Potter's Mill Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 149 votes
Potter's Mill Logo

Choose My State

IA

Potter's Mill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Fried Pickles

$6.99

Served with zesty sweet comeback sauce, item is vegetarian

Por Belly Cracklins

$7.99

Item is gluten free

Smoked Chicken Wings

$6.99

Item is gluten free

Smoked Salmon

$8.99

Served cold with a corn relish, item is gluten free

Fried Green Tomatoes

$8.99

Hand breaded garden green tomatoes fried & served with homemade comeback sauce & topped with a chilled crab meat salad

Burnt Ends

$7.99

Served friday & saturday only

Rib Tips

$7.99


Salads & SoupDressing: ranch, french, honey mustard, raspberry vinaigrette and southem chipotle ranch

Blackened Catfish Salad

$7.99

Mixed greens, blackened catfish fillet, all topped with a roasted corn salsa, item is gluten free

House Salad

$6.99

Mixed greens, red onion, tomatoes, croutons, carrots, served with choice of our house dressings, item is vegetarian

Grilled Pineapple Salad

$6.99

Mixed greens, grilled pineapple chunks, candied walnuts, sweet red peppers & apples

Smoked Chicken Salad

$7.99

Southern influence on a traditional chicken salad, served over a bed of leaf lettuce with a side of french bread, item is gluten free

Soup

$2.99 - $3.99

Your choice of gumbo or sour soup of the day


SandwichesServed with a choice of one side dish

Breaded Shrimp Po Boy

$9.99

Breaded fried shrimp paired with lettuce, tomato & house made remoulade all on a toasted bun

Blackened Catfish Po Boy

$9.99

Cast-iron blackened catfish served on a hearty bun with leaf lettuce, tomato on a toasted bun

BBQ Chicken

$7.99

Slow smoked & hand pulled served on a toasted kaiser bun

Pulled Pork

$8.99

Slow smoked pork & served on a toasted bun

Beef Brisket

$8.99

Tender brisket smoked to perfection & served on a gourmet bun


From the PitAll pit dinners are served with combread & your choice of two sides. Each item is hand rubbed with flatted fifths home seasonings then slow rasted with a hickory smoke essence

Pulled Pork Dinner

$14.99

Homemade spice rub, hickory smoked & hand pulled

St. Louis Style Rib Dinner

$14.99

Chef trimmed rib racks hand rubbed & slow smoked

Smoked Chicken Dinner

$13.99

Marinated and smoked half-chickens

Brisket Dinner

$15.99

Choice brisket hickory smoked hand sliced


Southern SpecialtiesBelow meals are served with a choice of two sides

Southern Fried Chicken

$13.99

Quartered golden fried chicken

Blackened Catfish

$14.99

A perfectly blackened fillet topped with crab meat & lightly drizzled with bearnaise sauce

Fried Catfish

$14.99

Hand breaded & deep fried fillet

Barbeque Shrimp

$15.99

Shrimp sauteed in butter, rosemary, garlic, worcestershire & a dash of hot sauce, item is gluten free


Southern Specialties_ABelow meals are served with a choice of soup or salad

Chicken Etoufee

$12.99

A creamy roux served with celery, onions, peppers & chicken served over a bed of rice

Shrimp & Cheesey Grits

$15.99

Sauteed shrimp in a light sauce over roasted vegetables & wqhite cheddar grits, item is gluten free

Shrimp Creole

$15.99

Shrimp served in a spicy tomato broth served over a bed of rice

Chicken Pot Pie

$12.99

Smoked chicken in savory filling with onions, celery, carrots, peas & corn topped with a flake crust

New Orleans Bouillabaisse

$16.99

Scallops, shrimp, little neck clams, & whitefish stewed in a rich tomato broth of onions, tomatoes, white wine, olive oil, garlic, saffron & fresh herbs, served with rice & french bread

Chicken Tchoupitoulas

$14.99

Two blackened chicken breasts topped with a creamy bearnaise sauce & served over sauteed potatoes, ham, onions & peppers

Red Beans & Rice

$12.99

Tender red beans paired with smoked sausage onions, celery & a bit of garlic, served over white rice, item is gluten free

Chicken & Sausage Jambalaya

$12.99

Creole-style jambalaya with tender smoked chicken, andouille sausage, bell peppers, celery, onion and rice, item is gluten free


SidesAdd an additional side $2.00

Side Salad

Price may varies

Grilled Pineapple Cole Slaw

Price may varies

Dirty Rice

Price may varies

Baked Beans

Price may varies

Corn Bread

Price may varies

Seasoned Smoked French Fries

Price may varies

Red Beans & Rice Potato Salad

Price may varies

Corn Maque Choux

Price may varies

Potato Salad

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading