Papa Joe's Italian Eatery Menu and Prices

4.3 based on 175 votes
Papa Joe's Italian Eatery Logo
Italian

Choose My State

NY

Papa Joe's Italian Eatery Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Appetizers

Greens & Beans

$6.99

Clams Casino

$7.99

Garlic Cheese Bread

$3.99

Fried Calamari

$8.49

With hot banana peppers and marinara dipping sauce

Shrimp Cocktail

$7.99

Garlic Bread

$2.99

Grilled Portobello Mushroom

$5.99

Antipasto Platter

$8.99

Assortment of italian relishes, provolone cheese, prosciutto and panino

Greens & Sausage

$7.49

Artichoke Hearts French

$7.49

Steamed Clams

$7.99

One dozen clams with drawn butter


SaladsDressings: Bleu cheese, vinaigrette, caesar, fat free dijon, honey mustard, fat free french, ranch, poppy seed, crumbly bleu cheese add $0.79

Garden Salad

$4.99

Grilled Chicken Salad

$7.99

Tomato, cucumber, chick peas, pepperoncini and olives

Caesar Salad

$6.99

Homemade Caesar dressing with anchovies, croutons and parmesan cheese

Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken

$9.99

Artichoke Salad

$6.99

Marinated hearts in a vinaigrette dressing over a bed of romaine lettuce


Soups

Stracciatella

$2.99 - $3.99

Zuppa del Giorno

$2.99 - $3.99

New England Clam Chowder

$3.49 - $4.49


Specialty SandwichesAll sandwiches are served with chips and a pickle

Chicken French

$6.99

With escarole on a hard roll

Chicken Parmigiano

$6.99

Melted mozzarella and tomato sauce on a hard roll

Eggplant Aglio E Olio

$5.99

Breaded eggplant with oil and garlic on panino bread

Grilled Sausage

$6.99

Peppers and onions on panino bread

Grilled Chicken Italiano

$6.99

Provolone and roasted red peppers on a hard roll

Grilled Portobello Sandwich

$6.99

Grilled portobello mushroom with red peppers and provolone on a hard roll

Meatball

$6.99

Melted mozzarella and tomato sauce on panino bread

Eggplant Parmigiano

$6.49

Melted mozzarella and tomato sauce on panino bread

Steak Sandwich

$8.49

Rib eye steak with sauteed mushrooms, onions and mozzarella on a hard roll


Homemade Pasta and MoreFull orders include soup or salad

Eggplant Parmigiano

$12.99 - $8.99

With a side of pasta

Homemade Ravioli

$11.99 - $7.99

Homemade Gnocchi

$11.99 - $7.99

Lasagna

$11.99 - $7.99

Tripe

$13.99 - $9.99

Manicotti with Ricotta Cheese

$11.99 - $7.99


PastaFull orders include soup or salad

Pasta

$11.49 - $7.49

Choose your favorite pasta: Penne, linguine, capellini. Choose a savory sauce: Tomato, marinara, oil and garlic


Pasta SpecialtiesFull orders include soup or salad

Penne Arrabbiata

$8.99 - $11.99

Portobello mushrooms and pancetta, simmered in a spicy marinara sauce

Penne Alla Bolognese

$8.99 - $11.99

Tasty tomato sauce with tender pieces of beef, veal and diced carrots

Penne Broccoli

$8.99 - $11.99

Oil and garlic, broccoli & penne pasta

Carbonara Romana

$8.99 - $11.99

Pancetta and homemade sausage in a cream sauce over linguine, topped with parmesan cheese

Linguine Bellone

$8.99 - $11.99

Chef john’s creation sauteed with prosciutto, diced tomatoes, onions and garlic sauce

Linguine Puttanesca

$8.99 - $11.99

Traditional dish with olives, tomatoes, capers and a hint of anchovy

Capellini Tribotte

$8.99 - $11.99

Chef glenn’s creation oil and garlic, parmesan cheese, artichoke hearts, kalamata olives and bread crumbs


ChickenSoup, salad, pasta, potato. Half order choice of one side. Full order choice of two sides

Gambero

$11.99 - $15.99

Sauteed with jumbo shrimp in a butter, lemon, wine sauce

Saltimbocca

$11.99 - $15.99

Sauteed with prosciutto, kalamata olives, mushrooms, served over escarole

Marsala

$11.99 - $15.99

Sauteed in sweet sicilian wine and mushrooms

Della Casa

$11.99 - $15.99

Mushrooms, artichoke hearts, melted provolone cheese in a white wine sauce

French

$11.99 - $15.99

Egg dipped and sauteed in a lemon, sherry wine and butter sauce, served over escarole.

Parmigiano

$11.99 - $15.99

Smothered in tomato sauce and mozzarella


VealSoup, salad, pasta, potato. Half order choice of one side. Full order choice of two sides

Gambero

$12.99 - $16.99

Sauteed with jumbo shrimp in a butter, lemon, wine sauce

Saltimbocca

$12.99 - $16.99

Sauteed with prosciutto, kalamata olives, mushrooms, served over escarole

Marsala

$12.99 - $16.99

Sauteed in sweet sicilian wine and mushrooms

Della Casa

$12.99 - $16.99

Mushrooms, artichoke hearts, melted provolone cheese in a white wine sauce

French

$12.99 - $16.99

Egg dipped and sauteed in a lemon, sherry wine and butter sauce, served over escarole.

Parmigiano

$12.99 - $16.99

Smothered in tomato sauce and mozzarella


SeafoodSoup, salad, pasta, potato. Half order choice of one side. Full order choice of two sides

Shrimp Scampi

$11.99 - $15.99

Butter, garlic, wine and lemon sauce, served over linguine

Clam Sauce

$9.49 - $13.49

Classic dish made with chopped clams over linguine with red or white sauce

Haddock Florentine

$11.99 - $15.99

Broiled in white wine sauce and lemon, served over escarole

Fra Diavolo Pescatore

$12.99 - $16.99

Spicy marinara sauce with shrimp, scallops, calamari and whole clams, served over capellini

Zuppa di Pesce

$12.99 - $16.99

Calamari chopped clams, shrimp and haddock in a white wine sauce, served over capellini

Linguine al Pirata

$12.99 - $16.99

Shrimp, scallops and calamari in a spicy wine sauce with onions, hot banana peppers, roasted red peppers and kalamata olives

Frutti di Mare

$12.99 - $16.99

Scallops, shrimp, calamari and whole clams in a white wine sauce, served over capellini


BeefAll beef entrees are served with choice of two: Soup, salad, pasta or potato

Rib Eye Steak

$21.99 - $23.99

All beef entrees are served with choice of two: Soup, salad, pasta or potato

Prime Rib

$21.99 - $27.99

All beef entrees are served with choice of two: Soup, salad, pasta or potato


SidesWith dinner

Meatballs

$1.79

Baked Potato

$1.99

Pasta

$2.99

Sausage

$2.49

Vegetables

$2.49

Side Salad

$3.99

French Fries

$2.49

Gnocchi

$3.99

Side Caesar Salad

$4.99


Children's MenuChildren 10 years of age or less

Spaghetti & Meatball

$5.99

Chicken Fingers with French Fries

$5.99

Rib Eye Jr. Sandwich with French Fries

$6.99

Ravioli

$6.49


Dessert

Chocolate Nut Torta made with Nutella

Price may varies

Old meets new in this gluten free classic nut torta that sparkles with roasted hazelnuts and almonds and a milk chocolate icing and hand slathered with nutella

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie with Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Price may varies

The popular candy bar in a pie dark chocolate and peanut butter mousse full of reese’s peanut butter cups. Reese’s and the peanut butter cup symbol are registered trademarks and used with permission

Lemon Berry Mascarpone Cake

Price may varies

Cream cake topped with blueberries, cranberries and vanilla crumb. Cake is filled with lemon cream and finished with vanilla cake crumb on the sides and a dusting of sugar

Tiramisu

Price may varies

Clouds of light mascarpone cream on pillows of coffee brandy soaked lady fingers, finished with imported sweet cocoa. This exquisite tiramisu is a craveable pick meup

Caramel Apple Granny

Price may varies

Buttery caramel and toffee studded custard hug fresh granny smith apples piled high in our melt in themouth shortbread crust.

Cannoli

Price may varies

Crispy cannoli shell filled with creamy ricotta and lightly drizzled with chocolate syrup and garnished with whipped cream

Oreo Cookie Bash

Price may varies

An oreo cookie universe of white ‘n milk chocolate cream, starry with oreo chunks and showered with dark chocolate drizzle. Oreo is a registered trademark of kraft foods holding, inc. used under lice

Ricotta Cheesecake

Price may varies

Creamy, fluffy and feather light this favorite has just a whisper more texture than our other cheesecakes. Made with snowy white ricotta, it’s slightly less sweet and lusciously rich.


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading