Menu With Price > Menu > Sheridan's Frozen Custard

Sheridan's Frozen Custard Menu and Prices

4.7 based on 458 votes

Ice Cream

Choose My State

GA IL KS MO NE NV OH TN TX

Sheridan's Frozen Custard Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

For Startersbasic chocolate or vanilla custard in a cup or a cone

For Starters

$1.50 - $2.90

Concretes

Standard Concrete

$3.26 - $3.83

includes one topping

Caramel Pretzel Crunch

$3.61 - $4.17

fresh vanilla custard blended with caramel and crunchy pretzel

Courtney's Dirt and Worms

$3.66 - $4.30

fresh vanilla custard and oreo cookies blended and topped with chocolate sprinkles and gummy worms

Grant's Grasshopper

$3.64 - $4.24

fresh vanilla custard, green mint flavor, and chocolate chip all blended together

Elvis Pick

$3.68 - $4.12

fresh vanilla custard, peanut butter, and sliced bananas all blended up

Mount Rush 5" more

$3.70 - $4.37

fresh vanilla custard, hot fudge, marshmallow creme, and graham crackers all blended up

Brett's Butter Pecan

$3.65 - $4.33

fresh vanilla custard, butterscotch, and roasted pecans all blended together

Mike's Mocha Almond

$3.61 - $4.19

fresh chocolate custard, rich espresso, and crunchy almonds all blended together

The Mother-In-Law

$3.58 - $4.04

"known to make some noise" fresh vanilla custard, chocolate chip, bananas, and rice krispies all blended up

The Tahiti Treaty

$3.53 - $3.97

signed for the summer with tangy mango and pineapple blended with fresh vanilla custard into a smooth and refreshing delight

ET's Charming Cheesecake

$4.00 - $4.67

fresh vanilla custard blended with a piece of New York style cheesecake and the topping of your choice

Apple and Pumpkin Pie (Fall Special)

$3.64 - $4.18

fresh vanilla custard blended with a piece of apple or pumpkin pie topped with whipped cream and cinnamon sugar

Sundaesandes mint, banana, blueberry, brownie bites, butterfinger, butterscotch, caramel, cherry, chocolate chip, chocolate sprinkles, chocolate syrup, cookie dough, coconut flakes, espresso, grahams crackers, gummy warms, heath bar, hot fudge, key lime, lemon,

The Royal Turtle

$3.90

vanilla custard, hot fudge caramel, roasted pecans and cherries

Buck-A-Roa

$3.74

vanilla custard, strawberries, sliced bananas, and hot fudge

Straw-Ana

$3.59

vanilla custard, strawberries, and sliced bananas

Sweet Pea's Favorite

$3.60

vanilla custard, hot fudge, covered with sliced bananas and a cherry

Mango Dango

$3.59

vanilla custard, fresh mangos, topped with roasted pecans and cherries

Key Lime

$3.54

vanilla custard topped with tangy lime, roasted pecans and cherries

Razzle Dazzle

$3.69

vanilla custard, whole raspberries, and hot fudge

Sheridan's

$3.98

two shortcakes topped with strawberry sauce, vanilla custard, rare strawberries & whipped cream

Standard Sundae

$3.04

fresh vanilla custard, one topping & a cherry

Hot Fudge Sundae with Pecans

$3.60

vanilla custard, hot fudge, covered with roasted pecans and cherries

Banana Split

$4.55

whole banana, vanilla custard, topped with marshmallow creme, pineapple, hot fudge, strawberries, roasted pecan pieces and cherries

Dolly's Pie in the Sky

$4.85

a rich brownie, vanilla custard, extra hot fudge, marshmallow creme, roasted pecan pieces and cherries

The Hoss Super Sundae

$4.48

fresh vanilla custard, your favorite topping, roasted pecans and cherries

Suicide Squeeze

$4.57

chocolate bunds cake, vanilla custard, hot fudge & whole raspberries

Gone Bananas

$4.43

caramel banana bunds cake, vanilla custard, bananas and caramel

Baseball Helmet Sundae

$2.75

your favorite baseball bean turned into a sundae with hot fudge, whip cream and a cherry

Smoothies

$3.73

1 or 2 fruits

Appetizers

Guacamole Live!

Price may varies

Ultimate Loaded Queso

Price may varies

Fajita Chicken Con Queso

Price may varies

Empanadas

Price may varies

Border Sampler

Price may varies

Firecracker Stuffed Jalapenos

Price may varies

Guacamole

Price may varies

Chile Con Queso

Price may varies

Grande Fajita Nachos

Price may varies

Chicken Flautas

Price may varies

Salads & Soup

Sizzling Fajita Salad

Price may varies

Chicken Fiesta Salad

Price may varies

Grande Taco Salad

Price may varies

Chicken Tortilla Soup

Price may varies

House Salad

Price may varies

Fajita Grillall fajitas are served sizzling with choice of refried or black beans, Mexican rice, fresh tortillas, sour cream, pico de pollo and choice of cheese or guacamole.

The OTB Original Fajita

Price may varies

mesquite grilled, carnitas, mesquite grilled steaks, shrimp, grilled vegetables

The Ultimate Fajita

Price may varies

mesquite grilled steak, marinated chicken, sauteed shrimp & roasted pork carnitas.

Fajita Favorites

Price may varies

monterrey ranch chicken, 7 pepper steak, blackened chicken

Off the Grill

Ranchiladas

Price may varies

Banera Sirloin

Price may varies

Carne Asada & Shrimp

Price may varies

Pico Chicken & Shrimp

Price may varies

Baja Chicken

Price may varies

Margarita Chicken

Price may varies

Border Smart Chicken

Price may varies

Burritos & Chimi's

Three-Sauce Fajita Burrito

Price may varies

Beef Burrito

Price may varies

Chicken Burrito

Price may varies

Build Your Own Burrito

Price may varies

The Big Bordurrito

Price may varies

Border Chimichanga

Price may varies

Favoritos

Double-Stacked Club

Price may varies

Quesadillas

Price may varies

Superior Dinner

Price may varies

Corona Extra Dinner

Price may varies

Quesadillas

Price may varies

Tres Enchiladas

Price may varies

Shrimp & Seafood

Salmon Mexicano

Price may varies

Mexican Shrimp Scampi

Price may varies

Dos XX Fish Tacos

Price may varies

Bebidas

Primo Margaritas

Price may varies

borderita grande, mercedes OTB meltdown, gold rocks

Classic Margaritas

Price may varies

fruit, swirls, OTB house, mango passion fruit

Wine

Price may varies

chardonnay, cabernet sauvignon, white zinfandel, merlot, pinot griglo

Tequila

Price may varies

patron anejo sauza tres generaclones, sauza conmemorativeo, herradura anejo, 1800 reposado, sauza hornitos, patron silver, jose cuervo gold, herradura silver

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.