Prime Meats Menu and Prices

4.6 based on 152 votes
Prime Meats Logo
Cocktails
Steak
German

Choose My State

NY

Prime Meats Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Salads

Bibb Lettuce Salad

$12.00

pumpkin seeds, radish, lemon & austrian pumkin seed oil.

Salad Nicoise

$16.00

sicilian tuna, salad of hard boiled eggs, potatoes, white anchovies, haricot vert, red wine mustard vinaigrette

Steak Frites

$30.00

bavette of wagyu steak served with hand-cut french fries.

The Prime Meats Burger

$18.00

1/2 lb. creekstone certified black angus, house-made sesame roll & fermented dill pickle, lettuce, tomato, onion & hand-cut french fries

Lancaster Baby Swiss

$2.00

maytag blue or grafton cheddar cheese add

Faicco's Thick Cut Bacon

$2.00

add

Bibb Lettuce

$14.00

pumpkin seeds, radish, lemon & austrian pumpkin seed oil

Mixed Greens

$11.00

lemon & pumpkin seed oil vinaigrette

Salad Nicoise

$16.00

sicilian tuna, salad of hard-boiled eggs, potatoes, white anchovies, haricot vert, red peppers & red wine mustard vinaigrette


Sandwiches

Egg & Swiss Cheese Sandwich

$9.00

Egg & Swiss Cheese Sandwich

$2.00

add bacon

Prime Meats Turkey Club

$12.00

house-roasted turkey, faicco's bacon, lettuce & tomato

Roast Beef

$12.00

roasted rib eye, pickled shishito peppers & mayonnaise

Benton's Smokey Mountain BLT

$13.00

benton' smokey mountain bacon, bibb lettuce and tomato with hellman's mayonnaise

Sausage Sandwich

$11.00

knackwurst, hot pickle salad

Sausage, Egg & Cheese Biscuit

$11.00

gruyere cheese

Smoked Salmon

$15.00

open faced, red onion, arugula & horseradish

Benton's Smokey Mountain BLT

$13.00

thick cut bacon, bibb lettuce and tomato with hellman's mayonnaise

Roast Beef

$12.00

roasted rib eye, pickled shishito peppers & horseradish mayonnaise


Hand Crafted Sausages

Weisswurst

$10.00 - $17.00

Thuringian Bratwurst

$13.00

Jägerwurst

$14.00

Dry Aged Beef

$16.00

Knackwurst

$14.00

Frankfurters

$13.00

2 housemade frankfurters on potato buns with sauerkraut & potato salad

Weisswurst

$17.00 - $10.00

Bratwurst & Sauerkraut

$13.00

Jagerwurst

$14.00

Dry Aged Beef

$16.00

Wurstbrett

$35.00

sausage tasting board including knackwurst, jagerwurst, bratwurst and dry aged beef.


Dinner

Oysters

Price may varies

Bibb Lettuce

$14.00

pumpkin seeds, radish, lemon & austrian pumkin seed oil

Chilled Iceberg

$12.00

maytag blue cheese buttermilk dressing & bacon

Arugula

$11.00

bosc pears, feta cheese & pecans

Frisee

$14.00

sunchokes, lardons & confit hen egg

Roasted Beet & Carrot

$11.00

sea salt, aleppo & cayenne pepper cream

Tartare Of Wagyu Beef

$14.00

anchovy, capers, shallots, tabasco, worcestershire & mustard oil

Charred Octopus

$13.00

plums & 3 celeries

Herb & Gruyere Spatzle

$9.00

Market Fish

Price may varies

Pickle Brined Amish Chicken

$22.00

chicken breast brined & barley risotto

Hampshire Grilled Pork Chops

$26.00

hamhock collard greens & potato puree

Pork Schnitzel

$21.00

pork loin, breaded and fried served with home-made potato salad.

Steak Frites

$30.00

bavette of wagyu served with hand-cut french fries & sauce bearnaise

The Prime Meats Burger

$18.00

1/2 lb. creekstone certified black angus, house-made sesame roll & fermented dill pickle, lettuce, tomato, onion & hand-cut french fries

Lancaster Baby Swiss

$2.00

maytag blue cheese or grafton cheddar add

Faicco's Thick Cut Bacon

$2.00

add

Friday & Saturday - Debragga & Spitler

$142.00

dry-aged côte de boeuf for 2. 6 day dry-aged certified black angus served with watercress salad.


Specials

Ithica Yogurt

$7.50

housemade granola & fresh berries

Old Fashioned Griddle Cakes

$13.00

vermont butter & maple syrup

Brioche French Toast

$12.00

Biscuits & Gravy

$14.00

benton's farm bacon & 2 sunnyside up eggs

Smoked Salmon & Grits

$14.00

poached eggs & cream cheese

Eggs Benedict

$15.00

poached eggs, maple-cured ham & hollandaise sauce

Fines Herbes Egg White Omelet

$12.00

field greens

Gruyere Cheese Omelet

$12.00

french fries

Farmer's Breakfast

$13.00

2 sunnyside up egges, sausage, bacon, ham, breakfast potato & country toast

Mushrooms & Bratwurst

$10.00

poached egg

Steak And Eggs

$16.00

"vaca frita" skirt steak, chimichurri & country toast


Sides & Additions

Seasonal Fruit

$6.00

Breakfast Potato

$4.00

Hand-Cut French Fries

$6.00

Faicco's Thick Cut Bacon

$4.50

Grilled Bratwurst

$5.50

Grits

$5.00


House Specials

Weisswurst

$17.00 - $10.00

traditional german white sausage served with sweet mustard & pretzel roll

The Prime Meats Burger

$18.00

1/2 lb. creekstone certified black angus, house-made sesame roll & fermented dill pickle, lettuce, tomato, onion & hand-cut french fries

Lancaster Baby Swiss

$2.00

maytag blue cheese or grafton cheddar add

Faicco's Thick Cut Bacon

$2.00

add


Coffee

Espresso

$2.50

Cappuccino

$3.50

Latte

$4.00

Coffee Or Refills

$2.50 - $1.00


Tea

Tea

$4.00

ceylon, chai, roobois, lavender mint, green jasmine, earl grey

Iced Black

$3.00

Iced Green

$4.00


Juice $3

Orange

Price may varies

Grapefruit

Price may varies


Cocktails

Mimosa

$10.00

Bloody Mary

$11.00

fresh horseradish, spices, tomato juice & aquavit

Italian Fizz

$9.00

carpano antica sweet vermouth, fernet branca, soda & orange twist

Campari & Fresh Grapefruit

$9.00

Brunch Punch

$5.00

weekends only


Delivery

Seasonal Soup

$9.00

Bibb Lettuce Salad

$8.50

pumpkin seeds, radish, lemon & austrian pumpkin seed oil

Chilled Iceberg

$12.00

maytag blue cheese buttermilk dressing & bacon

Arugula

$11.00

bosc pears, feta cheese & pecans

Frisee

$14.00

sunchokes, lardons & confit hen egg

Roasted Beet & Carrot

$11.00

sea salt, aleppo & cayenne pepper cream

Herb & Gruyere Cheese Spätzel

$9.00

Pork Schnitzel

$21.00

pork loin, breded and fried served with home-made potato salad

Steak Frites

$30.00

niman ranch bavette served served with hand-cut french fries

The Prime Meats Burger

$18.00

1/2 lb. creekstone certified black angus, house-made sesame roll & fermented dill pickle, lettuce, tomato, onion & hand-cut french fries

Emmentaler Cashel Blue Or Grafton Cheddar

$2.00

add

Faicco's Thick Cut Bacon

$2.00

add


Sparkling

Melon De Bourgogne

$13.00

belle vue, vin mousseux de qualité nv.

Ugni Blanc

$9.00

henry varnay, blanc de blanc nv


White

Prime Meats House White

$9.00

chardonnay. fingerlakes, new york

333. Melon De Bourgogne

$11.00

chateau du coing de saint-fiacre, muscadet sèvre et maine ‘12. loire, france

336. Pinot Gris

$13.00

keller, trocken ‘12. rheinhessen, germany

337. Semillion, Sauvignon Blanc

$12.00

château graville lacoste, graves blanc '12. bordeaux, france

341. Weissburgunder

$11.00

scheu, weissburgunder trocken ‘11. pfalz, germany


Red

Prime Meats House Red

$9.00

merlot, petite verdot (served chilled). north fork, long island, new york

565. Cabernet Sauvignon

$11.00

jeanne marie ‘11 california

507. Syrah

$10.00

charles helfenbein, vin de pays des collines rhodaniennes ‘11 rhône, france

591. Pinot Noir

$15.00

lundeen, ‘11. willamette valley, oregon

568. Tempranillo

$14.00

viña alberdi, rioja, reserva ‘06. la rioja alta, spain


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading