Thelma Fay's Cafe Menu and Prices
Coffee
Choose My State
Thelma Fay's Cafe Menu
Last Update: 2025-03-14
Appetizers and Sides
Onion Rings
$2.99
0
French Fries
$1.99
0
Chili Cheese Fries
$5.99
0
Fried Pickle Chips
$4.99
0
Macaroni Salad or Slaw
$1.00
0
Fried Mushrooms
$4.99
0
Potato Knish
$2.89
0
Frito Chili Pie
$4.75
0
Homemade Potato Chips
$4.00
0
Loaded Chips (Bacon & Cheese)
$5.50
0
Soups and Salads
Bowl of Soup
$3.99
0
Soup or Salad & Grilled Cheese
$5.00
0
Chef Salad
$4.50 - $8.00
0
Soup and Greek Salad
$6.00
0
Greek Salad
$3.99 - $6.99
0
Chicken Fajita Salad
$6.99
0
Philly Steak Salad
$7.99
0
Hot Wings
10 Piece Wings
$5.99
0
20 Piece Wings
$10.00
0
Hoagies
Philly Steak Hoagie
$7.99
0
Grilled Veggie Hoagie
$5.99
0
Chicken Fajita Hoagie
$7.99
0
Steak Fajita Hoagie
$7.99
0
BBQ Chicken Hoagie
$7.99
0
The Jerrie
$5.99
Beef patty with lto cheese
0
Buffalo Chicken Hoagie
$7.99
0
Ny Style Deli SandwichesAll of our sandwiches come with a slice of pickle and your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, rye, wheat, hoagie roll or soft pretzel roll ($0.50) all bread is grilled unless otherwise requested.
Beef Salami
$6.99
0
Pastrami
$6.99
0
Smoked Ham
$5.50
0
Turkey Breast
$5.50
0
Fried Bologna BBQ or Reg
$4.50
0
Roast Beef
$6.50
0
Corned Beef
$6.50
0
Chicken Salad
$5.99
0
Classic BLT
$4.50
0
The Monster
$15.99
Over one pound of corned beef, pastrami, saurkraut &swiss stack high on righ with 1000 island
0
The Monte Cristo
$8.99
Turkey, ham american & swiss on capÂ’n crunch french toast with syrup and preserves
0
The Big Tex
$6.99
Roast beef frilledonions, bbq sauce and cheddar on texas toast
0
Thelma Fays Favorite
$6.99
Turky bacon smoked gouda 1000 island on wheat
0
Classic Reuben
$6.99
0
Pastrami Reuben
$7.99
0
The Rachel
$6.99
Turkey swiss slaw on rye with 1000 island
0
Triple Decker Club
$5.99
0
Sammy
$7.99
Salami ham american lettuce tomato onion with 1000 island
0
Chicken Sandwiches
Breaded Chicken
$5.50
0
Grilled Chicken
$5.50
Both served with lettuce and tomato
0
BurgersServed on our soft pretzel roll with your choice of lettuce tomato and onion with a pickle spear. Add cheese $0.25
1/3 Pound Deluxe Burger
$4.99
0
Double Deluxe
$6.99
0
Chili Cheeseburger
$5.99
0
Black & Blue
$5.99
0
Mushroom Swiss
$5.99
0
BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger
$5.99
0
Jalapeno Cheddar Burger
$5.99
0
Veggie Burger
$4.99
0
Hot Dogs
1/4 Lb Hot Dog
$2.99
0
1/4 Lb Hot Dog Platter
$5.99
0
Double Dog Platter
$7.99
0
Wv Dog
$1.50
(Reg size dog with chili slaw and onion)
0
Kids MenuServed with chips or fries & drink
5pc Chicken Nuggets
$5.00
0
Hot Dog
$4.00
0
Cheeseburger
$4.50
0
Grilled Cheese
$4.00
0
Desserts
Fried Cheesecake
$4.99
0
Ny Style Cheesecake
$3.99
0
Assorted Cakes and Pies
$2.50
0
All Drinks
$1.99
0
DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
Popular Brands
-
Applebee's Menu2.7 -
Arby's Menu3.7 -
Burger King Menu3.4 -
Chick-fil-A Menu3.8 -
-
Cook Out Menu1.5 -
-
-
KFC Menu3.2 -
McDonald's Menu2.9 -
-
-
Pizza Hut Menu3.3 -
-
Wendy's Menu2.9 -
-
Red Lobster Menu1.4 -
-
-
