The Pickle Guys Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 176 votes
The Pickle Guys Logo
Other

Choose My State

NY

The Pickle Guys Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Pickles

New Pickles

$23.00

1/2 Sour Pickles

$23.00

3/4 Sour Pickles

$23.00

Sour Pickles

$23.00

Hot New Pickles

$23.00

Hot Sour Pickles

$23.00

Horseradish Pickles

$23.00

Sweet Gherkins

$30.00

Bread & Butter Pickles

$57.00


Tomatoes

Pickled Tomatoes

$24.00

Red Plum Tomatoes

$24.00

Tomatilloes

$38.00

Grape Tomatoes

$38.00

Sun-Dried Tomatoes

$57.00

Marinated Sliced Green Tomatoes

$57.00


Olives

Whole Green Olives

$40.00

Pimento Olives

$48.00

Garlic Stuffed Olives

$57.00

Jalapeno Stuffed Olives

$57.00

Cerignola Olives

$57.00

Greek Olives

$40.00

Kalamata Olives

$54.00

Sun-Dried Tomato Olives

$57.00

Almond Stuffed Olives

$57.00


Peppers

Sweet Peppers

$38.00

Sliced Hot Peppers

$38.00

Cherry Peppers

$38.00

Jalapeno Peppers

$38.00

Jamaican Bonnets

$38.00

Pepperoncini

$38.00


Other Pickled Goodies

Pineapples

$48.00

Pickled Mangoes

$57.00

Pickled Watermelon

$24.00

Giardinera

$38.00

Pickled Celery

$38.00

Pickled Baby Carrots

$38.00

Baby Corns

$48.00

Turnips

$48.00

Pickled Beets

$48.00

Cocktail Onions

$48.00

Pickled Okra

$54.00

Pickled String Beans

$54.00

Pickled Garlic

$57.00

Marinated Mushrooms

$57.00

Sweet Kraut

$22.00

Sour Kraut

$22.00

Mustard

$22.00

Sweet Relish

$24.00

Horseradish

$3.50

Pickled Capers

$4.50

Small Pickle Platter

$26.00

Large Pickle Platter

$45.00


Souvenirs

Pickle Guy's Mousepad

$5.00

Original Pickle Guys White T-Shirt

$15.00

New Pickle Guys Color T-Shirt

$18.00


Fish

Pickled Herring

$5.50

Creamed Pickled Herring

$5.50

Matjash In Oil

$5.50

Matjash In Wine

$5.50

Schmaltz Herring

$5.50

Spicy Schmalt Herring

$5.50

Pickled Lox

$8.00

Creamed Pickled Lox

$8.00

Roll Mops

$6.00

White Fish Salad

$6.50


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading