Otter Lodge Bar Menu and Prices

4.5 based on 111 votes
Otter Lodge Bar Logo

Choose My State

NY

Otter Lodge Bar Menu

Last Update: 2025-03-14


Main Menu

French Onion Soup

$4.99

Our take on the menu staple

Soup O the Day

Price may varies

Otter Mac & Cheese Bowl

$7.99

4 Cheese blend with smoked ham, baked perfectly

Otter Mac & Cheese Bowl with Blue Crab

$9.99

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$8.99

Baby spinach & artichoke with cream cheese & swiss. Served with toasted bread. Add crab $10.99

Mozzarella Stix

$6.49

Fresh mozzarella hand bread & fried perfect with homemade marinara

Pizza Logs

$6.99

Chicken Tenders

$7.99

Large breaded chicken breast strips with choice of sauce for dippin

Otter Blue Balls

$7.99

Bite sized balls filled with chicken, ham & swiss cheese. Served with a honey mustard dipping sauce

Otter Pot Stickers

$7.49

Spicy & crisp with orange poppy seed chutney for dipping

Otter Ole Quesadillas

$9.99

Our huge flour tortilla filled with black olives, tomato, red onion, & cheddar. Add the trademark otter brisket or grilled chicken

Otter Onion Rings

$4.99

Served with our unique o-ring lubrication

Nachos Mucho Grande

$8.99

Crispy homemade tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce, tomato, black olives & jalapeno. And now we have breased & seasoned brisket

Potato Skins

$6.99

Loaded with bacon & cheddar served with sour cream

Otter Lodge Potato Chips

$4.99

Made in house & fried cajun, otter style or sea salt & pepper

The Otter Fry Familia

$4.99

Any basket choose from steak, curly or sweet potato

The Otter Fry Familia - Loaded Baskets

$6.49

Bacon, cheese


All-StarsSandwiches include a pickle and homemade other chips $1.00 extra for choice of fries, mac salad or side salad

Darren's Pastrami

$10.99

1/2 Lb of pastrami piled upon griddled local rye bread with swiss cheese & darren's beer mustard

Timmy's Brisket Sandwich

$10.99

Our own smoked brisket with provolone, onion, mushroom & bell pepper served with a pepper jus

Erica's Crab Cake Sandwich

$9.99

With a japanese horseradish aioli, mesclun & tomato

Bluc Crab Melt

$8.99

Served open face with melted swiss cheese, shreeded lettuce & diced tomato

Bipo's Filet Mignon Sandwich

$12.99

Char grilled filet mignon, sauteed onion & mushroom, melted swiss, all on a fresh malek's roll


The GreensDressings: homemade bleu cheese, homemade ranch, honey mustard, italian, thousand island, balsamic vinaigrette & raspberry vinaigrette

Side Salad

$4.99

Field greens and romaine with tomato, black olives, onion & cucumber

Otter Lodge Salad

$6.49

Field greens and romaine with tomato, black olives, onion & cucumber. Add: brisket $9.99, crab cake $9.99, chicken $8.99

Classic Caesar Salad

$6.49

Hearts of romaine, parmesan & croulons. Add brisket $9.99, crab cake $9.99 or chicken $8.99

Chipotle Fajita Taco Salad

$9.49

Choice of grilled chicken or brisket served on field greens with tomato, black olives & onions'n a fried shell bowl. Dressed with our delicious chipolte ranch dressing & shredded cheddar cheese


Last Minute Entrees

10 oz. Char Grilled Ribeye

$14.99

Open face with choice of fries & sauteed onion & mushroom cooked to specification

Grilled Chicken Breast

$8.99

Served with sauteed onion, peppers & mushrooms, melted swiss cheese & choice of fries

Fish & Chips Everyday

$13.99

Two beer battered haddock filets with cole slaw & choice of fries


On Deck Famous Otter Wings

Dozen Wings

$10.99

Served with homemade bleu cheese & celery favorite style. Extra bleu cheese $0.50. Buffalo: mild, medium, hot, otter than hot, bourbon honey BBQ, guinness BBQ, garlic parmesan, ragin cajun, tangy ter

Boneless Wings

$9.99

Available with all favorite sauces


Otter Sampler

Chicken Tenders

$11.99 - $17.99

Chicken Wings

$11.99 - $17.99

2 Sliders

$11.99 - $17.99

Pizza Logs

$11.99 - $17.99

Onion Rings

$11.99 - $17.99

Mozzarella Stix

$11.99 - $17.99

Potato Skins

$11.99 - $17.99

Served with dipping sauce & celery


From the GridironThese sandwiches are available as a burger, grilled chicken or wrap. Includes pickle & otter chips $1.00 extra choice fries, mac salad or side salad

The Monroe

$7.99

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with smoked bacon & cheese

The Winton

$8.49

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with smoked bacon & bleu cheese

The Culver

$8.49

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with otter meat sauce, american cheese & chopped onion

The Westfall

$8.99

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with a fried egg & ham

The East

$7.99

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with mushrooms & swiss cheese

The Highland

$8.49

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with brisket, peppers, onions, mushrooms & provolone

The Elmwood

$7.49

8 oz. Ground beef or 8 oz marinated chicken breast with jalapeno, cheddar cheese & smoked bacon

The 490

$14.99

Any of the above presented double style for the hearty appetite

Otter Lodge Sliders

$10.99

Four traditional ground beef sliders, caramelized onion & american cheese, on a bed of choice fries, steak, curly or sweet potato

The Otter Veggie Burger

$8.99

Handmade with cannellini bean & crimini mushroom. Served with choice of cheese & 1000 island dressing

Fresh Haddock Sandwich

$8.99

Beer battered and presented with tartar sauce, lettuce & tomato on a roll


Hall of Fame

Thr Lodge Plate

$8.99

Two 1/4 lb burgers cheese optional or two hot dogs served with hot meat sauce, onions, mustard & choice of two mac salad, baked beans, or choice of one of our fries

The Bipo Plate

$13.99

The same as the otter plate, but with 4 hot dogs or two 1/2 lb burgers


DISCLAIMER: Information shown on the website may not cover recent changes. For current price and menu information, please contact the restaurant directly.

People Are Reading