Papa Sal's Pizza Menu and Prices

3.9 based on 70 votes
Papa Sal's Pizza Logo
Pizza

Choose My State

NY

Papa Sal's Pizza Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Menu Coupons

Large Cheese Pie and 1-Liter Pepsi Special

$14.75

2 Regular Cheese Slices and Small Soda Special

$5.00


Beverages

Canned Soda

$1.25

Bottled Soda

$1.95 - $1.75

Bottled Water

$1.25

Fountain Soda

$1.50 - $1.75


Appetizers

Arancini

$2.50

Classic with meat, peas and mozzarella cheese.

Rice Balls

$2.50

Classic with meat, peas and mozzarella cheese.

2 Pieces Cheese Arancini

$2.50

Mozzarella and Parmesan.

Ham and Cheese Arancini

$2.50

12 Piece Buffalo Wings

$8.95

Served with blue cheese dressing.

Calzone

$6.00

Freshly made, stuffed with ham and cheese or 2 cheese.

6 Piece Chicken Fingers

$6.95

Appetizer Combo

$10.95

4 Buffalo wings, 3 chicken fingers, 3 mozzarella sticks and french fries.

French Fries

$3.50

Sweet Potato

$4.50

Garlic Bread

$3.50

Garlic Bread with Melted Mozzarella

$4.50

6 Piece Garlic Knots

$2.00

Jamaican Beef Patty

$2.50

Jamaican Beef Patty with Cheese

$3.50

6 Piece Mozzarella Sticks with Marinara

$5.75

Mozzarella Caprese

$11.95


Salads

Avocado Salad

$8.45

Mixed greens with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and red onions.

Baby Spinach Salad

$8.45

Baby spinach, mushrooms, artichoke hearts and red onions.

Caesar Salad

$6.45

Romaine lettuce, Parmigiano-Reggiano and croutons.

Greek Salad

$8.45

Tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, red peppers, black olives and feta cheese and with extra virgin olive oil.

House Salad

$5.50

Romaine lettuce, plum tomatoes, cucumbers, olives and onions.

Mediterranean Salad

$8.45

Tomatoes, Kalamata olives, red onions, cucumbers, feta and Romaine lettuce.

Papa Sal's Salad

$7.45

Tomatoes and onions with extra virgin olive oil and red vinegar.

Seafood Salad

$12.50

Broiled shrimps, calamari, squid, celery and carrots with extra virgin olive oil.

Cold Antipasto Salad

$10.50

Salami, pepperoni, provolone, tomatoes and olives.


Entrees

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Dish

$9.95

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Entree

$13.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Eggplant Parmigiana Dish

$9.95

Eggplant Parmigiana Entree

$13.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Eggplant Rolatini Dish

$8.95

Eggplant Rolatini Entree

$12.95

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Veal Francese Dish

$10.95

Veal Francese Entree

$16.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Chicken Francese Dish

$9.95

Chicken Francese Entree

$14.95

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Chicken Marsala Dish

$9.95

Chicken Marsala Entree

$14.95

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Veal Marsala Dish

$10.95

Veal Marsala Entree

$16.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Shrimp Parmigiana Dish

$10.95

Shrimp Parmigiana Entree

$16.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Dish

$10.95

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana Entree

$16.50

Served with house salad or vegetable and pasta.


Seafood Entrees

Fried Calamari with Marinara Sauce

$9.95

Baked Clams

$8.95 - $16.95

Shrimp Parmigiana Dish

$10.95

Shrimp Parmigiana Entree

$16.50

Shrimp Scampi Dish

$10.95

Shrimp Scampi Entree

$16.50

Shrimp Fra Diavolo Dish

$10.95

Shrimp Fra Diavolo Entree

$16.50

Mussels Marinara Fra Diavolo Dish

$9.95

Mussels Fra Diavolo Entree

$13.50

Seafood Platter

$17.50

Mussels, shrimp and clams.


Pasta Dishes

Baked Ziti

$9.50

Chicken Baked Ziti

$14.50

Veal Baked Zitii kin

$15.50

Cheese Ravioli

$9.50

Chicken Cheese Ravioli

$14.00

Veal Cheese Ravioli

$14.95

Lasagna

$9.50

Chicken Lasagna

$14.50

Veal Lasagna

$15.50

Manicotti with Ricotta

$9.50

Chicken Manicotti with Ricotta

$14.00

Veal Manicotti with Ricotta

$14.95

Stuffed Shells with Ricotta

$9.50

Chicken Stuffed Shells with Ricotta

$14.00

Veal Stuffed Shells with Ricotta

$14.95

Linguini Alfredo

$9.50

Chicken Linguini Alfredo

$13.50

Shrimp Linguini Alfredo

$15.95

Chicken and Broccoli Linguini Alfredo

$14.95

Penne Vodka

$9.50

Chicken Penne Vodka

$13.50

Shrimp Penne Vodka

$15.95

Chicken and Broccoli Penne Vodka

$14.95

Pasta with Clam Sauce

$9.95

Pasta with Garlic and Oil

$7.50

Pasta with Marinara Sauce

$8.50

Pasta with Tomato Sauce

$8.50

Pasta with Meat Sauce

$9.50

Pasta with Pesto Sauce

$7.95

Spaghetti with Homemade Meat Balls

$9.95


Wraps and Paninnis

BBQ Chicken

$6.50

Grilled BBQ chicken with cheddar cheese, chopped tomato and lettuce.

BBQ Chicken with Fries

$7.50

Grilled BBQ chicken with cheddar cheese, chopped tomato and lettuce.

Breaded Chicken Cutlet

$6.50

Served with mayo, lettuce and tomato.

Breaded Chicken Cutlet with Fries

$7.50

Served with mayo, lettuce and tomato.

Grilled Chicken Fajita Wrap

$6.50

Grilled Chicken Fajita Wrap with Fries

$7.50

Healthy Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

$6.50

Healthy Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap with Fries

$7.50

Vegetarian Wrap

$6.50

Vegetarian Wrap with Fries

$7.50


Hot Heroes

Chicken with Sauce Hero

$6.75

Chicken Parmigiana with Sauce Hero

$7.95

Eggplant with Sauce Hero

$6.75

Eggplant Parmigiana with Sauce Hero

$7.95

Meatball Hero

$6.75

Meatball Parmigiana Hero

$7.95

Sausage Hero

$6.75

Sausage Parmigiana Hero

$7.95

Sausage with Onions and Pepper Hero

$6.95

Sausage with Onions and Pepper Parmigiana Hero

$7.95

Shrimp with Sauce Hero

$8.95

Shrimp Parmigiana with Sauce Hero

$9.95

Veal Hero

$8.00

Veal Parmigiana Hero

$9.00

Mixed Peppers and Egg Hero

$6.00

Potato and Egg Hero

$6.50

Gyro Hero

$6.50

Beef or chicken, lettuce, onion and tomato with Tahini sauce.


Pizza Corner

Cheese Pizza

$12.50 - $14.75

Vegetarian Pizza

$15.50 - $17.50

Salad Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Grilled chicken Caesar, plain Caesar or garden salad.

Chicken and Tomato Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Fried chicken cutlet, with Caesar dressing and chopped fresh tomatoes.

White Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Ricotta, mozzarella cheese, with a sprinkle of pecorino Romano.

Hawaiian Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Fresh Boar's Head ham and pineapple.

Chicken and Vodka Sauce Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Fresh Mozzarella and Fresh Tomatoes Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Tex Mex Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Scallions, bacon, cheddar cheese, tomato and grilled chicken with Caesar dressing.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$18.50 - $23.50

Grilled chicken, cheddar cheese and BBQ sauce.

Regular Pizza Slice

$2.50


Sicilian Pizza Corner

Cheese Sicilian Pizza

$16.50

9 pieces.

Stuffed Sicilian Pizza

$24.50

9 pieces.

Sfincione Sicilian Pizza

$17.50

9 pieces. Thick pizza topped with tomatoes, onions, a few anchovies and grated casciocavallo cheese, bread crumbs and seasoned with oregano.

Grandma Sicilian Pizza

$17.50

9 pieces. Sauteed onions with marinara sauce and Parmesan cheese.

Grandpa Sicilian Pizza

$19.50

9 pieces. Fresh mozzarella, sauteed onions with marinara sauce.

Sicilian Pizza Slice

$2.50


Deep Dish Pizza Corner

Original Cheese Deep Dish Pizza

$16.50

2 Style Chicken and Broccoli Deep Dish Pizza

$22.50

Half grilled chicken and half breaded chicken with broccoli.

Chicken and Fresh Spinach Deep Dish Pizza

$22.50

Chicken and Diced Tomato Deep Dish Pizza

$22.50

Chicken and Black Olives Deep Dish Pizza

$22.50

Vegetarian Deep Dish Pizza

$22.50

Fresh eggplant and ricotta cheese.

Vegetarian Pan Pizza

$22.50


Freshly Baked Rolls

Chicken Roll

$5.50

Marinara sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese.

Vegetarian Roll

$5.50

2 cheeses, mozzarella and Parmesan, and spinach or broccoli.

Eggplant Rolatini Roll

$5.50

Fresh eggplant, marinara sauce, ricotta cheese and Parmesan cheese.

Italian Sausage and Pepper Roll

$5.50

6 Piece Homemade Zeppoles

$2.00

Side Order of Meatballs

$4.50

Side Order of Italian Sausage

$4.50

Side Order of Sauteed Broccoli

$4.75

Side Order of Spinach

$4.75

Side Order of Mushrooms

$4.75


Individual Mini Pie

Cheese Mini Pie

$5.50

Vegetarian Mini Pie

$9.50

Salad Mini Pie

$9.50

Chicken and Tomato Mini Pie

$9.50

White Mini Pie

$9.50

Hawaiian Mini Pie

$9.50

Chicken and Vodka Sauce Mini Pie

$9.50

Fresh Mozzarella and Fresh Tomatoes Mini Pie

$9.50

Tex Mex Mini Pie

$9.50

BBQ Mini Pie

$9.50


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading