Sayville Modern Diner Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 178 votes
Sayville Modern Diner Logo

Choose My State

NY

Sayville Modern Diner Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Desserts

Chocolate Layer Cake

$2.75

Napoleon

$2.35

Lemon Meringue Pie

$2.75

Carrot Cake

$2.75

Strawberry Short Cake

$2.35

Plain Cheesecake

$3.25

Chocolate Horn

$2.25

Assorted Danish

$2.25

Pound Cake

$2.10

Lintzer Tart

$1.75

Black & White Cookie

$1.75

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$1.95

Apple Turnover

$1.75

All Fruit Pies: Blueberry, Apple, Cherry

$2.60

Jello

$1.85

Chocolate Pudding

$2.25

Rice Pudding

$2.25

Bread Pudding

$2.25


Beverages

Coffee Or Tea

$1.00

Decaffeinated Coffee

$1.00

Milk

$2.00

Chocolate Milk

$2.25

Iced Tea

$1.50

Iced Coffee

$1.50

Hot Chocolate

$1.25

Egg Cream

$2.25

Bottled Water

$1.50

Herbal Tea

$1.50

Seltzer

$1.00


House Wine

House Wine

$3.50

red, white, rose by the glass


Beers

Domestic

$3.35

Imported

$3.75


Milk Shakes

Milk Shakes

$3.25

assorted flavors: chocolate, vanilla, strawberry made with two scoops of ice cream


Soft Drinks

Soft Drinks

$1.95

coca cola, diet coke, sprite, root beer, lemonade


Ice Cream Sodas

Ice Cream Sodas

$3.75

assorted flavors: chocolate, vanilla, strawberry made with two scoops of ice cream and a cherry


Sundaes

Sundaes

$3.95

chocolate, vanilla or strawberry


Children's Menuchildren under 10 only pleas mother's take notice: baby bottles cheerfully warmed all served with jello or chocolate pudding with whipped cream or ice cream and milk, chocolate milk or small plain soda children's menu not available for take out

Monkey: Italian Spaghetti

$5.95

with meat or marinara sauce

Tiger: Grilled Cheese Sandwich

$5.95

with french fries

Zebra: Sliced Roast Turkey

$6.95

with dressing and giblet gravy

Mighty Mouse: Cheese Ravioli

$5.95

Superman Special: Hot Dog

$5.95

with french fries, lettuce and tomato

Lion: Sliced Roast Beef

$6.95

with vegetable and potato

Clown: Broiled Beef Patty

$6.95

with meat or marinara sauce

Batman: Chicken Fingers

$6.95

with french fries, lettuce and tomato


Soups

Soup Du Jour

$1.60 - $1.95

Homemade Onion Soup Gratinee

$3.35


Appetizers

Jalapeno And Cream Cheese Poppers

$6.55

Fried Calamari Rings

$6.75

Shrimp Cocktail

$8.95

Spinach Pie

$4.55

Dinner Greek Salad

$5.25

Fried Clams

$6.50

Chicken Fingers

$6.25

Potato Skins

$6.30

with bacon bits and cheddar cheese

Fried Popcorn Shrimp

$7.75

Stuffed Grape Leaves (6)

$3.75

Fried Mozzarella Sticks (7)

$5.25

with marinara sauce

Baked Stuffed Clams (5)

$5.75

Stuffed Mushrooms (4)

$5.75

Buffalo Wings

$6.50

Zucchini Sticks

$5.25

with bleu cheese

Chicken Fingers And French Fries

$7.75


Hot Open Sandwichesall above served with tossed salad or greek salad, potato and vegetable

Hot Roast Beef

$10.50

with brown gravy

Sliced Turkey

$10.50

with giblet gravy

Hot Corned Beef Or Pastrami

$10.50

Baked Meat Loaf

$10.50

Virginia Ham

$10.50


Greek Delights

Greek Pizza

$6.50

spinach and feta served on pita, topped with mozzarella

Greek Salad

$6.95

served with pita bread

Greek Salad Topped With Grilled Chicken

$10.50

Shrimp Santorini

$15.50

shrimp, feta cheese garlic and red wine sauce, served over rice pilaf with greek salad

Homemade Moussaka

$9.50

served with greek salad

Homemade Patitsio

$9.50

served with greek salad

Homemade Spinach Pie (2)

$9.50

with rice pilaf and greek salad


Greek Classicsabove served with french fries $1.50 extra, greek salad $2.50 extra

Souvlaki

$6.75

marinated chunks of pork topped with yogurt sauce on pita bread

Chicken Souvlaki

$6.75

marinated chunks of chicken topped with yogurt sauce on pita bread

Gyro On Pita Bread With Yogurt Sauce

$5.65

Chicken Gyro On Pita Bread

$5.65


Italian Specialtiesall above served with tossed salad or greek salad or soup

Penne Ala Vodka

$9.25

Spaghetti

$9.75

with meat sauce

Spaghetti

$8.75

with marinara sauce

Eggplant Parmigiana

$10.50

with spaghetti

Cheese Ravioli Parmigiana

$9.25

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$12.75

with spaghetti

Shrimp Parmigiana

$15.95

with spaghetti

Chopped Steak Parmigiana

$11.95

with spaghetti

Fish Cakes

$9.25

with spaghetti


Entreesall entrees served with tossed salad or greek salad or soup, potato and vegetable

