Rum Barrel Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 114 votes
Rum Barrel Logo
Bar Food
Gastropub

Choose My State

FL

Rum Barrel Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Flatbread Pizzas

Margherita

$10.00

vine ripe tomatoes, imported buffalo mozzarella, sweet basil, plain and simple, baked to perfection.

The Scampi

$12.00

sauteed shrimp, roasted garlic, oven dried tomatoes, shaved parmesan, and lemon confit.

The Cypress

$10.00

grilled artichoke, mediterranean olives, feta, garden basil, mint, and greek extra virgin olive oil.


Appetizers

Queen Conch Fritters

$11.00

a bahamian treat, with key lime cocktail sauce.

Rum Barrels Famous Philly Cheese Steak Spring Rolls

$8.00

2 jumbo spring rolls filled with tender grilled ribeye and sautéed onions with a creamy white cheddar sauce and roasted pepper salad.

Chicken Wings

$14.00

(gf). with house made ranch or blue cheese and celery sticks. bakers dozen.

Chicken Wings

Price may varies

choose your style - sunday drive, i’m late for work, the baby’s coming!

Rum Barrel Snack Pack

$12.00

a sampling of house made munchies.

Jamaican Jerk And Herb Butter Soft Pretzel Bites

$7.00

with habanero honey-mustard.

Deep Dish Nachos

$11.00

with frijoles, roasted tomato salsa, guacamole, queso fresco, fresh jalapenos, sour cream and warm tortilla chips on the side.

Deep Dish Nachos

$2.00

add chipotle spiced ground beef.

Peel And Eat Key West Pinks

Price may varies

(gf). down and dirty with cocktail sauce, lime and plenty of napkins ½ lb or 1 lb.

Chicken Tenders

$10.00

5 crispy chicken tenders lightly fried and tossed in your choice of jerk, bbq, hot or mild sauce. house ranch or blue cheese.

Mick’s Signature Blue Crabcake

$11.00

panko dusted and fried with a thai cucumber noodle salad and sriracha aioli.

Seared Diver Scallops

$13.00

(gf). with yo mamas grits, cilantro and a lime brown butter sauce.

Island Curry Grilled Shrimp

$11.00

over a coconut couscous salad and warm toasted almond oil.

Loaded Cannon Fries

$9.00

(gf). a rum barrel classic, crispy golden french fries loaded up with house bacon, melted cheese, pico de gallo, fresh jalapenos and sour cream.

Spicy Sparagus

$9.00

(gf). tender asparagus spears sautéed with caramelized onions and peppers, then tossed with crispy bacon and house szechuan sauce.


Leaves And BowlsAdd Grilled Chicken, Mahi, Scallops Or Shrimp To Any Salad

Croce Salad

$14.00

(gf). pc’s signature salad. baby greens, crumbled bleu cheese, carrots, tomatoes, hard-boiled egg, bacon, red grapes, dried cranberries, scallions and pistachios.

Our House Salad

$8.00

(gf). with mixed field greens, cherry tomatoes and crisp cucumbers. dressings - balsamic, ranch, caesar and florida citrus

Classic Caesar

$9.00

with shaved parmesan and soft pretzel croutons.

The Wedge

$9.00

(gf). crisp iceberg lettuce with house made bacon, cherry tomatoes, red onions and maytag blue cheese dressing

French Onion Soup

$7.00

day old crouton and swiss cheese.

Key West Red Conch Chowder

$8.00

(gf). tender bahamian queen conch, potatoes, bacon, celery and a blend of island spices.


BunsWith Fries Or A Side Salad

Maine Lobster Roll Island Style

$17.00

tender chunks of new england lobster mixed with spices, mayo and caribbean fruits served on a toasted roll.

Classic Philly Cheese Steak

$11.00

aged ribeye grilled with sweet onions served on an amoroso roll "wit" your choice of provolone, american or whiz

"Best Of Philly Winner Chicken Cheese Steak "

$12.00

tender chicken breast sauteed with garlic, shallots, fresh thyme, roasted portobello mushrooms, shredded parmesan and provolone on a toasted roll.

Fire Grilled ¼ Pound Kobe Beef Hot Dog

$11.00

house made kraut, grain mustard and diced dill pickles on a toasted new england bun.

Big Ass Burger

$14.00

key west’s biggest burger! a fire grilled ten ounce burger with lettuce, tomato, red onion and dill pickle with your choice of cheese on a toasted bistro bun. american, swiss, cheddar or provolone.

Big Ass Burger

$1.75

add house made bacon

Barrel Burger

$11.00

8 oz fire grilled with lettuce, tomato, red onion and dill pickle with your choice of cheese on a toasted bistro bun. american, swiss, cheddar or provolone.

Barrel Burger

$1.75

add house made bacon

The "Reef" Burger

$14.00

8 oz fire grilled buckhead beef patty topped with shrimp salad, melted cheddar, vine ripe tomato on a toasted bun with old bay fries.

Blackened Yellow Tail Snapper Reuben

Price may varies

house thousand island, kraut, swiss and toasted rye bread.

Grilled Chicken "BLT"

$12.00

fire grilled chicken breast topped with house bacon, lettuce, vine ripe tomato and mayo on a toasted bistro bun.

Tuna Avocado Melt

$13.00

grilled tuna steak topped with fresh avocado, vine ripe tomato, key lime - avocado mayo and melted swiss cheese served on a toasted pretzel bun .

House Made Crispy Scrapple Sliders

$10.00

served open face over a savory french toast with shaved apples and lancaster honey.

Slider Of The Day

Price may varies

chef’s daily preparation.


Big Plates(GF) - Gluten Free

Steak Frites

$27.00

(gf). a classic pub offering, fire grilled 10 oz ny strip steak with green pepper corn butter, a pub salad and fries.

Joe’s Tug Mahi Mahi

$19.00

(gf). over a spiced sweet potato puree with a shaved fennel salad and a florida citrus vinaigrette.

Lobster Mac And Cheese

$11.00 - $21.00

sweet maine lobster with elbow macaroni and a creamy cheddar cheese sauce topped with toasted bread crumbs

New Orleans Chicken Etouffee Pasta

$21.00

sautéed chicken breast with andouille sausage, crawfish and a classic creole etouffee served over penne pasta with grilled sourdough bread.

Stuffed Yellowtail Snapper

$24.00

yellowtail snapper from our half shell fish market stuffed with chefs mick’s crab cake served with asparagus, baby greens and a key lime beurre blanc.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading