Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Menu and Prices
Sandwiches
Seafood
Eastern European
Choose My State
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Menu
Last Update: 2025-03-14
BeveragesBeverages
Bottle of Poland Spring
$1.00
0
Can of Seltzer
$1.00
0
Can of Diet Coke
$1.50
0
Dr. Brown's Soda
$1.50
0
Bottle of Mexican Coke
$2.25
0
Fizzy Lizzy
$2.00
0
Regata Ginger Beer
$2.50
0
Abita Root Beer
$2.50
0
Sprecher's Cream Soda
$2.50
0
Fentiman's Soda
$2.50
0
Ashlawn Farm Coffee
$2.00 - $3.00
0
Palais de Thes Tea
$2.00 - $3.00
0
Simple SchmearsSimple Schmears
Plain Cream Cheese
$3.25
0
Scallion Cream Cheese
$3.50
0
Ben's All Natural Cream Cheese
$4.50
0
Ben's All Natural Vegetable Cream Cheese
$4.50
0
Horseradish Cream Cheese
$4.25
0
Olive Cream Cheese
$4.50
0
Super Loxy Lox Cream Cheese
$4.50
0
Smoked Whitefish Salad
$8.99
0
Smoked Bluefish Salad
$8.50
Contains nuts.
0
Baked Salmon Salad
$8.99
0
Pickled Herring Salad
$7.50
0
Egg Salad
$5.00
0
Chopped Liver
$8.50
0
Butter
$2.50
0
SandwichesSandwiches
Member of the Tribe Sandwich
$11.50
Gaspe nova, scallion or plain cream cheese. Served on a bagel or bialy.
0
The Fancy Pants Sandwich
$15.00
Fatty lake sturgeon, house cured gravlax, Ben's cream cheese, tomato and red onion served on a bagel or bialy.
0
Peter Shelsky Sandwich
$13.50
Gaspe nova, sable, pickled herring with cream sauce and onion, scallion cream cheese. Served on bagel or bialy.
0
Brooklyn Native Sandwich
$13.50
Gaspe nova, smoked whitefish salad, pickled herring, sour pickle, served on bagel or bialy.
0
Brooklyn Transplant Sandwich
$13.00
Fatty kippered salmon, apple horseradish, cream cheese, pickled herring salad, served on pumpernickel or rye.
0
Shelsky's Pastrami Sandwich
$13.25
Pastrami salmon, mustard herring, Riesling braised sauerkraut, served on pumpernickel or rye.
0
Dr. Goldstein Special Sandwich
$11.00
Duck fat-laced chopped liver and apple horseradish sauce served between two schmaltz fried potato latkes.
0
The Great Gatsby Sandwich
$12.50
Pastrami cured salmon, honey mustard, horseradish cream cheese and red onion, served on caraway seeded rye.
0
El Vincente Sandwich
$15.50
Lake sturgeon, plain cream cheese, fresh jalapenos and heirloom tomato (sour pickle when tomato is out of season) served on bagel or bialy.
0
The Spicy Red Sandwich
$12.00
Baked salmon salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.
0
The Spicy White Sandwich
$12.00
Smoked whitefish salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.
0
Spicy Blue Sandwich
$12.00
Smoked bluefish salad with roasted hazelnuts fennel and oranges, cucumber salad and Sriracha chili sauce, served on rye or pumpernickel.
0
The Holy Mackerel Sandwich
$9.25
Smoked peppered mackerel, Ben's vegetable cream cheese and cucumber salad served on a toasted bialy.
0
The $20 Smoked Salmon Sandwich
$20.00
Ruby red wild Alaskan sockeye salmon, butter, red onion, served on a toasted bialy.
0
The Whitefish Club
$12.00
Door county whitefish fillet, tomato, onion, jalapeno, cilantro and cream cheese on a bagel or bialy.
0
The Tribute Sandwich
$13.00
Door county smoked whitefish salad, horseradish cream cheese, wasabi tobiko, served on a bagel or bialy.
0
The Fishless Sandwich
$8.50
Tomato, pickled tomato, cilantro, jalapeno, red onion, apple horseradish sauce and mayonnaise served on a bagel or bialy.
0
Salads and SpreadsSalads and Spreads
Smoked Whitefish Salad
$14.50 - $22.00
0
Smoked Bluefish Salad with Oranges, Fennel and Roasted Hazelnuts
$13.00 - $20.00
0
Baked Salmon Salad
$14.50 - $22.00
0
Homemade Chopped Liver (Chicken Livers)
$8.50 - $12.99
0
Plain Cream Cheese
$4.79 - $7.25
0
Scallion Cream Cheese
$5.45 - $8.25
0
Lox Cream Cheese
$8.09 - $12.25
0
Whole Smoked FishWhole Smoked Fish
Whole Smoked Red Trout
$15.00
0
Whole Smoked Whitefish
$42.00
0
Bering Cisco
$21.00
Similar to chubs.
0
Hand Sliced Smoked Salmon, Lox and Cured SalmonHand Sliced Smoked Salmon, Lox and Cured Salmon
Hand Sliced Gaspe Nova Smoked Salmon for 2 People
$11.99
0
Hand Sliced New Brunswick Smoked Salmon for 2 People
$9.99
0
Hand Sliced Mild Scottish Salmon for 2 People
$12.99
0
Hand Sliced Double-Cure Irish Organic Salmon for 2 People
$12.99
0
Hand Sliced Wild King Salmon for 2 People
$14.99
0
Hand Sliced Ruby Red Wild Alaskan Sockeye for 2 People
$21.99
0
Hand Sliced Salty Belly Lox for 2 People
$11.99
0
Hand Sliced House Cured Gravlax for 2 People
$13.99
0
Specialty Sliced Smoked FishSpecialty Sliced Smoked Fish
Hand Sliced Smoked Sable for 2 People
$16.99
0
Hand Sliced Fatty Lake Sturgeon for 2 People
$17.99
0
HerringHerring
Small House Pickled Herring with Cream Sauce and Onions
$7.00
0
Small House Pickled Herring with Wine Sauce and Onions
$7.00
0
Small French Oak Smoked Herring Fillets
$8.50
0
Small Schmaltz Herring
$11.00
0
Small Matjes Herring
$11.00
0
SweetsSweets
1 lb. Homemade Assorted Rugelach
$14.50
0
Homemade Chocolate Babka
$14.50 - $40.00
0
Mama Ilene's Coconut Macaroons
$1.00
0
Homemade Honey Cake
$14.50 - $40.00
0
Chocolate Chip Cookies with Sea Salt
$4.00
Bag of five.
0
2 Pieces Raspberry Rugelach
$2.50
0
2 Pieces Apricot Rugelach
$2.50
0
2 Pieces Chocolate Lingonberry Rugelach
$2.50
0
2 Pieces Clementine and Ginger Rugelach
$2.50
0
DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.
People Are Reading
Popular Brands
-
Applebee's Menu2.7 -
Arby's Menu3.7 -
Burger King Menu3.4 -
Chick-fil-A Menu3.8 -
-
Cook Out Menu1.5 -
-
-
KFC Menu3.2 -
McDonald's Menu2.9 -
-
-
Pizza Hut Menu3.3 -
-
Wendy's Menu2.9 -
-
Red Lobster Menu1.4 -
-
-