Roast Prime Rib Of Beef, Au Jus

$15.95

Roast Top Sirloin Of Beef, Au Jus

$12.95

Roast Young Turkey

$11.95

with dressing and cranberry sauce

Roast Virginia Ham

$12.25

Half Broiled Chicken

$10.95

with scampi sauce

Half Roast Chicken

$10.25

with stuffing

Fried Chicken

$10.25

with french fries

Chopped Steak

$9.95

with onion rings


From The Landall above served with tossed salad or greek salad or soup, potato and vegetable

Rib Eye Steak

$14.95

with mushroom caps and onion rings

Sea & Land

$19.95

broiled roumanian steak, 2 stuffed shrimp and 2 stuffed mushrooms served with soup or salad, potato and vegetable

Chicken Ala Sayville

$15.95

broiled chicken breast with broccoli, artichokes and fresh mushrooms, topped with mozzarella cheese, served with soup or salad, potato and vegetable

N.Y. Cut Sirloin Steak

$16.50

with french fries, onion rings & mushroom caps

Broiled Roumanian Steak

$14.95

with french fries and onion rings

London Broil

$13.95

with onion rings and mushroom sauce

Sugar Cured Hawaiian Ham Steak

$11.95

Beef Liver

$9.95

with bacon and onions

Two Broiled Pork Chops

$12.95


Seafood Delightsall above served with tossed salad or greek salad or soup, potato and vegetable

Broiled Filet Of Sole

$14.25

with lemon butter and herbs

Broiled Shrimp

$15.50

with scampi sauce

Broiled Swordfish

$14.50

Broiled Salmon

$14.50

Stuffed Baked Clams

$10.95

with spaghetti

Stuffed Filet

$15.50

with crabmeat or spinach and feta cheese

Stuffed Shrimp

$14.95

with crabmeat, garlic butter and herbs

Fried Filet Of Sole

$12.25

with tartar sauce

Fried Scallops

$13.95

with tartar sauce

Fried Shrimp

$14.85

with tartar sauce

Fried Seafood Combination Platter

$15.95

shrimp, scallops, filet of sole and fried clams

Broiled Fisherman's Platter

$17.95

stuffed shrimp, stuffed filet, scallops and stuffed clam

Broiled Seafood Combo

$18.25

filet of sole, shrimp, scallops and baked clams

Fried Popcorn Shrimp In The Basket

$10.95

with french fries served with soup or salad

Fried Clams

$10.25

with french fries, lettuce and tomato served with soup or salad


Side Orders

Disco Fries

$5.25

curly fries with melted cheese and gravy

Curly Fries

$3.75

Curly Slaw

$1.85

Cottage Cheese

$2.50

French Fries

$2.75

French Fries With Cheese

$4.75

Potato Salad

$1.85

Tossed Salad

$3.50

Bacon, Ham Or Sausage

$2.50

Onion Rings

$4.65

Vegetable Du Jour

$1.80

Home Fries

$2.75

Corned Beef Hash

$3.50

Canadian Bacon

$3.50

Spaghetti

$4.55

with marinara sauce


Burger Cornerburger served with cole slaw and pickle deluxe burgers served with french fries, onion rings, homemade cole slaw, lettuce, tomato and pickle, burger Extra: cheese $1.00, fried onions $0.50, tomato $0.50, sauteed mushrooms $1.25, bacon $1.50

Beefburger

$3.95 - $5.95

Cheeseburger

$4.45 - $6.45

Pizza Burger

$5.25 - $7.25

Twin Burger

$7.50 - $9.50

Twin Cheeseburger

$8.70 - $10.70

Buffalo Burger

$5.45 - $7.45

Veggie Burger

$4.65 - $6.65

Turkey Burger

$4.15 - $6.15

Texas Burger

$7.20 - $9.20

with mushrooms, fried onions, peppers and cheddar cheese

Patty Melt

$5.70 - $7.70

cheeseburger on grilled rye with fried onions

Happy Days Burger

$7.95 - $9.95

with ham, bacon, cheese and fried onions


Lo-Carb Salads

Salad Supreme

$8.95

egg salad, tuna salad and chicken salad over romaine lettuce

Sayville Salad

$9.95

romaine lettuce with chicken breast or turkey, bacon, tomatoes, onions and mushrooms topped with cheddar cheese and hard boiled egg


Wrapsserved with a cup of soup and french fries

Tuna Salad Wrap

$7.95

with lettuce and tomato

Chicken Salad Wrap

$7.95

with lettuce and tomato

Grilled Chicken Wrap

$8.95

grilled chicken, sauteed onions, peppers, tomato and american cheese

Philly Steak Wrap

$8.95

with sauteed onion, peppers and american cheese

Turkey Wrap

$7.95

with lettuce & tomato

Egg Salad Wrap

$6.95

with bacon, lettuce and tomato

Roast Beef Wrap

$7.95

with lettuce, tomato and american cheese

Gyro Wrap

$9.95

with lettuce, tomato sauteed onions peppers and feta cheese

Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

$8.95

Chicken Parmigiana Wrap

$9.95

Pork Souvlaki Wrap

$8.95

Turkey, Bacon And Cheddar Wrap

$8.95

lettuce and tomatoes


Sandwichessandwiches with tomato $0.50 extra with cheese $1.00 extra english muffin, bagel or roll or pita $0.50 extra all sandwiches served with cole slaw and pickle. deluxe your sandwich add french fries for $1.50 extra

One Egg, Cooked To Order

$2.15

One Egg, Cooked To Order

$3.60

with ham, bacon or sausage

Western Egg

$3.85

Frankfurter On A Bun

$2.50

Meat Loaf

$4.95

Bacon, Lettuce And Tomato

$4.40

Virginia Ham

$5.25

Grilled American Or Swiss Cheese

$3.95

Grilled American Or Swiss Cheese

$4.30

with tomato

Grilled American Or Swiss Cheese

$4.75

with ham or bacon

Grilled American Or Swiss Cheese

$5.15

with canadian bacon

Chopped Egg Salad

$3.85

Chopped Egg Salad

$4.85

with bacon

Shrimp Salad

$4.95

Tuna Fish Salad

$4.85

Chicken Salad

$4.85

Fried Filet Of Sole

$6.95

Ind. Salmon

$6.95

with lettuce and tomato

Ind. Sardines

$4.95

with lettuce and tomato

Ind. Tuna

$5.25

with lettuce and tomato

Roast Vermont Turkey

$6.25

Prime Roast Beef

$6.25

Corned Beef

$6.25

Roumanian Pastrami

$6.25


Triple Deckersserved with potato salad or french fries, cole slaw and pickle

Sliced Turkey

$7.95

with bacon, lettuce and tomato

Chicken Salad

$6.95

bacon, lettuce and tomato

Egg Salad

$6.85

bacon, lettuce and tomato

Tuna Salad

$7.15

sliced egg, bacon, lettuce and tomato

Roast Sirloin Of Beef, Swiss Cheese

$7.95

lettuce and tomato

Bacon Lettuce And Tomato

$6.25


Chicken Sandwichesserved on a hard roll with cole slaw and pickle

Grilled Chicken Breast

$6.75

Garlic Chicken Melt

$7.95

with melted mozzarella

Chicken Parmigiana

$8.95

Golden Flash

$9.95

grilled chicken with sauteed mushrooms, fried onions, bacon and cheese

Grilled Chicken Breast

$8.25

with broccoli and melted cheddar cheese


...

Main Street

$8.25

corned beef or pastrami, or roast beef or turkey with melted swiss cheese served with french fries and pickle

Modern Classic

$9.25

grilled roast beef on toasted pita with peppers, onions and tomatoes topped with melted mozzarella

Tuna Melt

$6.65

tuna salad with melted american cheese on choice of bread served with french fries, onion rings, lettuce and tomato, cole slaw and pickle

Deli Duo Twin Sandwich

$9.25

corned beef, turkey, pastrami or roast beef on hard roll your choice of two meats served with french fries

French Dip

$8.95

roast beef with melted mozzarella cheese on a hard roll, served in au jus sauce with french fries

Reuben Sandwich

$7.75

corned beef and sauerkraut on rye bread topped with melted swiss, cole slaw, potato salad and pickle

Open Philly Steak

$7.95

with american cheese and fried onions on a roll served with french fries

London Broil

$10.50

served on a roll with french fries, lettuce, tomato and onion rings

Veggie Pizza

$8.95

grilled vegetables on a pita bread topped with mozzarella pizza sauce


Cold Salads Plattersabove platters served with lettuce tomato, cole slaw and potato salad

Chef's Salad

$8.95

julienne turkey, virginia ham, roast top sirloin of beef, swiss cheese, american cheese, sliced egg and choice of dressing

Egg Salad Platter

$7.75

Tropical Health Platter

$7.50

a mixture of chilled fruits on a bed of crisp lettuce, topped with cottage cheese and jello

Whole Shrimp

$13.95

with sliced egg and cocktail sauce

Spinach Salad

$7.45

a bowl of fresh spinach with crumbled bacon, fresh mushrooms and sliced egg, garni light vinaigrette dressing

Tunafish Salad

$8.75

with sliced egg

Spinach Salad

$10.45

with grilled chicken

Individual Tuna

$8.95

with sliced egg

Caesar Salad

$6.75

with pita bread

Freshly Made Shrimp Salad

$8.95

with sliced egg

Caesar Salad

$9.75

topped with grilled chicken

Individual Salmon

$9.95

with sliced egg

Chicken Salad Platter

$7.95

with sliced egg


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading