Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 158 votes
Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Logo

Choose My State

NY

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Fries

$3.95

Fresh cut style, lightly salted

Pizza Fries

$4.95

Covered with pizza sauce & mozzarella

Loaded Fries

$6.95

With chili, bacon & melted cheddar

Onion Rings

$4.95

Thick cut onions, beer battered

Garlic Bread

$4.95

Giant loaf with melted mozzarella

Hot Soup

$3.95

Grandma Carmella's Italian recipes

Chili

$4.95

Melted cheese $1.00

Fried Mushrooms

$4.95

With choice of one sauce

Mozzarella Sticks (5pc.)

$5.95

Side of tomato sauce

Mozzarella Sticks (10pc.)

$9.95

Side of tomato sauce

Pizza Fingers

$7.95

4pc, mozzarella, pepperoni, tomato sauce

Sausage Slingers

$9.95

Chunks of Italian sausage, wing sauce

Potato Skins

$9.95

4pc. with bacon & melted cheddar cheese

Pizza Skins

$9.95

4pc. with mozzarella, pepperoni & pizza sauce

Buffalo Calamari

$10.95

Choice of wing sauce with blue cheese

Fried Calamari

$9.95

Flash fried calamari, side tomato sauce

Sicilian Calamari

$11.95

Kalamata olives, peppers, asiago


Fresh SaladDressing choices italian, blue cheese, ranch, caesar, country french, honey mustard, greek dressing, thousand island, lite italian, fat free ranch & fat free raspberry vinaigrette

Macaroni Salad

$3.95

Add Mama Toni’s beef hot sauce or sweet country $1.00

Side Salad

$3.95

With romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions. Choice of dressing

Tossed Salad

$6.95

With romaine mix, tomatoes, carrots, cucumbers, and onions. Choice of dressing

Tuna Topped Salad

$8.95

Our tossed salad covered with our very popular tuna fish with Hellmann's mayo. Same tuna we use on oura mazing subs

Caesar Salad

$8.95

Our tossed salad, mushrooms, croutons, bacon, asiago cheese, and caesar dressing. With grilled chicken $10.95

Antipasto Salad

$8.95

Our tossed salad with ham, provolone, salami, pepperoni, pepperoncini and black olives. Choice of dressing

It’s Greek to Me

$8.95

Our tossed salad with feta cheese, kalamata olives & greek dressing.

Grilled Chicken Salad

$9.95

Our tossed salad with sliced grilled chicken and mozzarella cheese. Choice of dressing

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$9.95

Our tossed salad with our chicken fingers covered with mild wing sauce and cheddar cheese

Cajun Chicken Salad

$9.95

Our tossed salad with sliced grilled Cajun chicken breast and cheddar cheese. Choice of dressing

Calamari Salad

$9.95

Our tossed salad covered with fried calamari. Choice of dressing.

Buffalo Calamari Salad

$9.95

Our tossed salad covered with fried calamari, choice of wing sauce & blue cheese.

Sicilian Calamari Salad

$10.95

Our tossed salad covered with fried calamari, asiago cheese, kalamata olives, peppers and balsamic italian dressing

4oz. Grilled Chicken

$2.55

Sliced Steak

$2.55


SupersliceExtra topping on any Superslice $0.69

SuperSlice

$4.25

1/4 of a Large Pizza. Double mozzarella or mozzarella & pepperoni

Specialty SuperSlic

$4.95

Chef's Special. One of our Specialty pizzas

Super Slice Combo

$7.00

With 20 oz. soda & choice of chips or cookie

Super Slice & Wing Combo

$7.00

SuperSlice with 5 pc. wings & choice of sauce


Calzone

Calzone

$10.95

Medium pizza dough, stuffed & folded in half. Comes with lots of mozzarella and choice of 2 pizza toppings with 4 oz. pasta sauce. Extra toppings: $1.95


WingsWing sauce: Garlic parmesan, mild buffalo wing sauce, hot buffalo wing sauce, sweet country style, BBQ sauce

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (10 pc.)

$9.95

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (20 pc.)

$17.90

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (30 pc.)

$25.85

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (40 pc.)

$33.80

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (50 pc.)

$41.75

Jumbo Fresh Wings & Boneless Wings (100 pc.)

$80.50

Wing Mac Snack

$7.95

5pc. wings with mac salad & bread

Sausage Slingers

$9.95

Chunks of Italian sausage & wing sauce

Sweet Country Breaded Wings

$11.95

10pc. Rochester style


Italian Subs & WrapsExtras: Roll $0.65, medium or wrap $0.75, large $0.95. extra cheese, meat, bacon, mushrooms, coleslaw, extra anything. extra: 2oz wing sauce & mama toni beef hot sauce $1, 2oz blue cheese

Sub Platters

$49.95

Wrap Platters

$59.95

Cold Subs

$4.95 - $8.95

Italian assorted, roast beef, baked ham, genoa salami, tuna fish, ham cappicola, turkey breast, cheese sub or veggie sub.

Hot Subs

$5.55 - $9.55

Shaved steak, meatball, italian sausage, pizza sub, blt, eggplant parm, chicken parm, grilled chicken, chicken finger, buffalo chicken, hamburger sub, or Big Bertha fish.


WrapsWraps: Plain, wheat, tomato basil, garlic pesto

Chicken Caesar

$7.55

Grilled chicken, romaine, asiago & caesar dressing.

Cajun Chicken

$7.55

Sliced cajun chicken, romaine, tomatoes & mexican ranch dressing

Buffalo Chicken

$7.55

Chicken fingers tossed w/ wing sauce, romaine, tomatoes & blue cheese


ChickenExtra: 2oz wing sauce $1.00, 2oz blue cheese $1.00

Breaded Chicken Sandwich

$7.95

With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$8.95

With fresh cut style fries and custom dressed

Chicken Cordon Blue Sandwich

$8.95

Choice of chicken, swiss cheese & ham w/ fries

Chicken Fingers (2pc.)

$5.95

Choice of sauce, blue cheese & fresh cut style fries

Chicken Fingers (5pc.)

$10.95

Choice of sauce, blue cheese & fresh cut style fries


Pub Burgers

1/3lb. Burger

$4.95

Cheeseburger

$5.55

Italian Burger

$5.55

Salvie Burger

$5.55

BBQ Burger

$5.55

Blue Cheeseburger

$5.55

Swiss Burger

$5.55

Mushroom Burger

$5.55

Double Burger

$6.95

Double Cheeseburger

$7.55

Salvie Plates

$11.55

Zweigle's Red Hot

$3.95


Salvie PlatesChoice of 2 sides: Mac salad, grilled baked beans, or fresh cut fries. Topped with fresh diced onions and mama toni’s famous hot sauce

Hot Dog

$11.95

Hamburger

$11.95

Cheeseburger

$11.95

Italian Sausage

$11.95

Chicken Fingers

$11.95

Grilled Chicken

$11.95

Shaved Steak

$11.95

Fish Fry Plate

$11.95

Grilled Veggie

$11.95


Rico's BBQ RibsChoice of 2 sides: fresh cut style fries, mac salad, coleslaw, or grilled baked beans. With BBQ sauce.

1/2 Rack

$13.95

W/ choice of two sides

Full Rack

$24.95

W/ choice of two sides


Fishalicious

Big Bertha’s Fish Sub

$9.55

Fried Haddock on large sub bread custom dressed

Haddock Fish Fry

$11.95

11 oz. Haddock, fries, coleslaw or mac salad, roll & tartar

Haddock Parmesan

$13.95

With tomato sauce & melted mozzarella w/ side of pasta

Shrimp Dinner

$11.95

10pc. breaded shrimp, fresh cut style fries & choice of two sauces

Salvatore Style Shrimp Dinner

$12.95

10pc. Covered w/ sweet country sauce. Side mac salad & fries

Fried Calamari

$9.95

Flash fried breaded calamari served with side of tomato sauce

Buffalo Calamari

$10.95

Fried breaded calamari with choice of wing sauce & blue cheese

Sicilian Calamari

$11.95

Kalamata olives, asiago cheese, peppers & balsamic italian


Famous Pizza

Salvatore’s Medium 12" Pizza

$13.95

Pizza cut into 8 pieces with lots of mozzarella

Salvatore’s Large 16" Pizza

$16.95

Pizza cut into 16 pieces with lots of mozzarella

Manhattan 19 NY Style 19" Pizza

$18.95

Pizza cut into 8 pieces with lots of mozzarella

Salvatore’s 32pc. Sheet Pizza

$24.95

Pizza cut into 32 pieces with lots of mozzarella

Topping Selections

Price may varies

Meat: Pepperoni, italian sausage, grilled chicken, meatballs, baked ham, bacon, genoa salami, ham cappicola, shaved steak, old fashioned, pepperoni. Cheese: mozzarella, cheddar, blue cheese, asiago,

Thin Thin Pizza

$7.95

Individual 12", extremely thin, european style pizza. On wheat dough with mozzarella & 1 Topping

Gluten Free Pizza

$9.95

Individual 12" thin pizza. On gluten-free dough w/ mozzarella


Specialty Pizzas

Salvatore’s Supreme Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Tomato sauce base, mozzarella, pepperoni,mushrooms, giant Italian sausage, green peppers, onions & olives

The Salvatore Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, fresh mushrooms & giant Italian sausage

Linda Da’ Veggie Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, diced onions, green peppers, fresh mushrooms & black olives.

Chicken Charlie Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Blue cheese base, chicken charlie mild wing sauce on chicken fingers & lots of mozzarella

The Breath Mint Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Our garlic pizza, olive oil base, fresh garlic, onions, sliced tomatoes & lots of mozzarella.

Meathead Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Tomato sauce base, lots of mozzarella, pepperoni, giant Italian sausage, meatballs & bacon.

Steak Boomba Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Tomato sauce base or sweet country base, steak with grilled peppers & onions, with lots of mozzarella

Alfredo- Not My Brother Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Alfredo sauce base, grilled chicken, artichokes, roasted red peppers, olives, & asiago cheese

SoccerSam’s Low Fat Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Multi-Grain dough, no mozzarell a, extra tomato sauce, diced onions & green peppers, fresh mushrooms

Uncle Rico’s BBQ Chicken Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

BBQ base sauce, grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, diced onions covered with cheddar cheese.

Mama Toni’s Plate Pizza

$18.95 - $30.95

Mama Toni’s beef hot sauce base, hamburger, fries, diced onions, mac salad covered w/ cheddar cheese

The Taco Pizza Since 1978

$18.95 - $30.95

Salsa sauce base, cheddar cheese, diced onions, seasoned beef, lettuce, tomato and sour cream.

Breakfast Pizza Meat or Veggie

$18.95 - $30.95

Eggs, cheddar and mozzarella Veggie: Onion, peppers & mushrooms meat: sausage, ham & bacon


Italian Dinners

Baked Pasta with Mozzarella & Sauce

$9.95

Pasta & Meatballs

$10.95

Spaghetti, penne or soccer ball with sauce

Stuffed Shells

$11.95

5 ricotta filled shells, mozzarella & sauce

Eggplant Parm

$11.95

Breaded with mozzarella, sauce & pasta

Chicken Parm

$12.95

Breaded with mozzarella, sauce & pasta

Grilled Chicken Parm

$13.95

Grilled w/ mozz., sauce & pasta

Haddock Parm

$13.95

Fried Haddock w/ mozz., sauce & pasta


Pasta Sides

Meatball Dish (2)

$4.95

Eggplant Dish

$4.95

Italian Sausage (Chunks)

$4.95

Side Order Pasta

$4.95

Extra Garlic Bread

$4.95


Dessert

Cookie

$1.25

5 Pack Cookies

$5.00

Cannoli (Ricotta Filled)

$2.95

5 Pack Cannoli

$12.95

Italian Cheesecake

$4.95

Carrot Cake

$4.95

Peanut Butter Pie

$4.95

Chips, Nuts & More

$4.95


Cold Drinks

Soda (20 oz.)

$1.80

Milk, Juice & Bottled

$1.80

Teas & Gatorade

$2.00

Sobe Type Drinks

$2.25

Soda (1 Liter)

$2.39

Soda (2 Liter)

$2.69

Power Drinks & More

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading