Menu With Price > Menu > Pops Sunset Grill

Pops Sunset Grill Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 162 votes

Choose My State

Pops Sunset Grill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Sunset StartersYou will enjoy Pop's anytime of the day but particularly as the sun sets along the intracoastal waterway

Buffalo Style Shrimp

$10.95

Served mild, medium, hot, or volcanic; with celery sticks and bleu cheese dressing

Coconut Shrimp

$11.95

Golden fried with a mild oriental and "colada" dipping sauces

Conch Fritters

$9.50

Slightly spicy with remoulade sauce

Wings 'n Things

$10.50

Four Styles - mild, medium, hot or teriyaki served with celery and bleu cheese dressing

Fried Calamari

$9.75

A generous portion of hand breaded golden fried calamari served with Pop's marinara sauce

Black Beans & Rice

$4.75

With sour cream & Pop's own salsa

Fried Pickles

$7.75

Surprisingly tasty fried dill spear/ranch dressing

Chili Topped Nachos - Big enough for two!

$8.75

Crispy tortilla chips, chili, creamy sharp cheddar cheese, fresh sliced jalapenos, our house made salsa, sour cream and guacamole

Grande' Quesadillas

$10.75

Chicken, shrimp, or veggie with jack cheese, peppers, onions, sour cream and our own salsa.

Casey Key SaladsSalads served with a choice of Oil & Vinegar, Ranch, Italian, Lemon Vinaigrette, Thousand Island, and Blue Cheese dressing, unless otherwise noted. *Enjoy our Casey Key Salads topped with your choice of wood grilled: Chicken $5.25; Shrimp $6.25; Mahi 9.25; Salmon $9.25

Pop's Caesar Style Salad*

$8.95

Fresh lettuce mix served with caesar dressing & topped with parmesan cheese and croutons

Mediterranean Style Salad*

$9.95

Crisp lettuce, tomato, green pepper, banana peppers, cucumber, red onion, tossed with black olives & feta cheese. Served with grilled pita bread, hummus and lemon vinaigrette

West Coast Salad

$14.95

Mixed greens, spinach leaves topped with wood grilled shrimp, orange & grapefruit sections, tomato, avocado, cucumber and lemon herb vinaigrette.

Pop's House Salad

$5.95

Fresh mixed greens topped with ripe tomato, cucumber and red onion slices.

Casey Key Soup Mugs

Pop's Seafood Gumbo

$5.95

Loaded with Seafood in a rich tomato broth

Clam Chowder

$5.95

Creamy New England Style

Today's Soup Selection

Your server will tell you more Always special

Pop's "In Paradise" BurgersOur 8 oz all beef burgers are wood grilled and served on a freshly baked bun with a pickle and a choice of fries, edamame salad or coleslaw. Substitute sweet potato fries for $2.25 or our house salad for $3.50 additional. Burgers Cooked to a minimum - Pink or No Pink. Please be aware that there is an inherent risk of food borne illness when consuming under cooked or raw animal products

USA Classic Burger

$9.95

Grilled all beef burger meets garden-fresh lettuce, lush tomatoes and a crunchy dill pickle. What more could a mouth want? Served with American or Cheddar cheese

Harbor Island Bahama Mama

$10.95

Our 8 oz burger topped with a slice of pineapple and mozzarella cheese with a mild teriyaki sauce.

Black Jack Burger

$10.50

Smokin' hot, grill-blackened burger. Pepper Jack cheese, crisp lettuce and tomatoes. Garnished with fresh sliced jalepenos

Turkey Burger

$9.50

Grilled ground turkey, crisp fresh lettuce, tomato, and guacamole

Portobello "Veggie Stack"

$9.95

Large portobello mushroom cap (no meat here!) topped with grilled onions, lettuce, peppers, tomato and dill pickle slices on a soft fresh roll

Sandwiches & WrapsOur sandwiches are served with a pickle and a choice of fries, edamame salad or coleslaw. Substitute sweet potato fries for $2.25 or our house salad for $3.50 additional

Turkey, Bacon, Swiss Panini

$11.95

Roast turkey breast, bacon, tomato & Swiss cheese grilled hot and melted together on whole grain Panini

Grilled Salmon BLT

$14.25

Topped with bacon, lettuce and tomato on rye

Crab Salad Croissant

$16.95

A generous portion of Pop's own homemade crab salad on a fresh croissant, topped with lettuce and tomato

Our "Famous" Grouper Reuben

$15.75

A fried filet, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and thousand island dressing. A Pop's local favorite!

Spicy Tuna Wrap

$14.25

Sliced fresh tuna in a warm sesame wrap with crispy slaw and wasabi mayo

Chicken Wrap

$10.50

Wood grilled chicken with bacon, lettuce, tomato and a bistro sauce

Brick Oven Breads Not your typical pie!We use super thin flatbread with fresh toppings and bake it in our brick oven - great for sharing!

Margherita Flatbread

$13.95

A combination of vine ripened tomato, fresh mozzarella and basil.

Big Eye Pepperoni Flatbread

$13.95

Oversized pepperoni slices with a blend of provolone and mozarella cheeses.

Features From Our Wood Burning GrillCooked over our wood fired grill with your choice of fries, edamame salad or coleslaw. Substitute sweet potato fries for $2.25 or our house salad for $3.50 additional.

Grilled Mango Rub Shrimp

$17.95

Large shrimp grilled with a not too spicy rub, and drizzled with Mango BBQ Sauce

Grilled Chicken Kebobs

$14.95

Chicken glazed with a Jack Daniels BBQ sauce

Mixed Seafood Grill

$25.75

Lobster tail, a mango shrimp skewer and our catch of the day

Rack of Ribs

$18.95

Wood grilled rack of pork ribs layered with a Jack Daniels BBQ sauce.

Today's Catch of the Day

Your server will tell you more!

Pop's Entree PlattersSelections Served with a choice of any two sides. The items are served with a choice of; French Fries, Coleslaw, Edamame Salad, Sweet Potato, Vegetable Skewer, Black Beans & Rice, Baked Mac 'n' Cheese. Substitute our house salad for $3.50 additional

Pop's Deviled Crab Cakes

$21.95

A generous portion of Pop's special recipe

Pop's Fried Seafood Platter

$22.95

Shrimp, scallops, white fish, & deviled crab

Chilled Jumbo Shrimp & Crab Combo

$17.95

We pair chilled jumbo shrimp with our own delicious housemade crab salad served on a bed of lettuce with a side of edamame salad

Pop's "Red Plate" Special

Your server will tell you more!

Kids Menufor the Young..or for the young at heart! Served with choice of Apple Sauce, Baked Mac & Cheese or French Fries and dessert pudding

Cheeseburger

$6.95

Popcorn Chicken or Shrimp

$6.95

Fish Fingers

$6.95

Chicken and Cheese Quesadilla

$6.95

Unlimited Beverages

Iced Ted

$2.50

Sweet Tea

$2.50

Coffee

$2.50

Decaf Coffee

$2.50

Pepsi

$2.50

Diet Pepsi

$2.50

Mt. Dew

$2.50

Sierra Mist

$2.50

Dr. Pepper & Lemonaide

$2.50

Our Favorite Desserts

Warm and Gooey Pineapple Upside Down Cake

$6.25

Key Lime Pie

$6.25

Hershey Chocolate "Cobbler" Cake

$6.25

with Vanilla Bean Ice Cream

Pop's Traditional Old Fashioned "Fry" BasketsAll favorites for many years, served with a choice of french fries, coleslaw or edamame salad. Substitute sweet potato fries for $2.25 or our house salad for $3.50 additional

Fried Shrimp

$14.95

Lightly seasoned and fried to a golden brown.

Fried Sea Scallops

$16.95

Lightly breaded and fried to perfection.

Fried Shrimp and Sea Scallops

$16.95

Hand breaded and lightly seasoned.

Coconut Shrimp

$14.95

Rolled in a coconut breading served with mild oriental and colada sauces

Fried Clam Strips

$9.25

Hand breaded and served with cocktail sauce

Fish Basket

$10.95

Mild white fish fried to a golden brown

Original Urbanek's Steamship PotsYour choice of any two seafood steamer items and include corn on the cob, red bliss potatoes, onions, carrots & celery from the steamer with drawn butter and spicy cocktail sauce

Full Steamship

$36.95

(Enough for Two!) Your choice of two of the following: 24 shrimp, 24 oysters, 2 lbs mussels, 2 lobster tails

Half Steamship

$28.95

Your choice of two of the following: 12 shrimp, 12 oysters, 1 lb mussels, 1 lobster tails

Seafood & Raw Bar

Chilled or Peel n' Eat Shrimp

$14.95 - $25.95

Mussels

$9.25 - $17.75

Lobster Tail

Oysters on the 1/2 Shell

Based on availability and quality

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.