Sam's Coney Island Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 154 votes
Sam's Coney Island Logo
Diner

Choose My State

MI

Sam's Coney Island Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Soups & Salads

Homemade Soup

$1.99 - $2.39

Homemade Chili

$2.25 - $2.59

Soup & Salad Combo

$4.89

Soup of the day with a dinner salad and a pita bread

Skinny Dinner

$6.89

Grilled chopped steak with slices of tomatoes, cottage cheese and crackers

Julienne

$6.79

Ham or turkey, tomatoes, hard boiled eggs and shredded cheese

Greek

$6.99

Ham or turkey, tomatoes, feta cheese, beets, greek olives, hard boiled eggs and pepperoncini. Add chicken in place of ham or turkey $2.00

Grilled Chicken

$7.09

Marinated chicken breast strips tomatoes and hard boiled egg

Fried Chicken

$7.29

Deep fried chicken breast strips with tomatoes, hard boiled egg and shredded cheese

Dinner Salad

$3.09

Served with a pita bread


PastaServed with garlic bread and soup or salad

Spaghetti with Meat Sauce

$8.49

Chicken Parmesan

$8.99

Topped with spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese


SandwichesSubstitution: Onion rings add $1.00, fried mushrooms add $1.30, chili fried add $1.30, chili cheese fries add $1.70

Chicken Fillet

$6.79

Deep fried chicken breast on a french or kaiser bun with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo

Marinated Chicken

$6.99

Grilled marinated chicken breast on a french or kaiser bun, or pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes and mayo

Patty Melt

$6.09

Ground beef with swiss cheese and grilled onions served on grilled rye bread

Tuna Melt

$6.49

With swiss cheese served on grilled rye bread

Chicken Melt

$6.79

Grilled marinated chicken breast on grilled rye bread with swiss cheese and grilled onions

Reuben

$6.99

Corned beef or turkey with sauerkraut on grilled rye bread with swiss cheese

Rachel Reuben

$6.99

Corned beef or turkey with coleslaw and swiss cheese on grilled rye bread

Club Sandwich

$7.19

Slices of turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo

Fish Sandwich

$6.99

Two fresh fillets of cod topped with lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce

B.L.T.

$6.89

Served with coleslaw and fries

Grilled Cheese

$3.19

Grilled Cheese with Ham or Turkey

$4.19

Ham or Turkey

$6.29

Served on a french or kaiser bun, croissant or pita bread with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$7.19

Deep fried chicken breast topped with spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese on a french bun


Pita SandwichesServed with fries

Greek Gyro

$6.09

Sliced gyro meat with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and gyro sauce on a pita bread

Chicken Gyro

$6.99

Grilled marinated chicken breast strips with lettuce, tomatoes, onions and gyro sauce on a pita bread

Steak or Chicken Philly

$6.99

Your choice of shaved lean beef or grilled marinated chicken breast scrips with grilled onions and swiss cheese on a pita bread

Chicken Wrap

$6.99

Tender chicken strips wrapped in a pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes and cheese


BurgersAdd olives to any burger $0.25

Double Deck Cheeseburger Combo

$7.99

Half pound with cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo. Served with coleslaw and fries. Add bacon $1.35, sandwich only $5.39

Hamburger

$3.49

Cheeseburger

$3.69

Cheeseburger & Fries

$5.39

Bacon Cheeseburger

$4.29

Mushroom Cheeseburger

$4.29

Bacon & Mushrooms Cheeseburger

$4.49


Seafood

Seafood Platter

$11.19

A selection of clams, jumbo shrimp and cod

Fried Clams

$8.29

Strips of fresh clams fried to a golden brown

Fish & Clam Combo

$9.99

Two cod fillers and clams

Combo

$10.39

Two cod fillets and four jumbo shrimp

Fish & Chips (3 Pcs)

$9.49

Fish & Chips (2 Pcs)

$8.69

Lemon Pepper Cod (3 Pcs)

$9.49

Grilled cod fillets with lemon pepper seasoning

Lemon Pepper Cod (2 Pcs)

$8.69

Grilled cod fillets with lemon pepper seasoning

Shrimp Basket

$8.49

Golden fried served with cocktail sauce

Jumbo Shrimp

$10.49

Eight pieces of jumbo shrimp fried to golden brown


Coneys

Hot Dog

$1.99

Coney Island

$2.39

Hot dog topped with spiced ground beef, fresh onions and mustard

Chili Dog

$2.29

Hot dog topped with chili, fresh onions and mustard


Combos

Coney Dog & Fries

$4.09

Chili Dog & Fries

$4.49


Dinner MenuAll dinners are served with your choice of two sides: Soup, salad, potatoes, coleslaw, cotage cheese or applesauce

Steak & Shrimp

$12.89

New york strip 8oz. grilled to order, served with four jumbo shrimp alongside

Center Cut Pork Chops

$9.09

Three boneless center cut chops

Fried Chicken

$11.09

Four pieces deep fried to a golden brown

Chicken Strips

$9.29

Tender strips deep fried to a golden brown

Hamburger Steak

$8.49

Topped with sauteed onions

Smothered Chicken

$9.39

Marinated chicken breasts topped with sauteed onions, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese

Baked Ham Steak

$8.39

Grilled center cut ham with a pineapple rings

Roast Beef

$9.39

Tender slices of beef topped with brown gravy

Chicken Breast

$8.59

Two marinated chicken breast grilled, served with a pita bread

Baby Beef Liver

$8.09

Smothered with sauteed onions

New York Strip

$11.19

Strip 8oz grilled to order

Hot & Hearty

$7.49

Your choice of: Hot ham, hot hamburger or hot turkey sandwich, topped with brown garvy

Hot Roast Beef Sandwich

$8.09

Topped with brown gravy

Smothered Hamburger Steak

$8.99

Topped with sauteed onions, mushrooms and mozzarella cheese


Sides

Mozzarella Sticks

$4.59

Chili Fries

$3.39

Chili Cheese Fries

$3.89

Onion Rings

$2.89

Fried Mushrooms

$3.09

Hash Browns or French Fries

$2.19

Mashed Potatoes and Gravy

$2.19

Applesauce or Coleslaw

$2.09

Cottage Cheese

$2.29

Pita Bread

$1.69


KidsFor kids under 12

Cheeseburger

$4.09

With fries

Hot Dog with Fries

$4.09

Grilled Cheese with Fries and Ice Cream

$4.49

Spaghetti with Ice Cream

$4.49

Fish with Fries and Ice Cream

$4.49


Desserts

Homemade Rice Pudding

$2.59

Carrot Cake

$2.29

Brownie Sundae

$4.39

Fresh Pies

$2.79

A la mode add $0.99

Ice Cream (One Scoop)

$1.59

Ice Cream (Two Scoop)

$2.59


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading