Menu With Price > Menu > Pappa's Coney Island

Pappa's Coney Island Menu and Prices

4.4 based on 112 votes

Diner

Choose My State

Pappa's Coney Island Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Sandwiches

Club Sandwich

$4.85

bacon, ham, turkey, lettuce, tomato & mayo

Turkey Sandwich

$3.50

Reuben Sandwich

$5.00

corned beef, mustard, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, on rye bread or onion roll

Corned Beef Sandwich

$4.50

corned beef, swiss cheese, mustard, on rye bread or onion roll

Tuna Sandwich

$3.55

tuna, lettuce, tomato & mayo

Tuna Melt

$3.80

tuna, swiss cheese on rye bread

Ham Sandwich

$2.95

Grilled Ham & Cheese

$3.60

Grilled Cheese

$1.65

Blt

$2.95

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

$4.60

Fried Chicken Sandwich

$3.00

Chicken Club Sandwich

$4.40

chicken breast parry, bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo

Steak Sandwich

$4.60

Fish Sandwich

$2.95

Pita Sandwiches

Gyro

$3.75

lettuce, tomato, onion & gyro sauce

Chicken Delight

$4.60

fried chicken strips w/swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo

Grilled Chicken Pita

$4.80

lettuce, tomato & mayo

new Grilled Chicken Caesar

$5.55

Ham Pita

$4.35

lettuce, tomato & mayo

Steak Pita

$5.15

Tuna Pita

$4.30

Turkey Pita

$4.30

Corned Beef Pita

$5.05

swiss cheese & mustard

Submarine Sandwiches

Steak Hoagie

$4.50

swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & mayo

Philly Steak & Cheese

$4.70

green peppers, onion, lettuce, mayo, tomato & swiss cheese

New Corned Beef & Cheese Sub

$5.45

Mushroom Steak & Swiss

$5.25

lettuce, tomato & mayo

Grilled Chicken Sub

$5.15

lettuce, tomato, mayo & american cheese

Tuna Sub

$4.30

lettuce, tomato & mayo

Ham & Cheese

$4.50

lettuce tomato & mayo

Turkey Sub

$4.30

lettuce, tomato & mayo

Coneys

Plain Hot Plain

$1.25

w/mustard & onions

Coney Island

$1.45

chili, mustard & onions

Coney Special

Price may varies

hot dog w/loose burger, chili mustard & onions

Loose Burger

$1.95

seasoned ground beef, chili, mustard & onions

Coney Taco

$2.55

seasoned ground beef, chili, cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions.

Fire Dog

$2.25

spicy sausage, chili, mustard & onions

Kraut Dog

$1.85

sauerkraut & mustard

Fish Dog

$2.35

tartar sauce in a hot dog bun

Chili

Bowl Of Chili

$2.25

Bowl Of Chili Special

$2.75

Burgers1/4 lb. all beef patty on a sesame seed bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, ketchup, mayo & mustard. add chili on fries $1.10 extra. add chili & cheese $1.60 extra. deluxe orders include fries.

Hamburger

$2.55 - $4.25

Cheeseburger

$2.80 - $4.50

Bacon Burger

$3.40 - $5.10

Bacon Cheeseburger

$3.65 - $5.35

Double Burger

$3.95 - $5.65

Double Cheeseburger

$4.25 - $5.95

Double Bacon Burger

$4.70 - $6.40

Double Bacon Cheeseburger

$5.75 - $7.45

Chili Burger

$3.15 - $4.85

Patty Melt

$3.25 - $4.95

Mushroom & Swiss Burger

$3.50 - $5.20

Side Orders

French Fries

$1.60

Chili Fries

$2.10

Chili Fries

$2.70

w/squeeze cheese

Chili Fry Special

$3.35

fries topped w/ground beef, chili & cheese

Onion Rings

$2.50

Breaded Mushrooms

$2.75

Cheese Sticks

$3.10

Wing Ding Snack

$4.05 - $12.35

Chicken Snack

$5.25

wing ding/chicken snacks served with texas toast

Shrimp Basket

$4.85

w/texas toast

Side Of Corned Beef

$3.00

Chicken Strips

$5.50

w/texas toast

Chicken Breast

$4.00

Slice Of Turkey

$1.65

New York Steak

$4.00

Feta Cheese

$1.50

Hard Boiled Egg

$0.60

Ranch Dressing

$0.50

Hot Peppers

$0.65

Melted Cheese

$0.60

Saladsall salads are served with pita bread & choice of dressing. cucumbers come in all salads except the chef salad.

Tossed Salad

$2.45

lettuce, tomato & onion

Tuna Salad

$5.65

lettuce, tomato, tuna & egg

Turkey Salad

$5.65

turkey, lettuce, tomato, swiss & american cheese & egg

Chef Salad

$5.65

lettuce, tomato, american & swiss cheese, ham, turkey & egg

Greek Salad

$5.65

lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, pepperoncinis, beets & feta cheese

New Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

$7.25

lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, swiss & american cheese, boiled egg, mixed with caesar dressing

New Chicken Finger Salad

$6.45

6 fried chicken strips w/lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, egg, swiss & american cheese

Grilled Chicken Salad

$6.70

fresh marinated chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, egg, swiss & american cheese

Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

$8.35

lettuce, tomato, onion, olives, pepperoncinis, beers, feta cheese, and topped w/special seasoned marinated grilled chicken breast.

Nachos

Plain

$2.20

With Cheese

$3.65

With Meat & Cheese

$4.35

Nacho Supreme

$6.05

nacho chips, chili, lettuce, tomato, cheese, olives, ground beef, hot peppers & topped with sour cream

Beverages

Pop

$1.00 - $1.55

Coffee

$1.00 - $1.25

Hot Tea

$1.05

Hot Chocolate

$1.10

Milk

$1.05

Juice

$1.30

Desserts

Cake

$2.10

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.