Super's Cafe Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 115 votes
Super's Cafe Logo
Coffee

Choose My State

NY

Super's Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Burgers, Paninis, Sandwiches and WrapsBurgers, paninis, sandwiches and wraps come with your choice of regular or sweet potato fries

The Montauk

$14.00

Half pound beef burger topped with Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, sauteed mushrooms and garlic mayo

The Hampton's

$14.00

Half pound beef burger topped with crumbled pepper bleu cheese, crispy fried onions, lettuce, tomatoes and tangy steak sauce

The South Shore

$14.00

Half pound beef burger topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, sauteed onions and mushrooms, lettuce, tomato and bbq sauce

The North Shore

$11.00

Veggie burger topped with mesclun greens and tomato and served with chipotle mayo

The Plainview

$11.00

Turkey burger topped with grilled terriyaki glazed pineapple and red onion

Super's Blazing Hot

$14.00

Blackened beef burger, bleu cheese dressing, hot sauce, lettuce and tomato

Build A Burger - Beef

$12.00

Add any of the following: american, cheddar, swiss, provolone, or bleu cheese, peppers, mushrooms, sauteed onions, or crispy onion strings $50.00 each Bacon, ham, or fried egg $1.00 each

Build A Burger - Turkey

$11.00

Add any of the following: american, cheddar, swiss, provolone, or bleu cheese, peppers, mushrooms, sauteed onions, or crispy onion strings $50.00 each Bacon, ham, or fried egg $1.00 each

Build A Burger - Veggie

$11.00

Add any of the following: american, cheddar, swiss, provolone, or bleu cheese, peppers, mushrooms, sauteed onions, or crispy onion strings $50.00 each Bacon, ham, or fried egg $1.00 each

The Cuban Panini

$12.00

Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, pickles and honey mustard

The Italian Panini

$12.00

Grilled balsamic glazed chicken, spinach, roasted peppers, mozzarella and pesto mayo

The French Panini

$12.00

Grilled chicken, ham, swiss cheese and thousand Island dressing

The American Panini

$12.00

Roast beef, turkey, ham, american cheese, tomatoes and garlic mayo

The Vegetarian Panini

$12.00

Grilled eggplant, yellow and green zucchini, sundried tomatoes, roasted peppers, red onions, mozzarella and balsamic glaze

Turkey Club

$11.00

Triple decker with turkey, American cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato

Chicken Club

$13.00

Triple decker with grilled or blackened chicken, cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato

Steak Sandwich

$15.00

Marinated skirt steak, melted Swiss cheese, peppers, mushrooms and crispy fried onions on garlic bread

Caribbean Chicken Sandwich

$13.00

Sweet glazed grilled chicken, pineapple salsa, mesclun greens and red onion

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$13.00

Grilled chicken tossed in hot sauce and topped with bleu cheese dressing

BBQ Roast Beef Wrap

$14.00

Hot, sliced roast beef, caramelized onions, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and tangy bbq sauce

Southwest Chicken Wrap

$13.00

Grilled chicken, black beans, corn, cheddar cheese, diced tomatoes, onions and lettuce

Plainview Wrap

$11.00

Turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and thousand island dressing

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$12.00

Grilled chicken, chopped romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese all tossed in a zesty caesar dressing

Grilled Vegetable Wrap

$11.00

Grilled eggplant, yellow and green zucchini, roasted peppers and mozzarella drizzled with a balsamic glaze


Appetizers

Buffalo Wings - 1/2 Dozen

$7.00

Lightly breaded served crisp with your choice of hot, medium, bbq, or terriyaki sauce and bleu cheese or ranch dipping sauce

Buffalo Wings - Dozen

$12.00

Lightly breaded served crisp with your choice of hot, medium, bbq, or terriyaki sauce and bleu cheese or ranch dipping sauce

Fried Calamari

$9.00

Crisp and golden brown served with our homemade marinara

Quesadilla - Cheese

$9.00

Flour tortilla stuffed with sauteed onions, peppers and cheese, and your choice of chicken, steak, or shrimp served with sour cream and salsa

Quesadilla - Chicken

$12.00

Flour tortilla stuffed with sauteed onions, peppers and cheese, and your choice of chicken, steak, or shrimp served with sour cream and salsa

Quesadilla - Steak

$15.00

Flour tortilla stuffed with sauteed onions, peppers and cheese, and your choice of chicken, steak, or shrimp served with sour cream and salsa

Quesadilla - Shrimp

$16.00

Flour tortilla stuffed with sauteed onions, peppers and cheese, and your choice of chicken, steak, or shrimp served with sour cream and salsa

Potstickers

$9.00

Steamed vegetable dumplings served with sweet and spicy chili and terriyaki soy dipping sauces

Spinach Dip

$8.00

Sauteed spinach and onions blended with parmesan and cream cheese served with tri color tortilla chips

Seared Tuna

$12.00

Sesame encrusted tuna seared rare served with pineapple salsa and wasabi

Nachos

$11.00

Tortilla chips topped with homemade chili and melted cheddar cheese served with sides of sour cream, salsa and guacomole

Crab Cake

$11.00

Twin crab cakes served with remoulade

Loaded Fries

$8.00

Crispy fries topped with melted cheddar cheese and crumbled bacon

Chicken Fingers

$9.00

Golden brown and served with your choice of buffalo, bbq, or honey mustard sauce

Mozzarella Sticks

$7.00

Served with our homemade marinara sauce

Super Sampler

$15.00

A perfect sampling of wings, chicken fingers, mozzarella sticks, sweet potato fries, and onion strings served with dipping sauces


Soups & Salads

French Onion Soup

$8.00

Caramelized onions in a beef broth poured over a toasted baguette and topped with Swiss cheese, broiled until brown and bubbly

Vegetarian Chili

$8.00

Hearty triple bean chili, with black, pinto and kidney beans, tomatoes, onions and peppers

Soup Du Jour

$8.00

Chef's homemade soup

Apple Walnut Chicken Salad

$13.00

Mesclun greens topped with grilled chicken strips, sliced apples, crumbled bleu cheese and walnuts, served with a light raspberry vinaigrette

Caribbean Chicken Salad

$13.00

Sweet glazed chicken, pineapple salsa, cucumbers, red onions, and grape tomatoes on a bed of romaine and mesclun greens, served with a citrus vinaigrette

Southwest Steak Salad

$15.00

Seared, thin sliced skirt steak, black beans, corn, grape tomatoes, red onions, mixed cheddar cheese and crispy onion strings over a mix of romaine and mesclun, served with ranch dressing

Cobb Salad

$10.00

Crisp romaine lettuce topped with diced tomatoes, avocado, sliced egg, crumbled bacon and bleu cheese served with your choice of dressing

Asian Chicken Salad

$13.00

Terriyaki glazed chicken, mandarin oranges, walnuts, and crispy oriental noodles on a bed of romaine and mesclun greens, served with a citrus vinaigrette

Super's Garden Salad

$9.00

Romaine and mesclun greens mixed with crumbled bleu cheese, grape tomatoes, dried cranberries and granola served with balsamic vinaigrette

Wedge Salad

$11.00

Crisp iceberg lettuce wedge with crumbled bacon, crumbled bleu cheese and ranch dressing

Caesar Salad

$8.00

Chopped romaine lettuce, croutons, and parmesan cheese tossed in a zesty caesar dressing


Entrees

Grilled Chicken

$18.00

Grilled or blackened chicken served with mashed potatoes and vegetables

Caribbean Chicken

$19.00

Tangy sweet glazed chicken toppped with pineapple salsa and served with white rice and broccoli

Balsamic Chicken

$19.00

Balsamic glazed chicken with roasted peppers and asparagus over mashed potatoes

Kung Pao Chicken

$19.00

Marinated chicken, celery, carrots, peanuts, and chili peppers in a spicy sauce served with white rice

Chicken Francaise

$19.00

Lightly battered chicken breast sauteed in a lemon, garlic and butter sauce served with rice and vegetables

Grilled Salmon

$20.00

Grilled or blackened salmon served with mashed potatoes and vegetables

Lemon Dill Salmon

$20.00

Pan seared salmon in a buttery lemon dill sauce over white rice and sauteed spinach

Ginger Salmon

$20.00

Flame grilled salmon in a ginger soy glaze over white rice and vegetables

Herbed Tilapia

$19.00

Seasoned, grilled tilapia topped with a tomato garlic brushetta and served with mashed potatoes and spinach

Chilean Sea Bass

$25.00

Pan seared sea bass served with grilled asparagus, grape tomatoes and mashed potatoes

Sesame Crusted Tuna

$23.00

Sesame encrusted tuna seared rare and served with vegetables and white rice

Fried Shrimp

$18.00

Battered shrimp served with mashed potatoes and vegetables

Churrasco

$22.00

Flame grilled seasoned skirt steak topped with chinichurri sauce and served with white rice and black beans

New York Strip Steak

$22.00

Seasoned, grilled strip steak served with mashed potatoes and vegetables. Add grilled shrimp $6.00

Surf and Turf

$23.00

Grilled skirt steak and sauteed shrimp served with mashed potatoes and vegetables


PastasAll our pasta dishes are served with garlic bread. Add chicken $4.00, shrimp $6.00, steak $7.00, or salmon $8.00 to any of our pasta dishes

Penne Bolognese

$18.00

Penne topped with homemade beef bolognese

Rigatoni Leo

$19.00

Sundried tomatoes, broccoli, roasted peppers, grilled chicken, and rigatoni in a light garlic and wine sauce

Fettucine Alfredo

$17.00

Fettucine tossed in a parmesan cream sauce

Rigatoni Primavera

$17.00

Seasonal vegetables sauteed in garlic and oil and tossed with rigatoni

Penne A La Vodka

$17.00

Penne tossed in a creamy pink sauce

Fettucine Florentine

$17.00

Fettucine tossed in a sauteed spinach and cream sauce

Chicken Piccata

$19.00

Lightly battered pan sauteed chicken, capers and mushrooms in a light lemon sauce over linguine

Penne Pesto

$18.00

Penne tossed in our basil and parmesan pesto

Seafood Scampi

$22.00

Shrimp, calamari, and crab meat sauteed with butter, garlic and wine and served on a bed of linguine


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading