Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 68 votes
Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Logo
Italian
Pizza

Choose My State

NY

Plum Tomatoes Pizzeria Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Hot Antipasto

$12.75

a combination of shrimp, clams oreganata, mussels, eggplant rollatini and stuffed mushroom served with marinara sauce

Mozzarella Primavera

$11.95

fresh homemade mozzarella with tomatoes, roasted peppers, garlic, extra virgin tuscan olive oil and fresh basil

Mussels Posillipo

$11.95

mussels sauteed with marinara sauce, parsley and fresh basil

Clams Oreganata

$11.75 - $7.75

littleneck clams on the half shell stuffed with seasoned bread crumbs and herbs, then lightly grilled

Mozzarella Sticks

$6.75

mozzarella in seasoned bread crumbs served with tomato sauce

Fried Calamari

$10.95

lightly fried calamari served with our classic marinara sauce

Chicken Fingers With French Fries

$9.75

lightly breaded chicken tenders served with honey mustard or italian tomato sauce

Eggplant Rollatini

$9.45

ricotta stuffed eggplant topped with a hearty marinara sauce and mozzarella cheese

Crispy Buffalo Wings

$9.75

served with bleu cheese and crudite

Pepperoni Pinwheel

$3.25

sliced pepperoni and mozzarella rolled in our homemade pizza dough

Garlic Knots

$3.25 - $4.50

baked pizza dough knots marinated with fresh garlic, parsley, grated cheese and olive oil

Chicken Roll

$5.50

pizza dough rolled with tender strips of sauteed chicken, tomato sauce, onions, mozzarella cheese and spices

Sausage Roll

$5.25

pizza dough rolled with sausage peppers, onions and mozzarella cheese

Spinach Roll

$5.25

pizza dough rolled with sauteed spinach, garlic, onions and mozzarella cheese

Cheese Calzone

$5.75

pizza dough pockets filled with whole milk ricotta and mozzarella cheese

Cheese Calzone

$1.00

add your choice of stuffing

Garlic Bread

$3.50

french garlic, olive oil, grated cheese and spices

Garlic Bread

$4.00

with mozzarella

Broccoli Pinwheel

$3.25

sauteed broccoli, mozzarella and grated cheese rolled in our homemade pizza dough.

Shrimp Cocktail

$12.95

6 succulent shrimp chilled and served on a bed of lettuce and cocktail sauce

Stuffed Mushrooms

$8.95

stuffed with mushrooms, seasoned bread crumbs, fresh garlic and roasted peppers topped with fresh plum tomato sauce

Focaccia Sticks

$3.75 - $4.75

fresh garlic, caramelized onions, fresh plum tomato sauce topped with pecorino romano cheese


SaladsAny Chopped Salad Extra $2.

Caesar Salad

$8.50

romaine lettuce combined with croutons and parmesan cheese in anchovy garlic dressing

Caesar Salad

$10.50

with grilled chicken

Garden Salad

$10.95

lettuce, tomato, cucumber, shredded carrots, broccoli and onions topped with mozzarella red peppers and black olives. served with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

Italian Salad

$7.95 - $5.25

lettuce, tomatoes, pepperoncini, red onions and black olives served with our own homemade balsamic vinaigrette dressing

Greek Salad

$11.25

mixed greens, plum tomatoes, red onions, black olives, feta cheese and stuffed grape leaves served with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette dressing

Grilled Seafood Salad

$12.50

grilled calamari, slipper lobster tail and shrimp over a bed of greens and topped with a lemon vinaigrette dressing

Plum Tomatoes Salad

$12.50

fresh grilled breast of chicken surrounded in a mixture of green olives, fresh greens, vegetables and gorgonzola cheese served with a creamy balsamic vinaigrette dressing.

Antipasto Supreme

$11.95

imported provolone, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella soppressata, ham, marinated olives, artichoke mushrooms tomatoes, red onion and radicchio on a bed romaine lettuce served with balsamic vinaigrette dr

Warm Goat Cheese Salad

$11.25

,mesclun salad, warm battered goat cheese, sliced beets, grilled pears, dried cranberries and candied walnuts topped with homemade raspberry vinaigrette dressing

Flame Roasted Corn Salad

$12.75

mixed greens, plum tomatoes, red onions goat cheese, sliced beets, shredded carrots, fresh toasted corn and grilled chicken tossed in our homemade balsamic vinaigrette


SoupsOutgoing / To Stay

Minestrone

$6.45 - $5.45

hearty vegetable soup

Stracciatella Florentina

$4.95 - $5.95

spinach, eggs and parmesan cheese in a delightful chicken broth

Soup Of The Day

$6.45 - $5.45

Tortellini In Brodo

$5.95 - $4.95

Pasta Fagioli

$6.45 - $5.45

mixed cut pasta and cannellini beans with a touch of fresh tomato, garlic and italian prosciutto


PizzaRound 8 Slices / Sicilian 12 Slices / Slice $2.25 / Slice Of The Week $4 Toppings: sausage, mushrooms, peppers, onions, meatballs, anchovies, pepperoni, garlic, sun dried tomatoes, olives, fresh artichokes, fresh roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella cheese a

Cheese

$16.95 - $13.50

One Topping

$16.25 - $19.25

Two Toppings

$20.75 - $17.75

Three Toppings

$22.25 - $19.25

Deluxe

$23.75 - $21.25


Specialty PizzaAll Specialty Pizzas Are Also Sold By The Slice Except Whole Wheat And Gluten Free Pizza.

Vegetable Delight

$20.95

fresh broccoli, spinach, red pepper, mushrooms and pecorino romano cheese.

White Pizza

$20.95

ricotta, mozzarella, grated cheese, fresh garlic and parsley

Margherita

$20.95

fresh plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil on a brick oven style crust. topped with extra virgin olive oil and grated cheese.

Salad Pizza

$19.95

lettuce, fresh plum tomatoes, red bermuda onion extra virgin olive oil, salt, pepper, oregano and grated cheese.

Taco Pizza

$22.95

spiced fresh chopped meat, monterey jack cheese, diced tomatoes and shredded lettuce topped with cheddar cheese on a brick oven style crust

Marinara Pizza

$18.95

fresh plum tomatoes, sauce, basil and pecorino romano cheese on a sicilian crust

Bar Pie 12" - Delicious

$7.50

whole wheat thin crust, mozzarella and tomato sauce

Grandma

$20.95

thin crispy crust topped with mozzarella cheese and sprouted with flavorful plum tomato sauce, grated romano cheese and herbs

Bruschetta

$21.95

thin crispy crust topped with mozzarella cheese, fresh plum tomato salad and extra virgin olive oil and flavored with spices.

Chicken Plum

$22.95

diced fried chicken spotted with tomato sauce, extra virgin olive oil, mozzarella and grated romano cheese

Focaccia Primavera Square

$22.95

fresh mozzarella cheese and sliced plum tomatoes topped with pesto sauce and flame roasted peppers in extra virgin olive oil on garlic crust

Buffalo Wing Pizza

$22.95

diced chicken sauteed in a spicy wing sauce served on brick oven style crust, then topped with mozzarella cheese, bleu cheese and scallions

Upside Down Square

$22.95

fresh square dough topped with a cooked plum tomato sauce, homemade fresh mozzarella cheese and grated pecorino romano cheese

Gluten Free Pie

$13.95


HerosAll Cold Heros, Including Chicken Club, Topped With Lettuce, Tomato And Home Made Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing Add Parmigiana To The Following Subs $0.75 Extra.

Shrimp

$9.50

Meatball

$7.75

Sausage

$7.75

Sausage And Peppers

$8.25

Eggplant

$7.75

Veal Cutlet

$8.75

Chicken Cutlet

$8.25

Peppers And Egg

$7.25

Ham Or Salami And Provolone

$6.25

Combo

$6.75

Grilled Chicken Club

$8.50

Grilled Chicken Broccoli Rabe

$9.25

sauteed broccoli rabe, cherry peppers and extra virgin olive oil.

Premium Burger

$10.95

served with lettuce, beef steal tomatoes sliced bermuda onions, cheddar cheese served with french fries

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$8.95

on wheat wrap with our special homemade dressing served with french fries


Panini $6.95Fresh Homemade Oven Baked Stuffed Rolls.

1. Grilled Chicken

Price may varies

flame roasted peppers and sauteed broccoli rabe, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil

2. Prosciutto

Price may varies

fresh homemade mozzarella cheese beefsteak tomato, spices and extra virgin olive oil

3. Marinated Grilled Eggplant

Price may varies

fresh homemade mozzarella cheese, beefsteak tomato, spices and drizzled with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing

4. Flame Roasted Portobello Mushroom

Price may varies

fresh homemade mozzarella cheese, beef steak tomato, spices and drizzled with a balsamic vinaigrette dressing


PastaServed With Breaded Whole Wheat Pasta Add $1.50 Or Gluten Free Pasta (Penne, Linguini, Spaghetti) Add $3.

Penne Vodka

$11.25

penne served in a light pink vodka cream sauce

Linguini Shrimp Fra Diavolo

$12.95

shrimp sauteed in a spicy marinara sauce and fresh basil served over linguini

Penne Melanzane

$12.25

penne with diced eggplant and roasted ricotta salata cheese in a delightful red sauce

Capellini Primavera

$12.25

angel hair pasta with assorted fresh spring vegetables in a delicate white sauce

Linguini Contadino

$12.50

a combination of linguini, grilled chicken breast, fresh tomatoes, asparagus, garlic and fresh basil

Capellini Arrabiata

$14.50

angel hair pasta with shrimp, clams, mussels and calamari sauteed with capers in a white wine sauce. sa touch on the spicy side

Tortellini Alfredo

$12.25

pink or white sauce cheese filled tortellini in a white or pink cream sauce with imported romano cheese and fresh parsley

Fettuccini Alla Filetto Dimanzo

$13.95

fresh fettuccini pasta topped with sauteed filet mignon and portobello mushrooms in a port wine sauce

Linguini

$12.50

red or white clam sauce chopped littleneck clams sauteed with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic and white wine over linguini

Spaghetti

$9.25

with tomato sauce

Spaghetti

$9.25

with marinara sauce.

Spaghetti

$9.95

with meat sauce

Spaghetti

$9.50

garlic and oil. sauteed garlic and extra virgin olive oil over spaghetti topped with grated pecorino romano cheese and fresh parsley

Fettuccini Alfredo

$12.25

fresh homemade fettuccini in a delicate cream sauce topped with grated pecorino romano cheese and fresh parsley

Calamari Fra Diavolo

$12.50

calamari sauteed in a spicy marinara sauce and fresh basil served over linguini

Gnocchi Sorrentino

$12.50

fresh potato dumplings sauteed with garlic, plum tomato sauce and fresh basil topped with diced homemade fresh mozzarella

Spaghetti Carbonara

$12.50

sauteed italian pancetta, onions and chicken stock topped with locatelli romano cheese

Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

$13.95

orecchiette pasta, sauteed fresh garlic, extra virgin olive oil, broccoli rabe and sausage


DinnersServed With Salad, Bread And Spaghetti.

Eggplant Parmigiana

$14.25

sliced battered eggplant served with our homemade marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

Meatball Or Sausage

$14.25

served with homemade tomato sauce

Chicken Parmigiana

$14.95

chicken cutlet served with our homemade tomato sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

Veal Parmigiana

$15.95

veal cutlet served with plum tomato sauce and topped with mozzarella cheese

Shrimp Parmigiana

$15.95

shrimp served with marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese.

Fried Calamari

$14.95

Calamari In Marinara Sauce

$13.95

Eggplant Rollatini

$14.95

sliced, battered eggplant, stuffed and roiled with a creamy seasoned ricotta cheese filling, topped with marinara sauce and mozzarella.

Stuffed Shells

$13.95

shells filled with ricotta cheese, fresh parsley, grated romano cheese and topped with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese.

Lasagna

$13.95

layers of pasta, ricotta cheese, ground beef, mozzarella, tomato sauce and grated romano cheese

Baked Ziti

$11.50

ziti with whole milk ricotta, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, then baked

Manicotti

$11.50

fresh pasta crepe filled with seasoned whole milk, ricotta cheese, tomato sauce and mozzarella, then baked to perfection

Cheese Filled Ravioli

$11.50

cheese filled ravioli with tomato sauce and topped with fresh parsley


Chicken $14.75Served With Potato And Vegetable Of The Day.

Chicken Capriccios

Price may varies

two grilled chicken breasts topped with romaine lettuce, tomato and onion salad served with balsamic vinaigrette dressing

Chicken Pizzaiola

Price may varies

breast of chicken sauteed with mushrooms in a hearty tomato sauce and served with spaghetti.

Chicken Sorrentino

Price may varies

chicken sorrentino sauteed in a light brown sauce topped with eggplant and mozzarella cheese.

Chicken Francese

Price may varies

breast of chicken dipped in egg and sauteed in a butter lemon white wine sauce

Chicken Piccata

Price may varies

chicken breast sauteed in a butter and lemon white wine sauce

Chicken Marsala

Price may varies

chicken breast sauteed with mushrooms in butter and marsala wine


Veal $15.75Served With Potato And Vegetable Of The Day.

Veal Sorrentino

Price may varies

veal scaloppine sauteed in a light brown sauce and topped with eggplant and mozzarella cheese.

Veal Piccata

Price may varies

veal scaloppine sauteed in a butter and lemon white wine sauce

Veal Marsala

Price may varies

veal scaloppine sauteed with mushrooms in butter and marsala wine

Veal Francese

Price may varies

veal scallopini dipped in egg and sauteed in a butter lemon white wine sauce


SeafoodServed With Rice, Zuppa Di Pesce Served With Linguini.

Grilled Salmon

$15.50

grilled salmon served in a lemon caper sauce

Shrimp Oreganata

$15.50

lightly breaded shrimp topped with seasoned bread crumbs in a lemon butter white wine sauce

Shrimp Scampi

$15.50

shrimp sauteed with garlic, butter, lemon and white wine

Zuppa Di Pesce

$24.95

shrimp, clams, mussels, lobster tail and calamari topped with a hearty spicy marinara sauce


Extras

Grilled Chicken Strips

$3.25

Individual Shrimp

$1.25

Vegetables

$2.00

spinach broccoli

Meat Sauce

$2.00

Tomato Sauce

$0.75

Garlic And Oil

$2.00

Salad Dressing

$1.00

Ricotta Cheese

$1.00

Mozzarella Cheese

$1.25

Marinara Sauce

$0.75


Side Orders

French Fries

$3.95

Broccoli

$7.50

sauteed with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic and spices, or steamed.

Broccoli Di Rabe

Price may varies

sauteed with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic and spices, or steamed.

Spinach

$7.25

sauteed with extra virgin olive oil, fresh garlic and spices, or steamed.

Sausage

$4.95

Meatballs

$4.95

Spaghetti Or Penne

$6.25

with tomato sauce or marinara sauce.

Marinara Sauce Or Tomato Sauce

$4.75 - $6.95

Meat Sauce

$5.75 - $7.75


Desserts

Tiramisu Cup

$4.75

imported mascarpone cheese layered with ladyfingers, soaked in espresso and topped with cocoa.

Black And White Mousse Cup

$4.75

belgium white chocolate mousse nesting on a bed of fine chocolate mousse topped with chocolate ganache.

Tartufo

$5.25

chocolate and vanilla ice cream with raspberry sauce, black cherry, diced almond and covered in chocolate.

American Cheesecake

$4.95

Apple Cheesecake

$4.95

Italian Ice

$1.95 - $2.30

assorted flavors, rainbow, cherry, lemon and chocolate.

Sorbet

$4.95

lemon or orange in natural fruit shell.


Beers

Budweiser

$5.00

Coors Light

$5.00

Moretti

$5.50

Moretti Dark

$5.50

Corona

$5.50

Amstel Light

$5.50

Heineken

$5.50

O'Doul's Non Alcoholic

$5.00


Beverages

Coffee

$1.65

Tea

$1.50

Espresso

$2.50

decaf

Double Espresso

$3.75

Cappuccino

$3.75

decaf

Bottled Soda

$2.20 - $3.20

Bottled Water

$1.70 - $2.50

Snapple

$1.75

San Pellegrino

$3.85 - $1.75


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading