The Fat Man Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 57 votes
The Fat Man Logo
Pizza

Choose My State

NY

The Fat Man Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Garlic Bread

$2.79

W/ melted mozzarella cheese. Spinach and tomato for garlic bread add $1.00.

Steak Fries

$2.99

W/ gravy add $0.50.

Onion Rings

$3.99

Curly Q-Fries

$3.29

Mozzarella Sticks (6)

$5.59

Potato Skins (6)

$7.59

W/ bacon cheddar.

Jalapeno Poppers (6)

$5.99

Small Garlic Bread W/ Cheese

$1.79

Deep Fried Veggies

$6.29

Sweet Potato Fries With Butter

$3.25

Bread Stixs

$7.99

Nacho Cheese Dip

$0.75

Nacho Cheese Dip With Chips

$2.50

Nacho Supreme

$12.99


SaladsSalad dressings bleu cheese, italian, low-cal italian, french, ranch, caesar, 1000 island, creamy parmesan & honey mustard. Extra dressings an additional $0.69. (add chicken, steak or chicken fingers for $1.50).

Antipasto

$7.29 - $9.99

Made with fresh, crisp lettuce, topped with tomato, onion, green olives, pepperoncini, sweet peppers, black olives, ham & cappicola, salami, pepperoni, cucumber, croutons & cheese, with your choice o

Julienne Salad

$6.29 - $7.99

Made with ham, turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, black olives, cucumbers, croutons & cheese, with your choice of dressings.

Garden Salad

$4.79 - $5.99

Made with lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, black olives, cucumbers, croutons & cheese, with your choice of dressings.

Greek Salad

$6.29 - $7.99

Tomato, black olive, feta cheese, cucumber, croutons, with your choice of dressing.

Garden Salad

$4.25 - $5.99

Made with lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, black olives, cucumbers, croutons & cheese, with your choice of dressings.

Taco Salad Chicken

$6.29 - $7.99

Beef

$6.29 - $7.29

Made with lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, taco meat, black olives, jalpenos, cheese, and chips, served with slasa and sour cream on the side.

Tuna

$5.99 - $6.99

A garden salad with a mound of tuna and crackers.

Caesar Salad

$7.29

Crouton s, romaine, parmesan cheese. Add additional veggies at no charge.

Cobb Salad

$7.29 - $9.99

Made with ham, turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, black olives, egg, bacon, cucumbers, croutons & cheese, with your choice of dressings. Add chicken or steak $1.00.

Chop House Salad

$7.29 - $9.99

Chicken or steak made with lettuce, tomato, onion, sweet peppers, black olives, cucumbers, croutons & cheese, with your choice of dressings.


Deli SandwichesOn white bread or rye bread served with fries or rings.

Corn Beef

$7.99

Pastrami

$7.99

Roast Beef

$7.99

Turkey

$7.99

Ham

$7.99

The Willy

$9.99

(All 5).


Sandwiches, Wraps, BurgersAdd feta or spinach for $1.00.

1/2 Pound Angus Burger

$7.99

Add bacon $0.60.

Grilled Chicken

$6.99

Chicken Finger Melt Or Wrap

$6.99

Reuben

$7.29

Beef On Weck Or Kaiser

$6.79


Submarines - Cold SubsAll rolls are oven toasted. All subs include lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese (swiss & provolone available upon request). Your choice of oil, mayo or mustard. Extra meat $1.50, hot peppers, sweet peppers & olives $0.30.

Cappicola

$6.79 - $4.99

Assorted - Ham, Cappicola, Salami

$6.79 - $4.99

Ham

$6.79 - $4.99

Ham & Turkey

$6.79 - $4.99

Salami

$6.79 - $4.99

Tuna

$6.79 - $4.99

Turkey

$6.79 - $4.99


Submarines - Hot SubsAll rolls are oven toasted. All subs include lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese (swiss & provolone available upon request). Your choice of oil, mayo or mustard. Extra meat $1.50, hot peppers, sweet peppers & olives $0.30.

BLT

$6.99 - $5.99

Cheese - Provolone, Mozzarella, American, Swiss

$6.99 - $5.99

Chicken Parmesan

$7.59 - $5.99

Spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese.

Eggplant

$6.99 - $5.99

Spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese.

Fish - Haddock Filet

$8.99 - $5.99

Balogna & Onions

$6.29 - $5.99

Fried with grilled onions.

Sausage

$7.29 - $5.99

Sausage Parmesan

$7.29 - $5.99

Spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese.

Sausage Hoagie

$7.59 - $5.99

Sweet pepper & onion.

Meatball

$7.29 - $5.99

Oven Baked Roast Beef

$7.89 - $5.99

Hot or cold.

Pizza Sub

$6.29 - $5.99

Royal - Sausage & Cappicola

$7.89 - $5.99

Steak

$7.89 - $5.99

Cheeseburger

$7.99 - $5.99


Specialty Subs

White Pizza

$5.99 - $3.99

White or red sauce, mozzarella cheese & (3) veggie toppings.

Fatman Meatball

$7.59 - $5.29

Spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese, with choice of hot peppers, sweet peppers, onions or loaded.

Bacon Cheeseburger

$8.59 - $5.59

Chicken Breast

$7.99 - $5.59

ChiavettaÂ’s.

Chicken Club

$8.29 - $5.59

Chicken & bacon.

Chicken Hoagie

$8.29 - $6.29

Fried onions, sweet peppers & mushrooms.

Chicken Finger

$7.89 - $5.59

Sausage & Steak

$9.29 - $5.59

Sausage & Steak Hoagie

$9.59 - $6.29

Sweet pepper, mushroom & onion.

Steak Hoagie

$8.99 - $6.29

Fried sweet pepper, mushroom & onion.

Deluxe Assorted

$7.59 - $5.59

Ham, turkey, roast beef & salami.

Veal Parmigiano

$6.99 - $5.59

Spaghetti sauce & mozzarella cheese.

Ham Club

$6.99 - $5.29

Ham & bacon.

Turkey Club

$7.89 - $5.59

Turkey & bacon.


The Marcanelli Delight

The Marcanelli Delight

$7.29 - $32.95

We start with white sauce and seasoning. Top it with chicken, steak, & mozzarella cheese. Add $2.00 extra toppings of your choice - on the house.

Chicken Finger

$7.29 - $31.95

Bleu cheese, wing sauce, chicken fingers (hot, medium, mild, or bbq) and mozzarella cheese.

The New Yorker

$7.29 - $26.99

Extra thin dough, extra large pepperoni, and a spicy red sauce. With one topping.

Hawaiian Pizza

$6.99 - $24.95

Topped with ham, green peppers, & pineapple.

The Works

$7.29 - $31.95

Pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, onion, sweet/hot peppers, black and green olive. No substitute.

Meat Lovers

$7.29 - $29.95

Pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, beef, & cappicola.


PizzaCreated with freshly made dough, tasty pizza sauce & ooodles of mozzarella cheese.

Slice

$1.79 - $0.69

Personal 8” Cut In 4

$5.99 - $1.59

Small 12” - Cut In 6

$8.99 - $1.99

Large 17” - Cut In 10

$12.99 - $2.29

Party Tray 18” x 26” - Cut In 30

$19.99 - $3.99

1/2 Party Tray 12” x 18” - Cut In 16

$13.99 - $2.99

Create Your Own Combo

Price may varies

Thick or thin crust - add $1.00 toppings - pepperoni, anchovies, extra cheese, ham, bacon, mushrooms, black olives, green olives, hot peppers, sweet peppers, onions, meatballs, cappicola, tomatoes, j


Pizza Flip

Pizza Dough

$7.29

(turn-over) filled with pepperoni, sauce extra items or sauce on the side ricotta cheese.


Gourmet Pizzas

Traditional White

$6.99 - $27.95

An italian gourmet delight! No red sauce, with grated parmesan cheese, mozzarella cheese, fresh cut tomatoes, onions, 100% olive oil, black olives, & spices.

Mexican Pizza

$6.99 - $27.95

Features seasoned salsa covered with cheddar & monterey jack cheeses, tomatoes, ground beef, green peppers, black olives. Try chicken for $1.75 more.

Veggie Pizza

$6.99 - $28.95

White or red sauce, 4 different cheeses & 5 veggie toppings of your choice.

Steak Or Chicken

$6.99 - $31.95

Our special seasonings, onions, sweet peppers and mushrooms. Topped with with mozzarella cheese. Try hot Peppers.


Calzones

Ricotta, Mozzarella & Our Pizza Dough

$9.29

(2) Toppings served with a side sauce. Add $0.50, add $1.50.


Dinners

Baked Penne

$7.99

Spaghetti And Meatballs

$7.99

Veal Parmesan

$10.99

Chicken Parmesan

$10.99

Eggplant Parmesan

$10.99

Meat Lasagna

$9.99

Fried Chicken

$7.99

Comes with fries, rings or salad.

Strip Steak Melt

$9.99

W/ mushroom, onion & cheese on garlic toast; comes with fries, rings or salad.


Chicken FingersAll fingers served with fries, celery & blue cheese. With hot, medium, extra hot, or bbq sauce. Try our fingers with bbq sauce or cajun on the grill.

Chicken Fingers

$8.29 - $18.99

(Single 5, double 7, triple 12).


Value Packs - Daily Specials

1 Item Pizza

$15.29 - $24.99

Small cheese & 1 item pizza & single wings (10), large cheese & 1 item pizza & double wings (20).

1 Item Pizza Plus

$29.99 - $42.99

1/2 Tray cheese & 1 item pizza plus 30 wings, party tray cheese & 1 item pizza plus bucket of wings (50).


Value Packs - Daily Seafood SpecialsAvailable fried, cajun or broiled. Salmon and tilapia available during lent.

Fish Fry

$9.29

(Haddock, fries, lemon, roll and tartar).

Shrimp Dinner

$8.99

(7 Butterfly shrimp, fries, roll, lemon).

Seafood Platter

$13.99

(Fish fry, shrimp, scallops, fries).


Combo Lunch SpecialsLunch specials 11 am - 4 pm.

Any Mini Sub With Fries Or Onion Rings

$7.29

Personal Pizza & (5) Wings

$7.99

(Cheese & 1 item).

2 Slices And A Drink

$4.99

Small Garden Salad, Soup

$5.99

Family Special

$23.99

(Every day). Large 1 item, bread sticks, 4 regular drinks 10 wings or 5 fingers.


Jumbo TacosServed with a soft shell choice of nacho chips or fries.

Bean & Cheese

$5.59

Bean, Cheese, Lettuce, Tomat

$5.59

Beef, Bean & Cheese

$5.59

Beef, Bean, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$5.59

Beef & Cheese

$5.59

Beef, Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato

$5.59


Specialty TacosServed with lettuce, tomato & cheese with nacho chips.

Steak Taco

$6.29 - $5.29

Fried onions, peppers (sweer & hot), & mushrooms.

Chicken Taco

$6.29 - $5.29

Fried onions, peppers (sweer & hot), & mushrooms.

Veggie Taco

$3.50

Lettuce, olives, sweet peppers, tomato & cheese.

Extras

Price may varies

Jalapeno peppers, cheese, sour cream add $0.45.


Chicken WingsA buff alo original made with: tangy hot, medium, mild, extra hot or bbq sauce, or new honey mustard. Includes crispy celery and our own homemade bleu cheese dip.

Chicken Wings

$7.99 - $26.99

(Single 10, double 20, triple 30, bucket 50).

Extra Bleu Cheese

$1.29

Extra Celery

$1.29

Extra Celery

$1.29

BBQ Wings

$1.29

(Add).


Chargrilled WingsCajun, honey bbq or bbq, honey mustard or our new raspberry.

Chargrilled Wings

$8.29 - $27.99

(Single 10, double 20, triple 30, bucket 50).


Soft Drinks

Soft Drinks

$1.89 - $2.69

Coke, diet coke, sprite, iced tea, loganberry, root beer, water.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading