The Bagel Shoppe Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 142 votes
The Bagel Shoppe Logo

Choose My State

NY

The Bagel Shoppe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


BagelsWith toppings

Butter, Jelly or Fresh Preserves

$1.59

Cream Cheese and Jelly, Fresh Jam Preserves

$2.99

Flavored Cream Cheese

$2.99

Peanut Butter

$2.99

Hummus

$2.99

Peanut Butter and Jelly or Jam

$2.99

Non-Fat Cream Cheese (plain)

$2.99

Non-Fat Cream Cheese Flavored

$2.99


Homemade Spreads

Plain and Fat Free

$6.99

Garlic, strawberry, scallion, lox, jalapeno olive and pimento, walnut raisin 1b

Plain Vegetable and Fat Free Vegetable

$7.99

1b


BreakfastServed on bagel, roll or choice of bread

Farm Fresh Double Eggs

$1.89

Farm Fresh Double Eggs and Cheese

$1.99

Farm Fresh Double Eggs and Cheese

$2.99

With choice of ham, sausage or bacon

Double Eggs

$6.95

With ham, bacon, or sausage with home fries and bagel

Assorted Muffins

$2.50

Croissants

$2.79

Chocolate Croissants

$3.29


Fresh Authentic Water BagelsBialy's, bagel twists, flagels $0.95, mini bagels $0.50, pizza bagels $1.50

Plain

$0.85 - $9.99

Poppy

$0.85 - $9.99

Cinnamon Raisin

$0.85 - $9.99

Salt

$0.85 - $9.99

Whole Wheat Onion

$0.85 - $9.99

Everything

$0.85 - $9.99

Sesame

$0.85 - $9.99

Garlic

$0.85 - $9.99

Pumpernickel Egg

$0.85 - $9.99

Triceratops

$0.85 - $9.99

Jalapeno

$0.85 - $9.99

Marble

$0.85 - $9.99

Multi Grain Rye

$0.85 - $9.99

Blueberry

$0.85 - $9.99

French Toast

$0.85 - $9.99

Carrot Walnut Raisin Flaxseed

$0.85 - $9.99

Asiago

$0.85 - $9.99

Multi-Bagel

$0.85 - $9.99

Cinnamon Stick Irish Soda Bread

$0.85 - $9.99


MuffinsRegular, no fat low, fat yogurt

Corn

$2.50

Raisin

$2.50

Blueberry

$2.50

Banana Chocolate Chip Lemon Poppy

$2.50

Capppuccino

$2.50

Pound Cake

$2.50

Cranberry Orange

$2.50

Cinnamon Coffee

$2.50

Chocolate Chocolate Chip

$2.50


Omelets3 Farm fresh eggs, served with home fries and buttered bagel

Hot Shot

$6.99

Onions, peppers and jalapeno jack cheese

Onion and Olive

$6.99

Onion, oil cured olives and black olives

Bacon and Cheddar

$6.99

Crispy bacon and NYS sharp cheddar

Ham and Swiss

$6.99

Fresh grilled ham and imported swiss

Sausage and Provolone

$6.99

Grilled sausage and imported provolone

Portabella Mushroom

$6.99

Grilled portabella mushroom and tomato

The Shoppe

$6.99

Ham, bacon, sausage and cheese

The Italian

$6.99

Roasted peppers and imported provolone


Special SandwichAlways made with 2 farm fresh eggs, make your selection

Hobo

$4.49

Ham, eggs, cheese and home fries

Irishman

$4.49

Corned beef, eggs, cheese and home fries

New Yorker

$4.49

Pastrami, eggs, swiss cheese

Rosemary's Bagel

$4.49

Rosemary ham, eggs with jalapeno jack cheese

Chuck Wagon

$4.49

Roast beef, eggs, cheese and home fries

Portabella

$4.49

Portabella mushroom, eggs and mozzarella cheese

Shoppe Sandwich

$4.49

Ham, bacon, sausage, eggs with cheese

The Monte Cristo

$4.49

Eggs, ham, turkey and swiss

Irishman

$4.49

Corned beef, eggs, cheese and home fries

New Yorker

$4.49

Pastrami, eggs, swiss cheese

Rosemary's Bagel

$4.49

Rosemary ham, eggs with jalapeno jack cheese

Chuck Wagon

$4.49

Roast beef, eggs, cheese and home fries

Portabella

$4.49

Portabella mushroom, eggs and mozzarella cheese

Shoppe Sandwich

$4.49

Ham, bacon, sausage, eggs with cheese

The Monte Cristo

$4.49

Eggs, ham, turkey and swiss


Sides

Home Fries

$3.50

Home Fries with Cheese

$3.99

Cheese

$0.75

Grilled Ham or Bacon or Sausage

$1.25


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading