Sheffield's Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 137 votes
Sheffield's Logo
Bar Food
Barbecue

Choose My State

IL

Sheffield's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Starters

Sliders of the Week

Price may varies

Fried Green Tomato Sliders

$10.00

Served with arugula, goat cheese and jalapeno basil vinaigrette

Bucket-O-Bones

$14.00

Babyback ribs with onion strings

Bucket-O-Bones w/ 1/2 Pound of Wings

$18.00

BBQ Flat Bread

$10.00

Hickory smoked chicken, balsamic onions, coffee stout BBQ and cheddar or jack cheese on flat bread

Veggie Flat Bread

$10.00

Spinach, green onion, parsley, parmesan bechamel, grape tomatoes, marinated artichokes and shaved asiago and romano cheeses on flat bread

Wings

$12.00

A pound of free range chicken wings naked. Comes with Buffalo sauce and blue cheese or ranch dressing

Wings (1/2 order)

$7.00

A pound of free range chicken wings naked. Comes with Buffalo sauce and blue cheese or ranch dressing

Housemade BBQ Chips

$5.00

Served with Cajun dipping sauce

Hand Cut Fries

$5.00

Served with garlic aioli

Sweet Potato Fries

$6.00

Served with peppered maple mayo

Irish Nachos

$10.00

Potato chips, IPA queso, cumin crema, tomatillo, avocado relish, Jack Daniels BBQ sauce, pimentos, black beans, green onions, jalapenos, cilantro and guacamole. Add pulled chicken, pork or chopped br

BBQ Bites

$10.00

BBQ pulled pork, roasted red peppers, monterey jack in a fried wonton

Tasso and Cheese Platter

$14.00

House made tasso, apple bourbon chutney, welsh rarebit, pretzel crostini, hooks 3 year cheddar and water crackers

Smoked Marinara and Goat Cheese

$9.00

Served with grilled flat bread

Buffalo Chicken Rolls

$10.00

Smoked chicken, buffalo sauce, cheddar and monterey jack cheese in a fried wonton

Armadillo Eggs

$7.00

Panko coated, smoked brisket, pepper jack filled pickled jalepeno peppers with our BBQ ranch


SaladsDressings: champagne vinaigrette, balsamic vinaigrette, bbq ranch, ranch, bleu cheese and caesar. All of our salads, except the caesar are served with the dressing on the side

IPA Salad

$10.00

Spinach, beer battered fried asparagus, fresh mozzarella, pickled radishes, cucumbers, cherry tomato and IPA vinaigrette

IPA Salad with Grilled Chicken

$13.00

Sheffield's Salad

$9.00

Sliced apple, red onion, tomato, bleu cheese, candied pecans, mixed greens with champagne vinaigrette. Gluten-free

Sheffield's Salad with Grilled Chicken

$12.00

Caesar Salad

$7.00

Romaine lettuce, parmesan and brioche croutons

Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken

$10.00

Southern BBQ Salad

$12.00

Pulled chicken, pulled pork or beef brisket, mixed greens, roasted corn, tomatoes, monterey jack and cheddar cheeses, fried onions and BBQ ranch dressing


Soups 'N' Such

Chili

$7.00

Sheff's specialty chili made with our smoked brisket and pork, chorizo, bacon, peppers, beans and cheddar sour cream or onion

Veggie Chili

$6.00

White and black bean chili with a mix of peppers, corn, fire roasted tomatoes and tomatillos. Want cheese, sour cream or onion

Chicken Tomatillo Soup

$6.00

Served with tortilla chips, cilantro and queso fresco

Five Cheese Beer Mac and Cheese

$7.00

Cheddar, pepper jack, romano, asiago and parmesan, porter cheese sauce, pasta shells and panko crust. Add pulled pork, chicken or chopped brisket $10.00. Add bacon $1.00, add jalapenos or buffalo sau


BBQ PlattersAll platters are served with corn bread and coleslaw you choose: hand cut fries, potato salad, baked beans. Other sides may be substituted for an additional charge. Our BBQ sauces are made from scratch and served on the side coffee stout, sheffield's orig

Carolina Pulled Pork

$15.00

Fourteen hour slow smoked pork shoulder, hand pulled to order

Beef Brisket

$18.00

Smoked for eighteen hours over savory hickory and apple wood, sliced

BBQ Ribs

$17.00 - $23.00

Baby back ribs, dry rubbed, smoked and finished on the grill

Smoked Chicken Platter

$16.00

Free range chicken raised by amish farmers, marinated and then smoked for three hours

Combo Platter

$24.00

Choose any two: 6 oz pork or brisket, sausages, a quarter chicken or a half slab of ribs


Slap It on the BunSandwiches come with house made BBQ chips, hand cut fries, baked beans or potato salad. Other sides may be substituted for an additional charge. Bread choices include brioche bun, whole wheat or sliced brioche bread

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

$12.00

Marinated, three hour smoked free range chicken, lettuce, tomato, pepper jack cheese and alabama sauce

Brisket Sandwich

$12.00

Smoked beef brisket on a brioche bun. Sheffield's style: pimento cheese spread, pickled jalepenos and caramelized onions

Brisket Sandwich - Sheffield's Style

$14.00

Smoked beef brisket on a brioche bun. Sheffield's style: pimento cheese spread, pickled jalepenos and caramelized onions

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$10.00

Smoked for fourteen hours and pulled to order.

Pulled Pork Sandwich - Sheffield's Style

$12.00

Sheffield's style: coleslaw, melted pepper jack cheese, onion strings and carolina BBQ sauce

BLT

$11.00

Thick cut applewood smoked bacon, romaine, tomato and sriracha aioli on sliced brioche

Killer Grilled Cheese

$10.00

Aged cheddar, pepper jack and smoked gouda cheeses, tomato on sliced brioche or whole wheat

Killer Grilled Cheese with Bacon

$11.00

Aged cheddar, pepper jack and smoked gouda cheeses, tomato on sliced brioche or whole wheat

Killer Grilled Cheese with Pork or Brisket

$12.00

The Sheffield Stack

$12.00

Grilled chicken, pepper jack, crispy onions, cilantro, lettuce, tomato and ancho mayo on brioche bun

Veggie Burger

$12.00

Black bean, beet and brown rice burger topped with swiss cheese, arugula, tomato, red onion, pickle and a sun-dried tomato spread

Smoke Room Burger

$14.00

1/2 pound angus burger, burnt ends, aged cheddar, balsamic onions and tomato on a brioche bun

Peanut Butter Burger

$13.00

Smoked peanut butter, red onion, jalapeno, pepper jack cheese, bacon and a 1/2 pound angus burger on a brioche bun


BBQ Sauces

Coffee Stout

Price may varies

Sweet and spicy

Sheffield's Original Jack Daniels

Price may varies

Smoky and spicy

Vinegar Sauce

Price may varies


Sides

Corn Bread

$3.00

Carolina Coleslaw

$3.00

Baked Beans and Bacon

$4.00

Potato Salad

$4.00

Collard Greens

$4.00

Mac & Cheese

$4.00

Side Salad

$4.00

Gluten free


Desserts

Mud Pie

$4.00

Coffee and vanilla bean ice cream in an Oreo cookie crust, candied pecans, whipped cream and chocolate sauce


Desserts - Sweet Finish

Monkey Munch

$5.00

Chex, peanut butter, chocolate, bacon, banana chips and carmel corn

Sweet, Salty and Boozy

$6.00

Salt and pepper potato chips with three sweet dips: chocolate dragon's milk stout, bourbon caramel and framboise raspberry

Two Scoops

$5.00

Cracker jack ice cream with a shortbread cookie


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading