Otto's Sea Grill Menu and Prices

4.0 based on 84 votes
Otto's Sea Grill Logo
Seafood

Choose My State

NY

Otto's Sea Grill Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Salads

SHRIMP SALAD

$16.95

SEAFOOD SALAD

$16.95

LETTUCE, TOMATO and ONION

$7.50

CHEF’S SALAD

$16.95

Turkey Breast, Ham, Swiss Cheese and American Cheese Garnished with Tomato, Egg and Olives

FRESH FRUIT SALAD

$12.95

CAESAR SALAD

$10.50

GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR

$14.95

A Traditional Caesar Salad with Strips of Tender Grilled Chicken

GRILLED SHRIMP CAESAR

$16.95

A Traditional Caesar Salad with 5 Succulent Grilled Shrimp


From The Soup Kettle

BAKED FRENCH ONION SOUP

$6.00

with Mozzarella

MANHATTAN CLAM CHOWDER

$4.50 - $5.95

NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER

$4.50 - $5.95


Casting Off

SHRIMP COCKTAIL SUPREME

$10.95

CARIBBEAN COCONUT SHRIMP

$11.95

with Pineapple Mango Salsa

GARLIC BREAD with MELTED MOZZARELLA

$5.00

MARYLAND CRAB CAKE

$10.50

FRIED POTATO SKINS

$7.95

with Melted Cheese and Bacon Bits

FRESH VEGGIE PLATTER

$9.95

with Dip

CHICKEN TENDERS

$8.50

with Honey Mustard Sauce

ONION URCHIN

$8.95

A Colossal Onion Lightly Breaded, Fried and Served with Our Special Sauce

FRIED MOZZARELLA STICKS

$7.95

HOT WINGS

$8.50

Served with Bleu Cheese and Celery Strips

JALAPENO POPPERS

$7.95

Jalapeno Peppers Stuffed with Cheese.


Clam Digger Delights

HOT CLAM SAMPLER (6)

$13.00

BAKED CLAMS (Chopped) (6)

$12.00

CLAMS CASINO (4)

$9.95

CLAMS on the Half Shell

$8.50 - $14.95

Steamed with Lemon and wine Extra $2.00

STEAMERS

Price may varies

STEAMED MUSSELS

$12.95

MUSSELS MARINARA

$14.95

BLUE POINT OYSTERS

$9.95 - $18.95

OYSTERS ROCKEFELLER (4)

$12.95

SCREAMING OYSTERS

$12.95

FRIED CALAMARI

$14.50

Medium or Hot Sauce

RAW BAR COMBO

$14.95

3 Oysters, 3 Clams, 2 Shrimp


Sandwiches & BurgersBurgers are Served with Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle and French Fries

SPECIAL SHELL STEAK

$17.95

with French Fries

SMOKED TURKEY and CHEDDAR CHEESE WRAP

$12.95

with Chiffonade of Romaine with a Tomato Vinaigrette Wrapped in a Basil Tortilla

SOFT SHELL CRAB SANDWICH

Price may varies

with French Fries

GRILLED FRESH CATCH OF THE DAY

$14.95

Grilled to Perfection and Brushed with Lemon, Butter and Wine

FRIED FILET of SOLE

$12.95

with French Fries

BURGER

$8.95

CHEESEBURGER

$9.95

Choice of American, Swiss, Cheddar or Mozzarella

BACON CHEESEBURGER

$11.95

TRIPLE DECKER CLUB

$11.95

with Potato Salad

GRILLED STEAK TIDBITS or CHICKEN TIDBITS

$14.95

with Mozzarella on Garlic Bread

GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST

$12.95

on a Sesame Seed Bun with French Fries

PAN-FRIED MARYLAND CRAB CAKE SANDWICH

$12.95

with French Fries


Out Riggers

FRENCH FRIED ONION RINGS

$4.50

FRENCH FRIED POTATOES

$4.00

BAKED POTATO

$3.00

GARLIC BREAD

$4.00

WARM ROLLS

$2.50

with Butter

VEGETABLE OF THE DAY

$3.50

BAKED SWEET POTATO

$4.00


Main Deck Entrees - Hooked & CookedAll Our Entrees are Served with a Complimentary Basket of Warm Rolls and Butter, Choice of Creamy Cole Slaw or Crisp Green Salad, Choice of Rice, Baked Potato, French Fries or Vegetable

SWORDFISH

$24.95

Grilled Lightly, Brushed with Lemon and Butter

STRIPED BASS OREGANATA

$23.95

TALAPIA

$22.95

with Pignoli Herb Crust

BROILED STUFFED FLOUNDER

$24.95

with Crabmeat and Shrimp

WHOLE BROILED FLOUNDER

$21.95

BROILED or FRIED FILET of SOLE

$22.95

SOLE FLORENTINE

$22.95

with Spinach

SAUTEED SOLE ALMONDINE

$22.95

LINGUINE

$18.95

with White or Red Clam Sauce

FRIED BLUEPOINT OYSTERS

$21.95

FRIED CLAM STRIPS

$17.95

Lightly Breaded and Battered

FRIED BUTTERFLY SHRIMP

$24.95

BROILED or FRIED SCALLOPS

$24.95

Succulent Bay or Sea

POACHED or BROILED SALMON

$24.95

with Dill or Dijon Sauce

SHRIMP SCAMPI

$24.95

Sauteed in Our Special Garlic Butter and Served over Linguine or Rice Pilaf

FRIED CALAMARI

$20.95

with Marinara Sauce on a Bed of Linguine


Main Deck Entrees - The Captain’s Nautical SpecialsAll Our Entrees are Served with a Complimentary Basket of Warm Rolls and Butter, Choice of Creamy Cole Slaw or Crisp Green Salad, Choice of Rice, Baked Potato, French Fries or Vegetable

WHOLE LIVE BROILED LOBSTER

Price may varies

priced according to size

STUFFED JUMBO LOBSTER TAIL (16 oz.)

Price may varies

JUMBO LOBSTER TAIL (16 oz.)

Price may varies

TWIN LOBSTER TAILS

$39.95

STUFFED LOBSTER TAIL

$38.95

Stuffed with Crabmeat and Shrimp

SURF and TURF

$44.95

Filet Mignon and Lobster Tail

ALASKAN KING CRAB LEGS

Price may varies

FRIED or BROILED FISHERMAN’S SPECIAL

$29.95

Filet of Sole, Scallops, Shrimp and Clams

FRIED SOFT SHELL CRABS, In Season (2)

Price may varies

PAN-SEARED MARYLAND CRAB CAKES

$24.95

SHRIMP and SCALLOPS COMBO

$26.95

Tomatoes, Mushrooms, Black Olives in a Delicious Scampi Sauce, Served over Linguine or Rice Pilaf

SEAFOOD POSILLIPO

$27.95

Filet of the Day, Shrimp, Scallops, Clams and Mussels in a Zesty Sauce over a Bed of Linguine or Rice Pilaf

PENNE ALLA VODKA

$17.95

PENNE ALLA VODKA

$19.95 - $22.95


Land Lubbers Fare

GRILLED 20 oz. BLACK ANGUS PORTERHOUSE STEAK

$34.95

SAUTEED or GRILLED CHICKEN BREAST

$21.95

with Mushroom Sauce

CHICKEN CORDON BLEU

$21.95

BLACK ANGUS FILET MIGNON (10 oz.)

$26.95

Topped with Onion Rings


Captain Kidd’s Menu10 and Under Children’s Dinners are Served with French Fries and Ice Cream

LINGUINE

$8.00

with Tomato Sauce

HAMBURGER

$8.00

CHEESEBURGER

$9.00

FRIED SHRIMP

$9.00

FRIED FILET of SOLE

$8.00

CHICKEN TENDERS

$8.00

CHICKEN and SHRIMP COMBINATION

$10.00


Exotic Frosted Delights

MAI TAI

Price may varies

MARGARITA

Price may varies

PINA COLADA

Price may varies

PLANTERS PUNCH

Price may varies

STRAWBERRY DAIQUIRI

Price may varies

BANANA DAIQUIRI

Price may varies


After Dinner Coffees

COFFEE, TEA or MILK

$2.50

ICED COFFEE or ICED TEA

$2.50

ESPRESSO

$3.95

CAPPUCCINO

$5.50


International Coffees

NUTTY IRISHMAN

$8.00

Bailey’s Irish Cream and Frangelico

IRISH COFFEE

$8.00

COFFEE

$8.00

JAMAICAN COFFEE

$8.00


Sweet After Thoughts

ICE CREAM SUNDAE

$6.95

Chocolate, Strawberry, Vanilla

PEACH or STRAWBERRY MELBA

$6.95

ICE CREAM

$4.50

ASSORTED PIES

$4.75

Apple, Lemon Meringue, Blueberry, A La Mode Extra $3.00

CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CAKE

$6.00

CHEESE CAKE

$5.50

CHOCOLATE MUD PIE

$6.00

RASPBERRY BOMBES

$6.00

NATURAL FRUIT SORBETS

$6.00

TIRAMISU

$6.00

FRESH FRUIT

$4.50

In Season

BERNICE’S HOMEMADE CHERRY CHEESE CAKE

$6.00


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading