Pumpernickel Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 105 votes
Pumpernickel Logo

Choose My State

NY

Pumpernickel Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


SteaksFirst choose your steak, then choose your style

Grilled NY Strip

$23.00

Skirt Steak

$22.00

100% Certified Angus Beef

Steak Style - Diner Style

Price may varies

Served with french fries and daily vegetable

Steak Style - South Beach

Price may varies

Pico de gallo and side garden salad

Steak Style - Churrasco

$2.00

Madrid sauce (parsley & garlic sauce), rice, and vegetable

Steak Style - Pizzaiola

$3.00

Red wine tomato sauce, onions, sweet bell peppers, garlic and crushed red pepper served with rice.

Steak Style - Chicago

$3.00

Smothered with grilled onions, mushrooms, and gorgonzola cheese. Served with roasted potato

BBQ Baby Back Ribs

$20.00 - $15.00

Slow roast pork ribs covered with our Kansas City style BBQ sauce and char grilled to perfection. Served with coleslaw and sweet potato fries.


StartersSmall 1-2 people, large 3-4 people.

Chicken Tenders

$8.00 - $14.00

Served w/honey mustard dipping sauce.

Fried Calamari

$8.00 - $14.00

W/marinara sauce & lemon wedge.

Fried Ravioli

$8.00 - $14.00

W/ marinara sauce.

Mozzarella Sticks

$8.00 - $14.00

Served w/ fresh marinara.

Buffalo Style Chicken Tenders

$8.50 - $15.00

Served w/ bleu cheese dipping sauce.

Spinach and Artichoke Dip

$8.50 - $15.00

Served w/ toast crisps.

Loaded Potato Skins

$8.50 - $15.00

Twice baked idaho potatoes loaded with hickory smoked bacon & three cheeses served w/ side of sour cream.

Pumpernickel Sampler

$15.00

Mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings, bbq ribs & freaky fried onions.

Italian Combo

$16.00

Tender calamari, fried ravioli, mozzarella sticks and parmesan chicken tenders served w/ our homemade marinara dipping sauce.

PEI Mussels

$7.00 - $11.00

Choose From 5 sauces: Pumpernickel (steamed w/white wine, tomatoes, jalapeno & cilantro) Marinara or Fra Diavolo (sauce made from scratch, we use only imported plum tomatoes, fresh basil & italian sp

Wings

$9.00 - $26.00

(Buffalo style or boneless nickel nuggets) served w/ celery & carrot sticks Buffalo, honey buffalo, teriyaki, bbq, cajun dry rub (spicy only) Bleu cheese dressing or avocado ranch sauce on request Ex


Homemade Soup & Chili

French Onion Soup

$6.50

Made from scratch, topped w/ toasted croutons & melted swiss cheese.

Daily Soup

$5.00

Ask your server about today’s selection. Some chowders priced higher.

Turkey Chili

$8.50

Northern white beans, creamy cheddar sauce, country style guacamole & cilantro served w/ tortilla chips.

Cashew Chili

$9.00

Award winning vegetarian chili served w/ tortilla chips.

Pumpernickel Chili

$8.50

Beef, beer & sausage, chili, melted cheddar, guacamole & sour cream served w/ tortilla chips.


From The FieldAdd tuna salad or chicken breast $3.75, tequila lime chicken $4.50, salmon or steak $7.00, jumbo shrimp or ahi tuna $8.00, served grilled or blackened.

Garden Salad

$5.00 - $8.00

Mixed field greens, tomato, cucumber & onion served w/ choice of dressing.

Traditional Caesar Salad

$6.00 - $9.00

Chopped romaine lettuce tossed w/ creamy caesar dressing, baked croutons and aged parmesan.

Harvest Salad

$8.00 - $11.00

Pears, gorgonzola cheese & candied walnuts w/ our signature poppy seed dressing over mixed field greens.

Mediterranean Salad

$7.00 - $10.00

Marinated chickpeas, tomatoes, cucumbers, artichokes & red onion in a red wine vinaigrette topped w/ feta over mixed field greens.

South Western Salad

$8.00 - $11.00

Black bean & corn marinade w/ avocado & mangos served w/ honey mustard dressing over mixed field greens.

Roasted Beet Salad

$11.00

Crumbled gorgonzola & tossed field greens, roasted beets, burgundy poached pears & baked apples over mixed field greens tossed w/ our signature sweet poppy dressing.

Blackened Chicken & Fresh Orange Salad

$15.00

Fresh cut california style spinach & chopped florida oranges tossed w/ almonds & our homemade honey orange dressing topped w/ blackened chicken breast.


Handcrafted Burgers

Classic Burger

$9.00

Choose beef, turkey or grilled chicken. served plain w/ french fries, cole slaw and pickle. We will gladly substitute a side garden salad & choice of bread on request.

Classic Cheese Burger

$10.50

(American, swiss, cheddar, mozzarella, cheddar-jack) add to any above tomato, lettuce, raw onion $0.25, grilled, frizzled or freaky onions, grilled mushrooms, hot cherry peppers, sliced jalapeños, fr

Pumpernickel Burger Deluxe

$11.00

Lettuce, tomato & freaky fried onions on toasted bun w/ french fries.

Old Fashioned Burger

$11.00

Grilled onions smashed right into our seasoned burger w/ lettuce, tomato, mayo & pickle on toasted white bread served w/ stixx fries.

Hamburger Club

$15.00

Hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, red onion & mayo on toasted pumpernickel w/ french fries.

California Veggie Burger (No Bun)

$12.00

Homemade brown rice veggie burger served w/side southwestern salad, (no fries) choice of bread on request.

Not Just A Turkey Burger

$11.00

Served w/ sliced avocado, lettuce, tomato & fripps.

Black & Bleu Burger

$11.00

Topped w/ imported gorgonzola served w/ french fries.

Cow Girl Burger

$12.00

Hickory smoked bacon, Kansas city style BBQ sauce & grilled onions served w/ french fries.

Chef’s Burger

$14.00

Swiss cheese, red onion marmalade, field greens, hot cherry peppers, ffo & sweet potato fries.

Cubano Burger

$12.00

Ground beef & chorizo sausage blend, ham, swiss, pickles & mustard sauce served w/ french fries.

Inside Out Burger

$12.00

Our jumbo burger stuffed w/red bell pepper & cheddar jack served w/ stixx fries.

Knife And Fork Burger

$15.00

Two 1/4 pound burgers, served open faced topped w/house made chili, melted cheddar jack cheese sauce, chopped onions & hot cherry peppers served w/ fries.

Onion Lover’s Burger

$12.00

Topped w/ frizzled onions, chef’s sweet onion marmalade, sliced red onion & chopped scallions served w/ french fries.

Stuffed Turkey Burger (No Bun)

$13.00

Stuffed w/ apple raisin stuffing & whole berry cranberry relish, topped the same way w/turkey sage gravy & sweet potato fries.

Ahi Tuna Steak Burger

$16.00

Seared tuna steak w/ spicy wasabi infused guacamole & bok choy slaw served w/ fripps.

Bourbon Street Burger

$14.00

Our hand formed beef burger topped w/ chef’s secret bourbon sauce, swiss cheese, grilled mushrooms & bacon served w/ fries.

Tucson Turkey Burger

$13.00

Granny Smith apple, honey mustard sauce, cheddar, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce & tomato served w/ fripps.

Hippie Fish Burger

$14.00

Cajun tilapia filet w/ sliced avocado, tomato, red onions, bourbon mayo & bok choy slaw served w/ fripps.

Al’s Jalapeno Burger

$13.00

Jalapenos mixed right into the burger topped w/ mozzarella cheese, hot pepper flakes & sliced avocados served w/ french fries.

Dirty Licious Burger

$14.00

Blackened cajun burger w/ bbq pulled pork, sliced tomato & freaky fried onions, served w/ sweet potato fries.


Entrees

Grilled Veggie Plate

$16.00

Chef’s choice fresh market vegetables, toasted pine nuts, shaved parmesan & basil pesto served w/ warm pita bread.

Blackened Chicken

$16.00

Hand trimmed marinated chicken breast served w/ rice and daily vegetable.

Herb Roasted Chicken

$15.00

Baked 1/2 chicken served w/ roasted potato & daily vegetable.

Penne Vodka

$14.00

Fresh herbs, sweet peas, shallots & parma style prosciutto in a creamy marinara sauce.

Spinach & Chicken

$15.00

Fresh cut california style spinach & chicken breast sauteed in garlic & oil over linguine.

Linguine Bolognese

$16.00

Slow simmered beef & pork ragu made w/ imported italian tomatoes, fresh herbs & a touch of cream.

Fettuccine Chicken Gardenia

$17.00

Fresh chopped tomato, artichokes, chicken breast, basil & roasted peppers sauteed in garlic and oil.


Seafood

Pan Seared Salmon

$19.00

North atlantic salmon filet served w/ roasted potato, vegetable & lemon butter sauce.

Bourbon Glazed Salmon

$20.00

Served w/ rice & daily vegetable.

Pan Seared Tilapia Filet

$16.00

Served w/ rice, vegetable & lemon butter sauce.

Southwest Tilapia

$17.00

Cajun spiced blackened tilapia w/ fresh mango salsa & small southwest salad.

Steak & Shrimp Combo

$24.00

Grilled jumbo shrimp and half order 100% cab skirt steak served w/ rice & daily vegetable.

Seafood Fra Diavolo

$21.00

Gulf shrimp, pei mussels, calamari & fresh atlantic salmon in a spicy marinara sauce over linguine.


Nachos & Quesadillas

Bar Size Nachos

$9.00

(1 to 2 People).

Table Size Nachos

$13.00

(3 to 4 People). Tortilla chips topped w/ pumpernickel chili, hot peppers, melted cheddar sauce, guacamole, salsa & sour cream.

Don Nachos

$13.00

Tortilla chips topped w/ tequila-lime chicken, white beans, chef’s cheesy bean sauce, jack cheese, guacamole, cilantro, sour cream & pico de gallo served in a basket.

Rio Rancho Nachos

$13.00

Tortilla chips topped w/ turkey chili, creamy white cheese sauce, country style guacamole & cilantro sprinkle.

California Style Nachos

$10.00

Tortilla chips topped w/ refried beans, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato, sour cream cilantro.

Buffalo Nickel Nachos

$11.00

Tortilla chips w/ chopped buffalo style nickel nuggets, cheddar, jack & bleu cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream & green onion.

Irish BBQ Nachos

$12.00

Slow roasted pulled pork, tomatoes, melted cheddar sauce, hot peppers & sour cream served over fripps (rippled potato chips).

Cheese Quesadilla

$9.00

Flour tortilla filled w/three cheeses, served w/ guacamole, pico di gallo & sour cream. Add chicken $2.00, pulled pork or buffalo chicken $3.00, steak $4.00.

Grilled Veggie Quesadilla

$10.00

Whole wheat tortilla filled w/ cheese & mixed grilled vegetables w/ guacamole, pico de gallo & sour cream.

Southwest Quesadilla

$12.00

Whole wheat tortilla filled w/ three cheeses, sliced avocado, sweet corn & black bean salsa served w/ pico di gallo & sour cream.


Between The BreadAll sandwiches served w/ fries (rippled potato chips) & coleslaw add $1.00 for fries, $2.00 for sweet potato fries.

Not Just A BLT

$10.50

Hickory smoked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato & mayo on country white.

Pub Pulled Pork

$12.00

Slow roasted pork shoulder, freaky fried onions & bbq sauce on a hard roll.

Steak Sandwich

$13.50

Tender grilled steak, caramelized onions, melted mozzarella & garlic mayo on a wedge roll.

Manhattan Deli Sandwich

$20.00

Corned beef, grilled pastrami & Swiss piled high on this huge triple decker sandwich served w/ coleslaw and pickle on rye.

Pumpernickel Reuben

$13.50

Choose corned beef, roasted turkey breast or pastrami, melted swiss, coleslaw & russian dressing on pumpernickel.

Garden Veggie Reuben

$13.50

Grilled squash, zucchini, roasted peppers, warm jicama pear slaw, melted swiss on pumpernickel.

Turkey Club

$13.00

Roasted turkey breast, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo on toasted country white.

Tuna Salad

$10.50

Made from all white meat albacore w/ lettuce & tomato on country white.

Homemade Greek Gyro

$13.00

Fresh seasoned ground beef & pork gyro, lettuce, tomato, red onion & tzatziki sauce served in a warm pita.

Chicken Souvlaki

$13.00

Marinated chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, cucumber, red onion,tzatziki sauce served in a warm pita.

Cheesy Cheddar Steak Wrap

$16.00

Tender grilled steak, sautéed onions, cheddar cheese & sliced avocado in a whole wheat wrap.

Grilled Veggie Wrap

$10.00

Chef selection of seasonal vegetables, mozzarella cheese & roasted peppers in a whole wheat wrap.

Wild Turkey Wrap

$12.00

Roasted turkey breast, sliced apple, mixed field greens & honey mustard sauce in a white wrap.

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$12.00

Grilled chicken breast, chopped romaine lettuce, aged parmesan & creamy caesar dressing rolled in a white wrap.

Buffalo Wrap

$12.00

Chopped buffalo style chicken breast, mixed field greens & freaky fried onions in a white wrap.

Pumpernickel Chicken Club

$15.00

Grilled chicken, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado & russian dressing on toasted pumpernickel.

Grilled Salmon BLT

$16.00

We added grilled salmon filet, fresh basil pesto & sliced avocado to this classic on toasted pumpernickel.


Sliders(Each order served w/ 3 sliders & french fries) served medium temperature and above only.

Original Aged Cheddar

$12.00

Original Classic

$11.00

W/ lettuce & tomato.

Italian Grilled Chicken

$14.00

Sliced tomato, melted mozzarella & fresh basil.

Chicken Parmigiana

$13.00

Served w/ side of homemade marinara.

Meatball Parmigiana

$12.00

Served w/ side of homemade marinara.

BBQ Turkey

$13.00

Grilled onions, hickory smoked bacon & kansas city bbq sauce.

BBQ Pulled Pork

$13.00

Slow roasted pork shoulder w/ kansas city bbq sauce & ffo.

Chicken BLT

$14.00

Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo.

Meatloaf

$12.00

W/ grilled mushrooms & brown gravy.


Melts

Lower East Side

$16.00

Hand formed jumbo beef burger, grilled pastrami, melted swiss & coleslaw on grilled rye bread served w/ fries.

Big Texas BBQ

$16.00

100% Certified angus steak, aged cheddar, grilled onions and kansas city style bbq sauce on grilled texas toast served w/ fripps.

Arizona Chicken

$13.00

Grilled chicken breast, granny smith apple, aged cheddar, hickory smoked bacon w/ honey mustard on grilled pumpernickel served w/ fripps.

Super Grilled Cheese

$10.50

French brie, aged cheddar & havarti w/ sliced tomato on grilled pumpernickel served w/ fripps.

Bacon Mushroom Chicken

$13.00

Grilled chicken breast, hickory smoked bacon, mushrooms, onions & melted swiss on grilled rye w/ fripps.

Bourbon Chicken

$14.00

Grilled chicken breast, aged cheddar, gorgonzola, bacon, & bourbon sauce on grilled texas toast served w/ fripps.


BasketsServed w/ french fries. All of our fried baskets are prepared in house, minimally processed and trans fat free.

Pub Style Fish & Fripps

$16.00

Hand dipped battered tilapia filet, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.

Fried Shrimp

$17.00

Panko crusted shrimp, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.

Fried Calamari

$16.00

W/ marinara sauce & lemon wedge.

Fried Clams

$16.00

Cut whole belly clam strips, tartar sauce & lemon wedge.

Shrimp & Tenders

$15.00

Handcut chicken tenders & fried shrimp served w/ honey orange dipping sauce.

Cajun Wings

$13.00

Cajun dry rubbed chicken wings served w/ avocado-ranch dipping sauce.

Chicken Tenders

$14.00

Served w/ honey mustard dipping sauce.

Pee Wee Grande

$13.00

Mini hot dogs baked in puff pastry.


Comfort Food

Baked Macaroni & Cheese

$12.00

The ultimate comfort food made w/ a creamy asiago, swiss & cheddar cheese sauce & topped w/ baked panko breadcrumbs.

Smothered Fried Chicken

$16.00

Half fried chicken smothered in southern style gravy served w/ mashed potatoes & vegetable.

Baked Penne

$14.00

Slow baked in our homemade cheesy cream sauce, w/ chopped meatballs, sweet italian sausage and mozzarella cheese topped w/ toasted panko.

Grandma’s Meatloaf

$15.00

Our all beef recipe served w/mashed potatoes, gravy & vegetable.

Hot Open Turkey Sandwich

$16.00

Hand carved roasted turkey breast served w/ turkey sage gravy, mashed potatoes & cranberry sauce on country white.

Petite Sliced Steak

$17.00

Half order certified Angus skirt steak served w/ mushroom gravy, mashed potatoes & vegetable.

Chicken Parmigiana

$16.00

Tender breaded chicken breast, melted mozzarella & homemademarinara sauce served w/ side of pasta.


Just For Kids(Ages up to 12). All meals come w/ juice and fries.

Pasta

$5.50 - $7.00

Marinara sauce or butter (add meatballs $2.50) mac & cheese style. (Served without fries).

Grilled Cheese

$6.00

Jr Burger (Beef Or Turkey)

$6.00

Jr Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$6.00

W/ cheese add $1.00.

Chicken Tenders

$6.00

Chicken Tenders - Parmigiana Style

$8.00

Chicken Tenders - Buffalo Style

$8.00

Ravioli

$7.50 - $9.00

Mac & cheese style or fried. (Served without fries).

Flat Bread Pizza

$7.00

(Add sausage $1.00). (Served without fries).

Pee Wee Basket

$7.00

Mini hot dogs baked in rolled pastry dough.

Jr American Combo

$8.00

Jr burger and mini hot dogs baked in rolled pastry dough.

Jr Fish Sticks

$9.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading