Sarah Cafe Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 166 votes
Sarah Cafe Logo
Coffee

Choose My State

NY

Sarah Cafe Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Soup

Soup Du Jour

$4.25 - $4.95

Daily fresh soup served with a buttered bagel.


House Specialty SaladsHalf-pound.

Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

$6.95

Grilled chicken, crispy lettuce and parmesan tossed with home-made caesar dressing.

American Cobb Salad

$6.95

Grilled chicken, bacon, avocado, roasted peppers, crispy romaine lettuce and balsamic vinaigrette.

Garden Tuna Salad

$6.95

On a bed of mixed greens and avocado, tossed with balsamic vinaigrette and lemon juice.

Greek Salad

$6.95

Feta cheese, chopped tomatoes, black olives, red onions, scallions, mixed peppers and crispy romaine lettuce tossed in house balsamic vinaigrette and extra virgin olive oil.

Grilled Chicken Almond Salad

$6.95

On a bed of mixed greens, grilled chicken, sweet corn, sliced almonds and mixed peppers. Served with toast and raspberry vinaigrette.


Toss Your Own SaladOver organic mixed greens or crispy romaine lettuce. served with your choice of bagel or bread. Salad dressing - choose one, fat-free italian dressing, fat-free raspberry vinaigrette, fat-free ranch dressing, fat-free caesar dressing, balsamic vinaigrette

Toss Your Own Salad

$7.50 - $9.00

Choice Of Roll Or Bagel

Price may varies

Choose one - kaiser roll, whole wheat bagel, sesame bagel, poppy seed bagel, plain bagel, cinnamon raisin bagel, onion bagel, everything bagel. With butter $0.50

Your Choice Of Ingredients

Price may varies

Optional - select as many as you like chopped tomato, carrots, green peas, kidney beans, corn, cucumber, scallions, green olives, hard-boiled egg, fresh mozzarella, parmesan cheese, feta cheese, broc

Dressing Placement

Price may varies

Choose one - dressing mixed in, dressing on the side.


Signature SandwichesOn your choice of bread, wrap or french baguette. With chips, kosher pickles over a bed of mixed greens.

Chicken Club Sandwich

$8.95

Grilled chicken, avocado, bacon and swiss cheese.

Zesto Cutlet Sandwich

$8.95

Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato and house sauce.

Down The River Sandwich

$8.95

Turkey, bacon, avocado, swiss, lettuce and tomato and mayo.

Hot Italian Sandwich

$8.95

Genoa salami, black forest ham, onions, red peppers, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and house sauce.

Cordon Bleu Sandwich

$8.95

Grilled chicken, ham, swiss, dijon, lettuce and tomato.

Cobb Sandwich

$8.95

Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes and house balsamic vinaigrette.

Zesto Pastrami

$8.95

Sandwich fresh sliced pastrami, melted swiss, lettuce, tomatoes and spicy mustard.

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$8.95

Sliced buffalo chicken breast, onions, lettuce, tomatoes and house sauce.


WrapsAll-natural ingredients. Served with chips and kosher pickles.

Caesar Wrap

$7.95

Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes and caesar dressing.

Tuna Wrap

$7.95

Tuna salad, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo.

French Wrap

$7.95

Smoked turkey, imported french brie with honey mustard.

Fajita Wrap

$7.95

Grilled chicken, salsa, cheddar, roasted peppers, onions and guacamole.

San Francisco Wrap

$7.95

Grilled chicken, avocado, roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes and ranch dressing.

Cuban Wrap

$7.95

Ham, turkey, swiss, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles and mustard.

Veggie Wrap

$7.95

Assorted grilled veggies, fresh mozzarella and vinaigrette.

Italiano Wrap

$7.95

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, pepper and pesto.

Veggie Tuna Wrap

$7.95

Tuna with no mayo, lettuce, tomato and avocado.


Grilled PaniniOn flat european bread. Served with chips & kosher pickles.

Chicken Italiano Panini

$7.95

Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted pepper and pesto sauce.

Copenhagen Panini

$7.95

Turkey, swiss, coleslaw and russian dressing.

Tuna Melt Panini

$7.95

Tuna salad, american cheese, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.

Cuban Panini

$7.95

Layers of ham, turkey, cheddar, mustard, lettuce, tomatoes and pickles.

Eggplant Parmesan Panini

$7.95

Grilled eggplant, mozzarella, marinara sauce and parmesan cheese.

Chicken Fajita Panini

$7.95

Chicken, salsa, roasted peppers, cheddar and onions.

Chicken Parmesan Panini

$7.95

Grilled chicken, marinara and mozzarella.

Mediterranean Panini

$7.95

Assorted grilled veggies, fresh mozzarella, vinaigrette and hummus.

Russian Panini

$7.95

Roast beef, muenster cheese, onions, lettuce tomatoes, and russian dressing.

Capri Panini

$7.95

Smoked turkey, provolone, cherry tomatoes and house balsamic.

Turkey Melt Panini

$7.95

Roasted turkey, french brie, lettuce and dijon.


Create Your Own Wrap Or PaniniChoose up to 3 fillings. Complementary lettuce & tomato.

Create Your Own Wrap Or Panini

$7.95

Turkey, salami, pastrami, american cheese, cheddar cheese, mozzarella cheese, ham, roast beef, roasted chicken, swiss cheese, provolone cheese, brie cheese.


On The PitaServed on whole-wheat or fresh plain pita bread.

Grilled Veggie Pita

$6.95

Hummus, assorted grilled veggies and lettuce.

Baba Ganoush Pita

$6.95

Eggplant, hummus and baba ganoush.

Greek Pita

$6.95

Feta cheese, tomatoes, black olives, cucumber, lettuce, red onions and mixed peppers.


BakeryBaked fresh daily.

Large Butter Croissant

$2.00

Yogurt Flavored Muffin

$2.00

Cookie

$1.00

Scone

$2.50

Apple Turnover

$2.50

Slice Of Cake

$4.25

Giant Cookies

$2.50

Classic Muffin

$2.00

Slice Of Pound Cake

$2.00

Danish

$2.50

Flavored Croissant

$2.50

Cinnamon Roll

$2.50

Jumbo Macaroons

$2.75

Rugelach

$0.95


Eggs And MoreServed all day.

Two Eggs

$2.75

On fresh-baked roll or bagel.

Two Eggs And Ham

$4.50

Or bacon on roll or bagel.

Eggs And Cheese

$4.25

On fresh-baked croissant.

Cheese Omelet Wrap

$4.95

Western Omelet

$5.95

With choice of bread.

Veggie Omelet

$5.95

With choice of bread.

Side Of Bacon

$4.25

Two Eggs And Cheese

$3.50

On fresh- baked roll or bagel.

Bacon, Eggs And Cheese

$5.25

On fresh- baked croissant.

Bacon, Egg Whites, Avocado

$5.95

Avocado and swiss wrap.

Three Cheese Omelet Wrap

$5.95

Ham Brie Omelet

$5.95

With choice of bread.

Greek Omelet

$5.95

With choice of bread.


Breakfast SpecialtiesServed all day.

Fresh- Baked Bagel

$1.00

Bagel

$2.25

With cream cheese.

Low- Fat Veggie

$2.95

Or scallion cream cheese on a bagel.

Egg On A Bagel

$2.75

Ham And Brie

$5.25

On a croissant.

Egg Salad

$5.95

On a bagel.

Tuna And Horseradish

$5.95

On a bagel.

Nova Lox

$7.95

With cream cheese on a bagel.

Fruit Cup

$4.25

Hot Oatmeal

$2.75 - $3.50

Served with cinnamon and raisins.

Belgian Waffle

$5.25

With Fresh Fruit served with maple syrup.

Fresh- Baked Bagel

$1.55

With butter.

Scallion Or Veggie Cream Cheese

$2.95

On a bagel.

Strawberry Cream Cheese

$2.95

On a bagel.

BLT

$4.95

On your choice of bread.

Lox Spread

$4.45

On a bagel.

Mayo-Free Tuna Salad

$5.95

On a bagel.

Mayo-Free Chicken Salad

$5.95

On a bagel.

Grilled Cheese

$5.95

Yogurt Parfait

$4.25

Low-fat yogurt with granola, fresh fruit.

Butter Belgian Waffle

$4.50

Served with maple syrup.

Double Eggs Over Belgian Waffle

$5.25

Served with maple syrup.


Beverages

Vitamin Water

$2.75

Flavored Soda

$1.50

Flavored Snapple

$2.25

Fresh OJ

$4.25

Red Bull

$3.00

Tropicana Juice

$2.50

Poland Spring Water

$1.50

Naked Juice

$4.25

Honest Tea

$2.75

Chocolate Milk

$2.50


Espresso Bar

Espresso

$2.50 - $3.00

100% Arabica Coffee

$1.75 - $2.25

Cafe Au Lait

$2.75 - $3.75

Latte

$3.25 - $4.75

Americano

$3.00 - $4.25

Extra Shot Of Espresso

$1.00

Frozen Caramel Mocha

$4.25 - $5.25

Gallon Of 100% Arabica Coffee

$14.95

Serves 10.

Macchiato

$3.25 - $4.00

Flavored Coffee

$1.75 - $2.25

Cappuccino

$3.25 - $4.75

Red Eye

$2.75 - $3.25

Mochaccino

$3.75 - $5.25

Hot Cocoa

$2.25 - $3.25

Iced Cappuccino

$4.25 - $5.25

Frozen Mochaccino

$4.25 - $5.25


Tea Time

House Tea

$1.75 - $2.25

Flavored Mighty Tea

$2.00 - $2.75

Iced Coffee

$3.00 - $4.00

Flavored Tazo Tea

$2.00 - $2.75

Herbal Tea

$2.00 - $2.75

Iced Tea

$3.00 - $4.00


Fresh Fruit Smoothies16 ounce / 24 ounce.

Fresh Fruit Smoothie

$4.95 - $5.95

Power Up Smoothie

$4.95 - $5.95

Berries, banana, ginseng and orange juice.

Sarah`s Choice Smoothie

$4.95 - $5.95

Banana, strawberry, pineapple, low-fat yogurt and soy milk.

Island Run Smoothie

$4.95 - $5.95

Pineapple, watermelon, berries and lemon juice.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading