Pullman Bay Restaurant Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 136 votes
Pullman Bay Restaurant Logo

Choose My State

OH

Pullman Bay Restaurant Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Entreesthese dinners served with your choice of two sides

Beef Manhattan

$9.79

shredded roast beef on texas toast covered with gravy, served with mashed and choice of one side

Chopped Steak

$9.49

with sauteed mushrooms or gravy - add $0.30

Broasted Chicken

$8.99

three pieces of plump chicken broasted to seal in natural juices and flavor

Wing Dinner

$5.89 - $6.79

Grilled Chicken Dinner

$12.29

two lightly seasoned, skinless, boneless chicken breasts

Chicken Finger Dinner

$10.99

five natural chicken fillet served with your choice of dipping sauce


Seafood Entrees

Deep Fried Whitefish

$11.99

tender deep-fried whitefish served with lemon and tartar sauce

Broiled Whitefish

$13.49

broiled whitefish fillet served with lemon and tartar sauce

Popcorn Shrimp

$9.99

a generous portion of breaded shrimp, delicately fried and served with zesty cocktail sauce

Shrimp Of The Bay

$11.99

seven large breaded shrimp served with cocktail sauce

Baked Salmon

$15.99

baked salmon fillets, lightly seasoned and served with dill sauce on the side


Drinks

Coffee Or Decaf

$1.29

Hot Tea

$1.29

Constant Comment Tea

$1.29

Iced Tea

$1.99

Hot Chocolate

$1.99

Milk

$1.09 - $1.49

white or chocolate

Juices

$1.49

orange, v-8, apple or grapefruit


Soft Drinks

Pepsi

$1.99

Diet Pepsi

$1.99

Sierra Mist

$1.99

Lemonade

$1.99

Root Beer

$1.99

Mountain Dew

$1.99

Dr. Pepper

$1.99


Desserts

Homemade Cheesecake

$2.89 - $29.99

homemade new york style cheesecake. with strawberry, caramel, chocolate or hot fudge topping - $3.29

Carrot Cake

$2.89 - $25.99

one serving

Homemade Pie

$2.89

a wedge of homemade goodness, you know, the kind with old fashioned flaky crust. ask your server for today's selection

Whole Pie

$15.99

for any occasion. you may need to order ahead

Hand Dipped Ice Cream

$0.99 - $1.69

Milk Shake

$2.99

vanilla, chocolate or strawberry


Pizzastoppings: pepperoni, sliced sausage, bulk sausage, hamburger, ham, bacon, mushrooms, onions, black olive, green olives, green peppers, banana peppers, pineapple, extra cheese

Cheese

$5.39 - $12.79

1 Topping

$6.09 - $13.99

2 Toppings

$6.79 - $15.99

3 Toppings

$7.49 - $16.39

4 Toppings

$8.19 - $17.59

5 Toppings

$8.69 - $18.39

6 Or More

$9.19 - $19.19


Oven Baked Subssub sandwiches served with choice of one side

Pizza Sub

$8.29

Italian Sub

$8.29

Big Pig

$8.29

Turkey-bacon-ranch Sub

$8.99


Pizza Lite

Traditional

$3.79

ultra thin crust, tomato sauce and cheese

Buffalo Chicken Pizza Lite

$5.49

with cheddar, mozzarella and tomatoes

Bbq

$4.89

pulled pork, bbq sauce, onion cheese

Chicken Club Pizza

$5.49

chicken, bacon, ranch dressing & tomatoes


Lighter Fareserved with your choice of two sides

Chicken Snack

$6.99

two pieces of broasted chicken

Broiled Whitefish

$9.99

fresh whitefish delicately broiled and served with lemon and tartar sauce

Fish Snack

$8.79

deep fried to a golden brown and served with tartar sauce

Grilled Chicken

$8.99

a perfectly seasoned, skinless, boneless chicken breast

Shrimp Snack

$7.89

served with zesty cocktail sauce

Baked Salmon

$10.99

baked salmon fillet lightly seasoned and served with dill sauce on the side


Pasta

Our Original Spaghetti

$7.49

topped with our homemade meat sauce and served with garlic toast and tossed salad

Spaghetti Lite

$5.99

half order of spaghetti served with garlic toast and one side

Lasagna

$9.99

layered with cheese and our own meat sauce. served with garlic toast and tossed salad


South Of The Bordermake a dinner! add chips, salsa and salad for $3 more

Super Nachos

$4.39

nacho chips with salsa, cheddar cheese and our homemade meat sauce. served with sour cream

Burrito

$3.49

flour tortilla with own special meat sauce, hot or mild sauce and your choice of mozzarella or cheddar cheese

Burrito Deluxe

$3.99

our burrito with onions, green peppers, tomatoes and mushrooms

Peda

$4.99

our unique mexican-style pizza with onions, green peppers, tomatoes and mozzarella cheese

Veggie Burrito

$3.99

flour tortilla with onions, green peppers, black olives, tomatoes, mushrooms, mozzarella or cheddar cheese, and hot or mild sauce

Two Tacos

$2.89

crispy corn tortillas, meat sauce, hot or mild sauce, lettuce and mozzarella or cheddar cheese. tomatoes, sour cream and onions are optional

Taco-burrito Combo

$4.89

cant decide? try one of each!

One Taco

$1.49

Chips & Salsa

$2.39


Kids Cornerfor children under 12, please All kids meals include a drink: soda, white or chocolate milk or apple juice and one side: corn nuggets, fries, mandarin oranges, green beans, applesauce or cottage cheese.

Mac-N-Cheese

$3.99

Hamburger

$3.99

Chicken Fingers

$4.59

two golden brown chicken tenders

Kids Drinks

$1.39

Hot Dog

$3.49

Grilled Cheese

$3.29

Breaded Fish

$3.99

Mini Burrito

$3.49

Mini Pizza Lite

$3.99

up to 2 toppings

Kids Sundae

$0.99


Mainsubstitute egg beaters for $0.10 per egg. substitute sweet roll for toast add - $0.79

Dining Car Continental

$2.99

fresh baked sweet roll with coffee or ten

Pullman Bay Breakfast

$4.69

two eggs, any style, ham, bacon or sausage, toast, jelly and coffee

Lakeshore Sunrise

$5.39

one slice of thick french toast, ham, bacon or sausage and one egg, any style

Grand Lake Special

$5.99

one egg, any style, two pancakes, butter & syrup, ham, bacon or sausage

North Shore Special

$5.99

one egg, any style, one waffle, butter & syrup, ham, bacon or sausage

Lighthouse Special

$5.49

two split buttermilk biscuits with sausage gravy

Windy Point Express

$5.39

waffle, butter & syrup, ham, bacon or sausage

Market Street Special

$8.49

an 8 oz. chopped steak, two eggs, any style, home fries, toast and jelly

Trolly Car Special

$2.99

two eggs, toast and jelly

Healthy Heart Special

$5.69

two egg beaters, toast and small bowl of fresh fruit

Egg Benedict

$6.59

split english muffin, ham and poached eggs smothered in cheese sauce


Potato Works

Plain Home Fries

$1.99

Create Your Own

Price may varies

start with plain home fries and add any of the following: american, swiss, cheddar, hot pepper cheese or mushroom - $0.39; green pepper, tomato or onion - $0.15; bacon, ham or sausage - $0.99; sausag


Omelettesmade with three farm fresh eggs, served with toast and jelly. omelettes made with egg beaters add - $ 0.30; add salsa - $0.50

Plain Omelette

$4.09

Ham And Cheese Omelette

$5.99

Mexican Omelette

$5.99

tomato, onion and hot pepper cheese

Veggie Omelette

$5.99

mushrooms, onions, green pepper and swiss cheese

Western Omelette

$6.99

mushrooms, onions, green pepper, ham, tomato and american cheese


Sides

Ham

$2.29

Bacon

$2.29

Sausage Links Or Patty

$2.29

Waffle

$2.99

Pecan Waffle

$3.39

1/2 Order Biscuits & Gravy

$2.79

Fresh Fruit

$2.79

Two Pancakes

$2.99

English Muffin

$1.19

Sweet Roll

$1.99

Hot Cereal

$1.69

Bagel

$1.19

One Egg, Any Style

$0.99

Two Eggs, Any Style

$1.89

Toast & Jelly

$1.19

French Toast

$1.99 - $3.49

Baked Potato

Price may varies

Mashed Potatoes

Price may varies

French Fries

Price may varies

Home Fries

Price may varies

Broasted Potatoes

Price may varies

Tossed Salad

Price may varies

Coleslaw

Price may varies

Cottage Cheese

Price may varies

Applesauce

Price may varies

Vegetable Of The Day

Price may varies


To Start

Chicken Fingers

$6.99

five natural chicken fillets served with your choice of dipping sauce

Deep Fried Mozzarella Sticks

$3.99

five cheese sticks with pizza sauce

Deep Fried Mushrooms

$3.29

Deep Fried Pickle Spears

$3.99

French Fries

$1.99

Onion Rings

$2.99


Soups

Chili

$3.19

Chili 2-way

$4.39

chili served with noodles

Chili 3-way

$4.79

chili served with noodles and cheese

Chili 4-way

$4.99

chili served with noodles and cheese & onions

Soup Of The Day

$2.99

ask your server for today's selection


Garden Greensdressings: ranch, french, poppyseed, italian, thousand island, honey mustard, bleu cheese, oil & vinegar, raspberry vinaigrette, balsamic vinaigrette. fat free options: italian, ranch, french, poppyseed

Grilled Chicken Salad

$7.59

with cheddar cheese and tomato

Chef's Salad

$5.99

with ham, cheddar cheese, tomato and egg

Tossed Salad

$2.59

Coleslaw

$1.99

Taco Salad

$5.99

a bed of lettuce with our meat sauce, salsa, cheddar cheese, tomatoes and black olives, served with tortilla chips

Spinach Salad

$5.39

with mozzarella, red onion, pecans and craisins (strawberries may be substituted for craisins when in season)

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$6.99

breaded or grilled chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, on a bed of lettuce, with cheddar cheese and tomato


Sandwichessandwiches served with your choice of one side. sandwiches without a side, subtract $0.40

Big Burger

$8.99

a full half pound of our own unique seasoned ground beef blend, served on a warm pretzel roll. personalize it by adding your favorite toppings

Basic Burger

$5.69

one quarter pound of our own ground beef blend

Bacon Cheeseburger

$6.99

Patty Melt

$6.39

a juicy burger topped with grilled onions and swiss cheese on grilled eye

Jumbo Tenderloin

$6.99

hand breaded, deep fried pork tenderloin

East Bank

$6.79

deep fried cod served on a toasted bun with tartar sauce

Broiled Fish Sandwich

$7.29

B.L.T.

$5.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$6.99

Safety Island

$6.99

grilled ham and swiss cheese, served on a hoagie bun with mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato

Montezuma Grilled Chicken

$7.99

skinless, boneless grilled chicken breast smothered with green pepper, onions, mushrooms and swiss cheese, served on a toasted bun with our special sauce

Montezuma Roast Beef

$8.99

slow roasted shredded beef topped with grilled onions, green peppers, mushrooms and swiss cheese. served with on a warm pretzel roll

Reuben

$8.99

a generous portion of lean corned beef, melted swiss cheese and sauerkraut served on grilled rye with dressing on the side

Club Island

$8.49

turkey, bacon, swiss cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce and tomato. served on white or whole wheat toast

Smoked Sausage Submarine

$7.89

smoked sausage, swiss cheese, sauerkraut and grilled onions on a hoagie bun with 1,000 island dressing on the side

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$8.99

smoked pork shoulder stacked high on a warm pretzel roll


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading