Pumpkin Hill Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 155 votes
Pumpkin Hill Logo

Choose My State

NY

Pumpkin Hill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


For the ChillinsAll served with fruit snacks; 12 and under

Grilled Cheese

$3.95

Baked Chicken Tenders

$5.95

With honey or ranch dipping sauce

Homemade Mac n Cheese

$4.95

All Beef Corn Dog

$3.95


Beginnings

Featured Appetizer du Jour

Price may varies

The Chef's Daily Soup Creation

Price may varies

Sauteed Shrimp

$9.95

In a zesty citrus BBQ butter served with grilled french bread

Baked Crab Phyllis

$7.95

With a blend of three cheeses and crab meat finished with a greens and lemon vinaigrette

Goat Cheese Tartlet

$8.95

With sweet caramelized shallots and pears drizzled with balsamic glaze

Mediterranean Antipasti

$8.95

An array of marinated grilled eggplant, portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers and kalamata olives served with hummus and homemade flat bread


PaninisOur pressed sandwich served on choice of ciabatta, wheat berry or country white breads. All sandwiches are served with a choice of our daily side dishes

The American

$7.95

Smoked turkey, applewood bacon, blue cheese and caramelized onions

East Meets West

$7.95

A festive blend of curried chicken salad, sliced grapes and mango

El Cubanito

$7.95

Cuban style roasted pork, thin sliced ham, pepper jack cheese, caramelized onions, dijon mustard and dill pickle

The Gardener

$7.95

A medley of grilled eggplant, roasted red peppers, red onions, spinach, portobella mushrooms, hummus and olive tapenade with feta cheese


Main Event

Cookie's Chicken Pot Pie

$8.95

Tender pouched chicken, peas, carrots and celery in a thyme laced finished with a tender crust

Farm House Roast

$13.95

Our old fashioned slow cooked pot roast with vegetables and herbed smashed potatoes

Shepherds Pie

$11.95

Ground beef, carrots, portobello mushroom, and peas simmered in a rich brown sauce topped with herbed potatoes and asiago cheese

Tortilla

$14.95

Cheese stuffed half moon shaped pasta with sauteed fresh tomatoes, basil, garlic and kalamata olives

Fingerlakes Maple Farm Duck Breast

$7.95

Served over mixed greens with a spicy three berry sauce, pears, caramelized walnuts, shaved fennel and goat cheese

Charred Sugar Crusted Salmon

$14.95

Served with saffron risotto and finished with a lemon beurre blanc and asparagus spears

Grilled Flat Iron

$20.95

With melted spinach, roasted reds and feta cheese with herb smashed potatoes with a grilled baguette

Pan Seared Tuna

$18.95

Over a fennel and onion confit and bread couscous with an olive tapenade sauce

When Pigs Can Fly

$16.95

Our stew roasted pork wings finished on the grill served over rice pilaf, finished with a bourbon reduction and caramelized pears


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading