Sayville Gourmet Deli Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 98 votes
Sayville Gourmet Deli Logo
Deli Food

Choose My State

NY

Sayville Gourmet Deli Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Gourmet Salads

Fitness Salad

$6.99

Cool creamy cottage cheese and fresh fruit salad over a bed of lettuce, topped with nuts & raisins

Cobb Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Mixed greens, bleu cheese, sliced egg, bacon, tomatoes, grilled chicken

Chef Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Crispy Iceburg lettuce with turkey, ham, cheese, eggs, tomato & cucumber.

Cranberry Field Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Mixed greens, gorgonzola cheese, cranberries, walnuts, grilled chicken with raspberry vinagrette

Caesar Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Hearts of romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, shaved romano cheese with our homemade caesar dressing

Caesar Salad with Chicken

$6.99 - $7.99

Greek Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Fresh iceberg with cucumbers, tomato, red onion, black olives & feta cheese.

Chicken Cutlet Club

$6.99 - $7.99

Breaded chicken cutlet strips, cheddar cheese, bacon bits & sliced hard boiled egg over a bed of lettuce.

Classic Spinach Salad

$6.99 - $7.99

Fresh baby spinach leaves, topped with mushrooms, red onions, bacon, hard boiled eggs & crumbled bleu cheese


Sayville Deli Salad BarAdd a scoop of: egg salad $2.59, tuna salad $2.99, chicken salad $2.99. Dressings: classic italian, greek, chipolte ranch, creamy italian, country french, ranch, honey mustard, chunky bleu cheese, thousand island, olive oil & vinegar, red wine vinegar

Sayville Deli Salad Bar

$2.99 - $3.99

Lettuce Selection

Price may varies

Iceberg, romaine, baby spinach, mixed field greens chopped or tossed

Toppings Selection

Price may varies

Toppings $0.50 each: cucumbers, mushrooms, red onions, shredded carrots, broccoli florets, black olives, green olives, chick peas/garbanza beans, bell peppers, hot peppers, banana peppers, croutons,


Salad SandwichesSandwiches served on white, rye or whole wheat. All of our salads are made with hellmanÂ’s mayonnaise. Sandwich extras: roll $ 0.25, bagel $ 0.50, hero $ 1.00, 7-grain roll $0.50, lettuce $ 0.25, tomato $ 0.50, roast peppers $ 0.75, hot peppers $ 0.50, che

Egg Salad

$4.50

Tuna Salad & Low Fat Tuna Salad

$5.75

Chicken Salad

$5.75

Seafood Salad

$6.50

Shrimp Salad

$7.50


Wrap SandwichesSandwich extras: roll $ 0.25, bagel $ 0.50, hero $ 1.00, 7-grain roll $0.50, lettuce $ 0.25, tomato $ 0.50, roast peppers $ 0.75, hot peppers $ 0.50, cheese $ 0.60, fresh mozzarella $ 1.00, bacon $ 1.00, pickle $ 0.50.

Main Street Wrap

$6.99

Field greens, chicken, cranberries, gargonzola cheese, raspberry vinaigrette on a herb garlic wrap

Old Dock Wrap

$6.99

Roast beef, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, horseradish sauce, on a herb garlic wrap

The Godfather Wrap

$6.99

Salami, ham cappy, provolone, lettuce, tomato. onions, on a herb garlic wrap

Garden Wrap

$6.99

Grilled vegetables, mozzarella, honey mustard on a spinach wrap

Deli Wrap

$6.99

Turkey, swiss, lettuce, tomato on a honey wheat wrap


Hero SandwichesSandwich extras: roll $ 0.25, bagel $ 0.50, hero $ 1.00, 7-grain roll $0.50, lettuce $ 0.25, tomato $ 0.50, roast peppers $ 0.75, hot peppers $ 0.50, cheese $ 0.60, fresh mozzarella $ 1.00, bacon $ 1.00, pickle $ 0.50.

Italian Deluxe Combo

$7.99

Capicolla, salami, pepperoni, & provolone with lettuce, tomato,onions, oil & vinegar

The All-American

$7.99

Ham, turkey, roast beef, american cheese, lettuce & tomato

Manhattan Special

$7.99

Hot roast beef, melted mozzarella, sauteed onions on a toasted garlic hero

Philly Steak

$7.99

Hot roast beef & cheddar, sauteed onions, peppers & mushrooms

The Soho

$7.99

Marinated grilled chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, bbq sauce on a toasted garlic hero

The Harvest

$7.99

Chicken salad, swiss cheese, red onion, lettuce & tomato with honey mustard


Burgers8 oz. on fresh roll.

Plain Burger

$4.50

Cheese Burger

$5.00

Veggie Burger

$5.00

Turkey Burger

$5.50

Pizza Burger

$5.50

Topped with mozzarella & sauce

Southwest Burger

$5.50

Topped with pepper jack cheese, bacon, & chipolte sauce

Buffalo Burger

$5.50

Burger, buffalo sauce, bacon, bleu cheese dressing, & red onions

Sayville Burger

$5.50

Burger, bacon, cheese, mushrooms, & onions

Deluxe Burger

Price may varies

With french fries cole slaw, pickles, lettuce & tomato Add 2.50. Extra cheese -$0.50, bacon - $0.50, onions - $0.25, mushrooms - $0.50, lettuce - $0.50, tomato - $0.50


Comfort Food

Grilled Cheese

$4.50

Bacon Lettuce & Tomato

$5.99

Cheddar & pepper jack cheeses with diced tomatoes & peppers with chicken add $2.00

Pizza Bagel

$4.00

Fish N Chips

$6.99

Codfish 4 pieces & French Fries Chicken Fingers

$6.99

4 pieces with Honey Mustard Fried Flounder Filet (2 piece)

$6.99

French Fries

$2.49 - $3.49


Carving Board

Premium Sandwichs on White, Rye, or Whole Wheat

$5.50

Roast beef, cajon roast beef, corned beef, pastrami #1 deluxe ham, honey ham, virginia ham, turkey breast honey, maple turkey, smoked turkey, peppermill turkey, salsalito turkey, chicken breast, buff

Specialty Sandwichs on White, Rye, or Whole Wheat

$5.75

Fresh turkey, breaded chicken cutlets, grilled chicken cutlets

Economy Sandwichs on White, Rye, or Whole Wheat

$4.50


PaniniÂ’s

The Captain

$7.49

Cracked peppermill turkey, pepperjack cheese, lettuce & tomato with chipolte ranch

Italian Stallion

$7.49

Genoa salami, ham cappy, provolone & roasted peppers with pesto

Sicilian

$7.49

Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & tomato with pesto

Chicken Delight

$7.49

Boars head chicken breast, alpine lace swiss, romaine lettuce & tomato w/fat free raspberry vinaigrette

The Smoker

$7.49

Smoked turkey, mozzarella, roasted peppers & romaine lettuce with chipolte mayo

Steakhouse Supreme

$7.49

Roast beef, munster cheese, sauteed onions, lettuce and thousand island dressing

The Cuban

$7.49

Virginia ham, fresh turkey, swiss, sliced pickles & mustard

Napolitano

$7.49

Sliced breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella, tomato & roasted peppers

Buffalo Bill

$7.49

Breaded chicken cutlets, blue cheese crumbles, romaine lettuce & hot sauce

Cranberry Field

$7.49

Smoked turkey, brie, dried cranberries & field greens with honey mustard

Sayville Bomber

$7.49

Smoked turkey, fresh mozzarella, plum tomatoes, roasted peppers, balsamic vinegar

The Villager

$7.49

Honey maple turkey, sliced red onion, tomatoes, romaine lettuce, honey mustard

California Club

$7.49

Cracked pepper turkey, provolone, roasted peppers, sliced red onions and mayo

Godfather 11

$7.49

Prosciutto, genoa salami, mozzarella, leaf lettuce, sliced tomato, red onions with pesto

The Ferry

$7.49

Smoked turkey, sundried tomatoes, mozzarella, with romaine lettuce & balsamic vinaigrette

Chicken Rustica

$7.49

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, & roasted peppers, try with pesto or honey mustard

Rustic Vegetarian

$7.49

Grilled vegetables, fresh mozzarella, romaine lettuce try with pesto or honey mustard

The Packer

$7.49

Virginia ham, swiss, field greens, honey mustard


Specialty SandwichesAdd $1.00 for hero

The Sayville Special

$6.99

Cranberry walnut chicken salad with lettuce, tomatoes on a whole wheat roll

The Sunset

$6.99

Cracked peppermill turkey, muenster cheese, bacon, onions, russian dressing on roll

Black Forest Delight

$6.99

Honey maple turkey, swiss, lettuce & tomato, russian dressing on rye

Roast Beef or Turkey Melt

$6.99

Roast beef or turkey, cheddar & bacon on a roll

Grilled or Breaded Chicken Cutlet

$6.99

Fresh chicken cutlet on white, rye, or whole wheat

The Montauk Special

$6.99

Chicken cutlet, virginia ham, melted swiss with honey mustard on a roll

Bayman Special

$6.99

Cajun roast beef, melted cheddar, lettuce & tomato, with chipolte mayo on a roll

The Boardwalk

$6.99

Turkey bacon, lettuce tomato & mayo on rye

Western BBQ Club

$6.99

Cajun roast beef, onions, melted monterey jack cheese, bbq sauce on a club roll

Old Smokey Club

$6.99

Smoked turkey, virginia ham, red onion, melted monterey jack cheese on a club roll

Peppermill Club

$6.99

Peppermill turkey, melted munster cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a club roll

Sayville Club

$6.99

Virginia ham, bacon, melted cheddar, russian dressing

Chicken Blt Club

$6.99

Our famous chicken salad, bacon, lettuce & tomato

Vermont Croissant

$6.99

Honey maple turkey, mozzarella, lettuce & tomato on a croissant

Rueben On Rye

$6.99

Grilled corned beef, swiss & sauerkraut on rye


Side Orders

French Fries

$2.49 - $3.49

Onion Rings

$2.49 - $3.49

Hot Wings

$4.75

Mozzarella Sticks (6 pc.)

$4.50


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading