Pie Shack Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 103 votes
Pie Shack Logo

Choose My State

NY

Pie Shack Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Menu CouponsShack Specials

1. 18" Pizza and 20 Wings Special

$21.99

2. 18" 1 Topping Pizza, 20 Wings, 2 Liter Soda and 10 Garlic Knots Special

$29.99

3. 18" Pizzas and 30 Wings Special

$35.99

Two pizzas.

4. 16" Pizza and 10 Wings Special

$14.99

5. 16" Pizza, 20 Wings and 2 Liter Soda Special

$21.99

6. 16" 1-Topping Pizzas and 2-Liter Soda

$24.99

Two pizzas.

7. 16" 1 Topping Pizzas, 50 Wings and 2 Liter Soda Special

$45.99

Two pizzas.

8. 18" Pizza and 50 Wings Special

$33.99

9. 8" Cold Subs, 2 Chips and 2 Cans of Soda Special

$9.99

Two cold subs.

10. 12" Cold Subs Special

$10.99

Two cold subs.

11. 8" Hot Subs and Fries Special

$12.99

Two hot subs.

12. Italian Dinners Special

$14.99

Two dinners.

13. 18" Pizzas Special

$22.99

Two pizzas.

14. Sheet Pizza, Free Topping, 50 Wings and 2 Liter Soda Special

$43.99

15. Sheet Pizza, Free Topping and 30 Wings Special

$32.99

16" Pizza Special (Pickup Only)

$6.99

16"-1 Topping Pizza Special (Pickup Only)

$7.99


DrinksDrinks

2 Liter Soda

$2.95

24 oz. Soda

$1.99

Arnold Palmer Arizona Iced Tea

$1.00

Can Soda

$1.00

Snapple

$1.75

Monster Energy Drink

$2.79

Vitamin Water

$1.50

Chocolate Milk

$1.50

Gatorade

$1.50

Juice

$1.50

Green Tea

$1.50

Powerade

$1.50


AppetizersAppetizers

Mozzarella Sticks

$4.75 - $8.50

Battered Mushrooms

$4.25 - $7.25

Fried Dough Ear

$2.50

Zucchini Sticks

$4.75 - $8.50

Chicken Tenders

$4.99 - $8.50

French Fries

$2.00 - $3.00

Gravy Fries

$2.75 - $4.00

Jalapeno Poppers

$4.75 - $7.99

Cheese Fries

$3.00 - $4.00

Cheese Fries with Bacon

$3.75 - $5.50

Garlic Knots

$1.25 - $3.50

Onion Rings

$3.99 - $6.99

Sampler Platter

$8.99

Three tenders, three mozzarella sticks, three poppers and small fries.

1/2 lb. Shrimp and Fries

$6.99

1/2 lb. Clams and Fries

$6.99


SaladsSalads

Garden Salad

$2.50 - $4.99

Iceberg, romaine, cucumbers, olives, green peppers, croutons, red onions and mozzarella.

Antipasto Salad

$7.50

Iceberg, romaine, roasted red peppers, banana peppers, olives, ham, salami, pepperoni, croutons, onions and mozzarella.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$6.99

Iceberg, romaine, tomatoes, onions croutons, Buffalo chicken (grilled or fried) mozzarella.

Chicken Ceaser Salad

$6.99

Romaine, roasted red peppers, onions, croutons, chicken (grilled or fried) shredded Parmesan.

Chicken Salad

$6.99

Iceberg, romaine, cucumbers, olives, green peppers, croutons, red onions, mozzarella, chicken (fried or grilled).

Julian with Bacon Salad

$6.99

Iceberg, romaine, tomatoes, cucumbers, green peppers, turkey, mozzarella, bacon, onions and croutons.


Hot SubsHot Subs

Loaded Philly Cheese Steak Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Steak and Cheddar Cheese Hot Sub

$4.99 - $5.95

Loaded Chicken Philly Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Chicken Parmesan Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Meatball Parmesan Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Chicken Cordon Bleu Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Buffalo Chicken Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Chicken Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Gianelli Sausage Parmesan Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

Sausage, Peppers and Onions Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95

BBQ Boneless Pulled Pork Hot Sub

$5.50 - $6.95


Italian DinnersItalian Dinners

Chicken Parmesan Italian Dinner

$8.99

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.

Baked Ziti Italian Dinner

$7.99

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.

Chicken Alfredo Italian Dinner

$8.99

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.

Spaghetti Italian Dinner

$6.50

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.

Lasagna Italian Dinner

$8.99

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.

Manicotti Italian Dinner

$8.99

Include small garden salad and garlic knots.


Seafood DinnersSeafood Dinners

Haddock Dinner

$10.99

Include small garden salad, fries, garlic knots, one side and tartar or cocktail sauce.

Fried Seafood Dinner

$10.99

Shrimp and clam strips. Include small garden salad, fries, garlic knots, one side and tartar or cocktail sauce.


BurgersBurgers

1/2 lb. Burger

$6.99

Cheeseburger and fries.


Fish FryFish Fry

Fish Fry Sandwich

$4.99

Include tartar sauce.

Fish Fry and Fries

$5.99

Include tartar sauce.


Cold SubsCold Subs

Ham Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Turkey Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Roast Beef Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Salami Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Albacore Tuna Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Italian Cold Sub

$4.25 - $6.25

Pepperoni, salami and ham.


SandwichesSandwiches

Ham Sandwich

$6.25

Turkey Sandwich

$6.25

Roast Beef Sandwich

$6.25

Salami Sandwich

$6.25

Albacore Tuna Sandwich

$6.25

Italian Sandwich

$6.25

Pepperoni, salami and ham.


WrapsWraps

Ham Wrap

$5.25

Turkey Wrap

$5.25

Roast Beef Wrap

$5.25

Salami Wrap

$5.25

Albacore Tuna Wrap

$5.25

Italian Wrap

$5.25

Pepperoni, salami and ham.


New York Style PizzaNew York Style Pizza

New York Style Cheese Pizza

$9.99 - $17.99


CalzonesCalzones

Calzone

$5.99

Served with ricotta cheese and you choice of toppings.


Chicken WingsChicken Wings

10 Piece Chicken Wings

$6.99

20 Piece Chicken Wings

$12.50

30 Piece Chicken Wings

$17.00

40 Piece Chicken Wings

$21.99

50 Piece Chicken Wings

$24.99


RollsRolls

Pepperoni Roll

$4.75

Sausage Roll

$4.25

Stromboli

$5.99

Pepperoni, ham, green peppers and onions.


Specialty PizzasSpecialty Pizzas

Chicken Wing Pizza

$15.99 - $17.99

Choice of mild, medium, hot or inferno.

Hawaiian Pizza

$15.99 - $17.99

Pineapple, ham, bacon and BBQ optional.

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza

$15.99 - $17.99

Steak, green peppers and onions mushrooms.

Garlic-Ricotta Tomato Pizza

$14.99 - $16.99

Tomato and ricotta cheese on garlic pizza.

Supreme

$15.99 - $17.99

Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers and onions mushrooms.

Meat Lovers

$15.99 - $17.99

Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon and meatball.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$15.99 - $17.99

Grilled chicken, bacon with ranch sauce.

Veggie Pizza

$15.99 - $17.99

Green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives and banana peppers.

Honey BBQ Chicken

$15.99 - $17.99

Grilled chicken with honey BBQ sauce.


DessertsDesserts

Homemade Cookie

$0.75

Homemade Brownie

$1.50

Cheesecake

$2.99

With chocolate or cherries.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading