomato Pie Logo

Choose My State

CA NC TX

Tomato Pie Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Garlic Knots

$5.00 - $2.00

tossed in our special olives oil / romano blend

Hot Wings

$6.75 - $12.00

baked and hot too spicy

Homemade Meatballs

$5.75

covered in marlene's meat sauce

Sausage Peppers & Onions

$6.00

state fair-style with seasoned potatoes, garlic & olive oil

Sauteed Vegetables

$5.25

mushroom, carrot, zucchini, olive oil & garlic

Eggplant Parmigiana

$5.00

breaded eggplant baked with mozzarella & marinara

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$5.50

homemade with tortilla chips

Polcasserole

$5.00

our version of macaroni cheese


SaladsRanch, Balsamic Vinaigrette, Blue Cheese, Caesar, Sesame, BBQ Ranch

Pasta Salads

$5.00 - $3.00

greek, italian pesto

Vegetable Salads

$3.00 - $5.00

cucumber, sicilian, potato, caprese

Mixed Green

$3.00 - $5.00

spring mix, roma tomato, black olive & garbanzo beans

Caesar Salad

$5.00 - $3.00

romaine, croutons, shaved parmesan & roma tomato

Chicken Apple

$8.50

spring mix, grilled chicken, granny smith apples, roma tomato, gorgonzola & garbanzo beans

BBQ Ranch & Bacon

$8.50

spring mix, grilled chicken, bacon, roma tomato, corn, cucumber, tortilla strips & garbanzo beans

Mediterranean

$7.75

spring, mix, kalamata olive, roma tomato, cucumber, feta, corn & pepperoncini

Antipasto

$8.50

spring mix, pepperoni, ham, salami, black olive, roma tomato, mozzarella, pepperoncini & garbanzo beans

Orange 44

$8.00

spinach, arugula, red onion, shaved parmesan, mandarin orange & pine nuts

Miss Ava

$7.75

spring mix, roasted red pepper, grilled asparagus & feta

The Bella

$8.50

spring mix, roasted butternut squash, walnuts, yellow raisin & gorgonzola


Subs $5

Italian

Price may varies

salami, pepperoni, capicolla, pepperoncini, provolone, lettuce, tomato, balsamic vinaigrette & mayo

Smoked Turkey Pesto

Price may varies

spring greens, tomato, avocado, shaved parmesan & mayo

Tuna Avocado

Price may varies

tomato, red onion, avocado, cucumber & spicy mayo spread

Meatball

Price may varies

* meatballs covered in marinara sauce & provolone

Grilled Chicken

Price may varies

* chicken on a toasted bun with provolone, lettuce, tomato, balsamic vinaigrette & mayo

Chicken Bake

Price may varies

* marinara, sauteed mushrooms, parmesan & melted mozzarella

Eggplant Parmigiana

Price may varies

* breaded eggplant cutlets, sauteed mushrooms, melted mozzarella & parmesan

Vegetable

Price may varies

grilled peppers, zucchini, mushroom, eggplant & red onion

Spicy Sausage

Price may varies

* hot italian peppers, red onion, bell pepper, sauteed with garlic & olive oil


Pastabilities $6

Spaghetti

Price may varies

Linguini

Price may varies

Rigatoni

Price may varies

Penne

Price may varies

Macaroni

Price may varies


ToppingsEach.

Chicken

$2.25

Sausage

$1.25

Meatball

$2.25

Mozzarella

$1.00

Vegetables

$2.25

Traditional

$1.50 - $2.00

american bacon, anchovy, artichoke, arugula, basil, black olive, broccoli, cilantro, corn, garlic, bell pepper, ham, jalapeno, hot italian peppers, kalamata olives, mushroom, pepperoni, pepperoncini,

Gourmet

$1.75 - $2.75

carnitas, chicken, eggplant, feta, goat cheese, gorgonzola, meatball, prosciutto, provolone, ricotta, roasted red pepper, shaved parmesan, spicy sausage, sausage link, tuna, caramelized onion, ground


Ravioli

Cheese

$7.00

Butternut Sq.

$8.00

Vegetable

$8.00

Bolognese

$8.00

Wild Mushroom

$8.00


Baked

Ziti

$7.50

Chicken

$8.75

Eggplant Parm

$8.75

Meat Lasagna

$9.25

Veggie Lasagna

$9.25

Marlene's Meat Sauce

Price may varies

slow-cooked marinara with crumbled pork and beef

Pesto

Price may varies

basil, garlic, olive oil and sun-dried tomato with parmesan and pine nuts

Alfredo

Price may varies

traditional garlic cream with white wine and romano

Riggies

Price may varies

spicy tomato cream with sauteed peppers and onions

Spicy Mamma

Price may varies

our famous grandma tomato sauce made spicy (non-spicy available)

Chinois

Price may varies

garlic cream with white wine soy sauce


East Coast FavoritesMed (14" 6 Slices) / Lg (18" 8 Slices) / Xlg (21" 10 Slices)

Traditional N.Y Style

$13.75 - $15.75

Sicilian

$16.50

square, thick crust

Tomato Pie

$12.75 - $10.00

square, no mozzarella

Grandma

$17.50 - $20.50

margherita

Mr. White

$12.75 - $15.75

garlic, olive oil, 3 cheese


Gourmet Pizzas $22Lg Only.

Tissy

Price may varies

roasted vegetables, goat cheese and mozzarella with a garlic soy-balsamic base

Prosciutto Happiness

Price may varies

thin-sliced prosciutto, caramelized onion, fresh fig, arugula, topped with a balsamic reduction

Ruthie Swan

Price may varies

salami, granny smith apples, gorgonzola & caramelized onion on a white base

Carnitas Way

Price may varies

slow-braised pork with grilled red pepper & onion on a chipotle gravy base, topped with scallions


House PiesMed (14" 6 Slices) $14.50 / Lg (18" 8 Slices) $18.50 / Xlg (21" 10 Slices) $22. Pizza Split Charge $0.75.

The Blanco

Price may varies

a mr. white base with two options: chicken, spinach, tomato & grilled chicken. veggie: spinach, tomato, white onion & broccoli

Hot Wing

Price may varies

syracuse-style: hot sauce ranch mix & chicken. buffalo-style: hot sauce blue cheese mix & chicken

Pesto Pie

Price may varies

sausage: red bell pepper, white onion & basil. chicken: artichoke, sun dried tomato & basil

Joe P.

Price may varies

grandma sauce with sausage, white onion & red bell pepper

BBQ

Price may varies

marinated chicken, caramelized white onion & bbq sauce

Meat Lovers

Price may varies

pepperoni, sausage, bacon & ham

Deluxe

Price may varies

sausage, ham, pepperoni, bell pepper, mushroom, red onion & black olive

Mediterranean

Price may varies

spinach, tomato, kalamata olive, artichoke, corn & feta

Florentine

Price may varies

spinach, broccoli, tomato, bell pepper, red onion & mushroom

Eggplant Parmigiana

Price may varies

breaded eggplant, spinach, mushroom & ricotta

Specialty Items

$9.75

calzone (crescent shaped) or stromboli (9" linear) golden brown turnover with mozzarella, ricotta and any 4 toppings. served with a side of marinara.


Desserts

Red Velvet

$3.50

red cocoa cake with honey cream cheese frosting

Cannoli

$3.00

vanilla cream chocolate chip

Tiramisu

$3.25

coffee & zablone cream on a layered cake, dipped in espresso

Chocolate Cake

$3.00

layers of dark sweet chocolate

Cheese Cakes

$3.00

ny style, ganache, seasonal

Cookies

$2.25

Brownies

$2.25


Drinks* Toasted

Fountain & Can Soda

$1.50

Specialty Drinks

Price may varies

($2-$4).


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading