Menu With Price > Menu > Pony Express Pizza

Pony Express Pizza Menu and Prices

3.8 based on 171 votes
Pony Express Pizza Logo
Pizza

Choose My State

OH

Pony Express Pizza Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Appetizers

Jalapeno Poppers (5)

$4.75

Cream or cheddar cheese with ranch sauce

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks (5)

$4.75

Cream or cheddar cheese with ranch sauce

Bread Sticks

$2.99

Cheese Bread and Sticks

$4.75

SaladsDressings: Ranch, fat-free ranch, blue cheese, italian, fat-free italian, caesar, balsamic vinaigrette, thousand island, french, sweet & sour

Large Antipasto

$5.95

Lettuce, salami, tomato, pepperoni, pepper, ham, provolone

Individual Size Antipasto

$2.95

Large Tossed Salad

$3.95

Individual Size Tossed

$1.50

Greek Salad

$7.99

Dinners

Chicken Fingers

$8.50

6 pieces, French fries, cole slaw & bun

Chicken Parmesan

$7.25

4 Tenders smothered in sauce and cheese

Fish Dinner

$6.95

3 pieces, French fries, cole slaw and bun

Shrinp Dinner

$7.50

16 pieces, French fries, cole slaw & bun

Greek Sandwich

$5.99

Authentic greek style gyros on pita bread with tomato, onion and special cucumber sauce

Traditional PizzaToppings: Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, double cheese, meatballs, ham, salami, anchovies, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, pineapple, bacon, tomato.

Plain Cheese Pizza

$6.00 - $11.00

Extra cheese $1.50 (small, 6 slice) $2.00 (medium, 8 slice) $2.50 (large, 12 slice). Each additional item $0.75 (small, 6 slice) $1.25 (medium, 8 slice) $1.75 (large, 12 slice)

Full Sheet Pizza

$21.00

Extra toppings $3.00. Extra cheese for pizza $4.00. (32 slices)

SubsAll subs include your choice of provolone cheese, hot peppers, mushrooms, green peppers and onions.

Italian

$5.50 - $6.75

Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, italian dressing, lettuce & tomato

Meatball

$5.50 - $6.75

Sausage

$5.50 - $6.75

Gyro

$5.99 - $6.75

Fish

$5.50 - $6.75

Chicken Parmesan

$5.50 - $7.00

ChickenA unique blend of vegtable oils low in saturated fats and cholesterol

Snack

$4.50

2 pieces and jo jo's or french fries, cole slaw and bun.

Snack All White

$5.50

1 breast and 1 wing

Regular Box

$7.50

4 pieces and jo jo's or french fries, cole slaw and bun.

Regular Box All White

$9.50

2 breasts and 2 wings

Jumbo Box

$13.25

8 pieces and jo jo's or french fries

Jumbo Box All White

$7.50

4 breasts and 4 wings

Family Box

$18.95

12 pieces and jo jo's or french fries

Family Box All White

$22.95

6 breasts and 6 wings

Dark Meat Special

$10.95

8 pieces of chicken all dark and 8 Jo Jo's

Chicken only 50 pieces Mixed

$58.50

Chicken only 50 pieces Dark

$53.50

Chicken only 50 pieces White

$75.00

Chicken only 50 pieces Breasts

$115.00

Chicken only 100 pieces Mixed

$115.00

Breast Chicken only

$3.00

Leg Chicken only

$1.25

Thigh Chicken only

$1.25

Wing Chicken Only

$1.25

Jumbo Buffalo WingsSauces: Flaming hot, medium hot, barbecue, garlic, teriyaki

12 Buffalo Wings

$8.95

20 Buffalo Wings

$15.50

24 Buffalo Wings

$16.50

50 Buffalo Wings

$31.75

100 Buffalo Wings

$57.50

Specialty PizzaThin crust available on medium or large sizes only

Veggie Pizza

$9.25 - $18.50

Mushrooms, green pepper, onion, black olives, tomato

Meatlover Delite

$9.25 - $18.50

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon, meatball

White Pizza

$7.75 - $15.50

Cheese, tomatoes, pepper rings, black olives. Choose your sauce - tasty ranch or garlic

Tropical Delite

$8.50 - $16.50

Pineapple, ham & bacon. Half dinner and half dessert

Italian Stallion

$9.25 - $18.50

Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, ham, hot peppers

Sheet Pizza

$21.00

32 pieces. Each additional item $3.00, extra cheese $4.00

Sides

Jo Jo's (4)

$1.50

French Fries (6 oz)

$1.99

Deep Fried Mushrooms

$1.99

Onion Rings

$1.99

Cole Slaw (4oz)

$1.50

Cole Slaw (12oz)

$2.75

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading

Popular Brands