Payne's Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 120 votes
Payne's Logo

Choose My State

IN

Payne's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


EntreesComes with cup of soup or fatoush.

Bangers and Mash

$14.00

Traditional British Sausage. rutabaga/potato mash and sweet Scrumpy's onion gravy

Main Street Pork Chop

$14.00

Bone-in grilled Indiana pork chop with mustard cream sauce & mash

British Chicken Curry

$14.00

Mild aromatic korma with steamed potatoes and naan bread

Fish 'n Chips

$16.00

Cod in traditional British crispy batter with fries and tartar sauce... and, of course, malt vinegar!

Country Style Ribs

$16.00

Indiana grown and cut ribs with our mash and green beans.

Grilled Chicken And Rosmary Salad

$12.00

Grilled chicken marinated in olive oil and rosemary over spinach and kale leaf


Breakfast

Oatmeal with Everything

$7.00

Raspberries, strawberries, raisins, pecans, walnuts

French Toast

$5.00 - $7.00

Whole wheat French bread soaked in batter - strawberries & custard +$2

Huntsman's Breakfast

$9.00

Grilled ham steak, grilled potato cake, over-easy eggs

Smoothies

$5.00

Fresh Fruit, Dark Berry, Mango Love or Almond Berry Spinach

Sausage Egg and Cheese Bagel

$6.00

on plain, whole wheat or gluten free bagel


Appetizers

Hummus & Pita

$6.00

Soup of the Day

$5.50

Ask for listing

Fatoush

$6.00

tomato, cucumber, radishes, spring onions, mint, parsley, garlic, Greek yogurt, pita

Bruschetta

$6.00

Baguette bread with slow roasted tomatoes and mozzarella

British Fries

$5.00

served with malt vinegar salt and ketchup

Roasted Root Vegetables

$8.00

roasted parsnips, carrots, red onions and beets with goat cheese

Poached Pear Salad

$7.00

poached in white wine served with goat cheese


Soups

Sweet Potato, Apple & Ginger with Pepper Jack Melt

$10.00

Potato and Onion with Bacon & Brie Melt

$10.00

Famous Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup

$10.00

Soup of the Day

$6.00

Black Bean & Tomato Soup with Lime and Cilantro & Pepperjack Melt

$10.00

Cock-a-leekie Soup with Gouda Grilled Cheese

$10.00

Scottish classic dating from 1598,leeks, prunes and chicken


SandwichesServed with Kettle Chips, Coleslaw for $1

Payne's Club House

$7.00 - $10.00

bacon, brie, spinach, turkey, tomato, grilled

Rye Reuben

$10.00

roast beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, Thousand Island, rye bread

The Earl of Pulled Pork

$12.00

Indiana pork shoulder, slow roasted with our housemade Kentucky Whiskey sauce

Tuna & Walnut Bourriche

$9.00

tuna, walnuts, mozzarella, raspberries

Pepperoni BBQ Bourriche

$9.00

pepperoni, mozzarella, our sweet barbeque sauce

Apple Walnut & Brie Panini

$8.00

Goat Cheese Club Wrap

$10.00

bacon, turkey, goat cheese, spinach, tomato, in a tomato basil wrap

Beef Burger

$14.00

grass fed beef, Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, tomato served with French fries (optional with potatoe chips $10)

Salmon Burger

$14.00

with slaw & sprouts and French fries (optional with potato chips $10)

Veggie Burger

$14.00

corn, black bean, red pepper & quinoa burger, with guacamole, tomato, sprouts, coleslaw served with French fries (optinal potato chips substitution $10)


Desserts

Sticky Toffee Pudding

$6.00

Bread Pudding with Caramel

$6.00

Rhubarb Crumble with Granola

$5.00

Dessert Taster Plate

$9.00

American Brownie

$6.00

Homemade, warm brownie with vanilla custard, hot fudge and strawberries.


Custard

Vanilla or Chocolate

$2.00 - $4.00

small or medium

Cookie Monster

$5.00

vanilla custard, Oreos, cookie dough, hot fudge

Hot Fudge

$5.00

vanilla custard, hot fudge, whipped cream, cherry

Oreo Crumble

$5.00

vanilla custard, Oreos, hot fudge, whipped cream

Jenny's Reese

$5.00

vanilla custard, peanut butter, hot fudge, Reese Cups

Turtle

$5.00

vanilla custard, hot fudge, caramel, pecans

Flustard

$5.00

vanilla custard topped with espresso

James Dean's Payne

$5.00

vanilla custard, raspberries, espresso

Worms and Dirt

$5.00

Vanilla custard with oreos and sour gummy worms


Smoothies

Fresh Fruit

$5.00

pineapple, banana, strawberries, apple juice

Dark Berry

$5.00

strawberries, blueberries, apple juice, banana

Almond Blue Spinach

$5.00

banana, strawberries, blueberries, spinach, almond milk

Mango Love

$5.00

pineapple, mango, orange juice, banana


Bar

Mimosas

$7.00

Traditional and Elderflower

Draft Ale

$4.50 - $15.00

Ask for listing, prices vary

Jax Vineyard

$7.00 - $33.00

Taureau "reb blend" or Jax "chardonnay"

Von Schleinitz

$7.00 - $30.00

Mosel Valley "Riesling"

Flor Prosecco

$7.00 - $33.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading