Schafer's Menu and Prices

4.1 based on 155 votes
Schafer's Logo

Choose My State

NY

Schafer's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Small Plates

Rhode Island Style Baked Clam Stuffies

$9.00

Stuffed cherrystone clams, chorizo, roasted corn, tomato.

Hummus Flat Bread

$8.00

Hummus, assorted flat breads, artichoke heart, roasted red grape tomato, cucumber, peppers kalamata olive, tzatziki yogurt sauce.

Pauls Calamari

$11.00

Fried calamari, cherry pepper rings, lemon, basil chiffonade, marinara, chipotle remoulade.

Pulled Pork Sliders

$9.00

Served on mini brioche rolls.

Tempura Rice Balls & Spicy Tuna

$11.00

Sushi style spicy tuna, tobiko, wakame, ponzu, pickled ginger, wasabi.

Crab Cake

$14.00

Chipotle remoulade, corn salsa.

Mussels & Andouille

$11.00

Prince edward island mussels, andouille sausage, garlic, white wine, lemon, thyme, tomatoes, scallion, crostini.

Mushroom & Beef Gratinee

$7.00

Caramelized shallots, braised beef, mushrooms, melted gruyere cheese, white truffle drizzle, toasted canape breads.

Steak House Fondue for Two

$14.00

Fondue of gruyere and aged dutch cheddar, steak frites, seared beef tips.

Tomato & Mozzarella Salad

$9.00

Ciligenie mozzarella balls, roasted grape tomatoes, red onion, basil, extra virgin olive oil, crostini

The Wedge

$9.00

Iceberg, tomato, cucumber, bacon and blue cheese dressing

House Salad

$9.00

Local field greens, pickled red onion, red grape tomato, spiced walnuts, gorgonzola, roasted peppers, carrot, cabernet sauvignon vinaigrette

Long Island Clam & Corn Chowder

$5.00


Seafood Bar & Sushi

Blue point Oysters ½ Dozen

$12.00

Classic cocktail sauce, chipotle mignonette, lemon

Littleneck Clams

$10.00

Classic cocktail sauce, chipotle mignonette, lemon

Colossal Shrimp Cocktail

$17.00

Classic cocktail sauce and tequila-lime sauce

Crab Cocktail

$17.00

Lump crab, cocktail sauce, tequila-lime sauce

Seafood Plateau for Two

$50.00

Blue point oysters, littleneck clams, shrimp cocktail, colossal lump crab, whole lobster, classic cocktail sauce, chipotle mignonette, tequila-lime sauce, lemon

Angry Tuna Roll

$10.00

Ahi tuna, tobiko, soy paper, sesame, dynamite sauce, pickled ginger, wasabi, ponzu

California Roll

$12.00

Crab, avocado, cucumber, soy paper, sesame, tobiko, pickled ginger, wasabi, soy

Lobster Avocado Roll

$14.00

Lobster, avocado, soy paper, mango, yuzu, ponzu, tobiko, pickled ginger, wasabi


Vegetarian Menu

Grilled Tofu & Ponzu Vegetable Stir-Fry

$19.00

Yuzu aioli, grilled tofu, asian vegetable stir-fry, roasted golden pineapple salsa, blood orange reduction

Cold Hummus Entree

$20.00

Hummus, assorted flat breads, marinated artichoke heart, roasted red grape tomato, cucumber, peppers kalamata olive, tzatziki yogurt sauce

Cavatappi Primavera

$18.00

Asparagus, roasted grape tomatoes, garlic, artichoke hearts, spinach, basil, cavatappi pasta


Specialty Plates

Horseradish Dijon Salmon & Potato Chive Pancake

$22.00

Pan seared north atlantic salmon, caramelized pearl onions, bacon and apple, horseradish dijon cream

Braised Boneless Beef Short Rib & Roasted Shallots

$23.00

Burgundy braised short rib, pancetta studded cheddar onion mashed, asparagus

Panko Crusted Tilapia

$20.00

Yuzu aioli, grilled tofu, asian vegetable stir-fry, roasted golden pineapple salsa, blood orange reduction

Wasabi & Crab Stuffed Flounder

$25.00

Blended wasabi potato & lump crab stuffing, grilled asparagus, lemon-basil hollandaise

Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna & Shrimp Fried Rice

$24.00

Cold kimchi, thai-mango sauce, pickled ginger, wasabi

Seafood Fra Diavalo

$27.00

Shrimp, scallops, lobster, prince edward island mussels, spicy tomato sauce, linguini

Chicken Cavatelli

$20.00

Sauteed chicken, tomato, basil, ricotta

Truffled Roasted Chicken & Lemon Garlic Risotto

$22.00

Roasted red grape tomatoes, demi glace, grilled asparagus grana padano

Sauteed Shrimp Caprese

$25.00

Shrimp, roasted grape tomatoes, garlic, white wine, basil, fresh mozzarella, garlic bread, cavatappi pasta

Chicken & Shrimp Jambalaya

$27.00

Chicken, shrimp, andouille sausage, bell peppers, onions, celery, tomato, dirty rice

Beer Battered Fish & Chips

$17.00

Tartar sauce, chipotle remoulade, cole slaw, steak fries, pickle.

Chicken Thomas

$19.00

Boneless chicken breast, tomato, provolone, caramelized shallot mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, demi glace, balsamic reduction.

Smothered NY Strip Steak

$30.00

Sauteed onions, portobello mushrooms, melted gruyere, caramelized shallot mashed, demi glace, grilled asparagus

Gorgonzola Crowned Filet Mignon & Cranberry Port Demi

$37.00

Potato chive pancake, caramelized pearl onions, apple & bacon.

Surf & Turf

$45.00

Grilled filet mignon, broiled lobster tail, caramelized shallot mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, demi glace, drawn butter.

Bacon Cheese Burger

$12.00

8 oz. Grilled angus burger, bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion straws, fries, cole slaw, pickle.

Lobster Roll

$23.00

Fresh lobster salad, herbed lemon mayo, croissant, cole slaw, pickle.

Simply Grilled

$13.00 - $24.00

Your choice of salmon, tuna, chicken or cod served over our house salad.

Lobster Tails

Price may varies

Caramelized shallot mashed potatoes, grilled asparagus, drawn butter, lemon.

Steamed Maine Lobster

Price may varies

Baked potato, grilled asparagus, drawn butter, lemon.

Crab Legs

Price may varies

Baked potato, grilled asparagus, drawn butter, lemon.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading