Menu With Price > Menu > Sutter's Mill Restaurant

Sutter's Mill Restaurant Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 118 votes
Sutter's Mill Restaurant Logo

Choose My State

CA

Sutter's Mill Restaurant Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Appetizers

Melted Cheese Toast

$5.95

Our garlic toast topped with cheddar cheese

Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

$9.95

Mushroom caps, with crab & parmesan

Bacon Wrapped Shrimp

$9.95

6 Large shrimp with our zesty red sauce

Sourdough Garlic Toast

$2.95

Great as an appetizer or with your salad

Shrimp Cocktail

$7.95

6 Large shrimp with our zesty cocktail sauce

Seared Rare Ahi Tuna

$12.95

1/2 lb. sliced & topped with avocado

Salad & Pasta

Garden Salad

$15.95

Served with a slice of our garlic mixed greens with vegetables, cheese & hard boiled egg

Simply Pasta

$14.95

Linguini with tomato basil or white cream sauce served with soup or salad and a slice of our garlic toast

Steaks and Prime RibServed with soup or salad (mixed green or the wedge) & choice of one of the following. Our famous stuffed baked potato (since 1958), plain baked potato, french fries, sutter’s fries, onion rings, grilled asparagus, sauteed zucchini or mac n’ cheese, a

Prime Rib - The Pioneer (8 oz.)

$28.95

Slow roasted for exceptional tenderness and flavor & carefully trimmed to give you what we call the “eye of the prime”

Prime Rib - The Prospector (12 oz.)

$34.50

Slow roasted for exceptional tenderness and flavor & carefully trimmed to give you what we call the “eye of the prime”

Prime Rib - The Nugget (16 oz.)

$39.95

Slow roasted for exceptional tenderness and flavor & carefully trimmed to give you what we call the “eye of the prime”

Steak Sandwich

$18.95

A 6 oz thin cut top sirloin served open-faced on our garlic toast

Ground Chuck Steak

$17.95

12 oz. - certified angus beef

Filet Oscar

$24.95

Two 3 oz. medallions topped with asparagus, crab & hollandaise

Top Sirloin (12 oz.)

$26.95

A larger version of our signature steak

Sutter's Signature Steak

$21.95

Strike it rich with our center cut 8 oz. top sirloin our most popular steak since 1958

Petite Ribeye (9 oz.)

$28.95

`

New York Steak (14 o\z.)

$34.95

Ribeye (14 oz.)

$36.95

Porterhouse (20 oz.)

$39.95

Filet Mignon

$28.95 - $34.95

The tenderest cut of all

Gold Country FavoritesChoice of group or salad and side. Add a second side $4.00

Grilled Chicken Breast (8 oz)

$16.95

Fried Chicken (3 pc)

$17.95

BBQ Beef Short Ribs

$18.95

Boneless 1/2 lb

Baby Back Pork Ribs

$18.95

Full rack add $7.00

SeafoodChoice of soup or salad and side. Add a second side $4.00

Deep Fried Breaded Cod (1/2 lb)

$16.95

Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp (3)

$19.95

Salmon Fillet (1/2 lb)

$22.95

Shrimp Scampi (1/2 lb.)

$22.95

Sauteed in butter, garlic & capers and served over linguini

Alaskan Halibut Fillet (1/2 lb)

$28.95

Alaskan King Crab (1/2 Lb.)

$29.95

Maine Lobster Tail (8-10 oz.)

$34.95

Australian Lobster Tail (10-12 oz.)

$49.95

Gold Coutnry Sandwich FavoritesServed with soup or salad and a side choice add bacon $1.50, avacado $1.00

Hamburger (1/3 lb)

$14.50

Cheeseburger (1/3 lb.)

$14.95

Wally Burger

$15.95

2/3 lb patty stuffed with cheese

Miner’s Dip

$18.95

Thin sliced prime rib on garlic toast

Combinations

Steak & Maine Lobster Tail

$36.95

An 8 oz. top sirloin and 8 oz. lobster tail

Steak & Alaskan King Crab Legs

$34.95

an 8 oz. Top sirloin and 8 oz. of crab legs specially prepared for easy eating

Steak & Scampi

$29.95

An 8 oz. top sirloin and 1/2 lb. of shrimp sauteed in butter & garlic

Steak & Australian Lobster

$36.95

An 8 oz. top sirloin and 1/2 cold water lobster tail (Approx. 6 oz.)

Sutter’s Ala Carte Sides

Mac and Cheese

$6.50

Sutter’s Fries

$5.50

French Fries

$5.50

Stuffed Baked Potato

$6.50

Plain Baked Potato

$6.50

Grilled Asparagus

$7.50

Bowl of Soup or Dinner Salad

$7.50

Desserts

Hot Fruit Cobbler

$6.50

Made on the premises cherry or peach ala mode $1.00

Deep Fried Cheesecake

$7.50

A pastry tortilla stuffed with cheesecake filling, deep fried an rolled in cinnamon & sugar

N.Y. Cheese Cake

$4.50

Topped with strawberries $1.25

Chocolate Cake

$6.50

Chocolate overload torte

Creme Brulee

$5.50

Dreyers Ice Cream

$4.50

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Pepsi

$2.95

Diet Pepsi

$2.95

Sierra Mist

$2.95

Lemonade

$2.95

Iced Tea

$2.95

Coffee

$2.95

Perrier Sparkling Water

$2.95

Milk

$2.95

Hot Tea

$2.95

Orange Juice

$2.95

Tomato Juice

$2.95

Cranberry Juice

$2.95

Pineapple Juice

$2.95

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands