Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 135 votes
Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop Logo
Sandwiches
Hoagies

Choose My State

PA

Peppi's Old Tyme Sandwich Shop Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Fund Raiser Subs

Italian, Ham 'n Cheese, Turkey 'n Cheese or Cheese Sub

Price may varies

All subs are served on a 9-10 inch fresh baked roll and come with a packet of lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing


Our Hall of Fame

The 7

$8.50

Peppi's rookie of the year aka "the roethliburger" a sausage and burger juggernaut topped with egg, american cheese

New Blazin Saddle

$8.10

Our ultra steak with cajun seasoning and special blazin' sauce hot peppers, served with ranch dressing

The Heath

$9.50

Double steak, onions, peppers and bbq sauce

Big Nate

$8.25

Fresh chicken breast, our steak, provolone cheese and grilled onions

The New Yorker

$7.50

Our steak with melted provolone and american cheese, grilled onions and crisp bacon

The Amazing Siegfried

$7.75

Fresh chicken breast, mushrooms, bacon, american and provolone cheese

Santucci

$7.50

A delectably messy sandwich: our hot italian with extra meat and extra cheese, grilled peppers, onions and mushroom topped with hot peppers

Pitisburgher

$9.50

Bring your game face for this one almost a pound of burger covered with melted american and provolone cheese, and grilled onions

Ultra Cheese Steak

$7.95

A peppi's original loaded with 6 oz. of steak, provolone and grilled onions

The Big Wheeler

$8.50

Our steak and sausage mix, covered in provolone, more than a sub, its a blues giant

Joey Porter Bella

$7.99

Grilled steak and portabella creation topped with swiss cheese and house radish sauce with a kick

The Wiz

$8.50

Our cheese steak with 6 oz. meat, extra cheese, grilled mushrooms and onions

The Phantom

$7.50

Our steak and egg with melted provolone, grilled mushrooms and onions

Wally Burger

$7.99

A beautiful burger with grilled mushrooms, bacon, melted provolone and grilled onions

Cathedral

$8.00

Our triple decker with hot grilled turkey and ham covered with provolone and chrisp bacon

Turkey Supreme

$7.25

Extra turkey breast covered with grilled mushrooms and onions with mustard vinaigrette


Steak SubsMade with 1/4lb. fresh cut rib-eye steak

Mushroom Cheese Steak

$6.99

Melted provolone cheese piled with mushrooms and grilled onions

Special Steak

$6.99

Smothered with onions, peppers and melted provolone cheese

Special Steak w/ Mushroom

$7.25

Steak and Egg

$6.75

What else

The South Philly

$6.75

Melted american cheese and grilled onions

Cheese Steak

$6.75

Melted provolone cheese and grilled onions

Regular Steak

$6.25

With grilled onions

Pizza Steak

$6.99

Zesty pizza sauce and melted provlone


Italian Subs

The Franco

$6.50

Our italian regular with extra genoa salami and rosa salami

Italian Regular

$5.99

Genoa salami, rosa salami, capacola and provolone cheese

Genoa Salami and Cheese

$6.30

The Sicilian

$6.99

A true italian delight with genoa salami, rosa salami, extra capicaola and extra provolone

Provolone Cheese

$5.99

Capacola And Cheese

$6.30


Burger and Sausage Subs

Mushrooms Swiss Burger

$7.49

Plain Ole Burger

$6.40

Over a 1/3lb. of fresh ground beef

The Forbes Field

$7.49

An old tyme burger served with grilled onions, sweet peppers and melted provolone

Bacon Cheese Burger

$7.49

Cheeseburger

$6.90

American or provolone cheese

Hot Sausage Special

$6.75

Served with grilled sweet peppers, grilled onions and melted provolone cheese


Chicken Breast SubsLettuce, tomato, and onions grilled or raw. Also a choice of mayonnaise, our italian dressing, hot sauce, ketchup, mustard or mustard vinaigrette

Chicken Swiss Mushroom

$7.24

Chicken Parmesan

$6.99

Zesty tomato sauce and provolone

Grilled Chicken Breast

$6.00

Grilled onions and peppers

The Butcher

$6.99

Peppers, cheese, and mustard vinaigrette

Chicken Barbeque

$6.99

Barbeque sauce and provolone cheese


Deli Style Subs

Carol Delight

$6.99

Hot grilled turkey, bacon and provolone

Ham and Cheese

$6.25

American or provolone

Deli Delight

$7.45

Hot grilled turkey and ham covered with provolone cheese

Ham and Egg

$6.25

Turkey Breast

$5.85

Turkey Breast with Cheese

$6.50


Veggies and Stuff

Portabella Mushrooms

$7.50

Grilled portabella mushrooms with melted provolone, grilled onions, and roasted peppers

Fish Sandwich

$8.00

Fried fish with tartar sauce

Pepper and Egg

$5.75

The Shadyside

$6.00

The vegetarian grilled onions, grilled mushrooms, sweet peppers and melted provolone

Tuna Salad Sandwich

$6.25

Tuna Melt

$7.00

Our grilled tuna salad with melted american and provolone cheese

Chicken Fingers

$8.00

Chicken tenders with french fries


Special Salads

Famous Steak Salad

$7.99

Topped with fresh cut fries cut fries, juicy steak and grated cheese

Chef Salad

$7.99

Topped with 1/2 lb. meat of ham and turkey

Tossed Salad

$5.75

A plethora of fresh veggies and grated cheese

Chicken Breast Salad

$7.99

Fresh grilled chicken covered in sweet peppers, onions, and grated cheese

Tuna Salad

$7.99

A healthy portion of tuna and grated cheese


French Fries and Onion RingsFresh cut fries every day

French Fries

$2.50 - $3.25

Cheese

$3.15 - $3.99

Cajun w Ranch

$3.30 - $3.99

Onion Rings

$3.50


ExtrasAdditional toppings for subs or salads.

Meat

$2.25

Fried Sweet Peppers

$0.65

Bacon

$0.65

Fries

$0.65

Buns

$1.00

Cheese

$0.65

Crushed Cherry Peppers or Hot Peppers Rings

$0.45

Egg

$0.65

Mushrooms

$0.65

Dressing

$0.65


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading