Pie by the Pound Menu and Prices

4.2 based on 163 votes
Pie by the Pound Logo
Pizza
Vegetarian

Choose My State

NY

Pie by the Pound Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Salads

House

$6.00

tomato, bell peppers, white onion and romaine.

Seasonal

$6.50

arugula, tomatoes, feta, red onion, bell peppers, capers and lemon dressing.

Caprese

$6.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil and romaine.

Grilled Chicken

$8.00

grilled chicken, tomato, romaine, radicchio and white onion.

Chef

$8.00

genoa salami, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, white onion and romaine.

Greek

$7.00

feta, black olive, romaine, radicchio, tomato and red onion.

House

$6.00

tomato, bell peppers, white onion and romaine.

Seasonal

$6.50

arugula, tomatoes, feta, red onion, bell peppers, capers and lemon dressing.

Caprese

$6.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil and romaine.

Grilled Chicken

$8.00

grilled chicken, tomato, romaine, radicchio and white onion.

Chef

$8.00

genoa salami, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, white onion and romaine.

Greek

$7.00

feta, black olive, romaine, radicchio, tomato and red onion.


Truffle Grilled Sandwiches $7.95

Goat Cheese

Price may varies

goat cheese, portabella mushroom, red onion, tomato and truffle oil.

5 Cheese

Price may varies

five cheeses, tomato and truffle oil.

Ham & Provolone

Price may varies

ham, provolone, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil and truffle oil.


Cheese Pie

Cheese Pie

$14.50

mozzarella and tomato sauce.

Fresh Mozzarella

$16.00

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil.

Fresh Cubed

$16.75

cubed fresh mozzarella, mozzarella, tomato sauce, cubed tomato, garlic, oregano, basil, arugula and olive oil.

Saucy Fresh Mozzarella

$15.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic, oregano and basil.

Caprese

$16.00

fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, oregano and basil.

Snow White

$16.00

mozzarella, ricotta, oregano and garlic.

5 Cheese

$16.75

mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, gorgonzola and parmesan.

Red Eye

$16.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce dollops on top, tomato sauce, parmesan and basil.

Cheese Pie

$10.95 - $19.95

mozzarella and tomato sauce.

Fresh Mozzarella Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce and basil.

Fresh Cubed Pie

$23.75 - $14.25

cubed fresh mozzarella, mozzarella, tomato sauce, cubed tomato, garlic, oregano, basil, arugula and olive oil.

Saucy Fresh Mozzarella Pie

$13.75 - $17.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, garlic, oregano and basil.

Caprese Pie

$18.75 - $22.95

fresh mozzarella, sliced tomato, oregano and basil.

Snow White Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

mozzarella, ricotta, oregano and garlic.

5 Cheese Pie

$22.95 - $13.95

mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, provolone, gorgonzola and parmesan.

Red Eye Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce dollops on top, tomato sauce, parmesan and basil.


Veggie Pie

Eggplant

$15.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, grilled eggplant, parmesan and arugula.

Zucchini

$15.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, zucchini, red onion and arugula.

3 Pepper

$15.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, red, arugula, yellow and green pepper.

Mushroom

$15.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, portobello mushroom and arugula.

Garden

$16.25

mozzarella, zucchini, red onion, sliced tomato, peppers and lemon.

Greek Salad

$16.25

feta cheese, red onion, olive, lettuce, tomato, raddichio and tomato sauce.

Spinach

$15.95

mozzarella, ricotta, spinach and garlic.

Marinara

$13.25

capers, garlic, tomato sauce, oregano and basil.

Potato

$16.25

Veggie Marinara

$16.00

mixed vegetables, tomato sauce, capers, oregano and basil.

Olive & Onion

$15.25

black olives, spanish onion, tomato sauce, oregano and basil.

Mushroom & Eggplant

$15.50

garlic, portobello mushroom, eggplant, tomato sauce, oregano and arugula.

Eggplant Pie

$18.75 - $22.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, grilled eggplant, parmesan and arugula.

Zucchini Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

mozzarella, tomato sauce, zucchini, red onion and arugula.

3 Pepper Pie

$22.95 - $13.95

mozzarella, tomato sauce, red, yellow & green pepper and arugula.

Mushroom Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

mozzarella, tomato sauce, portobello mushroom, portabella mushroom and arugula.

Potato Pie

$13.95 - $22.95

Garden Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

mozzarella, zucchini, red onion, sliced tomato, peppers and lemon.

Greek Salad Pie

$22.95 - $18.75

feta cheese, red onion, olive, lettuce, tomato, raddichio and tomato sauce.

Spinach Pie

$13.95 - $18.75

mozzarella, ricotta, spinach and garlic.

Marinara Pie

$11.95 - $18.95

(vg). capers, garlic, tomato sauce, oregano and basil.

Veggie Marinara Pie

$21.75 - $13.25

(vg). mixed vegetables, tomato sauce, capers, oregano and basil.

Olive & Onion Pie

$20.95 - $15.95

(vg). black olives, spanish onion, tomato sauce, oregano and basil.

Mushroom & Eggplant Pie

$11.95 - $20.95

(vg). garlic, portobello mushroom, eggplant, tomato sauce, oregano and arugula.


Meat Pie

Chicken

$16.75

mozzarella, chicken, tomato sauce, rosemary, diced tomato and arugula.

Genoa Salami

$16.75

mozzarella, ricotta, genoa salami, tomato sauce and arugula.

Ham & Pepperoni

$16.25

mozzarella, italian ham, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

Sausage

$16.25

mozzarella, sweet italian sausage, onions, tomato sauce and arugula.

Pepperoni

$15.50

mozzarella, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

Bacon

$16.75

mozzarella, bacon, tomato sauce and scallion.

Brunch

$16.75

mozzarella, american cheese, bacon, egg and scallion.

Prosciutto Pizza

$16.25

mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, tomota sauce and arugula.

Chicken Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, chicken, tomato sauce, rosemary, diced tomato and arugula.

Genoa Salami Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, ricotta, genoa salami, tomato sauce and arugula.

Ham & Pepperoni Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, italian ham, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

Sausage Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, sweet italian sausage, onions, tomato sauce and arugula.

Pepperoni Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, pepperoni and tomato sauce.

Bacon Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, bacon, tomato sauce and scallion.

Brunch Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, american cheese, bacon, egg and scallion.

Prosciutto Pie

Price may varies

mozzarella, ricotta, prosciutto, tomato sauce and arugula.


Dessert

Brownie

$3.50

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$3.00

Mudslide Cookie

$3.00

Lemondrop Cookie

$3.00

Black And White Cookie

$3.50

Large Cookie

$2.95

Nutella Pie

$18.00 - $25.00

nutella, mascarpone, and powdered sugar.

Apple Pie

$15.00 - $18.00

apple and cinnamon.


Beverages

Poland Spring Water (GF)

$1.50

Canned Soda (GF)

$1.75

coke, diet coke, sprite

Honest Tea

$2.25

peach white, 1/2 & 1/2, pomegranate blueberry

Boylan's Soda (GF)

$2.25

orange soda, cream soda, black cherry soda, ginger ale, seltzer, root beer, diet root beer

Harmless Harvest Coconut Water

$5.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading