Pony Express To Go Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 136 votes
Pony Express To Go Logo

Choose My State

NY

Pony Express To Go Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


The Watering HoleThe Watering Hole

Spring Water

$1.50

Bottled Sodas

$1.75

Natural Sparkling Juices

$1.75

All Natural Iced Tea

$2.00

Natural Cane Sodas

$1.75


Soup

Vegetarian Black Bean Chili

$3.25 - $4.75

Southwestern Beef Chili

$4.25 - $6.25


SaladsSalads

Phil's Salad

$9.25

Grilled shrimp, guacamole, toasted tortilla, shredded lettuce, tomato, salsa and Express sauce.


Chopped Salad Saddle BagsChopped Salad Saddle Bags

Chopped Salad Saddle Bags

$6.75 - $4.50

A bed of fresh natural greens and sliced tomatoes with your choice of protein.


SlidersSliders

Plain Sliders

$5.95

Just beef. Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

Natural Cheddar Cheese Sliders

$6.25

Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

Chili Sliders

$6.25

All beef. Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

Smothered Sweet Onions Sliders

$6.25

Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

Relish Sliders

$6.25

Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

The Works Sliders

$6.75

Two sliders served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.


Big BurgerBig Burger

The Swiss Burger

$7.95

Burger topped with melted Swiss cheese and smothered vidalia onions. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

The St. Louis Burger

$9.50

Burger topped with pulled pork, smothered vidalia onions, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

Forest Burger

$9.50

Burger topped with portobello mushrooms, smothered vidalia onions and chunky blue cheese. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

El Mexicali Burger

$9.50

Burger topped with guacamole, salsa and jalapeno-jack cheese then drizzled with chipotle sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil. Spicy.

The Charro Burger

$9.50

Burger topped with lettuce, pickles, smoked bacon, jalapeno cheese and spicy chipotle sauce. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

The Bomb Burger

$7.95

Burger topped with lettuce, tomato, mayo and cheddar cheese. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

The Surf and Turf Burger

$14.95

Burger topped with lobster and peaky-toe crab salad and two grilled shrimp. Served on a toasty handmade roll with crispy french fries cooked in zero trans fats oil.

The Portobello Burger

$7.75

Grilled portobello cap, sauteed onion, lettuce, tomatoes, guacamole and your choice of salad or fries. Served on a toasty handmade roll.


Hot DogsHot Dogs

Plain Hot Dog

$3.00

100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

Sauerkraut Hot Dog

$3.50

100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

Smothered Onions Hot Dog

$3.50

100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

Southwestern Chili Hot Dog

$3.75

100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.

Black Bean Chili Hot Dog

$3.50

100% organic beef in natural casing. Served on fresh homemade toasted rolls.


SeafoodSeafood

Lobster Roll

$13.50

Chucky Maine lobster. peaky-toe crab, organic roasted corn, celery and our special lobster sauce stuffed into our toasted hot dog roll with your choice of french fries or salad.

2 Crab Cake Sliders

$8.95

Served with your choice of french fries or green salad. Topped with Express sauce.


Southwestern WrapsSouthwestern Wraps

Black Bean Wrap

$6.50

Southwestern black beans, lettuce, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

Beef Wrap

$7.50

Southwestern all beef chili, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

Chicken Wrap

$7.50

Southwestern-spiced chicken, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

Shrimp Wrap

$8.25

Southwestern-spiced shrimp, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

Pork Wrap

$7.50

Southwestern pulled pork, lettuce, cheese, onions and salsa. Served in a large toasted tortilla.

Guac 333 Wrap

$8.25

Guacamole, salsa and chips. Served in a large toasted tortilla.


Pulled BBQPulled BBQ

Pulled Chicken Sandwich

$7.75

Pulled chicken, melted cheese and BBQ sauce on a toasted handmade roll. Served with your choice of side.

Pulled Pork Sandwich

$7.75

Pulled pork, melted cheese and BBQ sauce on a toasted handmade roll. Served with your choice of side.


ChickenChicken

Grilled Chicken BLT

$7.75

Grilled chicken breast on top of a toasted handmade roll splashed with Pony's chipotle sauce with two strips of Dines organic bacon, lettuce and tomatoes. Served with your choice of side.

Chicken Chipotle Cheese Roll

$7.25

Grilled chicken, melted cheese, smothered onions, smokey chipotle sauce and salsa on a toasted handmade hot dog roll. Served with your choice of salad or french fries.


Our Original Saddle BagsOur Original Saddle Bags

Chicken Saddle Bags

$6.95

Served on a bed of crispy french fries.

Shrimp Saddle Bags

$8.95

Served on a bed of crispy french fries.


TaquitosTaquitos

Southwest Beef Chili Taquito

$3.95

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Black Bean Chili Taquito

$3.75

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Crab and Lobster Taquito

$4.50

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Pulled Chicken Taquito

$3.95

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Grilled Chicken Taquito

$3.95

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Pork Taquito

$3.95

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.

Shrimp Taquito

$4.50

All-natural gluten-free crisp or soft tortilla filled with shredded lettuce, salsa and avocado with your choice of sauce.


QuesadillasQuesadillas

Original Quesadilla

$6.50

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

Vegetarian Black Bean Chili Quesadilla

$6.75

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

Chicken Quesadilla

$7.25

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

Shrimp Quesadilla

$8.25

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

Just Plain Gooey Cheese Quesadilla

$6.25

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.

Pulled Pork Quesadilla

$7.75

All-natural tortilla, smothered onions, salsa and cheddar-jack cheese, grilled and served with Express dipping sauce.


SidesSides

French Fries

$2.95

Cheese Fries

$3.50

Cheese Fries with Chili

$4.25

Sweet Potato Fries

$3.75

Sweet Potato Fries with Cheese

$4.25

Sweet Potato Fries with Chili

$4.75

2 Picklelicious Pickles

$1.25

Pony's Express Sauce

$3.25 - $4.75

Pony's Chipotle Sauce

$3.25 - $4.75

Guacamole

$4.25 - $6.25


Kid's Hoppy MealKid's Hoppy Meal

Kid's Hoppy Meal

$6.50

Served with french fries, all-natural apple juice, organic cookies and an organic fruit strip.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading