Peppers On The Plaza Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 422 votes
Peppers On The Plaza Logo
Mexican

Choose My State

NM

Peppers On The Plaza Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


TapasSmall plates as appetizers

Green Chile Cheese Wontons

$6.95

with Pineapple-Jalapeno Salsa

Frijoles Fundido

$6.95

bean dip Mesilla style with chorizo, cheeses and pico de gallo

Peppers Chile Con Queso

$7.95

cheese and chilies with crispity tostada chips

Fried Guacamole

$6.95

crispy outside, creamy inside

Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Jalapenos

$6.95

balsamic - orange glaze

Classic Crispy Calamari

$9.95

tabasco marinade, pepperoncini mayonnaise

Elote En Vaso

$6.95

butter roasted corn with chile sauce, lime, sour cream and spices

Tipsy Tower of Onion Rings

$9.95

Towere of skewer of whiskey battered onion rings served with 2 dippers: chile verde ranch and old fashioned ketchup


SoupsHouse Made

Green Chile Pork Posole

$5.95

onions, lime, oregano

Soup of the Day

$4.95

chef's choice

Green Chile Pork Posole

$5.95

onions, lime, oregano

Soup of the Day

$4.95

chef's choice

Green Chile Pork Posole

$4.95

onions, lime, oregano

Soup of the Day

$3.95

our Executive Chef's creations


Salads & SandwichesSandwiches served with beer battered french fries, cole slaw, house made sweet potato chips, veggies or fresh fruit

Roasted Chicken Cobb Salad

$11.95

tomato, avocado, Applewood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, hard-boiled egg on mixed greens, green goddess dressing

Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad

$12.95

fresh pineapple wedge, chardonnay poached chicken salad, cranberries, Mesilla Valley pecans, fresh fruit

NY Strip Steak Salad

$16.95

5 oz New York Strip steak, bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, avocado, crispy onions on mixed greens, buttermilk ranch dressing

Soup & Salad

$11.95

cup of soup of the day & half a salad: chicken cobb, cranberry chicken salad, fresh fruit or green salad

Soup & Sandwich

$11.95

cup of soup of the day & half a sandwich: café club, san franciscan, cranberry pecan chicken salad, Cuban, veggie santa fe

Club Sandwich

$11.95

grilled chicken breast, avocado, bacon jam, marinated tomato, crispy onions on toasted sourdough

The San Franciscan Sandwich

$12.95

turkey breast, applewood smoked bacon, green chile, avocado, tomato, Monterey jack cheese on grilled sourdough

Cranberry-Pecan Chicken Salad Sandwich

$11.95

chardonnay poached chicken, cranberries, Mesilla Valley pecans, black pepper, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato on grilled sourdough

Ghost Pepper Cuban Sandwich

$11.95

shave country ham, dill pickles, mustard ghost pepper cheese on a butter grilled rustic roll

Prime Rib Cheesesteak Sandwich

$12.95

shave prime rib, green chile, caramelized onions, chile con queso on wheat beer hoagie roll

Veggie Santa Fe Sandwidh

$10.95

grilled zucchini, peppers, onions, black beans with guacamole on a butter grilled rustic roll

Grilled Chicken Guacamole Salad

$10.95

Generous scoop of guacamole, grilled chicken breast strips, mandarin oranges, red onions, cucumbers and tomatoes on crisp greens


BurgersBurgers served with beer battered French fries, cole slaw, house made sweet potato chips, veggies or fresh fruit

World's Largest Green Chile Cheeseburger

$29.95

20 oz burger, green chile, queso fresco

Classic Burger

$11.95

lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, mayo on toasted brioche bun

Relleno Burger

$13.95

so throw a relleno on it and cover it with chile con queso

Mesilla Green Chile Cheeseburger

$12.95

half pounder with green chile & American cheese on toasted brioche bun

Jalapeno Bleu Burger

$12.95

fresh chopped jalapenos and bleu cheese crumbles mixed into a half pound burger, bleu cheese dressing for dipping

Chciken Mesilla "Burger"

$11.95

grilled breast of chicken, sautéed sweet onions, green chile, Monterey jack cheese, sliced avocado on a butter grilled brioche bun

World's Largest Green Chile Cheeseburger

$29.95

20 oz burger, green chile, queso fresco

Classic Burger

$11.95

lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, mayo on toasted brioche bun

Relleno Burger

$13.95

so throw a relleno on it and cover it with chile con queso

Mesilla Green Chile Cheeseburger

$12.95

half pounder with green chile & American cheese on toasted brioche bun

Jalapeno Bleu Burger

$12.95

fresh jalapeno, chopped, and bleu cheese crumbles mixed into a half pound burger, bleu cheese dressing for dipping

Chicken Mesilla "Burger"

$11.95

grilled breast of chicken, sautéed sweet onions, green chile, Monterey jack cheese and avocado on a butter grilled brioche bun


Mesilla FavoritesNew Mexico Cuisine from the Mesilla Valley

Chicken Mesilla

$11.95

grilled breast of chicken, green chile, sautéed sweet onions, Monterey jack cheese, sliced avocado, flour tortilla

Big Jim Chile Rellenos

$8.95 - $13.95

hatch 'Big Jim' green chile, 3 cheeses, tempura crisp, green sauce

Seafood Chile Relleno

$9.95 - $15.95

bay shrimp & scallops, tempura crisp, green sauce

Cheese Enchiladas

$11.95

three rolled corn tortillas stuffed with three cheeses, topped with red chile, green chile or Christmas

Panco Villa Fajitas

$12.95

chicken, beef or veggie sour cream, guacamole, tortillas

Tacos Mesilla Style

$11.95

three soft or crispy corn tortillas with choice of red chile taco beef or green chile roast chicken

Fish Tacos Baja Style

$11.95

two soft flour tortillas with crispy cod fillets, shredded cabbage, green chile verde sauce

Guadalupe Street Burrito

$10.95

redi chile taco beef or green chile roasted chicken, refried beans and cheese tucked into a flour tortilla

Plato Mexicano

$12.95

1 green cheese enchilada, 1 red chile beef taco and 1 chile relleno

Chicken Mesilla

$11.95

grilled breast of chicken, green chile, sautéed sweet onions, Monterey jack cheese, sliced avocado, flour tortilla

Big Jim Chile Rellenos

$8.95 - $13.95

hatch 'big jim' green chile, 3 cheeses, tempura crisp, green sauce

Seafood Chile Relleno

$9.95 - $15.95

bay shrimp & scallops, tempura crisp, green sauce

Cheese Enchiladas

$11.95

three rolled corn tortillas with red chile or green chile or Christmas

Pancho Villa Fajitas

$12.95

chicken, beef or vegetarian Mexican marinade, sour cream guacamole, tortillas

Tacos - Mesillero Style

$11.95

three soft or crispy corn tortillas

Plato Mexicano

$12.95

green cheese enchilada, red chile brisket taco & chile relleno

Fish Tacos - Baja Style

$11.95

two soft flour tortillas with crispity cod fillets, shredded cabbage, green chile salsa verde

Gaudalupe Street Burrito

$10.95

red chile taco beef or green chile roasted chicken with refried beans and cheese tucked inside a flour tortilla

Plato Mexicano

$12.95

Combo plate of green cheese enchilada, red chile beef taco and chile relleno


Cafe Entrees & House Aged SteaksSteaks from the only dedicated Beef Ageing Room in New Mexico

Agave Lime Salmon

$16.95

pan seared fillet, seasoned shaved Brussel sprouts, beer battered French fries

Chicken Fried NY Strip Steak Plate

$12.95

aged NY Strip steak, chicken fried, with today's veggie, buttermilk mashed potatoes, cream gravy

Old Fashioned Meatloaf

$12.95

caramelized onions and mushrooms, buttermilk mashed potatoes, red wine demi-glace

Chipotle Chicken & Gnocchi

$12.95

grilled breast of chicken, chopped and sautéed with chipotle cream sauce, scallions and buttery potato dumplings

Vegetable Coconut Curry

$10.95

seasonal veggies, red curry, coconut milk, jasmine rice

Teres Major "Bistro Tender" Steak

$24.95

aged 38 to 60 days; pepper roasted medallions of beef steak; with choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

Delmonico Boneless Ribeye

$39.95

Our Most Popular Steak Selection; 14 oz; aged 36 to 42 days with choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day, choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

New York Strip Steak

$39.95

14 ounces; aged 36 to 42 days; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

Filet Mignon - Petite

$28.95

aged 28 to 35 days; 4 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or season vegetable

Filet Mignon - Grande

$38.95

aged 28 to 35 days; 8 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable


DessertsSomething sweet with a New Mexican Twist

Coconut Flan

$6.95

coconut sauce, Chantilly cream, strawberry accent

Banana Enchiladas

$6.95

tender crepes, bananas, vanilla bean ice cream, caramel pecan sauce

Tres Leches Cake

$6.95

house made vanilla cake infused with 3 sweetened caramelized milks

Key Lime Cloud Pie

$6.95

lime chiffon pie, blood orange sorbet

Churro Cheesecake

$6.95

a trip to cinnamon sugar and cheesecake heaven

Blood Orange Sorbet

$4.95

exotic blood orange juice iced into sorbet

Coconut Flan

$6.95

coconut sauce, Chantilly cream, strawberry accent

Tres Leches Cake

$6.95

house made vanilla cake infused with 3 sweetened caramelized milks

Churro Cheesecake

$6.95

house made, warm crispy outside, creamy cheesecake goodness inside

Key Lime Cloud Pie

$6.95

Lime chiffon pie with blood orange sorbet

Banana Enchiladas

$6.95

tender crepes, bananas, vanilla bean ice cream, caramel pecan sauce

Blood Orange Sorbet

$4.95

Exotic blood orange juice iced sorbet style

Bananas Foster - Flambe For Two

$9.95

prepared tableside with bananas, brown sugar, Jamaican rum with vanilla bean ice cream

Creme Brule traditionale

$6.95

creamy custard, caramelized sugar crust, seasonal berries

Bianca's Flourless Chocolate Cake

$6.95

layered with chocolate mousse and finished with chocolate ganache

Key Lime Cloud Pie

$6.95

Lime Chiffon pie and blood orange sorbet

Mile High Cheesecake

$7.95

NY Style cheesecake with choice of raspberry sauce, chocolate sauce or caramel pecan sauce

German Napoleon

$6.95

coconut caramel filling finished with toasted coconut

Blood Orange Sorbet

$4.95

after dinner serving


Tapas on the PlazaSmall plates as appetizers

Green Chile Cheese Wontons

$6.95

with Pineapple-Jalapeno Salsa

Freid Guacamole

$6.95

crispy outside, creamy inside - a real taste treat

Peppers Chile Con Queso

$7.95

cheese and chilies; served with crispy tostada chips

Frijoles Fundido

$6.95

Mesilla style bean dip with chorizo, cheeses and pico de gallo

Bacon Wrapped Stuffed Jalapenos

$6.95

Balsamic - orange glaze

Classic Crispy Calamari

$9.95

tabasco marinade; pepperoncini mayonnaise

Elote En Vaso

$6.95

butter roasted corn with chile sauce, lime, sour cream and cotija cheese, served with crispit tostada chips

Tipsy Tower of Onion Rings

$9.95

Tower of skewered whiskey battered onions rings served with 2 dippers: chile verde ranch and old fashioned ketchup

Chips and Guacamole

$6.95

Generous scoop of house made guacamole


Salads

Roasted Chicken Cobb Salad

$11.95

tomato, avocado, Applewood smoked bacon, bleu cheese, hard-boiled egg on mixed greens, green goddess dressing

Cranberry Pecan Chicken Salad

$11.95

fresh pineapple wedge, chardonnay poached chicken salad, cranberries, Mesilla Valley pecans, fresh fruit

NY Strip Steak Salad

$16.95

5 oz New York Strip steak, bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, avocado, crispy onions on mixed greens, buttermilk ranch dressing

Soup & Salad

$11.95

cup of soup of the day & half a salad: chicken cobb, cranberry chicken salad, fresh fruit or green salad

Grilled Chicken Guacamole Salad

$10.95

Generous scoop of house made guacamole, grilled chicken breast strips, mandarin oranges, red onions, cucumber and tomato on crisp salad greens

Crispy Duck Salad

$13.95

duck leg confit, organic savoy spinach blend, whiskey soaked raisins, mandarin orange vinaigrette

Steakhouse Wedge

$7.95

iceberg wedge, applewood smoked bacon, tomatoes, blue cheese

Tableside Caesar Salad for Two

$8.95

Romaine, anchovies, parmesan, coddled egg, house made garlic croutons


Café EntreesChef's special interest menu items

Agave Lime Salmon

$16.95

pan seared fillet, seasoned shaved brussels sprouts, beer battered French fries

Old Fashioned Meatloaf

$12.95

caramelized onions, mushrooms, red wine demi-glace, buttermilk mashed potatoes

Vegetable Coconut Curry

$10.95

seasonal vegetables, red curry, coconut milk, jasmine rice

Chicken Fried NY Strip Steak Plate

$12.95

aged NY Strip Steak "tenderized and chicken fried" with seasonal veggie, buttermilk mashed potatoes, cream gravy

Chipotle Chicken and Gnocchi

$12.95

grilled breast of chicken, chopped, sautéed with chipotle cream sauce, scallions and buttery potato dumplings


House Aged SteaksFrom the only dedicated Beef Ageing Room in New Mexico

Teres Major "Bistro Tender" Steak

$24.95

aged 38 to 60 days, pepper roasted medallions of beef steak; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day, choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

Delmonico Boneless Ribeye

$39.95

Our most popular steak selection; aged 36 to 42 days; 14 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

New York Strip Steak

$39.95

aged 36 to 42 days; 14 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

Filet Mignon - Petite

$28.95

aged 28 to 35 days; 4 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable

Filet Mignon- Grande

$38.95

aged 28 to 35 days; 8 oz; choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day; choice of potato or seasonal vegetable


Small PlatesSharable small plates

Seared Ahi Tuna "Nachos"

$12.95

wonton chips ,guacamole, , fire roasted jalapeno cream

Green Chile Cheese Wontons

$7.95

pineapple jalapeno salsa

Colossal Shrimp Cocktail

$17.95 - $24.95

colossal shrimp with traditional sauce

Classic Calamari

$8.95

tabasco marinade, pepperoncini mayonnaise

Crispy Duck Wings

$8.95

honey-soy glaze

Gnocchi & Short Rib Ragu

$13.95

house made potato dumplings, crispy shallot confit

Tipsy Tower of Onion Rings

$9.95

whisky battered onions, chile verde ranch and old fashioned ketchup dipping sauces

Cheese Plate - Serves 2

$10.95

aged cheddar, crème de brie, artisan crackers, grapes

Cheese Plank - Serves 4

$15.95

smoked gouda, Dutch fontina, herbed Boursin, artisan crackers, grapes

Cheese Board Room - Served 8

$26.50

herbed Boursin, crème de brie, Dutch fontina, fresh mozzarella, beefsteak tomato, all natural hard salami, black oak smoked sausage, apricot jam, bleu cheese stuffed olives, artisan crackers, grapes


EntreesServed with your choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day and your choice of Baked Potato,Twice Baked Stuffed Potato, Buttermilk Mashed Potatoes or Seasonal Vegetable

Breast of Chicken Mesilla - House Specialty

$23.95

grilled with sautéed sweet onions, green chile, monterey jack cheese, guacamole

Chicken Jerusalem

$23.95

bone-in breast butter sautéed, garlic, shallots, fume blanc wine, cream, artichoke hearts, button mushrooms

Roasted Pork Chop With Apples and Bacon

$29.95

bone-in 10 oz chop, roasted, sweet butter, spiced apple-bacon chutney

Parmesan Crusted Rack of Lamb

$34.95

New Zealand lamb, spicy cranberry relish


House Aged Beef & SteaksFrom the only dedicated Beef Ageing Room in New Mexico. We monitor the number of days at a temperature of a constant 35 degrees to allow the natural enzymes to produce a wonderfully tender steak. Beef is "All Natural" meaning antibiotic and hormone free. Each steak is personally selected and hand cut.

Teres Major "Bistro Tender" Steak

$24.95

aged 38 to 60 days pepper roasted medallions of beef

Delmonico Boneless Ribeye

$39.95

aged 36 to 42 days

New York Strip Steak

$39.95

aged 36 to 42 days

Filet Mignon

$28.95 - $38.95

aged 28 to 35 days

Tenderloin & Scallops Scampi

$38.95

petite filet paired with seared sea scallops, lemon-garlic buttersauce

Ribeye & Crispy Cheese Relleno

$43.95

14 oz ribeye, cheese relleno, green chile sauce


Table SidePrepared at your table for your enjoyment

Shrimp Scampi Italiano - Flambe'

$36.95

colossal shrimp butter sautéed with garlic, shallots, lemon, white wine, brandy served with garlic & parmesan gnocchi

Tournedos Maximillian - Flambe

$44.95

6 oz filet mignon medallions butter sautéed with garlic, mushroom and red wine bordelaise sauce

Chateaubraind Bouquetiere For Two

$46.95

12 oz beef tenderloin filet, roasted, carved tableside and presented with buttermilk mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, green chile cheese stuffed tomato with sauce bearnaise and red wine bordelai


Chef's Select Entreescomposed dishes by Executive Chef Luke Roberts; served as listed with choice of House Salad or Soup of the Day

Duck Confit

$28.95

crispy skin, black oak smoked sausage, creamed potatoes, caramelized carrots, red wine sauce

Agave Lime Salmon

$26.95

smokey, sweet agave nectar, grilled lime, sweet potato lattice chips, asparagus

Honey Kissed Black Cod

$26.95

miso, shitake mushrooms, wilted savoy spinach

Lacquered Mountain Trout

$28.95

house blend wild rice, asparagus tips, blistered cherry tomatoes

Cabernet Braised Beef Short Rib

$34.95

pan roasted rosemary potatoes, braised celery


Side DishesDelectable delights to add enjoyment to your meal

Beer Battered French Fries

$3.95

Whiskey Battered Onion Rings

$3.95

Loaded Baked Potato

$4.95

Twice Baked Cheddar Potato

$4.95

Buttermilk Mashed Potatoes

$4.95

Green Chile Mac & Cheese

$8.95

Baked Seafood Mac & Cheese

$11.95

Red Chile Roasted Corn

$6.95

Garlic Creamed Spinach

$4.95

House Blend Wild Rice

$3.95

Grilled Asparagus

$6.95

Sauteed Asparagus with Bearnaise

$9.95


Cocktails

The De Cosmo

$8.50

premium citron vodka, citronage orange liqueur, cranberry splash, lemon twist

Appletini

$8.00

premium vodka, sour apple pucker, splash of sweet n sour

The Big Sexy

$9.00

premium citrus vodka, citronage orange,fresh lime juice, splash of cranberry, splash of sweet n sour, sugared rim

Bloody-tini

$8.00

for the sophisticated bloody mary drinker! we shake it, strain it, pour it into a fancy martini glass

Green Chile Bloody Mary

$7.00

we infuse fire roasted hatch green chile with imported sobieski polish vodka, creating a flammable flavor profile that is addictive!

Mesilla Stinger

$5.00

try this shot! a mini mary- bloody shooter-hot shot-sangria on roids! guaranteed to hit the spot!

Jimmy Hendrick's

$9.00

cucumber and rose petal infused hendrick's gin, splash of dry vermouth and a slice of cucumber

Rock Star Root Beer

$9.00

premium root beer (i swear to god!) vodka & vanilla vodka with ginger ale. rock on!

Chocolate Covered Cherry

$10.00

premium chocolate vodka & cherry vodka, white crème de cacao, red cherry

Double Chocolate

$8.00

premium chocolate vodka, white crème de cacao, hershey's chocolate syrup

Lemon Drop

$8.00

premium vodka, fresh-squeezed lemon juice, sugared rim

Key Lime Pie

$8.00

premium citrus vodka, vanilla vodka, melon liqueur, cream, lime juice

John Daly

$6.00

move over, arnold palmer! we add sweet tea vodka (and i thought root beer vodka was unreal!!) to lemonade, garnish with a lemon slice

Bitter Ritter

$8.00

maker's mark bourbon, stirrings blood orange bitters, dash of cherry juice, lemon twist

Millionaire Mojito

$7.00

premium tommy bahama white sand rum (or try el tesoro platinum tequila) fresh mint, lime juice, sugar, sparkling soda

Blood Orange

$8.00

award winning charbay blood orange vodka, citronage orange, splash of cranberry

Espresso

$12.00

premium chocolate vodka, bailey's irish cream and a shot of espresso

Dire Straits

$8.00

premium magellan gin, mist of dry vermouth, shaken not stirred, lemon twist

The Bob Dylan

$8.00

premium gin, rosemary infused syrup, dash of dry vermouth, rosemary sprig garnish

Pineapple Express

$8.00

skyy pineapple vodka, premium citrus vodka, triple sec, sugared rim, lemon twist

Mango Tango

$8.00

absolut mango vodka, parrot bay rum, cranberry & pineapple juice, lemon twist

Manhattan

$7.00

premium bourbon, sweet vermouth, muddled cherry - on the rocks or up, cherry garnish

Diablo Rojo

$6.00

infused green chile vodka, tabasco hot sauce, clamato, sliced jalapeno garnish

Side Car

$8.00

a wonderful concoction from the 1940's of cognac, grand marnier orange liqueur and fresh-squeezed lemon juice with a sugared rim


Beer SelectionList Changes Weekly - Stop by and see what's chilling this week

Stella Artois, Belgium

Price may varies

On draught

Blue Moon White Ale, Colorado

Price may varies

Bud Light, Missouri

Price may varies

Coors Light, Colorado

Price may varies

Corona Exra, Mexico

Price may varies

Dos Equis Lager, Mexico

Price may varies

Green Flash Imperial Ipa, California

Price may varies

Guiness Foreign Extra Stout, Ireland

Price may varies

Heinekin, Holland

Price may varies

Marble Ipa, New Mexico

Price may varies

Mendicino Barley Wine, California

Price may varies

Mendicino Imperial Stout, California

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra, Missouri

Price may varies

Miller Lite, Wisconsin

Price may varies

Monk's Ale, New Mexico

Price may varies

Negra Modelo, Mexico

Price may varies

Odell's Foot Print Regionale, Colorado

Price may varies

Odell's Myrcenary Double Ipa, Colorado

Price may varies

O'doul's N/a, Missouri

Price may varies

Rogue Xs Imperial Stout

Price may varies

Ruiter Blonde Ale, Belgium

Price may varies


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading