The Cider Mill Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 55 votes
The Cider Mill Logo

Choose My State

AZ

The Cider Mill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Fresh From the Garden

Sue’s Caesar

$8.95

Crisp romaine, in-house baked croutons, parmesan cheese, topped with our soon-to-be-famous homemade dressing

Vic’s Chef Salad

$10.95

Diced ham and turkey over a bed of romaine tossed with cheddar, swiss, croutons, tomatoes, onion and a hardboiled egg

Super Dave’s Spinach Salad

$10.95

Farm fresh spinach with prosciutto ham, walnuts and dried cherries topped with a hardboiled egg and balsamic vinaigrette on the side

Chop Salad (No Lettuce)

$9.95

Fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, red onion, feta, hearts of palm, artichoke hearts and Italian dressing with wedges of grilled ciabatta bread

Carrie’s Caprese Salad

$8.95

Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and sweet basil topped with olive oil and balsamic vinaigrette

Chicken Fiesta Salad

$10.95

Grilled chicken breast, romain lettuce, corn, black beans, avocado, hot house tomatoes, cheddar cheese and our spicy southwest ranch dressing

Gilby’s Greek Salad

$9.95

Romaine lettuce, feta, red onion, artichoke, cucumber, pepperoncini, beets, tomatoes, tossed in our homemade greek dressing

Alexis’ Antipasto Salad

$10.95

Romaine lettuce, salami, turkey, artichokes, tomatoes, pepperoncini and olives tossed in our homemade Greek dressing

Cider Mill House Salad

$6.95

Romaine lettuce topped with carrots, cucumbers and tomatoes served with our homemade house dressing. Also available in a side salad for $4.95


Cider Mill's Homemade Soups

Soup Du Jour

$3.95 - $4.95


Savory SandwichesOur whole sandwiches are served with your choice of chips or substitute pasta salad, potato salad or spiked cottage cheese for $0.50

Sue’s Tomato Mozz Sandwich

$9.95

Roasted roma tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, provolone and fresh basil served hot on ciabatta bread

Classic Reuben

$9.95

Freshly thin sliced corned beef topped with sauerkraut, homemade thousand island and swiss served hot on rye

The Cider Mill Dip

$10.95

Hot Roast beef slathered with creamy horseradish and melted provolone on a crispy milano with a side of au jus for ultimate dippage

Tom’s Tuna

$8.95

Albacore tuna mixed with mayo, relish, onion and seasonings served cold on sourdough with lettuce and tomato. Add cheese & make it a melt for $1.00

Marty’s Mediterranean

$9.95

Freshly sliced turkey, white bean spread, marinated roasted tomatoes, provolone and lettuce served hot on nine grain bread

Brit’s Brie and Pickle

$9.95

Wedges of brie cheese, crisp dill pickles on a buttered baguette. Hewitt Style: add turkey and make it hot for $1.00

Mario’s Monster Mill-wich

$10.95

Freshly sliced turkey and roast beef topped with roasted red bell peppers, feta cheese and Italian dressing served hot on milano

Kim’s Chicken Caesar Sandwich

$10.95

Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, and melted parm with homemade caesar dressing served hot on ciabatta

Mandrew’s Chicken Sandwich

$10.95

Grilled chicken breast, tomatoes, lettuce, swiss and cheddar cheese served with ranch served hot on sourdough bread. Also available spicy buffalo style

Snoop’s Veggie Delight

$9.95

Our hot house roasted vegetables tossed in house dressing and melted provolone cheese served hot on Milano bread

Nay’s Milly Philly

$10.95

Hot roast beef topped with american cheese, grilled onion and green chiles served hot on sourdough

Build Your Own Sandwich

$9.95

Choose 1 from each category meats: corned beef, ham, turkey cheeses: american, cheddar, feta, provolone swiss, pepperjack breads: ciabatta, rye, sourdough, nine grain and milano additions: lettuce, o


Flatbreads

Chili w/Noodles (1 Notch)

$4.95

Chili w/Noodles & Cheese (2 Notches)

$5.50

Chili w/Noodles, Cheese & Onion (3 Notches)

$6.00

Chili w/Noodles, Cheese, Onion & Beans

$6.50


Barclay’s Bites

Nana’s Potato Salad

$1.95

Pasta Salad

$1.95

Spiked Cottage Cheese

$1.95

Add chicken, tuna, procuitto $2.00. Add avocado, beets, or walnuts $1.00. Extra meat or cheese $1.00. Add item to sandwich or salad $0.50

Potato Chips

$1.50

Original flavor


Tippy’s Corner for Tiny Tummies

PB & J Mill Style

$3.95

Smooth peanut butter with strawberry or grape jelly on your choice of bread

Cheese Flatbread

$8.95

Provolone and mozzarella melted over marinara saue on a flatbread

Brit’s Mac ‘n Cheese

$3.95

Pasta doused with our homemade cheese sauce

Adult Portion

$5.95

Grilled Cheese

$5.95

Grilled sourdough bread with melted american cheese


Shareable Snacks

Antipasto Plate

$16.95

Assorted meats and cheeses and olives served with toasted baguettes

Fruit and Cheese Plate

$14.95

Assorted fruits and cheeses served with toasted baguettes

Margherita Flatbread

$8.95

Fresh tomatoes and basil with olive oil and melted provolone cheese

Jumbo Pretzel

$2.95

Served hot with mustard add cheese or cheese sauce $1.00


Delectable Delights

Sundaes

$4.95

Ice Cream

$2.95

Extra scoop $1.00

Homemade Draft Floats

$3.95

Please ask for our assorted baked goods that change daily


Beverages

Bottled Water

$2.00

Coke Products

$1.50

Cider

$3.99

Homemade Mill Hard Cider

$7.00

Coffee

$2.00

Iced or Hot Tea

$2.00

16oz Homemade Draft Soda

$2.95

Homemade Draft Floats

$3.95

1/2 Gallon Growler Homemade Soda

$8.95 - $7.25


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading