Rusty Mackerel Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 92 votes
Rusty Mackerel Logo
American

Choose My State

NY

Rusty Mackerel Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Snacks

Marinated Olives

$5.00

Cod Croquettes

$7.00

saffron aioli

Zucchini-Herbed Ricotta Focaccia

$7.00

Sea Salt Potatoes

$5.00

smoked paprika aioli


Small Plates

I Heart NY Cheese Plate

$15.00

three farmstead cheeses, honeycomb

Cauliflower Chop

$13.00

cauliflower puree, fried shallots, golden raisin chimichurri

Octopus Bravas

$18.00

sea salt potatoes, romesco

Heirloom Tomato Salad

$14.00

fried green tomato, rhu-bbq, basil

Burnt Ends

$16.00

crispy braised pork belly, bbq pinto beans, pickles cucumbers, fried okra


Large Plates

Market Squash Carbonara

$16.00

housemade spaghetti, crispy bacon, aged pecorino

Free Bird Farms Pan-Roasted Chicken

$18.00

baba negra, heirloom tomatoes, shaved pecorino

Seared Scallops

$23.00

panzanella salad, candied bacon lardons, roasted tomatoes, meyer lemon vinaigrette

Steak Frites

$27.00

new york strip steak, yucca fries, bearnaise


Cocktails $12

Negroni

Price may varies

plymouth gin, antica carpano, aperol

Manhattan

Price may varies

rittenhouse rye, dolin rouge, grand marnier, angostura bitters

Dirty Mac

Price may varies

luksosowa vodka, pickled cucumber juice, hawaiian lava salt


Tap Beer

Stoudt's Pilsner

$8.00

pennsylvania

Ommegang Witte

$9.00

new york

Nectar IPA

$9.00

california


Bottled Beer

Bronx Pale Ale

$9.00

new york

Brasserie Dupont

$12.00

saison dupont, france

Pretty Things St. Botolph's Town

$18.00

massachusetts

Left Hand Nitro Milk Stout

$8.00

colorado

Einbecker Non-Alcoholic

$8.00

germany


Beverages

Pellegrino

$5.00

Pellegrino

$3.50

limonata, lemon/lime

Pellegrino

$3.50

pomelo, grapefruit

Pellegrino

$3.50

aranciata, orange

Pellegrino

$3.50

aranciata rossa, blood orange


Sparkling By The Glass

Gruet

$12.00

methode champenoise, blanc de noirs, new mexico, brut nv

Montalbera

$12.00

roseus, piedmont, italy, brut rose nv

Brigandat

$24.00

champagne, france, brut, nv

La Morandina

$10.00

moscatto d'asti, italy 2010


Tap WineGl / Carafe

Dry Riesling

$20.00 - $10.00

red tail ridge, ginger lakes, new york

Chardonnay

$8.00 - $14.00

santa helena, chile

Moscofilero

$20.00 - $10.00

gotham project, greece

Rose Of Monastrell

$9.00 - $18.00

gotham project, spain

Cabernet Sauvignon Blend

$24.00 - $12.00

gotham project, washington

Grenache/Syrah

$26.00 - $13.00

five thirteen, donkey & goat, el dorado, california


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading