The Sugar Shack Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 128 votes
The Sugar Shack Logo

Choose My State

NY

The Sugar Shack Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


CupcakesCupcake

Vanilla Mega Cupcake

$4.25

Chocolate Mega Cupcake

$4.25


Pudding CupsPudding Cup

Cup of Vanilla Pudding

$3.25

Cup of Chocolate Pudding

$3.25

Cup of Chocolate Mousse Pudding

$3.75

Cup of Apple Crisp Pudding

$4.00

Cup of Bread Pudding

$4.50


ParfaitParfait

Banana Pudding Parfait

$4.50

Pina Colada Parfait

$4.50

Cookies and Cream

$4.50


MuffinsMuffin

Banana Mega Muffin

$4.00

Blueberry Mega Muffin

$4.00

Pumpkin Mega Muffin

$4.50

Zucchini Bread Mega Muffin

$4.50


Mini CakesMini Cake

Vanilla Mini Cake

$5.50

Chocolate Mini Cake

$5.50

Carrot Mini Cake

$6.50

Pineapple Upside Down Mini Cake

$6.50


Mini PiesMini Pie

Apple Mini Pie

$6.00

Peach Mini Pie

$6.00

Lemon Meringue Mini Pie

$7.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading