Theo's Restaurant and Oyster Bar Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 92 votes
Theo's Restaurant and Oyster Bar Logo

Choose My State

NY

Theo's Restaurant and Oyster Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


AppetizersAppetizers Dinner

Tuna Tartare

$22.00

With sesame, avocado and finger lime.

Calamari

$18.00

Lightly fried with tartare sauce or charcoal grilled with oil lemon sauce.

Grilled Octopus

$21.00

Charcoaled grilled with gulten free yellow split pea puree.

Scallops with Black Ink Truffled Risotto

$22.00

Crab and Ricotta Gnocchi

$24.00

With ahi Amarillo, basil and paprika.

Salmon Tartare

$22.00

With fresh vanilla bean and chives.

Grilled Shrimp

$18.00

48 hour marinated tiger shrimp, charcoal grilled with oil lemon sauce.

Mediterranean Spreads

$12.00

Chef's selection of egg caviar mousse tarama and smoked eggplant caviar with grilled pita bread.

Lobster Mac Cheese

$19.00

Square pasta, lobster tail and assortment of cheese.

Wild Mushroom Spaetzle

$17.00

With pea shoots, fines herbs and Parmesan brodo.

Lobster Bisque Soup

$14.00

Tuna Tartare

$18.00

With sesame, avocado and finger lime.

Crab Cake

$19.00

With yogurt horseradish.

Grilled Octopus

$18.00

Charcoaled grilled with gluten free yellow split pea puree.

Calamari

$18.00

Lightly fried with tartare sauce or charcoal grilled with oil lemon sauce.

Salmon Tartare

$18.00

With fresh vanilla bean and chives.

Grilled Shrimp

$17.00

48 hour marinated tiger shrimp, charcoal grilled with oil lemon sauce.

Mediterranean Spreads

$12.00

Chef's selection of egg caviar mousse tarama and smoked eggplant caviar with grilled pita bread.


SaladSalad Dinner

Lobster and Citrus Salad

$22.00

With avocado, frisee, fines herbs and red leaf sorrel.

Theos Baby Gem Lettuces

$14.00

With sherry vinaigrette, garden vegetables and smoked almonds.

Beet and Smoked Goat Cheese Salad

$14.00

With wild arugula.

Greek Salad

$16.00

With beefsteak tomato, green pepper, shaved red onion, Kalamata olives, aged barrel feta and extra virgin olive oil.


Main CourseMain Course Dinner

1 lb. Steamed Maine Lobster

$28.00

With butter lemon sauce.

1 lb. Grilled Maine Lobster

$28.00

With butter lemon sauce.

Seared Yellowfin Tuna Steak Cut

$28.00

On a bed of haricot vert.

Grilled Organic Salmon

$24.00

With truffled cauliflower puree and sauteed baby spinach.

Grilled Australian Lamb Chops

$32.00

Australian lamb chops served with french fries.

2 lb. Stuffed Lobster with 90% Blue Crab

$98.00

Blue Crab Homemade Linguini

$26.00

Homemade linguini with flambe blue crab meat in a light white wine sauce.

Homemade Linguini Fruit de Mar

$38.00

With scallops, clams, shrimp and lobster flambe ouzo reduction in red sauce.

Brick Chicken

$24.00

With fingerling potatoes and side of demi-glace.

16 oz. Prime Ribeye

$45.00

Chargrilled with choice of 1 side.

1 lb. Steamed Maine Lobster

$28.00

With butter lemon sauce.

Grilled Lamb Chops

$18.00

Austrian lamb chops served with french fries.

Pan Seared Salmon

$24.00

With yogurt beet sauce.

Vegetable Risotto

$18.00

Seasonal vegetables in light white truffled cream.

Blue Crab Linguini

$21.00

Homemade linguini with flambe blue crab meat in a light white wine sauce.

16 oz. Prime Ribeye

$42.00

With grilled seasonal vegetables.


Whole Fish SelectionWhole Fish Selection Dinner

1 lb. Branzino

$23.00

Charcoal grilled.

1 lb. Royale Dorade

$25.00

Charcoal grilled.

1 lb. Branzino

$23.00

Charcoal grilled.

1 lb. Royale Dorade

$25.00

Charcoal grilled.


SaladsSalads Lunch

Lobster and Citrus Salad

$19.00

With avocado, frisee, fines herbs and red leaf sorrel.

Theos Baby Gem Lettuces

$14.00

With sherry vinaigrette, garden vegetables and smoked almonds.

Theos Cobb Salad

$16.00

With Vermont bacon, farm fresh egg, jasper hill blue cheese, avocado and tomato.

Beet and Smoked Goat Cheese Salad

$14.00

With wild arugula.

Greek Salad

$16.00

With beefsteak tomato, green pepper, shaved red onion, Kalamata olives, aged barrel feta and extra virgin olive oil.


Soups and SandwichesSoups and Sandwiches Lunch

Lobster Bisque

$12.00

Avocado Toast

$12.00

With grapefruit, smoked sea salt and cilantro.

Maine Lobster Roll

$19.00

Hot with butter lemon on a toasted roll or cold with mayo and chive on a toasted roll.

Theos Sirloin Burger

$16.00

With tomato, baby arugula and white cheddar on a brioche bun and served with french fries.

Blue Crab Burger

$16.00

With tomato, lettuce and tartare sauce on a brioche bun and served with french fries.

Lobster Mac and Cheese

$17.00

Square pasta, lobster tail and assortment of cheese.


SidesSides Dinner

Sauteed Assorted Wild Mushrooms

$9.00

Grilled Asparagus

$9.00

French Fries

$9.00

Seared Brussel Sprouts

$9.00

Fingerling Potatoes

$9.00

Sauteed Kale

$9.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading