The Buffalo House Cafe Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 107 votes
The Buffalo House Cafe Logo
Coffee

Choose My State

NY

The Buffalo House Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers And Soups

French Onion Soup

$3.95

simmered onions in broth, with croutons and baked with mild cheese

Homestyle Soup Du Jour

$2.45 - $2.95

Chili Con Carne

$2.45 - $2.95

an award winner! hot and hearty


Hemingway's House Gardenbleu cheese dressing $0.35 extra

Chef Salad

$3.75

the freshest selection from the market and the perfect addition to your dinner

Spinach Salad

$7.95

fresh spinach leaves with real bacon bits, buttery croutons, fresh mushrooms and chopped egg. topped with our special warm bacon dressing

Julienne Salad

$7.95

mixed greens, sliced cheeses, turkey breast, hart and all the fixins, your choice of dressing

Grilled Chicken Or Beef Caesar Salad

$8.95

tender chunks of boneless chicken breast served with crisp romaine lettuce and our original caesar dressing & croutons

Garden Souvlaki

$8.95

mixed greens topped with marinated beef or strips of charbroiled chicken, served with feta, cheese, onion, lettuce, tomato and our special dressing

Marinated Chicken Salad

$7.95

mixed greens topped with marinated chicken strips, served with feta cheese, onions, tomato and our special dressing

Cajun Chicken Salad

$7.95

over fresh greens and topped with shredded cheddar cheese

Taco Salad

$8.45

fresh greens, covered with shredded cheeses, diced tomatoes our famous chili, tortilla chips and taco sauce dressing. your choice of meat or chicken


Side Orders

French Fries

$2.45

Onion Rings

$2.45

Chicken Fingers

$8.45

tender strips of chicken in a crisp herbed breading served with bleu cheese, our special wing sauce and french fries

Catfish Fingers

$8.45

fresh catfish breaded with cornmeat. served with tartar sauce, lemon, french fries and cole slaw

Buffalo Chicken Wings

$6.95 - $12.95

Buffalo Potato Skins

$5.95

deep fried crisp and hot, smothered with melted swiss and cheddar cheese and topped with real bacon bits, served with sour cream

Hot Peppers

$5.45

breaded chili peppers stuffed with cheddar cheese

Nachos Supreme

$5.95

nacho chips with cheese, ground beef, tomatoes, sour cream and jalapenos

Mozzarella Sticks

$5.45

deep fried, crisp and hot, stuffed with melted mozzarella cheese

Garlic Bread

$2.45

Spinach Bread

$3.95

garlic bread topped with sauteed spinach and mozzarella cheese


Steak On The Open Pitthe "open pit" specials include your choice of soup or salad with fresh roll and butter.

8 Oz. N.Y. Strips Steak

$13.95

grilled on our open pit the way you like. served with onion ring garnish and choice of today's potato

8 Oz. N.Y. Strips Steak And Greens

$14.45

topped with sauteed spinach. seasoned just right, served with onion rings garnish and choice of today's potato

8 Oz. N.Y. Strips Steak Royale

$14.95

topped with sauteed onions, mushrooms, and peppers, seasoned just right, served with onion rings garnished and choice of today's potato


Burgers On The Open Pit

The Phantom

$5.75

ground beef, lettuce, tomato served on a roll with french fries.

The Showboat

$6.00

ground beef topped with cheese, lettuce and tomato served on a roll with french fries.

The Showboat

$6.25

ground beef topped with cheese, lettuce and tomato served on a roll with french fries., with strips of bacon

A Chorus Line

$6.50

ground beef topped with bleu cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato, served on a roll with french fries.

Fiddler On The Roof

$6.50

ground beef topped with shredded cheddar cheese and tangy barbecue sauce. served on a roll with french fries.

The King And 1

$6.50

(turkey burger) ground turkey, lettuce, tomato served on a roll french fries.

Sugar Babies

$7.95

9 oz. ground beef, lettuce, tomato served on a roll with french fries, each additional topping at $0.25 cents


Theater District Specialsthe specials include your choice of soup on salad with roll & butter, (available after 3:00 p.m only)

Shrimp And Broccoli Alfredo

$14.45

tender shrimp and fresh broccoli topped with our delicious alfredo sauce. served on a bed of pasta

Chicken And Broccoli Alfredo

$13.45

boneless chicken and fresh broccoli topped with our delicious alfredo sauce. served on a bed of pasta

Ravioli

$11.95

spinach and cheese ravioli simmered in marinara sauce with fresh basil. served with garlic bread

Shrimp, Chicken & Cashew Stir Fry

$14.95

tasty shrimp, chicken, cashews and assorted fresh vegetables stir-fried. sherry, your choice of rice today's potato

Stuffed Shells

$10.45

extra large sea shells stuffed with creamy ricotta cheese, topped with sauce

Shrimp Scampi

$14.95

(an award winner) scampi over steamed rice

Chili Pepper Fettuccini

$13.95

fajita grilled chicken, tossed with chili pasta, black olives and sweet peppers, flavored with tequila lime and our southwestern pesto


The Theatre Attraction

Alleyway Theatre

$7.95

5 oz. new york strip steak charbroiled to your specifications. topped with sauteed onions, peppers, mushrooms and melted cheese. served on a roll with french fries

The Cabaret

$7.95

(specify cajun) 5 oz. new york strip steak charbroiled to your specification. served on garlic toast with french fries

Pfeifer Theatre

$6.25

boneless chicken breast topped with barbecue sauce. served on a roll with french fries

Stanley Theatre

$6.95

boneless chicken breast topped with seasoned spinach and melted provolone cheese. served on a roll with french fries.

Hallwalls

$6.95

boneless chicken breast topped with strips of bacon and melted cheese. served on a roll with french fries.

Irish Classical Theatre

$7.25

boneless chicken breast topped with seasoned spinach. melted provolone cheese, strips of bacon served on a roll with french fries.

Apollo Theatre

$6.45

roast beef served on a fresh kummelweck or roll with french fries. may we suggest our special hot horseradish sauce

Shea's Buffalo Theatre

$8.95

(souvlaki) souvlaki-marinated beef or strips of charbroiled chicken with feta cheese, onion, tomato and greek dressing. served in pita bread

Open Face Roast Beef

$8.45

served on white bread. topped with hot gravy and today's potato

Franklin Theatre

$5.95

three decker club sandwich served with turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato and bacon, french fries included

Buffalo Ensemble Theatre

$6.45

chicken finger sandwich topped with melted cheese, lettuce and tomato, served on a roll with french fries

Marquee At The Tralf

$6.75

(jerk chicken sandwich) a treat from islands, moni tender chicken breast marinated in a blend of soy sauce. pineapple, ginger, scallions, and other (secret!) spices. served with tomato, and lettuce,

Book Cadillac Theatre

$6.45

(turkey supreme sliced turkey breast served with your choice of cheese, bacon and tomato, state your choice of grilled bread. french fries included

Century Theatre

$6.75

(reuben sandwich) lean corned beef, swiss cheese and sauerkraut grilled on rye bread with russian dressing. french fries included

Studio Arena Theatre

$7.45

(philly steak sub) topped with cheese, peppers and onions, french fries included

Market Arcade Theatre

$6.95

(philly chicken sob) topped with cheese, peppers and onions, french fries included)

Full Circle Studios

$6.95

(chicken quesadilla) tortilla filled with chicken, three cheeses, tomatoes, onion, jalapeno peppers, served with salsa and sour cream, french fries included


The Naval Park

Fresh Haddock

$8.95

deep fried to a golden brown, served with french fries or today's potato. cole slaw, bread and butter, we'll happy to broil your fish, if you have a little extra time, (available thursday and friday


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading