Surefire Smokehouse Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 143 votes
Surefire Smokehouse Logo

Choose My State

IN

Surefire Smokehouse Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


BeveragesBeverage

Hannon's Root Beer Reborn

$2.50 - $7.95

Valpo's long gone favorite Root Beer is reborn and on tap.

Soda

$2.25

Fresh Brewed China Mist Unsweetened Iced Tea

$2.25

Douwe Egbert Brewed Coffee

$2.25

A classic continental style blend that's smooth and well rounded.


Surefire BeginningsSurefire Beginning

Burnt Ends

$10.50

A BBQ delicacy and double smoked brisket served with our own beer battered onion rings.

Rib Tips

$9.50

Surefire combination: our slow smoked pork rib tips and our That's It sauce served with our hand cut fries.

Pulled Pork Nachos with Hot Salsa

$9.50

Melted house four cheese blend, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, black olives, avocado, sour cream and fresh jalapenos.

Pulled Pork Nachos with Mild Salsa

$9.50

Melted house four cheese blend, shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, black olives, avocado, sour cream and fresh jalapenos.

Crab Cake

$8.95

One cake served with chipotle mayo and mango, corn, black bean, red pepper and diced jalapenos relish.

Spicy Stuffed Banana Peppers

$8.95

Banana peppers stuffed with our custom Italian sausage snuggled in marinara sauce, topped with Surefire four cheese blend and baked to perfection.

Hot Spinach Dip

$6.95

Fresh spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts and blended together with Parmesan cheese and served with toasted Italian bread.

Thick Sliced Onion Rings

$6.95

Double beer battered featuring Belgian Fat Tire served with our Surefire tangy white sauce.

Basket of Surefire Steak Fries

$3.95


Surefire SaladsSurefire Salad

Surefire Brisket Salad

$9.95

Our slow smoked brisket, marinated tomatoes, mozzarella cheese and red onion topped with our tequila vinaigrette. Served with warm bread.

Roasted Chicken Salad

$8.75

Chopped chicken with cranberries, walnuts and tart apples tossed in honey mustard dressing on mixed greens. Served with warm bread.

Roast Turkey Salad

$8.75

Roasted turkey breast, cucumbers, marinated tomatoes and red onions sprinkled with our house four cheese blend, topped with a dollop of guacamole and served with our house wasabi ranch dressing. Serv

Garden Salad

$5.00 - $1.00

Tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions and green peppers topped with our house four cheese blend. Served with warm bread.


PizzasPizza

Surefire Pulled Pork Pizza

$12.00 - $16.00

Pulled pork with mild Mempha-Lina sauce.

Surefire Brisket Pizza

$12.00 - $16.00

Beef brisket, onion and hot tequila sauce.

Cheeseburger Pizza

$12.00 - $16.00

Ground chuck, bacon, American cheese, onion and pickle over a light mustard sauce.

Banana Pepper Pizza

$12.00 - $16.00

Our own stuffed banana peppers and four cheese blend.

Build Your Own Pizza

$9.50 - $22.00

Start with a cheese pizza and add toppings to suit your tastes.


SeafoodSeafood

Filet of Sole

$17.50

Stuffed with crabmeat and topped with shrimp bisque served over a bed of shrimp rice pilaf.

Crab Cake Dinner

$17.50

Two cakes served with chipotle mayo and Surefire mango, corn, black bean, red pepper and diced jalapenos relish.

Fish and Chips

$11.50

Served with house made tarter sauce.


Surefire Signature SandwichesSurefire Signature Sandwiche

Surefire Pulled Pork Sandwich

$9.50

Our secret rub makes the most delicious bark, served with our house made crispy coleslaw and served on a toasted brioche bun. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a p

Surefire Beef Brisket Sandwich

$9.95

Smoked for over 14 hours, sauced and served with sliced onion on a toasted brioche bun. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spear and a sample of either our

Surefire's Bulls Eye Sandwich

$10.55

Beef brisket, house made pizza sauce, pepper rings and provolone cheese on a toasted steak roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spear and a sample of e

Ms. Fire's Pork Loin Sandwich

$9.50

Thinly sliced smosted pork loin, covered in our sassy Ms. Fire sauce and served with pepper rings on a kaiser roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spea

Iron Worker Sandwich

$9.00

Tender roast beef sliced thin with American cheese and pepperjack cheese, shredded lettuce, sliced tomato, white onion and mayo grilled on Pano rye bread. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our ho

Mill Worker Sandwich

$9.00

Sliced roast beef with sauteed peppers, white onions, roasted tomatoes and pepperjack cheese with white Surefire sauce served on a French roll with a side of au jus. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served

Surefire Reuben

$9.00

Tender corned beef, sauerkraut, Surefire Thousand Island dressing, Swiss and pepperjack cheese all grilled on rye bread. Yum. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a p

Surefire Cuban Sandwich

$9.50

Surefire's own marinated and slow roasted pork loin, off the bone ham, salami, pickles, Swiss cheese, mustard and mayo pressed on a steak roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips o

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$8.25

Roast chicken with celery, onion, boiled egg, diced pickle, mayo, a hint of horseradish, red grapes and a sprinkling of magic dust. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak frie

Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich

$8.25

Roasted chicken, smoked bacon, our house made ranch dressing, lettuce and tomato all served on a soft French roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spear

That's It Chicken Sandwich

$8.25

Our finely tuned Surefire That's It sauce is the star of this pulled chicken, hand cut fries and Swiss cheese sandwich served pressed on a steak roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house

Deep Fried Turkey Sandwich

$8.25

Beer battered turkey breast served with lettuce, tomato, onion and chipotle mayo on a kaiser roll. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spear and a sample of

Roast Turkey Sandwich

$8.25

Sliced turkey with avocado spread and lettuce on a toasted brioche bun. Includes 1/4 lb. of meat. Served with our house chips or steak fries, a pickle spear and a sample of either our coleslaw, potat


Tastes You CraveTastes You Crave

Half Slab of Surefire Ribs

$15.00

Slow roasted with a kiss of smoke in our southern pride smoker. Served with your choice of two sides.

Full Slab of Surefire Ribs

$22.00

Slow roasted with a kiss of smoke in our southern pride smoker. Served with your choice of two sides.

Combo Platter

$15.00

Served with your choice of two sides.

Home Style Pot Roast

$9.95

Old fashioned slow roasted pot roast oven brown potatoes, carrots and onions in rich brown gravy. Served with bread.

Pot Roast Sandwich

$9.95

Slow roasted pot roast, provolone cheese, tomato, white sauce and onion pressed on a steak roll.


Surefire SidesSurefire Side

Cole Slaw

$2.95

Potato Salad with Sweet Potato

$2.95

Homemade potato salad made with white potatoes and a touch of sweet potatoes.

Steak Fries

$2.95

Fresh steak fries.

Surefire Baked Beans with Pulled Pork

$3.95

Surefire special recipe baked beans.


DessertsDessert

Lava Cake

$5.00

A chocolate lover's dream. Moist, warm and gooey.

Peach Cobbler

$4.50

Like Grandma used to make.

Bread Pudding

$4.50

Rum sauce.

Fluffy Cheesecake

$5.00

Graham cracker crust with a light lemon filling.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading