Menu With Price > Menu > Papa Hughie's

Papa Hughie's Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 194 votes

Seafood

Choose My State

Papa Hughie's Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14

Soft Drinks

Soda

$1.75

Tea

$1.75

Coffee

$1.75

Milk

$1.75

Saratoga

$2.50

Juice

$2.00

Side Orders

Baked Potato

$2.75

Garden Salad

$3.00

Cole Slaw

$2.75

Potato Salad

$2.75

Bahamian Peas & Rice

$2.75

French Fries

$2.50

Vegetable

$3.00

Pasta

$3.50

Crumbled Blue Cheese

$1.00

Wine

Price may varies

be sure to check papa's wine list for a unique selection of fine wines, papa's favorite dishes

House Wines

Vendange

$3.95 - $14.95

Chardonay

$3.95 - $14.95

Merlot

$3.95 - $14.95

White Zinfandel

$3.95 - $14.95

Beer - Draft

Michelob

$3.00 - $8.50

Beer - Bottle

Budweiser

$3.25

Miller Lite

$3.25

Michelob Ultra

$3.25

Heineken

$3.75

Heineken Dark

$3.75

Corona

$3.75

Kalik

$3.75

Amstel Lite

$3.75

St. Pauli Girl

$3.25

non-alcoholic

Minnow's Menuunder 12 years old please

Chicken Fingers

$5.95

Popcorn Shrimp

$5.95

Fish Fingers

$5.95

with popcorn shrimp

Fish Fingers

$5.95

(broiled or fried)

Linguini Marinara

$3.50

Desserts Worth Diving Intoplease ask your waiters for today's homemade desserts.

Key Lime Pie

$4.25

Tiramisu

$4.25

Cheesecake

$5.95

Chowder

New England Clam Chowder

$3.95 - $5.95

(white)

Bahamian Conch Chowder

$4.95 - $6.95

(red)

Teasers

Conch Fritters

$8.95

(island specialty)

Fried Calamari

$8.95

(light & crispy, with marinara sauce)

Fish Dip

$6.95

"house secret" (like you've never tasted)

Wahoo Salad

$9.95

(all we can say is wahoooooo!) papa's favorite dishes

Stuffed Mushrooms

$7.95

(with fresh crab meat stuffing)

Stuffed Clams

$7.95

(homemade)

Crab Cake

$9.95

(with papa hughie's mustard sauce)

Tuna Or Swordfish Bites

$8.95

(blackened over seaweed salad)

Shrimp Cocktail

$9.95

(10 shrimp)

Shrimp Cocktail

$4.00

colossal

Cracked Conch Appetizer

$11.95

(tender & delicious)

Shrimp Salad

$10.95

(simply the best)

Conch Salad

$10.95

(authentic bahamian)

Seafood Vinaigrette

$9.95

(conch, shrimp, crawfish), papa's favorite dishes

Sesame Seaweed Salad

$4.95

(hiyashi wakame)

Oriental Calamari Salad

$7.95

(chuka ika sansai)

Sesame Seared Tuna

$12.95

(with seaweed salad & calamari salad)

Stone Crab Appetizer (Seasonal)

Stone Crab Claws

Price may varies

with papa hughie's mustard sauce

Simply Shellfish

Clams

$4.95 - $9.00

(steamed or raw)

Oysters On The Half Shell

$4.50 - $8.50

Mussels

$8.95

(red or white)

Seafood World Specialties

Snapper Francaise

$26.95

(the chef's finest)

Stuffed Fish

$26.95

(dolphin, snapper or grouper) (stuffed with fresh crab meat stuffing and topped with lobster sauce)

Surf-N-Turf

$39.95

(filet mignon & lobster tail) papa's favorite dishes

Sesame Seared Tuna

$25.95

with seaweed salad and calamari salad

Scallops

$19.95

(plump large sea scallops broiled or fried)

Crab Cake Dinner

$19.95

(award winning)

Fried Oysters

$16.95

(fresh shucked and lightly fried in beer batter)

Fried Combo

$17.95

(fresh catch, scallops, shrimp & conch fritters, (fried only))

Stone Crab Dinner (Seasonal)

Stone Crab Claws

Price may varies

with papa hughie's mustard sauce

Crab & Lobster

Alaskan King Crab Legs

Price may varies

(nicest legs anywhere) papa's favorite dishes

Dungeness Crab Clusters

$19.95

Snow Crab Legs

$19.95

Maryland Soft-Shelled Crabs

$19.95

(fried to perfection)

A Crab Lovers Feast

$34.95

complete crab dinner, (soft shell crab, crab cake & alaskan king crab)

Broiled Florida Lobster Tails

Price may varies

Maine Lobster

Price may varies

(steamed or stuffed)

Chef's Signature Saucesadd one of our famous homemade sauces to any dish

Teriyaki Ginger Sauce

$1.00

Mushroom Sauce

$3.00

Lobster Sauce

$5.00

Classic Shrimp

Peel 'N Eat Shrimp

$16.95 - $18.95

steamed in beer & old bay seasoning add $1.00

Large Popcorn Shrimp

$17.95

(fried in a light beer batter)

Shrimp For The Queen

$18.95

(fried in a light beer batter)

Jumbo Fried Shrimp

$22.95

(fried in a light beer batter)

Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp

$26.95

(fresh crab meat stuffing and topped with lobster sauce)

Papa's Pasta Dishes(served over linguini)

Mussels Or Clams

$17.95

(red or white)

Calamari Marinara

$17.95

Shrimp Marinara

$21.95

Our Chef's Famous Shrimp Scampi

$21.95

Lobster Fra Diablo

Price may varies

(mild or hot)

Zuppa De Pesce

$26.95

(mussels, clams, calamari, shrimp)

Conch Dishes, A Seafood World Specialty

Cracked Conch

$22.95

(lightly fried & beer battered) papa's favorite dishes

Complete Conch Dinner

$28.95

(includes conch chowder, conch fritters, conch salad, and cracked conch)

Specialties From The Land

Filet Mignon

$24.95

(tender and cooked to perfection)

Jerk Chicken

$16.95

(over peas & rice marinated in our own recipe)

Jerk Chicken

$19.95

(over peas & rice marinated in our own recipe) with shrimp

Chicken Fingers

$11.95

(breast tenders, lightly battered & fried)

DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.