Overtime Sports Grill & Bar Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 59 votes
Overtime Sports Grill & Bar Logo

Choose My State

SD

Overtime Sports Grill & Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Specialty DrinksMake your Margarita Grande for an exceptional value!

Classic Margarita

Price may varies

Sauza Tequila, Triple Sec, Sour Mix on the rocks

Frozen Margarita

Price may varies

Sauza Tequila, Triple Sec, Sour Mix blended with your favorite flavor. Strawberry, Mango, Peach, Raspberry

Premier Margarita

Price may varies

Patron Silver Tequila, Grand Marnier, Sour Mix on the rocks

Strawberry Daiquiri

Price may varies

Bacardi Superior Rum blended with Strawberry flavoring

Big Ginger

Price may varies

2 Gingers Irish Whiskey, Ginger Ale, Lime and Lemon

Moscow Mule

Price may varies

Absolut Vodka, Ginger Beer, Lemon and Lime in a copper mug

Electric Lemonade

Price may varies

Bacardi Limon, Absolut Citron, Blue Curacao, Lemonade, Sweet & Sour

Summer Skies

Price may varies

DeKuyper Peach Schnapps, Blue Curacao blended with Pina Colada flavoring

Watermelon Jalapeno Margarita

Price may varies

Fresh Jalapenos, Watermelon Puree, Sour Mix and Jose Cuervo Tequila


Draft BeerAsk about our rotating seasonal

Miller Lite

Price may varies

Bud Light

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra

Price may varies

Budweiser

Price may varies

Stella Artois

Price may varies

Bluemoon

Price may varies

Unfiltered Wheat Beer

Price may varies

Samuel Admas

Price may varies

New Belgium 1554

Price may varies

Shiner Bock

Price may varies


Domestics

Budweiser

Price may varies

Bud Light

Price may varies

Bud Select 55

Price may varies

Busch Light

Price may varies

Coors Light

Price may varies

Michelob Golden

Price may varies

Michelob Ultra

Price may varies

Miller Lite

Price may varies

MGD

Price may varies

MGD 64

Price may varies

Old Milwaukee Light

Price may varies

Pabst Blue Ribbon

Price may varies


Non-Alcoholic

O'Doul's

Price may varies

O'Doul's Amber

Price may varies


Imports & Specialty

Alaskan Amber

Price may varies

Angry Orchard

Price may varies

Corona

Price may varies

Corona Light

Price may varies

Fat Tire

Price may varies

Grain Belt

Price may varies

Guinness

Price may varies

Mike's Hard Lemonade

Price may varies

Mike's Hard Cranberry

Price may varies

Newcastle

Price may varies

O'Dell's IPA

Price may varies

Redd's Apple

Price may varies


Soft Drinks

Pepsi

Price may varies

Diet Pepsi

Price may varies

Mtn Dew

Price may varies

Diet Mtn Dew

Price may varies

Dr Pepper

Price may varies

Mist Twist

Price may varies

Mug Root Beer

Price may varies

Kick Start

Price may varies

Lemonade

Price may varies

Brisk

Price may varies

Life Water

Price may varies


Wine

White Zinfandel

Price may varies

Sutter Home

Chardonnay

Price may varies

Bota Box

Merlot

Price may varies

Bota Box

Cabernet

Price may varies

Bota Box

Riesling

Price may varies

Bota Box


Starting Line Up

Potato Skins

$8.99

Three full baked potatoes are halved and filled with melted Monterey Jack cheese, bacon and green onions. Served with sour cream

Quesadillas

$8.99 - $10.99

A flour tortilla stuffed with a blend of Monterey Jack cheese, pico de gallo and tender grilled chicken breast. Served with salsa & sour cream

Pub Style O-Rings

$7.79

Thick cut onion rings dipped in a beer batter and fried to crunchy perfection. Served with Southwest Ranch

Chislic

$10.49

Specially seasoned tender bite size pieces of steak, prepared either grilled or flash fried. Served with Texas toast and your choice of Ranch or BBQ sauce

Jumbo Pretzels

$5.49

Nothing goes better with an ice cold beer! Two of our soft giant pretzels are served warm with nacho cheese dip

Cheese Balls

$8.49

A cheese lover's delight! Wisconsin Cheddar Cheese, dipped in a special batter and golden fried. Served with Ranch

Mozzarella Bread

$6.99

Toasted garlic bread coated in gooey melted Mozzarella cheese. Served with Marinara dipping sauce

OT Bites

$8.99 - $14.99

You haven't really experienced the OT until you have tried our signature Bites! Tender cubes of chicken breast, add a slice of jalapeno, and wrap it in crispy bacon. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese

Southwest Fries

$8.29

Thick cut waffle fries covered in melted Monterey Jack cheese, bacon, scallions and drizzled with our famous Southwest Sauce. Sour cream served on side

Chips & Dip

$4.99

Our fresh tortilla chips and your favorite dipping sauce. Choose from homemade salsa, nacho cheese or our spicy pineapple salsa

Queso Dip

$6.99

Our Queso features a spicy blend of cheeses, spinach, green chilis and secret spices. Served with hot tortilla chips

Triple Dipper

$7.99

An endless basket of homemade tortilla chips and any 3 of our famous dips. Choose from salsa, nacho cheese, queso or our spicy pineapple salsa

Buffalo Quesadillas

$8.99

Your choice of our famous Hot or Mild Buffalo chicken, shredded lettuce, tomatoes and Monterey Jack between crispy grilled tortillas. Served with Ranch or Bleu Cheese


Slider ZoneSliders come three (3) to a basket with your choice of any 1 side. Sides: Fries, Waffle Fries, Seasonal Veggies, Cole Slaw, Chips & Salsa, Cottage Cheese, Broccoli & Cheese, Kettle Chips. Substitute Mac & Cheese $0.99, Cajun Fries $0.99, Onion Rings, Soup or Salad $1.79

Cheeseburger Sliders

$9.49

Savory mini beef burgers topped with melted American cheese and sauteéd onions

Pepper Jack Sliders

$9.99

Pepper Jack cheese, crispy bacon and a splash of our Hot sauce give these mini burgers the perfect amount of heat

Kickin Chicken Sliders

$8.99

White meat chicken patties tossed in our NEW Pineapple Kicker wing sauce and topped with shredded lettuce. May also be tossed in any favorite OT wing sauce


Mega NachosAt Over Time we take nachos to the extreme. Not only do we serve the largest plate but also the biggest variety of nachos anywhere. For those of you that are brave enough, there is also the Monster Nacho Challenge

OT Nachos Supreme

$6.99 - $13.99

The one that made us famous! Fresh homemade tortilla chips stacked to a ridiculous level and smothered with seasoned beef, cheese sauce, onions, tomatoes, black olives & jalapenos. Sour cream & salsa

Cajun Alfredo Nachos

$7.99

Created by OT employee Robert Brandon and winner of our Next Great Nacho Contest. A base layer of tortilla chips covered in Cajun seasoned chicken, Alfredo sauce, red and green bell peppers, green on

Buffalo Nachos

$6.99 - $13.99

Your choice of either Mild or Hot wing sauce coats tender pieces of chicken breast, tomatoes, green onions, cheese sauce and jalapenos. Served with choice of Ranch or Bleu Cheese on side

Bacon Ranch Nachos

$8.99

This unique nacho uses creamy Ranch dressing as a topping. Plenty of crispy tortilla chips topped with baked chicken breast, crunchy bacon pieces, green onions, tomatoes and nacho cheese sauce, all c

Margarita Nachos

$13.99

A huge platter of homemade tortilla chips topped with Margarita grilled chicken, melted Monterey Jack cheese, caramelized onions, lettuce, red, yellow and green peppers, jalapenos, habanero peppers a

Meat & Potato

$11.99

We love our meat & potatoes and this is the perfect way to enjoy them. Over a pound of waffle fries are covered in seasoned beef, cheese sauce, bacon, tomatoes and green onions. Sour cream & salsa on


Nacho Add-ons

Beef

$2.49

Chicken

$2.49

Bacon

$1.49

Salsa

$0.99

Pineapple Salsa

$0.99

Pico de Gallo

$0.99

Ranch

$0.50

Bleu Cheese

$0.50

Guacamole

$1.99

Southwest Ranch

$0.50

Wing Sauce

$0.99

Extra Cheese

$0.99

Sour Cream

$0.50

Shredded Lettuce

$0.50

Onion

$0.50

Green Onion

$0.50

Black Olives

$0.50

Jalapenos

$0.50

Tomatoes

$0.50

Mushrooms

$0.50

Green Olives

$0.50


Monster Nacho Challenge

Monster Nacho Challenge

$21.99

Think you've got what it takes to tame this beast? The Monster features 1 lb. chips, 1 lb. seasoned ground beef, 1 lb. waffle fries, 1 lb. cheese and 4 oz. each of jalapenos, black olives, onions and


Homemade PizzaAll pizzas are hand made and are large 14" family size (except personals). Choose from traditional rolled edge or no edge thin crust style. You may add or hold items on Specialty Pizzas, but no substitutions are allowed

Meat Lovers

$16.99

Pepperoni, Bacon, Sausage and Canadian Bacon

Bacon Cheeseburger

$14.99

Ketchup, Mustard, Bacon, Ground Beef, Onions, Pickles, Monterey Jack Cheese

Chicken Alfredo

$16.99

Alfredo Sauce, Tomatoes, Green Onions, Chicken

Buffalo Chicken

$16.99

Your choice of our Mild or Hot Wing Sauce, Green Onions, Tomatoes and Chicken

Taco

$15.99

Taco Sauce, Seasoned Beef, Lettuce, Shredded Cheese, Tomatoes, Black Olives and Tortilla Chips

Bacon Ranch Chicken

$15.99

Ranch, Bacon, Chicken, Tomatoes, Green Onions

Supreme

$16.99

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Onions, Black Olives, Mushrooms, Green Peppers

Ghost Pepperoni

$14.99

Ghost Pepper Cheese, Pepperoni, Jalapenos

Margherita

$13.99

No Sauce, Tomatoes, Cheese, Basil, Olive Oil


Build Your Own PizzaMeat Toppings: Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Chicken, Bacon, Ground Beef. Veggie Toppings: Broccoli, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Onions, Green Onions, Green Olives, Green Peppers, Tomatoes, Jalapenos, Pineapple.

Personal Cheese

$5.99

14" Cheese

$11.99


Home Run PastaAll pastas served with garlic toast and soup or salad

Shrimp Scampi

$11.99

Linguini noodles tossed with sautéed shrimp, red bell peppers, Parmesan cheese, parsley in a rich buttery scampi sauce

Cajun Chicken Pasta

$12.99

Penne pasta mixed with Cajun seasoned Alfredo, green peppers, mushrooms, green onions, fire-roasted red peppers, Parmesan cheese and parsley

Chicken Alfredo

$10.99

Tender chicken breast strips tossed with a rich and creamy Alfredo sauce and Penne. Topped with fresh Parmesan and parsley

Baked Mac and Cheese

$8.99

A special house blend of three cheeses, penne pasta, bacon, parsley, Parmesan cheese and bread crumbs baked on top


Jumbo WingsWe aren't saying our chickens are bullies but they are definitely bigger than the other guys! We made our reputation serving fresh JUMBO size wings and that is what you can always expect at OT. Whoever said size doesn't matter has obviously never tried our wings. All wings served with celery, Ranch or Bleu Cheese upon request. All flats or drummies add $0.79. Extra Celery, Ranch or Bleu Cheese $0.50 each. Celery, Bleu Cheese and Ranch are NOT included on Happy Hour Wings or All You Can Eat Tuesdays

Grilling Wings

$7.49 - $12.99

Served on a skewer, these wings are oven baked and char-grilled to perfection with minced garlic. They take a little longer (allow 20 mins.) but so worth the wait!

Naked Wings

Price may varies

Order our famous Jumbo, Boneless or Grilling Wings with the sauce served on the side

Jumbo Wings

$6.99 - $17.99

Boneless Wings

$8.49 - $15.99


Jumbo Wings SaucesMild to Wild! Choose your Style

Nuclear

Price may varies

Caution! Don't say we didn't warn you... this one should come with a waiver!

Hot

Price may varies

A Classic Buffalo style hot sauce

Pineapple Kicker

Price may varies

The sweet taste of pineapple followed by a powerful kick of heat

Triple Play

Price may varies

An awesome mixture of BBQ, Spicy Garlic & Hot create a perfect trio of spicy goodness

Tropical Habanero

Price may varies

Habanero peppers, spices, mango, pineapple and other flavors create a tropical sensation with a fiery heat

Caribbean Jerk

Price may varies

Reformulated with an extra kick of heat to mix with the sweet and tangy island spices

Gold Fever

Price may varies

Mild Buffalo sauce with a hint of Molasses and Mustard

Spicy Garlic

Price may varies

The perfect blend of garlic with just enough heat, make this sauce an all-time OT favorite

P, B & J

Price may varies

You read that right! The classic P, B & J is combined with hot sauce for an amazing sauce

Cajun

Price may varies

A dry seasoning mix of traditional Cajun spices

Thai Breaker

Price may varies

Sweet Thai chili peppers combined with a mild heat

Bourbon BBQ

Price may varies

A tangy BBQ sauce with a touch of heat, made with Jim Beam Kentucky Bourbon

Mild

Price may varies

Our traditional Buffalo sauce with all the taste but not all the heat

Parmesan Garlic

Price may varies

Creamy Parmesan cheese with a touch of garlic for a perfect compliment

Teriyaki

Price may varies

A sweet and mild soy sauce mix

BBQ

Price may varies

The classic sweet and slightly tangy BBQ taste


MVP FavoritesSides: Fries, Waffle Fries, Seasonal Veggies, Cole Slaw, Chips & Salsa, Cottage Cheese, Broccoli & Cheese, Kettle Chips. Substitute Mac & Cheese $0.99, Cajun Fries $0.99, Onion Rings, Soup or Salad $1.79

Beer Batter Fish & Chips

$9.99

Now featuring flaky white Atlantic cod dipped in beer batter and fried to a golden brown. Served with lemon, tartar and choice of 1 side

Fish Tacos

$8.99

Three flour tortillas stuffed with Atlantic cod, lettuce, Monterey Jack, and pico de gallo. Served with lemon slice and tartar

Wing Basket

$8.99

Five of our famous JUMBO wings covered in your favorite OT Wing Sauce. Choice of 1 side and Ranch or Bleu Cheese

Boneless Wing Basket

$9.99

Half pound of boneless wings covered in your favorite OT Wing Sauce. Served with 1 side item and Ranch or Bleu Cheese

Chicken Strips

$8.49

Golden brown chicken tenders are served with Ranch, BBQ, or Honey Mustard dipping sauce and choice of 1 side

Chislic Basket

$11.99

Our tender seasoned steak bites grilled or flash fried with your choice of side. Served with Ranch or BBQ

OT Bites Basket

$9.99

You asked for it and we delivered. Our famous bacon wrapped chicken and jalapeno bites are now available in a basket. Served with choice of side and Ranch or Bleu Cheese

Shrimp Basket

$12.49

Our Red Hook beer batter provides a simply amazing taste to a generous portion of Atlantic shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce and choice of 1 side item

Margarita Chimi

$11.99

Margarita marinated chicken, Monterey Jack and green chilis. Topped with more cheese, tomatoes and jalapenos on a bed of lettuce. Served with homemade tortilla chips, sour cream and pineapple salsa


Sizzlin' Fajitas

Classic Fajitas

$11.99 - $12.99

Our authentic fajitas are served with warm tortilla shells, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, salsa & sour cream, sizzling onions, red, yellow & green bell peppers

Margarita Fajitas

$12.99

Tender Margarita marinated chicken breast with caramelized onions, bell peppers, pineapple pico de gallo, jalapenos and habanero peppers. Served with cheese, lettuce, sour cream and spicy pineapple s


WrapsAll wraps are served with fresh tortilla chips and salsa

Southwest Wrap

$8.99

Specially seasoned fajita chicken breast, sauteéd red, yellow and green peppers, onions, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and our famous Southwest sauce

OT Chicken Wrap

$8.99

Choose from either grilled or breaded chicken coated in your favorite OT Wing Sauce, shredded lettuce, Monterey Jack and tomatoes in a flour tortilla


Soups & Salads

Chef's Specialty

$3.49

Available on select days only. Our chefs create seasonal homemade specialty soups for you to enjoy. Ask your server what's available today

Chicken Tortilla Soup

$3.49

A spicy cheese blend featuring chunks of chicken breast and topped with tortilla chips

Fajita Salad

$8.99 - $10.49

Fajita seasoned steak, chicken or shrimp, red, yellow green peppers, onions, pico de gallo, tortilla chips and Monterey Jack on a bed of fresh greens. Served with Southwest Ranch

Limitless Soup and Salad

$8.99

Unlimited refills of our fresh garden salad and our signature tortilla soup or specialty soup

Taco Salad

$8.99 - $9.99

A crispy tortilla bowl filled with shredded lettuce, seasoned taco beef, onions, jalapenos, tomatoes, black olives, and shredded cheese. Sour cream and salsa on side

OT Chicken Salad

$9.99

Choose either grilled or breaded chicken breast coated in your favorite OT Wing Sauce, tomatoes, onions, Monterey Jack and croutons on a crispy bed of salad greens

California Cobb Salad

$10.99

A variety of fresh greens, tender grilled chicken breast, bacon, tomatoes, black olives, Monterey Jack and topped with guacamole


Famous BurgersAll burgers served with your choice of 1 side item. Onion, pickles and tomato available upon request. Sub pretzel roll $1.49. Add cheese $0.99. Add Ghost Pepper cheese $1.49. Any burger may be replaced with a grilled chicken breast at no extra charge. Sides: Fries, Waffle Fries, Seasonal Veggies, Cole Slaw, Chips & Salsa, Cottage Cheese, Broccoli & Cheese, Kettle Chips. Substitute Mac & Cheese $0.99, Cajun Fries $0.99, Onion Rings, Soup or Salad $1.79

OT Burger

$8.49

The standard by which all other burgers are measured. The classic flame-grilled patty is served on a toasted bun

Blackened Chicken

$9.99

Ok, so technically it's a sandwich but who cares, it tastes great! Tender char-grilled chicken breast, blackened and served on a pretzel roll

Texas Burger

$10.49

Bet you can't resist this monster. Piled high as the Texas sky with crispy bacon, Cheddar cheese and topped with an onion ring & BBQ sauce

Egg Burger

$10.49

How do you improve on our great burgers? Put a fried egg on top, of course. American cheese, crispy bacon all topped with a hard side up fried egg

Southwest Burger

$9.99

All the great flavors of the Southwest on a burger. Grilled red, yellow and green peppers, onions, Pepper Jack and jalapenos. Southwest Ranch on the side

Bacon Cheeseburger

$9.99

An all-time American favorite. A fire-grilled beef patty, your choice of cheese and Applewood smoked bacon

Mushroom & Swiss

$9.49

Our juicy patty of ground steak is smothered with sauteéd mushrooms and Swiss cheese and served on a toasted bun

Blazing Burger

$10.49

Think you can handle the heat? This fiery hot burger features Ghost Pepper cheese, grilled jalapenos and our New Caribbean Jerk sauce.

Patty Melt

$9.49

This classic favorite features our delicious burger on rye bread, topped with American cheese, Swiss cheese and sauteéd onions


Spectacular SandwichesAll sandwiches served with your choice of any 1 side item. Sub a pretzel roll $1.49

Club Sandwich

$9.49

This grand sandwich has sizeable amounts of thinly sliced ham, turkey breast, bacon, Swiss & American cheeses, tomatoes and mayo on Texas toast

Colossal Philly

$10.99

Tender marinated steak or chicken smothered in melted Swiss, sauteéd onions, red, yellow and green peppers. All served open faced on a toasted hoagie roll

Big Fish Sandwich

$8.99

Beer battered Atlantic Cod on a toasted hoagie roll with American cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. Served with tartar sauce

Turkey Supreme

$9.99

Sliced turkey breast stacked on a toasted pretzel roll with Swiss cheese, smoked bacon, tomatoes, mayo and shredded lettuce

Chicken Ranch Melt

$9.49

Tender breaded white meat chicken, melted Pepper Jack cheese, Applewood smoked bacon on grilled Texas toast. Served with Ranch

BLT Sandwich

$6.99

This one never goes out of style. Double smoked crispy bacon, tomatoes, fresh lettuce and mayo on Texas toast

Deluxe Grilled Cheese

$5.99

Your childhood cheese sandwich, only better. Combination of American, Swiss and Cheddar cheese all grilled to perfection between Texas toast


AppetizerSelect Any 1 Appetizer to Share

Chips and Salsa

Price may varies

Chips and Queso Dip

Price may varies

Chips and Nacho Cheese

Price may varies

Mozzarella Bread

Price may varies

Half Order Southwest Fries

Price may varies

Jumbo Pretzels

Price may varies


EntreesSelect 2 Full Size Entrees

Chicken Strip Basket

Price may varies

Jumbo Wing Basket

Price may varies

OT Bites Basket

Price may varies

Personal OT Nacho Supreme

Price may varies

Personal Buffalo Nacho

Price may varies

Pepper Jack Sliders (2)

Price may varies

Taco Salad

Price may varies

Fajita Chicken Salad

Price may varies

Fish Tacos

Price may varies

Classic OT Burger

Price may varies


Desserts

Chocolate Torte Cake

$4.99

Chocolate mousse centered between layers of chocolate cake. Topped with chocolate icing on a chocolate graham crust

Cinnamon Pretzel Bites

$3.99

Bite size pieces of our famous giant pretzels coated in cinnamon and sugar and served with a warm frosting dipping sauce


Lunch Combo MealsAvailable Monday through Friday from 11 am until 2 pm. All value Meals served with your choice of any 1 side item. Sides: Fries, Waffle Fries, Seasonal Veggies, Cole Slaw, Chips & Salsa, Cottage Cheese, Broccoli & Cheese, Kettle Chips. Substitute Mac & Cheese $0.99, Cajun Fries $0.99, Onion Rings, Soup or Salad $1.79

Club Sandwich

$8.49

Generous amounts of thinly sliced ham, turkey, bacon, Swiss and American cheese, tomatoes and mayo on Texas toast

BLT Sandwich

$5.99

Double smoked crispy bacon, tomatoes, fresh lettuce and mayo on Texas toast

Big Fish Sandwich

$7.99

Beer battered Atlantic Cod on a toasted hoagie with American cheese, lettuce and tomatoes. Tartar sauce on side

Deluxe Grilled Cheese

$4.99

A combination of American, Swiss and Cheddar cheeses all grilled to precision between Texas toast

Cheeseburger Sliders

$5.99 - $8.49

Savory mini beef burgers topped with melted American cheese and sauteéd onions

Pepper Jack Sliders

$6.99 - $8.99

Pepper Jack cheese, crispy bacon and a splash of our Hot sauce give these mini burgers the perfect amount of heat

Kickin Chicken Sliders

$6.99 - $8.99

Breaded white meat chicken tossed in Pineapple Kicker wing sauce and topped with shredded lettuce. May also be tossed in any favorite OT wing sauce

Limitless Soup and Salad

$6.99

Unlimited refills of our fresh garden salad and our famous chili or chicken tortilla soup. Served with grilled Texas toast


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading